The Tragedy's original formulation is based on a false premise of land that was not Common but in fact had an owner who managed it. Overgrazing was due to mismanagement.
Meanwhile, land actually owned in Common has historically been managed very well, through informal techniques of social consequences for overuse.
The "Tragedy of the Commons" is usually used as a justification for more rigid management when the initial example is a false premise that indicated the opposite conclusion should be made.
Anyway this original article could probably just have been a Wikipedia link, but the question is right there: why should something be wrong simply because it's bad if everyone does it?
When we pull it apart we realize we actually had been doing the argument's work for it and engaging in a very normal debate about right vs wrong for individual actions. Example: what if everyone became teachers? Well there'd be no plumbers! No no of course we didn't mean the formulation to cover those kinds of things, we meant, like, bad stuff, like parking in front of stores! If everyone did that it would be bad, so nobody should do it. Well except for pregnant people or disabled people or old people... And so on.
That I have to put up with the common person, is truly a tragedy! Too few people truly consider themselves as part of the commons: if something inconveniences them or doesn't inconvenience a person/group that they disapprove of it is a massive issue, if others are inconvenienced by something they consider convenient then they are just moaning ninnies who need to be less so.
The bougie bagel place downstairs is quintessential this free for all parking mentality. They prefer the driveways of other people since there is no front door parking. But this me-first attitude is more prevalent in American driving of late, as well as more of society. I cannot help think it related to the attitudes of those at the top, a sort of trickle down effect.
Asshole behavior is learned and reinforced, usually due to lack of any type of punishment: legal, social, familial, etc. That said, on the balance of things, I'd rather live in a world where a guy parks in front of a walmart than a world where there are cops everywhere enforcing who-knows-what laws.
That is, of course a false dichotomy, but the guy parks there in the first place because maybe his teachers & classmates let him get away with bullying the new kid, maybe he shoplifts a pack of gum and no one tells him this is wrong, maybe he blows through a stop sign and realizes there's certainly no punishment if you don't get caught. This is why there's a famous saying, "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
Nahh, i've hung around enough of those guys to realize that often it's not a lack of consequences that drives their behavior, it's just that they literally do not care about the consequences.
They only do not care about the consequences because the consequences are lacking.
If the only consequence for parking like an asshole is that MAYBE somebody yells at you for a minute, they don't care.
If the consequence for parking like an asshole is that somebody slashes your tires and now you have to pay for new tires (and take the time to do it), suddenly they will care about THOSE consequences.
In other words, they only don't care about consequences when the consequences are so minor there might as well be no consequences at all
If forced (or allowed) to pick, I agree totally. And sometimes situations get fuzzy. Once we needed to buy diapers and the store parking lot was packed. (Black Friday’s an awful time to have a plumbing leak.) Rather than circling for half an hour to look for a space, my wife hopped out and ran in so I could circulate for a few minutes. I parked along the curb way, way far away from the entrance, with no one closer than a few hundred feet from me, engine running for warmth, ready to move at a moment’s notice if a fire engine was coming or whatever. Soon a bored guard tapped on my window: “you can’t park here”. OK. I went back to alertly watching and waiting. He knocked again: “you can’t park here.” I’m not parked, the engine’s running, I’m not blocking anyone, and my wife’s coming out shortly with diapers. “Sir, you have to move your car.” Fine. I moved 10 feet and put it back in park. “Sir, you have to keep moving!” I put it in drive and crept along at 0.1 mph. “You have to move!” I am moving!
I’m certain he thought I was an asshole. I’m certain I thought he was pedantically enforcing the letter of a rule that the spirit didn’t require. My loophole helped me while not hurting or disturbing anyone else in any way, except for the guard’s annoyance. And 2 minutes later, my wife came out and we went back home where the in-laws anxiously awaited our return.
That's clearly not what was done here - there is a specific example of behavior, and a perfectly reasonable way to examine that behavior was pointed out.
This world would get along a lot better if we avoided knee-jerk reactions to rational discussion based solely on what philosophy/philosopher is referenced. Frankly, if you can't find a kernel of truth and wisdom in most philosophies, it's on you, not the philosopher - baby, bathwater, etc...
I've found Kants categorical imperative one of the more reliable guides to morality, as with the Golden Rule "do unto others as you would have them do unto you."
Why do you feel it is inadequate or inappropriate, as it seems to produce the correct answer in a broad variety of cases.
When applying the categorical imperative (“what if everyone acted in accordance with this belief?”) I have found it useful to look at it game-theoretically (is everyone acting this way a stable equilibrium? where does the equilibrium end up?) and also examine the counterfactual causal consistency (if everyone had been acting this way previously, would we have arrived at the current scenario? when thinking of exploiting a commons before others do, consider that the commons could not have accumulated into existence in the presence of others’ exploitation; the fact that you have the opportunity is evidence that you are not in a race to use that opportunity).
Ultimately it is about following (unstated) rules. Whatever you tell yourself is just justification. OP is right. Society demands us to adjust ourselves to others, and this is a good thing.
Personally my amount of legal loophole finding is proportional to the amount of bullshit in the world.
When political and corporate leaders are doing things that make life hard for me -- taxing me too much, starting wars with that money that I don't want, wrecking the job market, not fixing basic infrastructure around me, doing things that make daily life more expensive -- I'll find more legal ways to amass more resources. Churning credit cards for massive sign-up bonuses, tax loopholes, free shit, quant trading to harvest more than my "fair share" of investment returns, etc.
When leaders are doing things right, I have little incentive to do these things.
That’s a good point. I’ll stand in line and wait my turn for as long as necessary. When everyone else gets out of line and shoves their way in, being the only one to wait in line ceases to be noble and starts to look a lot like being a sucker.
Basically, it’s not so much ignoring the rules as accepting that the rules have been rewritten.
I believe this argument exists only because it makes people feel better.
So far, I have only heard it from people looking for loopholes to avoid paying their fair share.
“Why should I pay taxes when politicians waste so much money?”
The right solution is to elect different politicians or to enter politics yourself—not to cheat society.
While you absolutely should vote, and enter politics (especially local) if you have skills to contribute, that’s at best a long term plan and at worst could have no tangible impact towards making your “fair share” truly fair.
For better or worse we have to live in society as it currently functions.
A problem with thinking this way is that it gives you overwhelmingly powerful incentives to believe that the world is presenting you with bullshit. There's a lot of corporate leaders who genuinely, passionately believe that the government has it out for them and they've been left with no choice but to take advantage of regulatory loopholes.
Tailgaters, excessive speeders, buzzed/reckless drivers, drivers who don't care about putting others in harm's way (NASCAR wannabes), non-friendly drivers, texting/reading cellphone drivers, drivers who won't get out of the fast-lane...
I'm betting most don't think they're assholes, even if they cause a wreck. Nobodies perfect, but practicing decency is a virtue.
I don’t think being occasionally decent makes a person an asshole. The action is that of an asshole. But that’s a reference, not an identity judgement.
> Tailgaters, excessive speeders, buzzed/reckless drivers, drivers who don't care about putting others in harm's way (NASCAR wannabes), non-friendly drivers, texting/reading cellphone drivers, drivers who won't get out of the fast-lane
Do arseholes _know_ they're arseholes, generally speaking?
Because everyone on that list, bar none is an arse-hole, by my reckoning, and I often see some of these people and think to myself, "do you _know_ you're an utter shit stain, and _choose_ to be that way"?
Consistently using loopholes makes you an asshole.
Loopholes are social slack. You can speed to the hospital, usually, in an emergency. If you’re running late to pick up your kid, sure, double park or streetside with hazards.
But if you turn this into a lifestyle, you’re broken. (Every person tweeting with religious zeal for Jensen falls into that camp.)
Those aren't loopholes. Those are just plain breaking the law, relying on the violation either not being caught or being dismissed as not worth prosecuting, or in the extreme case, relying on sympathy getting you off of the hook.
