Purism Launches Librem 5 v2, a RISC-V Phone to Empower People

100 points by gnufx a day ago on hackernews | 112 comments

Iolaum | 23 hours ago

Launches is very generous word here, IRC this is intended - If things go according to plan - to get delivered in mid 2028.

Phoronix announcement has much less bullshit and actual useful details

https://www.phoronix.com/news/Librem-5-v2-Announced

Lame specs, flagship price while not being available yet...

For $1,599 you can have Motorola Signature 27, specs (and security) are better by orders of magnitude and the phone will also support GrapheneOS.

dmitrygr | 23 hours ago

Small batch production of niche hardware will never match the prices brought to you by economies of scale. But that was never expected by anyone sane. This is yet another test of "there is demand for an open phone, I just FEEL it". We shall see how it plays out, but i wish them luck. I suspect they will need it.

bigfishrunning | 21 hours ago

I think there is demand for an open phone, and people would be happy to spend a few hundred dollars and have a marginally worse experience for that openness.

This, however, is about a $1000 premium for a much worse experience (slow processor, bad camera, etc...). it just doesn't pass cost/benefit.

Using that deal as a barometer for "nobody wants an open phone" is kind of sad, but that's what'll happen.

dmitrygr | 20 hours ago

> a few hundred dollars

Unless you have ~1e6 purchasers, a few hundred dollars buys you ... well, more or less nothing in terms of a custom phone. plastic molds are a large up front fixed costs. so are displays. many Si vendors won't even talk to you without a large purchase of parts. Factory lines are the same. Getting five boards made is simple at JLC, but getting a few tens of thousands means a line, and that line costs more or less the same if you make 1e5 phones on it or 1e7. More or less, there is a cost O(1e8) dollars before the projects goes anywhere, so you can either spread that as 1e6 phones each costing $1e2 or 1e5 phones each costing $1e3. there is not really an option for few cheap phones. fixed costs kill you here

PS: please do not argue specific numbers,. numbers given for illustration and are +/- 1.5 orders of magnitude

An "open phone" doesn't need small batch production of niche hardware.. relevant hardware is already produced, we just need laws that unlock it so the existing hardware can be repurposed (officially). Of course given that even the existing antitrust (or even GPL!) laws are not enforced (unlike IP laws which unfortunately are), this is extremely unlikely to happen..

Hackbraten | 9 hours ago

Even though that might help with repurposing the hardware, the L5’s value proposition goes further than than that.

For example, Qualcomm’s Snapdragon SoCs run their own proprietary code in EL3 (aka Secure Monitor). Even though the chip lets you install and run Linux on the CPU, their proprietary firmware keeps running on the same CPU cores too, and there’s nothing you or Linux can do about it, and EL3 code always wins against EL0/EL1. It interrupts your Linux anytime it feels like, sees all your data, and send it to whomever it wants.

Even if their proprietary code happens to be benign, it may have a bug that causes the CPU to silently corrupt your data, or reboot your phone every minute, and there’s absolutely nothing you’d be able to do to fix that.

What Purism promises you is that they design your phone so that it is largely free of those issues. Except for WiFi and mobile baseband, which can’t possibly work without proprietary code.

If none of these things matter to you, then fine, go with mainstream hardware. But you simply can’t use a mainstream SoC to build an open phone just yet.

I wasn't just talking about the standard "unlock the bootloader" scenario, I know that this doesn't let you control EL3 (and even EL2 on qualcomm? since we don't have unprotected kvm before elite gen 6).

That's why I said we need laws to ensure hardware can be repurposed - laws that would guarantee that the hardware can be "unfused" so we could flash those partitions we don't currently control. The proprietary code would help, but is not necessary, we'd just need laws which permit reverse engineering for repurposing the hardware.

My point was that none of this requires designing new hardware, it's just the software (and fusing). We don't have unlimited resources so such laws (the unfusing part might be challenging) would help reduce ewaste..

GalaxyNova | 23 hours ago

I love this kind of stuff, but it's hardly practical as an actual phone you have to use for serious stuff like banking, proprietary 2FA apps, et cetera. The price being as expensive as it is isn't helping either...

Hackbraten | 22 hours ago

I daily drive an L5. Guess I have to consider myself lucky not to be tethered to proprietary 2FA apps.

