Libreagi – Save OSS Models

122 points by satuke 9 hours ago on hackernews | 24 comments

InsideOutSanta | 9 hours ago

I don't understand why this is set up the way it is. Maintaining a BitTorrent tracker for models seems like a reasonably good idea, but you have to "apply to join" to be able to contribute?

To what end?

simonmales | 9 hours ago

Accountability?

InsideOutSanta | 9 hours ago

You mean for people trying to poison the swarm? Or what? I'm genuinely confused.

[OP] satuke | 9 hours ago

people not maintaining 1:1 ratio, read about private trackers

InsideOutSanta | 8 hours ago

The content will be mostly obsolete LLM models. I don't see the incentive to download them in large quantities.

captn3m0 | 8 hours ago

Just do it like how libgen does. Maybe publish a RSS torrent feed people can subscribe to for the newer publications - knowing someone is curating the feed.

Weird to have open licensed stuff on private tracker.

phantompeace | 8 hours ago

I can definitely picture a piece of content that's been scrubbed from everywhere except old copies of LLMs in which it still exists in a lossy form, with people trying to extract it from those old copies with the help of newer models. Private trackers have thrived for decades and will continue to do so because they allow a community to foster around a shared purpose (pardon the pun).

Although that being said, i doubt i would go through the trouble of signing up just for this purpose, personally.

: InsideOutSanta | 7 hours ago
> I can definitely picture a piece of content that's been scrubbed from everywhere except old copies of LLMs in which it still exists in a lossy form
Yes. So it seems to me that the purpose of the project is to maintain a common good, but then I don't see how keeping it private achieves that.

tliltocatl | 5 hours ago

And what are you going to train the models on?

gorszon | 4 hours ago

Its standard for private trackers, you don't want a malware infested hell like piratebay, plus generally you would want people to seed back what they downloaded at least.

InsideOutSanta | an hour ago

> generally you would want people to seed back what they downloaded at least

But the goal is preservation rather than sharing.

I'm confused about how the economics of that would work. If I wanted to contribute to this, I'd have to download the models, so I'd immediately be in the red, and then I could never get out of it because who's going to download these obsolete models? There's no download demand for them; if they were, the whole project would not be necessary.

: torben-friis | an hour ago
>then I could never get out of it because who's going to download these obsolete models?
Private trackers usually overcome this issue by also rewarding the length of time you share, even if no one downloaded. Either you get a ratio of 1 or share for a full week/whatever length they decide is enough.
The ai description of this specific site seems to imply they do it as well.

jcelerier | 8 hours ago

Why the restriction to safetensors and GGUF? onnx is the more common format and specifically made for interchange.

: wtallis | 2 hours ago
Does anybody use ONNX for LLMs? I've only encountered it for small models packaged to run on consumer devices, and never seen it show up in any workstation or datacenter scenario.

cat_screamer | 8 hours ago

I love this, but why do I have to login tho? Would love to seed if you remove login

: [OP] satuke | 8 hours ago
it's a private tracker

modimihir | 8 hours ago

I see the merit in keeping a decentralized archive for open models. But there has to be a better way to do it vs keeping it behind auth and an application form.

: [OP] satuke | 8 hours ago
it's light, not like usual trackers, it's only to make sure people seed 1:1 and to reduce load on a couple of people seeding large models to everyone. the only way to do that is to enforce it, and for that you need a place where you can possibly enforce it without making it platform run, so, that's why you have this.

Onavo | 6 hours ago

Support piratebay. The powers that be wants to take away your second amendment.

https://pirateface.co/audnai/penclaw-GLM-5.3-abliterated

rgbrgb | 6 hours ago

oink/waffles.fm [0] for models. very cool

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oink%27s_Pink_Palace

: nathancahill | 4 hours ago
RIP waffles and red.

randomblock1 | 4 hours ago

What is the difference between this and https://pirateface.co/ ? Private tracker, and a focus on old models?

: gorszon | 4 hours ago
There doesn't need to be a difference, as with other torrent trackers, there are many of them, and I think thats good if nothing else, for redundancy.

zymhan | 42 minutes ago

Huge miss not to call it Liberagi