A lot of these sorts rules are written with the assumption of infrequent enforcement only against those who do it the least tastefully or in the wrong setting or are a case of "yesterday's compromise is today's loophole".
Generations of useful idiots screeching about low compliance and demand enforcement of rules or systems never meant for it at scale rather than examine what the desired outcome ought to be is a special sort of slow moving "just barely not bad enough to trigger pushback by everyone else" naive evil that underpins a lot of the misery and discontent in the west today IMO
Selective enforcement is inherently unjust. I think people are right to demand either strict compliance, or the elimination of a rule entirely if it cannot be enforced consistently. Yes, that does break some existing compromises. I think it does us a disservice to pretend we can’t find alternative solutions.
Selective enforcement is a good thing because we can never think of all the exceptions. We need a way of admitting that we can't think of everything. "you broke the law for something that would have been an exception if we had thought of that situation in advance" is why selective enforcement should exist.
I don't want to downplay the abuse, but the alternative is worse.
Courts are too intrusive and painful. You have to spend days in a courtroom and talking to lawyers and such - instead of whatever you would normally do with your life.
There is so much more "selective enforcement" than you think. A good illustrative example is cryptocurrency. How's "code is law" going for the smart contract people?
You're right, but I think it does still boil down to social slack because it's selective enforcement. In the hospital example, there's precedent or even laws in some jurisdictions that allow it. People just don't know about them because they're not lawyers. It just makes sense to them. In the parking example, the same principle TFA applies, but from the point of view of the police officer: if every police officer enforced every statute without any regard for the circumstances, the judicial system would grind to a halt and society would suck. The devil is in the details, of course, but that's the idea.
Most loopholes were intentionally added. The question is should they be added?
A murder who gets off because a police officer had the wrong warrant when doing an investigation is an intentional loophole. I don't want murders to get off, but I also want police officers to get the wrong warrant and abuse the rights of law abiding people. (there has been a lot of effort to close this loop hole in various ways over the years)
The problem is that stuff scales. I live in a big city where people, especially delivery drivers, have gotten comfortable just slamming their brakes and putting their hazards on and blocking the road, even when there's a convenient parking space nearby. Roads are constantly blocked and causes all sorts of bottlenecks that backs up traffic by people "just stopping for a couple minutes."
Obviously, emergencies are the exception, but almost none of these behaviors are emergencies. Its just putting inconvenience on a random 3rd party so you can have convenience at their expense. I don't think we fully appreciate how so many systems in our lives are zero-sum and that if we excuse cheaters, then we are lowering the quality of our own lives. Then honest people feel the "sucker's payoff" and start cheating too and now we push the Nash equilibrium towards nearly everyone cheating, and now you have an entirely broken system.
I would more consider loopholes to be something where there's not normally social slack (it's weird or frowned upon to exploit a loophole so most people don't do it) versus something like speeding to the hospital in an emergency is rule-breaking, but socially accepted because it's for an exceptional and valid reason (and something most people would probably do in the circumstance).
I was trying to find a good example of a loophole and found this which was bizarre but sort of meets my imagined criteria:
"The Pudding Frequent Flyer Loophole: In the late 1990s, Healthy Choice ran a promotion giving away frequent flyer miles for buying their food products. A civil engineer named David Phillips realized that buying thousands of individual cups of pudding was the cheapest way to accumulate over 1.25 million airline miles, which he used for free travel while donating the pudding to charity for a tax write-off."
So a loophole is legal but not really "normal" behavior like the pudding example, while the speeding to the hospital example is rulebreaking (illegal) technically but is more accepted as "normal" due to the circumstances.
You can put a fake cast on your foot and you will be wheelchaired through Disney Land and skip the lines with your party in tow. Is it a loophole or a lifehack or a "crime"?
The wheelchairs aren't always due to ambulation problems, and they're not always for boarding problems per se, either, but that doesn't mean the people in them aren't disabled. For instance, if you're blind and you request assistance locating your gate because you can't read the signage, they just chuck you in a wheelchair push you there instead of leading you around.
Well, it's non-verbally telling a lie (that your foot is broken) to take something (wait time) from others. So it's a "crime". And it's definitely an asshole move.
Just to clarify, it's a made up scenario, but I can see it working unless a doctor's notice is required.
Another one - in the US I see many cars with disabled blue tags hanging from the rear view mirror. These are rather easily aqcured for minor disabilities. A normal person without any kind of limp will park in a spot for disabled right in front of the store.
> If you’re running late to pick up your kid, sure, double park or streetside with hazards.
I am having trouble drawing a line between "dealing with an issue of life / safety" and "I screwed up and want to shift the consequences onto society as a whole".
There is a town near me where a lot of the folks of a certain group hold religious services in their houses. They then don't pay (or pay very little) property taxes by delaring all of their homes houses of worship. They also don't get legally married, so that the mothers are all single mothers with no income, this getting government aid. Both legal AFAIK, and pretty big loopholes.
Afaik you could only declare a part of your house in this way. The marriage thing you need separate addresses, and also has its drawbacks, since you will have fewer legal protections and rights. Not sure if these are good examples of loopholes.
The marriage one is an excellent example of a loophole. It's extremely widespread in New York. The usual approach is that the marriages are done religiously but not legally. The mothers appear to the government as single mothers with large numbers of children. They get AFDC and Section 8 paid to their landlord, who conveniently happens to be the person who's actually married to the woman and the father of the children.
Not every loophole user is an asshole. Sometimes a loophole is how a badly designed rule gets exposed. Working around an arbitrary rule is a refusal to go along with something that doesn't make sense, not a failure of character.
Maybe we SHOULD park in front of the doors at Walmart, if the alternative is walking 10 miles to the nearest parking place.
There's about 20% of the population whom I really don't trust to decide for themselves which rules they have to follow and which ones they can ignore. However, it's unworkable to say that some people get to ignore rules while some people have to strictly follow them.
The norm has to be that everyone follows the rules, and goes through established processes to get the stupid rules fixed.
Anyone can choose to exploit a loophole, it's not a matter of genetics, even if you could prove that some subset of the human population is predisposed to doing it.
Culture can valorize people who exploit loopholes and by doing so encourage others to follow after those role models and do the same things.
The example cited--parking in a no-parking zone--isn't an example of a loophole. A loophole is usually understood as an act that honors that letter of the law but violates the spirit of the law.
The loophole is that someone only get punished if they get caught (by someone who wants to do something about it...), and it is unlikely they'll get caught if if they’re just running in to buy smokes or maybe some Pop Tarts for tomorrow.
Right - the loophole version of this is the NYC placard abuse.
People were illegally parking but because they had a city agency issued placard on their dashboard, it was a get out of jail free card.
Similar loophole was states like NJ having a temporary tag issuance fraud issue, such that people were driving around NYC with paper tags from out of state continuously.
And a whole bunch of people are gonna have to reconcile with the pushback from perfect (and often predatory or financially motivated) enforcement of rules that were only written and adopted as they were on the assumption of technical limitations on enforcement and the ensuing rule changes now that those technical limitations are gone.
And hopefully that will keep those people nice and busy because they're a pox upon any subject they direct their attention at.
There's nothing I like better than wasting my time in court fighting a red-light violation from an impossibly designed speed limit + yellow timing configuration, fighting a speeding claim when the camera captured my plate rather than the motorcycle passing me, or even just the increasingly common practice of printing somebody else's plate number for your toll violations.
>A loophole is a problem with the way the law is defined, not with how it is enforced.
Exactly. Stealing a driver's car, cash and belongings on the Interstate is, in fact, legal for police to do via "Civil Forfeiture"[0], but such laws were never intended to be used in that way. That's a loophole.