Except for banking. In Germany though, it fortunately still works just ok with a chip card reader. Not all banks support it though, and it feels like it's dwindling.

rationalist | 22 hours ago

I think it's trying to be a computer that you can truely own and trust, not a "practical" black box that you can't see inside of.

margalabargala | 21 hours ago

I have run nothing but grpaheneOS, and Copperhead before it, with only Fdroid apps for close to a decade now.

Open source OTP apps have been sufficient. Banking I do on a desktop, or through a web browser.

I decline to bank with banks requiring proprietary apps. This seems like a no brainer to anyone considering this. It's like complaining "oh but how will I get around if I can't install Uber?!"

Someone who cares enough to want this presumably already doesn't use services requiring proprietary shitware.

Hackbraten | 21 hours ago

> I decline to bank with banks requiring proprietary apps. This seems like a no brainer to anyone considering this.

This only works if you live in a country where you actually have a choice though.

margalabargala | 21 hours ago

Which countries have passed laws such that it is illegal for a bank to do business with a person who does not own a smartphone?
As the other poster says, in not all countries does one have a choice with banking. Local full-fledged banks might have dwindled through successive mergers to 3-5 choices that are all pushing a (Play Services-dependent) Android phone app as the obligatory second factor for their online banking website, and phasing out the old code cards and code calculators.

There are even cases here and there where functionality is being removed from the online-banking website, and can only be got through the bank's phone app.

margalabargala | 21 hours ago

Is the issue that it's inconvenient to take the time to research and then switch banks, or does a scenario actually exist where a person not owning a smartphone cannot have a bank account in some country?

Can the location of that scenario be named or is this a "I assume this exists somewhere because I've heard people require it and it would be inconvenient to swap banks"?

You're asking people here to potentially doxx their location and banking service, so don't be surprised to not get specific answers, but this is a phenomenon familiar in multiple EU countries now.* First of all, there's a difference between not being able to have a bank account at all -- obviously everyone can -- and not being able to use the bank's online services. But secondly, compatible smartphone penetration is basically total now, with alternative-OS holdouts like yourself statistically negligible and not worth a bank's consideration as a business.

* (Not to mention China, where you basically can't get by in life as a resident without WeChat.)

margalabargala | 18 hours ago

Someone might dox what country their pseudonym is in or near or has knowledge of? Someone concerned to that level of opsec is unlikely to be participating in random HN banking app discussions anyway.

I'll grant China is an exception here.

For the "this is a phenomenon familiar in some EU countries", I argue that this is mostly people confusing some larger banks making things difficult, with all banks making things difficult. While everyone in your demographic may have a smartphone, plenty of people 70+ do not but do own a desktop computer. These people are absolutely worth the bank's consideration as a business.

And indeed those people do operate online banks, in all of these countries.

seba_dos1 | 20 hours ago

Was about to say something similar. I've already heard claims that you can't do online banking without Android/iOS in my EU country, and yet I manage without troubles. I don't doubt that it may be harder in some places than others, but don't just blindly assume it's not going to work; do your research as there are many options out there.

margalabargala | 18 hours ago

Exactly. Even among banks that "don't" support it there are often ways you can access if you make enough of a fuss.

"I'd like to open an account. I don't have a smartphone; how can I bank on my laptop?" will get you a long way.

GalaxyNova | 17 hours ago

> Open source OTP apps have been sufficient

Consider yourself lucky :)

My university uses Cisco Duo

GuB-42 | 21 hours ago

I have given up on "interesting" phones, custom ROMs, etc... Got a cheap, boring Samsung. It is not really mine, I treat it like I would treat a work phone provided by my company, an utilitarian device, to do stuff adults have to do, not for tinkering with.

I can use other devices for non-mainstream stuff. Can be another phone, but I tend to prefer PCs.

agile-gift0262 | 20 hours ago

What I do is have the interesting phone I want (pixel with GrapheneOS) and a "spyware phone" (an old Samsung) in a drawer with the very few apps that I can't do without and refuse to work on GrapheneOS. But I mostly steer away from needing apps for anything

officeplant | 22 hours ago

I just want something to run Nura on (rebranding of PostmarketOS) that actually supports US market cellphone LTE bands, and is faster than the Pinephone Pro.