Yesterday a guy parked his big-ass truck AND TRAILER in the fire lane at Costco for nearly an hour. I know because I told the Costco manager, then went and ate my hotdog-soda nearly-free combo, truck was still there, then did all my shopping and paid and exited, truck was still there.
I asked the manager, do you need me to call the fire department for you? He said "you can make a call if you want, but we don't know who it is. I told the receipt checker to let me know when they come out so I can talk to them."
I called the fire department, they said they don't dispatch for this and to call the police. I called the police, they said since Costco parking lot is private property they won't come out unless it's a handicapped violation. I said even though they're blocking the fire lane? They said yes, the proper thing would be for Costco to call a tow truck and it would be at the owner's expense.
So I guess the guy was right, rules are only for those who have shame, if you're shameless you get special privileges like parking in the fire lane because you're huge truck is hard to find a parking spot for, and there's no consequences.
I've also seen on a near weekly basis now people bringing a dog that is clearly not a service animal (from its behavior) into the grocery store.
I'm reminded of George Costanza saying "We live in a SOCIETY!" or the entire Curb Your Enthusiasm show.
What to do? Accept the fact that terrible people get special privileges now that normal people don't, and just live with it? Become a bad person myself so I get the privileges? I can't decide, but I really don't like this timeline we're in. For some reason, very very ugly people have decided they don't have to be ashamed about their terrible behavior anymore. And I guess it's too much trouble for Costco OR THE POLICE to even do anything about. I know there are terrible people everywhere but the lack of consideration for others here in the USA is really reaching new heights all the time. It sucks.
Anyone got any suggestions? I don't want to become a bad person myself, but these events are starting to happen so often I feel like a sucker for not taking advantage. :(
Pretty likely that huge ass truck guy was a firefighter himself. That makes it arguably worse but that's the type of battle that you will probably never win.
For me, I think of them like mosquitos. Even in beautiful places that are otherwise divine, you occasionally have to deal with an annoying mosquito. For me, the big annoying mosquitos are private equity, cars in general (with hugeass trucks being a particularly annoying subset), one political party in particular, and social media/AI/the internet.
But it is important to keep in mind that if you go to a beautiful place, don't just think about the mosquitos. Extending the analogy, don't just think about mosquitos especially when there are people dying of malaria out there.
I think the loophole is “you don’t have to follow rules because enforcing them has friction”, which is not always true but is true often enough, eg some crimes don’t get investigated some rules don’t get enforced etc.
It’s not a great loophole per se but it’s a flawless example of what I might call “loophole thinking” which is kind of a transition from individualism to selfishness that has been happening for a long time (maybe there was never much of a difference)?
Conform: To be or act in accord with a set of standards, expectations, or specifications
Where do conformity and a shared set of behaviours split? Don't we conform to norms so that we can achieve maxima greater than the individual? Is it just the negative connotations of that word? What if we replace "conformity" with "consistency"?
Conformity stood once, or still stands by some, for conformity with puritanic christianity and a very rigid set of expectations how to live a life. (And where I was born, it meant conformity to socialism).
So yes, the word has a negative connotation to me. Bending yourself, to conform with something you do not want. I seldom heard it as "conform with basic human rights" for instance.
Interesting, I live in Sweden and here it seems they think conformity is a virtue, but conforming here means having liberal values, valuing equality, avoiding showing off or bragging too much, and so on.
Now that is interesting to me, I assumed Sweden had their share of nonconformist movement as well? In the alternative/punk sense I meant. But might be a rabbit hole chasing the differntiating meaning, originally it seems to have meant protestant christians
I might split “conformity” along lines of thoughtfulness.
The kind of conformity that’s unthinking or mindless can be at odds with empathy and generosity and virtue, sure. The “computer says no” school of blindly following the rules all the way to a perverse outcome.
In the same way, though, unthinking or mindless iconoclasm-for-its-own-sake tends to lead to perverse results. I know your modded motorcycle is very fun to blast loudly up and down the block all night, and also I know that the aggregate discomfort you’ve caused to all the people whose sleep you’re disturbing… will probably never weigh into your individualist calculus. The abstract unthinking-iconoclastic “you,” here, of course…
Whereas unselfishness can often lead people to considered conformity with mildly annoying expectations—like leaving the disabled parking spot free even if there’s no disabled person currently using it—to solve coordination problems cooperatively.
Not a virtue, more of a tactic—but social norms can provide an awfully low-cost, high-signal means of coordinating and operationalizing virtuous intentions, no?
So, coordination, fair enough. "Informed conformity", even. Still a risky business, because the pressure to conform without thinking can be subtle.
(There's a noisy motorbike that belongs to a house across the street, which is usually revving its motor in the middle of the day, when it sometimes disturbs my sleep. So my individualistic behavior is the problem there, maybe. Not sure what point I'm making ... agreement is complicated?)
True—and especially risky when well-meaning folks try to engineer or police conformity of thought or belief. Double especially when they’re trying to do so tactically, to avoid explaining why they think they’re right.
The counterpoint being, I think, that conformity can offer a decent default course to people when they’re new to any given nuanced or contentious social problem, or with limited vantage on the full consequences.
I don’t know, or want to know, why they don’t want a vehicle parked in this particular place between 7 and 11 AM on a Thursday. I could inquire further, and learn either that something legit happens then, or that it is in fact a pointless/outdated rule that I could reasonably ignore.
But if I don’t care—and I don’t—I can go with the default and be reasonably confident I’m not accidentally being an asshole.
(To the motorcycle situation—the motorcycle club I had in mind eventually negotiated an informal arrangement with the precinct and the agitators amongst the residents: the cops would leave them alone if they’d take it out to the nearby industrial district. The particular triumphed over conformity! The specific over the general! …Though the resulting peace is contingent on conformity with this new, particular agreement… which will no doubt look stupid to some new guard amongst the bikers, who will no doubt demand “respect” by bringing it back to the residential strip… and so the cycle will renew… or, put another way, the specifics will evolve, as they generally do!)
We have a whole system for aggreeing on this sort of confirmity, and enforcing it. It's called the law and the government, respectively. In this case, it's typically municipal/county bylaws and their governments that are responsible for enforcing them via noise bylaws (if you have them).
It's pretty common though, that there's a disconnect between the laws and the government, and the government does not actually enforce the laws evenly.
Extreme levels of conformity (or non-conformity) is pretty obnoxious. That said, conformity is the oil that makes a whole lot of society function.
For example, conforming to social norms around queueing at a store checkout prevents a lot of friction between yourself and other customers, and that allows cashiers to proceed smoothly
I dunno. I'd argue that some amount of conformity is absolutely a virtue. No one wants to deal with the assholes on transit who bring a wireless speaker to blast their music
Yeah I had fun once trying to wait in line in an Italian bakery :) everyone just screamed their way before my turn. But you learn pretty quickly how to do it yourself next time!
I think the prevalence of this not-even-a-loophole behavior increased during COVID and hasn't subsided. A lot of enforcement went down, and some people decided to act accordingly.
Quite similarly to the anecdote at start of link, there was a guy in my condo parking directly in front of the building for a while collecting tickets. Even if he got caught every time, the tickets are same prices as paying for a garage.. and he probably only got caught 1/4 of the time. Plus, parking directly at your front door is maximal convenience compared to some garage down the block.
Why doesn't everyone just do the same - well theres 200 residents and 1 front door. And the car illegally parked blocks the street sweepers, leaving the block you live on dirtier. Tragedy of the commons stuff.
Just one small infraction in a sea of bad behavior that accumulates & makes people feel like stupid chumps for actually following the laws. Very "this is how you get a low trust society" coded.
Perhaps think of process loopholes, in the same sort of way attackers look at security systems.
For example, if you park badly, civil parking enforcement officers patrol the streets.
...but if you park directly on a _pedestrian crossing_, in some jurisdictions that's now a criminal offence, so only the police can prosecute it, not the civil parking enforcers. But the police have better things to do than enforce parking. So you raise the stakes significantly but you're also more likely to get away with it. Double or quits. It goes without saying that you're being an enormous arsehole.
The crux of the problem (aside from arseholes existing), is the inverse correlation - the worse an infraction is, the less it gets punished, because of the increased scrutiny and limits on who can prosecute as the severity of infraction increases.
I've heard "rough justice" used for this. For example, if someone pays the amount of income tax they owe, but they do it by mis-classifying certain items of income/expense on their return, or by paying it in the wrong year, they have violated the letter of the law, but not the spirit. However, if you look this phrase up online, it seems the emphasis is more on extra-legal punishment, rather than any kind of general result that is in the spirit of the law.
OK - we could keep it in the same analogy ballpark: driver behaviour in heavy traffic. A very small minority do legal but antisocial (and very dangerous) things to improve their experience marginally at the cost of the entire population. If everyone followed their lead we'd shift the same traffic problems to some other permutation, lose any consistency we currently get and have more accidents. ex: zooming up the exit lane and then bullying your way back into through traffic makes you an asshole.
A loophole can also be an improperly weighed incentive or disincentive. For example, parking in the handicap spot at the strip mall grocery store, when you don't need it, because it's closer, is just being a regular jerk, but parking in an unmetered handicap spot before the gate to a parking garage, when you don't need it, because the size of the fine multiplied by its probability is less then the paid parking price, is being a jerk that's exploiting a loophole.
Exploiting a loophole can be done for the greater good, when rules are harmful. For example, there's an organization that is exploiting a loophole in the execution of the first amendment, to work around a regulation that prohibits feeding homeless people.
I’m surprised it’s not mentioned in the article because the real loophole in parking in a no parking zone is utilizing the “park anywhere lights” aka hazards.
It's basically the definition of hacking: using something in a way it was not intended to be used.
This can apply to computers, but also laws.
However, when someone hacks our financial system (e.g. tax evasion by using loopholes), they somehow are often not held accountable, whereas if someone hacks into a computer system they are ...
Nitpick: finding loopholes in the tax law that would grudgingly survive an audit is tax avoidance. Tax evasion is breaking the law, and is one of the few white collar crimes that’ll reliably get you sent upriver.
The most profitable loophole in tax system in USA is called "buy-borrow-die" .. the result is that the that zillionaires owning stocks don't pay taxes whatsoever and not only that those that inherit it, don't pay taxes on it.
I don't get how "buy borrow die" is supposed to work. If you take out a loan secured by your stock or business holdings or whatever, you need to make payments on that loan. Those payments need to be paid with liquid assets, right? You can't get liquid assets without triggering some kind of taxable event: accruing W2 or 1099 income that gets income taxed, selling stock and paying either short or long term capital gains on the gains they've made, etc. Plus you're paying interest on the cash you freed up by taking out the loan. So you pay taxes on the money you free up to make the payment, plus you pay interest on the loan.
What am I missing? Do you make payments on the loan by transferring stocks in a way (that I've never heard of) that somehow does not trigger a taxable event? Is that the loophole?
They keep the stock and don't cash it so in effect they never pay taxes on the proceeds to use the proceeds though, they can borrow against it for spending and never cash it. Also when they borrow they can deduct the interest.
"" Current law favors those who finance consumption through borrowing rather than selling assets ""
I still don't understand it. Where do they get the money to cover the interest on the loans? None of the articles linked cover that. They just say they borrow against their assets and then the heirs are left with the bill.
They can use a portion of the loan money to pay the interest on the loan. But either way, paying taxes on the stock they'd have to sell in order to pay the interest is much cheaper than paying taxes on everything.
They don't pay the taxes on borrowed money while the actual investment if cashed would incur massive of taxes and with borrowing they can deduct the interest .. its not just stocks..it any type of investment. The debt is piled up year after year but after say 2/3/4 years not paying taxes; it all depends on the growth of asset, the gains the made surpasses the amount they borrowed.. what is net worth.. assets minus
debt.. The asset will grow much faster than the debt.
If the loan payments are interest-only, you can simply keep on borrowing more money to pay the interest, and thus continue to pay no income tax.
In the U.S., the reverse-mortgage for a homeowner is the common person's version of "buy borrow die". In fact, you can effectively implement your own reverse mortgage by using a HELOC (home equity line of credit), where you only have to make interest payments, which you can fund by simply borrowing more. This can go on for a long time if you have sufficient equity, assuming you can renew your HELOC after a typical five or ten year loan period.
> If the loan payments are interest-only, you can simply keep on borrowing more money to pay the interest, and thus continue to pay no income tax.
Now you have two loans you need to make payments on. When does your lender get their principal back? They get paid out of the estate when you die? So your estate pays long-term capital gains when they liquidate whatever you've got in order to pay back the lender. The tax isn't unpaid, just deferred until you die?
Edit: what I was missing was the step up in basis after you die. Your heirs inherit your assets at their current price, not at the price you paid for them. They can then pay back the balance on the loans by selling the assets without incurring any capital gains tax on those assets. So to close the loophole, you'd need to have the loan paid out of the estate before the heirs get their inheritance.
You are not missing anything. This is a conspiracy theory. It doesn't work. People don't do this, they just sell their stock and pay the taxes. The insider transactions filing of any publicly traded company proves this.
My local Trader Joe’s. The parking lot has three lanes. One of them is one-way only. That happens to be the lane in front of the store too, and where you enter the rest of the lot.
The parking lot exit is also one way, but there are three ways to get there (the one-way lane is not one of them).
In any moment of moderate (or more congestion) the one way lane gets snarled with traffic. In part because people are looking for the closest spaces - and willing to sit and wait for them.
Meanwhile the far corners and farthest away lane have space.
So - sometimes I take advantage of a loophole (I guess) and enter the parking lot through the exit, and take a spot in the farthest away lane. But I see that as more productive for everyone else too - I am not waiting for the first spot in front of store and causing a huge line of cars behind me.
Parking lot is not huge. Just congested. It doesn’t have to be. Call me an asshole I guess.
I think asshole begets asshole here, and the original sin is with the parking lot trolls who can't be bothered to park in the first available spot, even if it's, gasp, 300 feet away from the store entrance.
As long as you're not adding to the snarl, I don't see the issue.
I'm very selective about when I shop my neighborhood Trader Joes. Parking is a huge reason. And our lot is massive. Don't even get me started on Costco. Woof.
That seems to me more like an example of breaking the letter of the rule but keeping to the spirit (not adding to the congestion): an anti-loophole, if you like.
> Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law."
I prefer the simpler but equivalent silver rule: "dont do unto others what you dont want others to do unto you". Another guidepost attributed to Buffet would be: Act such that you would be ok if it were printed in the front page of a newspaper.
Simple counterexample to show how this overly simple rule immediately falls down when applied to even the smallest bit of critical thinking: what about gender reassignment surgery? I don't want people to do that to me (and I assume this is true for most surgeons who perform such procedures), yet others very much want it done to them.
Kant's formula isn't vulnerable to this particular criticism because a maxim isn't the individual action and universal laws aren't about you in particular. The more quotidian formulations of the "silver rule" point at the same thing but with language that leaves more of the work of figuring that out to the interpreter. This is an interpretive failure on your part.
I myself prefer Kant's formulas because I think it's clearer, and it strikes the ear with enough alienness that it signals that something technical and precise is meant, and that understanding it requires considering the wider meta-ethics in which the formulas figure.
But this is also a matter of genre. Aphorisms are... aphoristic. That means they tend to be laconic and ambiguous. Part of the interpretive competency here is recognizing the genre and then reading the saying accordingly.
You're right that this kind of non-transparency is a weakness of aphorisms and slogans, though.