Wild they want to push out a RiscV variant this early on.

shlip | 22 hours ago

Fixed the title : Purism Launches Librem 5 v2 , A RISC-V Phone to Empower Rich People

bordercases | 22 hours ago

The "poor people" phones are subsidized by its data.

Hackbraten | 22 hours ago

To put that into perspective, you can buy a $1000+ iPhone with seven years of software support.

Or you can buy a $1600 L5 v2 with "it's going to be mainlined" years of support. On that scale, it's actually affordable. Not a bargain, but affordable.

bigfishrunning | 21 hours ago

the software support will be great if "going to be" turns into "will be". However, niche devices will have battery trouble after a few years, and it's a big gamble that you'll be able to get the parts to fix it. Doesn't matter how many software updates you get if it won't turn on.

Also, and i alluded to this above, many patches were "going to be mainlined" and then -- weren't.

janvlug | 20 hours ago

From [0]

The price of the Purism phone is $1599.

You might as well get the iPhone 17 Pro Max with that amount and save $$$ since it has millions of more apps and games on there.

This Purism phone is quite underdeveloped compared to the iPhone.

[0] https://puri.sm/librem-5-v2-crowdfunding-campaign/

officeplant | 22 hours ago

AI response?

I think the average HN user understands this has nothing to do with competing with the iPhone or even Android phones. A real uh... apples to oranges comparison.

john01dav | 22 hours ago

Who do you think that this phone is for, if not for a subset of existing iOS or android users who care about foss products (for whom this must then compete with those options)?

jackothy | 22 hours ago

Obviously it would be for those that care more about "foss" than other features and are willing to make this sacrifice. That this phone will have radically less mature software in comparison is a given.

rationalist | 22 hours ago

> existing iOS or android users

Only because we don't have many choices to choose from. This phone expands that pool to choose from. The next project/company will then be trying to aim for a subset of existing iOS, Andoriod, and Librem 5 users.

bornfreddy | 22 hours ago

For grapheneos / sailfishos / murenaos / ... users maybe? There is whole world outside of those two walled gardens.

bluebarbet | 22 hours ago

Do we really have to dismiss anything we disagree with as "AI"? There is zero evidence or suggestion that this was written by AI, and even if it was, the viewpoint it expresses is clearly human (and presumably quite widely shared).

Better just to respond to the argument, I say.

smallerfish | 22 hours ago

13MP camera? I'm not spending $1600 on a phone to have a barely useful camera.

rationalist | 22 hours ago

It'seasier to criticize anything for its shortcomings, rather than recognizing what it does better:

This is a phone that respects the user - not Samsung, Apple, Google, etc.

Reading all of the negativity, it sounds like people are implying we should never try because the first or second attempt will never have secondary features as goof as the mass market phones.

Remember: the primary feature is a phone that you truely own and can trust - you can't do that with the others.

charcircuit | 22 hours ago

The GrapheneOS Motorola Signature 27, already mentioned in the thread, is a much more serious and realistic product that serves this purpose.

rationalist | 22 hours ago

It seperates the cell modem as an untrusted USB device?

charcircuit | 22 hours ago

It isolates the cell modem using a hardware firewall.

https://motorolaimgrepo.vtexassets.com/arquivos/Motorola_Thi...

grapheneos | 7 minutes ago

Isolation for the cellular baseband is an industry standard feature and has been for a long time. Mainstream devices have much better isolation for this than connecting it via USB. Even the earliest devices supported by GrapheneOS including the Nexus 5 had isolated cellular. Nexus 5X and the first Pixel phones began properly isolating the Wi-Fi/Bluetooth baseband too. Isolated radios are part of the hardware requirements for GrapheneOS supported listed in the official requirements:

https://grapheneos.org/faq#future-devices

grapheneos | 12 minutes ago

GrapheneOS only supports devices with an isolated cellular radio. Strong isolation for each of the radios is part of the hardware requirements for GrapheneOS. Connecting a radio via USB provides far weaker isolation and security than a mainstream device. Cellular radios in most mainstream devices are much better isolated than that already.