Surely you can put your example in a more favorable interpretation: I wouldn't want a gender reassignment surgery categorically denied to me (whether I want it or not), so I also shouldn't deny it to others.
Another popular political example which projects onto people close to you: if you wouldn't be okay with your spouse being denied an abortion, you should not advocate against abortion rights for others. If you're biologically male, it obviously doesn't matter whether _you_ could get an abortion, but the spirit of the rule holds.
I might be misunderstanding your point but I don't think this is such a valid counterexample because it's misapplying the principal in an overly specific and incorrect way.
The universal wants in your example that would apply the principal are (1) access to healthcare providers (surgeons want access to a surgeon if/when they need an operation) and (2) bodily autonomy (I want to be able to choose whether or not I get such a surgery and have that choice be respected and applied).
The silver and golden rule both fail to capture the collective nature of the actions. There are many things where if one person does it, it really isn't that big a deal, but if everyone does it, it is. I don't care if you come by my house and pluck a twig off of a branch I happen to own. I won't even notice. But if a lot of people do that it becomes a problem. So you shouldn't pluck twigs off of a tree in a shared park even though it isn't that big a deal.
I tend to agree with the later philosophy that says Kant's idea is not a good foundation for philosophy itself, but as a social norm it is a useful one that captures something beyond the naive application of the golden or silver rules. If you want to abstract up above that naive application to the proposition that the golden or silver rules when understood more deeply encompasses this idea I wouldn't fight you, but I do think it is indeed an additional step and something that should be called out as an implication that is not immediately obvious to everyone.
I heard a Platinum Rule: Do unto others as they would have you do unto them.
I often get myself into all sorts of trouble for treating others the way I wish they would treat me!
On a related note I have autism. There's some interesting research finding that autistic people tend to get along just fine with each other, it's really the "cultural divide" between autistic and non-autistic where the problems come from.
So the Golden Rule and the Platinum Rule become one if you are surrounded with people who are like you, and both prefer to be treated the same way.
(See also: male-female relations, multiculturalism, etc.)
Lots of cultures around the globe live by exploring loopholes on their legal system and society rules.
Maybe they are all assholes, or trying to make their best even when rules don't make sense, created by those that never experience their flaws in first place, with their nice political jobs.
I think there could be some polite nudging in America, but people are genuinely afraid of having guns drawn on them for telling someone, for example, to stop littering.
You live in an insane place if that is your day to day reality. I will assume you've experienced more than reading "news articles" that "inform" you about how dangerous litter policing is these days. Move to the midwest where people are genuinely nice. Everyone still have guns though.
This is genuinely not true, the only people who think this are the top 1% deranged on bluesky, and they likely post hyperbole like this without actually believing it
That is the rub. I think we have too little social shaming in America, and it enables all kinds of bad behavior. But it's not hard to notice the failure modes of social shaming in Japan, either. I'm not sure how one could thread the needle between the two bad outcomes.
This recalls a recent experience. When I pick up groceries from Walmart, they always instruct me to park right in front of the main doors, instead of in the dedicated pickup spots. The dirty looks and judgemental stares I get for doing as i was instructed is wild. I believe that the vehicle I drive is contributing to the judgment, as I've added racing stripes to it.
>Consider what would happen if everyone subscribed to that worldview
And why exactly a fictional hypothetical scenario should affect my behaviour? I've never read Kant but all the pop philosophy articles I've seen basically treat it like something obvious or a religious dogma.
Using loopholes don't make you an asshole, abusing loopholes makes you an asshole. Loopholes aren't special though, abusing anything (people's kindness, honour systems, safety nets, etc) makes you an asshole.
Use and abuse are subjective enough to be entirely indistinguishable depending on your life philosophy. Which brings us directly to TFA’s point, that if you find yourself justifying your (ab)use of a loophole, you may be an asshole.
That's exactly the feeling I got from "The 4-Hour Workweek" by Tim Ferriss: use others to allow you to work way less. The book wasn't about helping everyone, only about helping some people take advantage by hiring personal assistant in cheaper countries. (Maybe I misremember the rest of the book, but this part stuck with me.)
I've always liked Bertrand Russell's comment on Kant in History of Western Philosophy:
"Hume, with his criticism of the concept of causality, awakened him from his dogmatic slumbers--so at least he says, but the awakening was only temporary, and he soon invented a soporific which enabled him to sleep again."
> You can park wherever you want. You can park right in front of the door of the store on sidewalk and walk right in. No one will do anything about it!
OP assesses that loopholes are for assholes. Then he poo-poos the assholes but assholes are just poopholes. Loopholes are for lassoos, see, and lassoos are a hassle for poop-holes so they just hoop it.
The example is horrible. We cannot all park in front of the Walmart because there's a limited number of parking slots. If you find a car parked illegally, spend 5 minutes on a call to have it towed. That is what assholes do.
The issue is less the presence of exceptions than the tendency of those exceptions to become the rule.
Therefore I would adjust TFA to point toward open loop systems, i.e. those lacking some feedback loop to keep the exceptions exceptional, as the bugaboo.
A coworker, some 10 years ago at non-current company: "You need an asshole to flush the shit down" - I felt really bad, and left a year later. It deeply affected me. Not sure why. Purely illogical, but left a scar. Does not make sense, but hit me hard. It's so vague, and diabolical, and takes on so many meanings depending on the context, state of mind, etc., etc. Anyway... I still remember this bit, and that's what's troubling...
turtleyacht | 4 hours ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons
komali2 | 3 hours ago
The Tragedy's original formulation is based on a false premise of land that was not Common but in fact had an owner who managed it. Overgrazing was due to mismanagement.
Meanwhile, land actually owned in Common has historically been managed very well, through informal techniques of social consequences for overuse.
The "Tragedy of the Commons" is usually used as a justification for more rigid management when the initial example is a false premise that indicated the opposite conclusion should be made.
Anyway this original article could probably just have been a Wikipedia link, but the question is right there: why should something be wrong simply because it's bad if everyone does it?
When we pull it apart we realize we actually had been doing the argument's work for it and engaging in a very normal debate about right vs wrong for individual actions. Example: what if everyone became teachers? Well there'd be no plumbers! No no of course we didn't mean the formulation to cover those kinds of things, we meant, like, bad stuff, like parking in front of stores! If everyone did that it would be bad, so nobody should do it. Well except for pregnant people or disabled people or old people... And so on.
dspillett | 2 hours ago
verdverm | 3 hours ago
debo_ | 2 hours ago
Toynbeeidea | 2 hours ago
Liuser | 2 hours ago
bigstrat2003 | an hour ago
dfxm12 | 3 hours ago
That is, of course a false dichotomy, but the guy parks there in the first place because maybe his teachers & classmates let him get away with bullying the new kid, maybe he shoplifts a pack of gum and no one tells him this is wrong, maybe he blows through a stop sign and realizes there's certainly no punishment if you don't get caught. This is why there's a famous saying, "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
rexpop | 3 hours ago
We don't need "cops everywhere", we just need the courage and social capital to stand up for ourselves.
Isn't that what your famous saying implies?
Here's another: "liberty is the mother, not the daughter, of order".
soperj | 3 hours ago
You live in a world with both already. The cops just aren't hassling you specifically.
happyopossum | 3 hours ago
pzxc | 2 hours ago
If the only consequence for parking like an asshole is that MAYBE somebody yells at you for a minute, they don't care.
If the consequence for parking like an asshole is that somebody slashes your tires and now you have to pay for new tires (and take the time to do it), suddenly they will care about THOSE consequences.
In other words, they only don't care about consequences when the consequences are so minor there might as well be no consequences at all
Even a wealthy person cares when the cost is time
kstrauser | 2 hours ago
I’m certain he thought I was an asshole. I’m certain I thought he was pedantically enforcing the letter of a rule that the spirit didn’t require. My loophole helped me while not hurting or disturbing anyone else in any way, except for the guard’s annoyance. And 2 minutes later, my wife came out and we went back home where the in-laws anxiously awaited our return.
blini-kot | 3 hours ago
happyopossum | 2 hours ago
That's clearly not what was done here - there is a specific example of behavior, and a perfectly reasonable way to examine that behavior was pointed out.
This world would get along a lot better if we avoided knee-jerk reactions to rational discussion based solely on what philosophy/philosopher is referenced. Frankly, if you can't find a kernel of truth and wisdom in most philosophies, it's on you, not the philosopher - baby, bathwater, etc...
gustavus | 2 hours ago
Why do you feel it is inadequate or inappropriate, as it seems to produce the correct answer in a broad variety of cases.
hypfer | 3 hours ago
Generally, probably good advice, but where it breaks down is that sometimes, what is sensible on the micro scale isn't on the macro scale.
Effective Altruism got the wrong idea there and pushed that way too far, but Kant alone doesn't work either in the real world.
It is however a good default to fall back on.
srean | 3 hours ago
A torus ?
fwlr | 3 hours ago
legacynl | 3 hours ago
qurren | 3 hours ago
When political and corporate leaders are doing things that make life hard for me -- taxing me too much, starting wars with that money that I don't want, wrecking the job market, not fixing basic infrastructure around me, doing things that make daily life more expensive -- I'll find more legal ways to amass more resources. Churning credit cards for massive sign-up bonuses, tax loopholes, free shit, quant trading to harvest more than my "fair share" of investment returns, etc.
When leaders are doing things right, I have little incentive to do these things.
kstrauser | 3 hours ago
Basically, it’s not so much ignoring the rules as accepting that the rules have been rewritten.
murphy1312 | 2 hours ago
The right solution is to elect different politicians or to enter politics yourself—not to cheat society.
lucaspm98 | 2 hours ago
For better or worse we have to live in society as it currently functions.
SpicyLemonZest | 2 hours ago
bloomingeek | 3 hours ago
I'm betting most don't think they're assholes, even if they cause a wreck. Nobodies perfect, but practicing decency is a virtue.
JumpCrisscross | 3 hours ago
alias_neo | 3 hours ago
Do arseholes _know_ they're arseholes, generally speaking?
Because everyone on that list, bar none is an arse-hole, by my reckoning, and I often see some of these people and think to myself, "do you _know_ you're an utter shit stain, and _choose_ to be that way"?
JumpCrisscross | 3 hours ago
Loopholes are social slack. You can speed to the hospital, usually, in an emergency. If you’re running late to pick up your kid, sure, double park or streetside with hazards.
But if you turn this into a lifestyle, you’re broken. (Every person tweeting with religious zeal for Jensen falls into that camp.)
jcranmer | 2 hours ago
cucumber3732842 | 2 hours ago
Generations of useful idiots screeching about low compliance and demand enforcement of rules or systems never meant for it at scale rather than examine what the desired outcome ought to be is a special sort of slow moving "just barely not bad enough to trigger pushback by everyone else" naive evil that underpins a lot of the misery and discontent in the west today IMO
derektank | 2 hours ago
bluGill | an hour ago
I don't want to downplay the abuse, but the alternative is worse.
derektank | an hour ago
I agree this is something our system needs to be flexible enough to accommodate. This should be adjudicated by the courts though, not law enforcement.
bluGill | an hour ago
mlsu | an hour ago
CSSer | 2 hours ago
bluGill | 2 hours ago
A murder who gets off because a police officer had the wrong warrant when doing an investigation is an intentional loophole. I don't want murders to get off, but I also want police officers to get the wrong warrant and abuse the rights of law abiding people. (there has been a lot of effort to close this loop hole in various ways over the years)
zoeysmithe | 2 hours ago
Obviously, emergencies are the exception, but almost none of these behaviors are emergencies. Its just putting inconvenience on a random 3rd party so you can have convenience at their expense. I don't think we fully appreciate how so many systems in our lives are zero-sum and that if we excuse cheaters, then we are lowering the quality of our own lives. Then honest people feel the "sucker's payoff" and start cheating too and now we push the Nash equilibrium towards nearly everyone cheating, and now you have an entirely broken system.
nadis | 2 hours ago
I was trying to find a good example of a loophole and found this which was bizarre but sort of meets my imagined criteria:
"The Pudding Frequent Flyer Loophole: In the late 1990s, Healthy Choice ran a promotion giving away frequent flyer miles for buying their food products. A civil engineer named David Phillips realized that buying thousands of individual cups of pudding was the cheapest way to accumulate over 1.25 million airline miles, which he used for free travel while donating the pudding to charity for a tax write-off."
So a loophole is legal but not really "normal" behavior like the pudding example, while the speeding to the hospital example is rulebreaking (illegal) technically but is more accepted as "normal" due to the circumstances.
sznio | 2 hours ago
do it once or twice and you'll start doing it forever
stasomatic | 2 hours ago
pzxc | 2 hours ago
consensus1 | an hour ago
whimblepop | an hour ago
AnimalMuppet | 2 hours ago
stasomatic | 2 hours ago
Another one - in the US I see many cars with disabled blue tags hanging from the rear view mirror. These are rather easily aqcured for minor disabilities. A normal person without any kind of limp will park in a spot for disabled right in front of the store.
gosub100 | 2 hours ago
Not limping is not a signal of health, however. They could have back pain or breathing issues or heart problems.
skeeter2020 | an hour ago
These are not as easy to get in Canada, apparently. They require pretty regular review by a doctor and renewal.
JumpCrisscross | an hour ago
breakwaterlabs | 2 hours ago
I am having trouble drawing a line between "dealing with an issue of life / safety" and "I screwed up and want to shift the consequences onto society as a whole".
jimmydddd | 2 hours ago
bethekidyouwant | an hour ago
CPLX | an hour ago
Many such cases. It's been very well documented.
bethekidyouwant | an hour ago
dersch | 3 hours ago
Maybe we SHOULD park in front of the doors at Walmart, if the alternative is walking 10 miles to the nearest parking place.
waltbosz | 3 hours ago
praxulus | 2 hours ago
The norm has to be that everyone follows the rules, and goes through established processes to get the stupid rules fixed.
dofm | 2 hours ago
Yeah man. Who the fuck put Chesterton's Fence there anyway?
vrganj | 3 hours ago
yipinwong | 2 hours ago
They ruin it by utilizing loopholes.
kg | 2 hours ago
Culture can valorize people who exploit loopholes and by doing so encourage others to follow after those role models and do the same things.
vehemenz | 2 hours ago
dfxm12 | 2 hours ago
whimblepop | 2 hours ago
loloquwowndueo | 2 hours ago
steveBK123 | an hour ago
People were illegally parking but because they had a city agency issued placard on their dashboard, it was a get out of jail free card.
Similar loophole was states like NJ having a temporary tag issuance fraud issue, such that people were driving around NYC with paper tags from out of state continuously.
intrasight | 2 hours ago
cucumber3732842 | 2 hours ago
And hopefully that will keep those people nice and busy because they're a pox upon any subject they direct their attention at.
hansvm | 2 hours ago
consensus1 | an hour ago
__MatrixMan__ | 2 hours ago
kstrauser | 2 hours ago
datsci_est_2015 | 2 hours ago
nobody9999 | an hour ago
Exactly. Stealing a driver's car, cash and belongings on the Interstate is, in fact, legal for police to do via "Civil Forfeiture"[0], but such laws were never intended to be used in that way. That's a loophole.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United...
pzxc | 2 hours ago
I asked the manager, do you need me to call the fire department for you? He said "you can make a call if you want, but we don't know who it is. I told the receipt checker to let me know when they come out so I can talk to them."
I called the fire department, they said they don't dispatch for this and to call the police. I called the police, they said since Costco parking lot is private property they won't come out unless it's a handicapped violation. I said even though they're blocking the fire lane? They said yes, the proper thing would be for Costco to call a tow truck and it would be at the owner's expense.
So I guess the guy was right, rules are only for those who have shame, if you're shameless you get special privileges like parking in the fire lane because you're huge truck is hard to find a parking spot for, and there's no consequences.
I've also seen on a near weekly basis now people bringing a dog that is clearly not a service animal (from its behavior) into the grocery store.
I'm reminded of George Costanza saying "We live in a SOCIETY!" or the entire Curb Your Enthusiasm show.
What to do? Accept the fact that terrible people get special privileges now that normal people don't, and just live with it? Become a bad person myself so I get the privileges? I can't decide, but I really don't like this timeline we're in. For some reason, very very ugly people have decided they don't have to be ashamed about their terrible behavior anymore. And I guess it's too much trouble for Costco OR THE POLICE to even do anything about. I know there are terrible people everywhere but the lack of consideration for others here in the USA is really reaching new heights all the time. It sucks.
Anyone got any suggestions? I don't want to become a bad person myself, but these events are starting to happen so often I feel like a sucker for not taking advantage. :(
mlsu | an hour ago
For me, I think of them like mosquitos. Even in beautiful places that are otherwise divine, you occasionally have to deal with an annoying mosquito. For me, the big annoying mosquitos are private equity, cars in general (with hugeass trucks being a particularly annoying subset), one political party in particular, and social media/AI/the internet.
But it is important to keep in mind that if you go to a beautiful place, don't just think about the mosquitos. Extending the analogy, don't just think about mosquitos especially when there are people dying of malaria out there.
nsoam | 2 hours ago
f17428d27584 | 2 hours ago
It’s not a great loophole per se but it’s a flawless example of what I might call “loophole thinking” which is kind of a transition from individualism to selfishness that has been happening for a long time (maybe there was never much of a difference)?
card_zero | 2 hours ago
skeeter2020 | 2 hours ago
Where do conformity and a shared set of behaviours split? Don't we conform to norms so that we can achieve maxima greater than the individual? Is it just the negative connotations of that word? What if we replace "conformity" with "consistency"?
lukan | an hour ago
So yes, the word has a negative connotation to me. Bending yourself, to conform with something you do not want. I seldom heard it as "conform with basic human rights" for instance.
brabel | an hour ago
lukan | an hour ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nonconformist_(Protestantism)
alwa | an hour ago
The kind of conformity that’s unthinking or mindless can be at odds with empathy and generosity and virtue, sure. The “computer says no” school of blindly following the rules all the way to a perverse outcome.
In the same way, though, unthinking or mindless iconoclasm-for-its-own-sake tends to lead to perverse results. I know your modded motorcycle is very fun to blast loudly up and down the block all night, and also I know that the aggregate discomfort you’ve caused to all the people whose sleep you’re disturbing… will probably never weigh into your individualist calculus. The abstract unthinking-iconoclastic “you,” here, of course…
Whereas unselfishness can often lead people to considered conformity with mildly annoying expectations—like leaving the disabled parking spot free even if there’s no disabled person currently using it—to solve coordination problems cooperatively.
Not a virtue, more of a tactic—but social norms can provide an awfully low-cost, high-signal means of coordinating and operationalizing virtuous intentions, no?
card_zero | an hour ago
(There's a noisy motorbike that belongs to a house across the street, which is usually revving its motor in the middle of the day, when it sometimes disturbs my sleep. So my individualistic behavior is the problem there, maybe. Not sure what point I'm making ... agreement is complicated?)
alwa | an hour ago
The counterpoint being, I think, that conformity can offer a decent default course to people when they’re new to any given nuanced or contentious social problem, or with limited vantage on the full consequences.
I don’t know, or want to know, why they don’t want a vehicle parked in this particular place between 7 and 11 AM on a Thursday. I could inquire further, and learn either that something legit happens then, or that it is in fact a pointless/outdated rule that I could reasonably ignore.
But if I don’t care—and I don’t—I can go with the default and be reasonably confident I’m not accidentally being an asshole.
(To the motorcycle situation—the motorcycle club I had in mind eventually negotiated an informal arrangement with the precinct and the agitators amongst the residents: the cops would leave them alone if they’d take it out to the nearby industrial district. The particular triumphed over conformity! The specific over the general! …Though the resulting peace is contingent on conformity with this new, particular agreement… which will no doubt look stupid to some new guard amongst the bikers, who will no doubt demand “respect” by bringing it back to the residential strip… and so the cycle will renew… or, put another way, the specifics will evolve, as they generally do!)
frenchy | an hour ago
It's pretty common though, that there's a disconnect between the laws and the government, and the government does not actually enforce the laws evenly.
bluefirebrand | an hour ago
Extreme levels of conformity (or non-conformity) is pretty obnoxious. That said, conformity is the oil that makes a whole lot of society function.
For example, conforming to social norms around queueing at a store checkout prevents a lot of friction between yourself and other customers, and that allows cashiers to proceed smoothly
I dunno. I'd argue that some amount of conformity is absolutely a virtue. No one wants to deal with the assholes on transit who bring a wireless speaker to blast their music
brabel | an hour ago
steveBK123 | an hour ago
Quite similarly to the anecdote at start of link, there was a guy in my condo parking directly in front of the building for a while collecting tickets. Even if he got caught every time, the tickets are same prices as paying for a garage.. and he probably only got caught 1/4 of the time. Plus, parking directly at your front door is maximal convenience compared to some garage down the block.
Why doesn't everyone just do the same - well theres 200 residents and 1 front door. And the car illegally parked blocks the street sweepers, leaving the block you live on dirtier. Tragedy of the commons stuff.
Just one small infraction in a sea of bad behavior that accumulates & makes people feel like stupid chumps for actually following the laws. Very "this is how you get a low trust society" coded.
amiga386 | an hour ago
For example, if you park badly, civil parking enforcement officers patrol the streets.
...but if you park directly on a _pedestrian crossing_, in some jurisdictions that's now a criminal offence, so only the police can prosecute it, not the civil parking enforcers. But the police have better things to do than enforce parking. So you raise the stakes significantly but you're also more likely to get away with it. Double or quits. It goes without saying that you're being an enormous arsehole.
The crux of the problem (aside from arseholes existing), is the inverse correlation - the worse an infraction is, the less it gets punished, because of the increased scrutiny and limits on who can prosecute as the severity of infraction increases.
mungoman2 | 2 hours ago
cucumber3732842 | 2 hours ago
__MatrixMan__ | 2 hours ago
I've heard "fudged the numbers" for when it's not a big deal (as opposed to "cooked the books" for when it is). But that's only for financial matters.
JambalayaJimbo | 2 hours ago
plasticchris | 2 hours ago
https://norselandsrock.com/john-fogerty-vs-john-fogerty/
PopAlongKid | 2 hours ago
skeeter2020 | an hour ago
RobotToaster | an hour ago
amiga386 | an hour ago
sgarrity | 2 hours ago
skeeter2020 | an hour ago
dlcarrier | 50 minutes ago
Exploiting a loophole can be done for the greater good, when rules are harmful. For example, there's an organization that is exploiting a loophole in the execution of the first amendment, to work around a regulation that prohibits feeding homeless people.
dieselgate | 32 minutes ago
amelius | 2 hours ago
This can apply to computers, but also laws.
However, when someone hacks our financial system (e.g. tax evasion by using loopholes), they somehow are often not held accountable, whereas if someone hacks into a computer system they are ...
alansaber | 2 hours ago
kstrauser | 2 hours ago
silverFork | 2 hours ago
1-more | 2 hours ago
What am I missing? Do you make payments on the loan by transferring stocks in a way (that I've never heard of) that somehow does not trigger a taxable event? Is that the loophole?
silverFork | 2 hours ago
"" Current law favors those who finance consumption through borrowing rather than selling assets ""
https://budgetlab.yale.edu/research/buy-borrow-die-options-r...
https://smartasset.com/investing/buy-borrow-die-how-the-rich...
agosz | an hour ago
claudiulodro | an hour ago
silverFork | an hour ago
islandfox100 | an hour ago
paying the interest on a loan involves significantly less liquid money than the principle on the loan.
PopAlongKid | an hour ago
In the U.S., the reverse-mortgage for a homeowner is the common person's version of "buy borrow die". In fact, you can effectively implement your own reverse mortgage by using a HELOC (home equity line of credit), where you only have to make interest payments, which you can fund by simply borrowing more. This can go on for a long time if you have sufficient equity, assuming you can renew your HELOC after a typical five or ten year loan period.
1-more | an hour ago
Now you have two loans you need to make payments on. When does your lender get their principal back? They get paid out of the estate when you die? So your estate pays long-term capital gains when they liquidate whatever you've got in order to pay back the lender. The tax isn't unpaid, just deferred until you die?
Edit: what I was missing was the step up in basis after you die. Your heirs inherit your assets at their current price, not at the price you paid for them. They can then pay back the balance on the loans by selling the assets without incurring any capital gains tax on those assets. So to close the loophole, you'd need to have the loan paid out of the estate before the heirs get their inheritance.
silverFork | an hour ago
consensus1 | 18 minutes ago
grvdrm | 2 hours ago
My local Trader Joe’s. The parking lot has three lanes. One of them is one-way only. That happens to be the lane in front of the store too, and where you enter the rest of the lot.
The parking lot exit is also one way, but there are three ways to get there (the one-way lane is not one of them).
In any moment of moderate (or more congestion) the one way lane gets snarled with traffic. In part because people are looking for the closest spaces - and willing to sit and wait for them.
Meanwhile the far corners and farthest away lane have space.
So - sometimes I take advantage of a loophole (I guess) and enter the parking lot through the exit, and take a spot in the farthest away lane. But I see that as more productive for everyone else too - I am not waiting for the first spot in front of store and causing a huge line of cars behind me.
Parking lot is not huge. Just congested. It doesn’t have to be. Call me an asshole I guess.
luckydata | 2 hours ago
schmookeeg | 2 hours ago
As long as you're not adding to the snarl, I don't see the issue.
I'm very selective about when I shop my neighborhood Trader Joes. Parking is a huge reason. And our lot is massive. Don't even get me started on Costco. Woof.
mikestew | 2 hours ago
grvdrm | an hour ago
Anthony-G | an hour ago
bwfan123 | 2 hours ago
I prefer the simpler but equivalent silver rule: "dont do unto others what you dont want others to do unto you". Another guidepost attributed to Buffet would be: Act such that you would be ok if it were printed in the front page of a newspaper.
WJW | 2 hours ago
whimblepop | 2 hours ago
thfuran | 2 hours ago
whimblepop | an hour ago
But this is also a matter of genre. Aphorisms are... aphoristic. That means they tend to be laconic and ambiguous. Part of the interpretive competency here is recognizing the genre and then reading the saying accordingly.
You're right that this kind of non-transparency is a weakness of aphorisms and slogans, though.
Felk | 2 hours ago
Another popular political example which projects onto people close to you: if you wouldn't be okay with your spouse being denied an abortion, you should not advocate against abortion rights for others. If you're biologically male, it obviously doesn't matter whether _you_ could get an abortion, but the spirit of the rule holds.
t_e_s | 2 hours ago
The rule is just "do medical stuff to people if they want it"
WJW | an hour ago
nadis | 2 hours ago
The universal wants in your example that would apply the principal are (1) access to healthcare providers (surgeons want access to a surgeon if/when they need an operation) and (2) bodily autonomy (I want to be able to choose whether or not I get such a surgery and have that choice be respected and applied).
jerf | 2 hours ago
I tend to agree with the later philosophy that says Kant's idea is not a good foundation for philosophy itself, but as a social norm it is a useful one that captures something beyond the naive application of the golden or silver rules. If you want to abstract up above that naive application to the proposition that the golden or silver rules when understood more deeply encompasses this idea I wouldn't fight you, but I do think it is indeed an additional step and something that should be called out as an implication that is not immediately obvious to everyone.
andai | 2 hours ago
I often get myself into all sorts of trouble for treating others the way I wish they would treat me!
On a related note I have autism. There's some interesting research finding that autistic people tend to get along just fine with each other, it's really the "cultural divide" between autistic and non-autistic where the problems come from.
So the Golden Rule and the Platinum Rule become one if you are surrounded with people who are like you, and both prefer to be treated the same way.
(See also: male-female relations, multiculturalism, etc.)
pjmlp | 2 hours ago
Maybe they are all assholes, or trying to make their best even when rules don't make sense, created by those that never experience their flaws in first place, with their nice political jobs.
fantasizr | 2 hours ago
"The average Japanese fears not the judgment of an omniscient God, but the judgment of his or her fellow Japanese."
thfuran | 2 hours ago
fantasizr | 2 hours ago
pluralmonad | an hour ago
93po | 9 minutes ago
bigstrat2003 | 2 hours ago
nancyminusone | 2 hours ago
Liuser | 2 hours ago
Caveat that this is for stores that don’t incentivize with getting your coin returned.
frenchy | 57 minutes ago
winkeltripel | 2 hours ago
scosman | 2 hours ago
andai | 2 hours ago
Well, they could be, that's the best part. I get that a lot, too: "You mean I could have just been doing things this whole time?"
Man rages at the open door more than the closed one.
andai | 2 hours ago
https://xkcd.com/958/
neuroticnews25 | 2 hours ago
And why exactly a fictional hypothetical scenario should affect my behaviour? I've never read Kant but all the pop philosophy articles I've seen basically treat it like something obvious or a religious dogma.
InsidiousWombat | 2 hours ago
The author thinks he is way more clever than he or his pet is
sligbad | 2 hours ago
bob1029 | 2 hours ago
cucumber3732842 | 2 hours ago
yieldcrv | 2 hours ago
Timpanzee | 2 hours ago
datsci_est_2015 | 2 hours ago
Centigonal | 2 hours ago
atleastoptimal | 2 hours ago
cranium | 2 hours ago
hippycruncher22 | 2 hours ago
mannyv | 2 hours ago
"Everyone shouldn't enforce the law, so nobody should enforce the law."
pdonis | 2 hours ago
"Hume, with his criticism of the concept of causality, awakened him from his dogmatic slumbers--so at least he says, but the awakening was only temporary, and he soon invented a soporific which enabled him to sleep again."
setnone | 2 hours ago
sgarrity | 2 hours ago
My biggest take-away: I misused the term 'loophole'. True - but remember, it kind of rhymes with 'asshole'.
profsummergig | 2 hours ago
You can?
c8d3f7b49897918 | an hour ago
Unfortunately, we castrate and bid the gelding be fruitful.
Fricken | an hour ago
1970-01-01 | an hour ago
bethekidyouwant | an hour ago
LogicFailsMe | an hour ago
pluralmonad | an hour ago
Also, loopholes are generally escape hatches in systems that cannot be perfectly spec'd for all its practical needs.
recursivedoubts | an hour ago
Unfortunately, we castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.
random3 | an hour ago
“What if everybody did that?” - by Ellen Javernick
https://www.prindleinstitute.org/books/what-if-everybody-did...
I think the topic is great for 4-7yo and honestly wondering how it became a topic for grownup philosophy students and then top of HN.
smitty1e | an hour ago
Therefore I would adjust TFA to point toward open loop systems, i.e. those lacking some feedback loop to keep the exceptions exceptional, as the bugaboo.
malkia | an hour ago