USB has a lot of complexity and immense attack surface in the Linux kernel. By default, GrapheneOS blocks new USB connections while locked at both a hardware and software level followed by disabling USB data at a hardware level when existing connections end. It would be a problem if internal components used USB. It's theoretically possible to rewrite all the Linux kernel USB controller, protocol, peripheral and gadget drivers in Rust along with isolating those but it hasn't been done and it's a massive amount of code riddled with vulnerabilities.

neilsimp1 | 22 hours ago

Which is built upon Android and runs on Google's phones

Klonoar | 19 hours ago

The Android security model and focus is leagues above the modern Linux setup.

grapheneos | 30 minutes ago

Motorola Signature 27 isn't a Google phone. GrapheneOS is a fork of the open source Android Open Source Project.

Hackbraten | 22 hours ago

Not everyone might be willing to use an effectively Google-controlled OS though.

charcircuit | 22 hours ago

AOSP is open source. The GrapheneOS developers are capable of reverting any hostile changes if need be.

fsflover | 21 hours ago

Until they aren't.

Hackbraten | 21 hours ago

A hostile change can also be an API that apps start depending on.

You can of course re-implement the feature so it’s less hostile. But then again, why keep fighting an OS that is designed by someone who doesn’t have your best interest in mind?

privacyishuman | 21 hours ago

>A hostile change can also be an API that apps start depending on.

That's already happening. Apps are using the Play Integrity API to block GrapheneOS. But GrapheneOS and their users have convinced some apps to officially support GrapheneOS. Roblox, for example, officially supports GrapheneOS.

AOSP is not anti privacy. They're adding helpful permissions like the local network just recently in Android 17.

charcircuit | 21 hours ago

>why keep fighting an OS that is designed by someone who doesn’t have your best interest in mind?

Most of the things people object to are not AOSP, but things from GMS (Play Services). AOSP does a much better job protecting the user via its security and privacy than other Linux distros.

29083011397778 | 20 hours ago

I've lost track of how many people said that about Brave re-instating or continuing support for Manifest V2. Turns out, no, the code base being open source is not enough to be able to maintain the changes your company needs

Especially if you're with fighting Google over their own code base

https://piunikaweb.com/2026/06/26/latest-brave-beta-manifest...

charcircuit | 18 hours ago

>your company needs

This is the key thing. Since practically nobody uses MV2 Brave does not really have a company need to support MV2. This means there is going to be less resources invested towards making sure it works and fully supported.

Andromxda | 17 minutes ago

Brave wrote their own content filtering engine in Rust, it's more performant than uBO and other JS-based adblockers, so it pretty much eliminates the need for MV2 in Brave. Firefox doesn't have a built-in adblocker, so it makes sense for Mozilla to keep supporting MV2.

stonogo | 15 hours ago

Graphene can barely get the code (Google releases it less and less frequently). Being "open source" doesn't mean much when the copyright belongs to Google.

grapheneos | 35 minutes ago

It's an issue for Pixels, not the Signature 27 and future Motorola devices.

jrootabega | 22 hours ago

How can you trust anything you didn't build and program yourself?

psychoslave | 22 hours ago

So, which people do you trust?

jrootabega | 21 hours ago

The better question is "what is your threat model?"

bryanlarsen | 21 hours ago

The openness which allows you to do so imparts a certain level of trust in itself. People with stuff to hide don't tend to open source their work.

There's no way you can check everything, but you can check some things, and others will check elsewhere directly or indirectly. You'll never get to 100% certainty, but you can move a long way from 0% certainty.

jrootabega | 3 hours ago

Technically, academically, that sounds fine. But I think it still means you cannot "truely" [sic] trust it.

Hackbraten | 21 hours ago

I boycott everything that’s not made by my hands, my hands, my hands. [0]

[0]: https://musiclink.one/song/bonaparte/boycott-everything

elorant | 21 hours ago

I have no issue with its shortcomings. The price though is quite steep. I get less phone than with a Pixel but pay more.

flanz_10 | 21 hours ago

Is it "quite steep"? Or is a Pixel phone, with economies of scale and margins de facto subsidized by users paying for services, quite cheap?

(well, yes, both tbh lol)

wowczarek | 21 hours ago

The thing is that these aren't volume manufacturers with carrier buy-in we're taking about. The price is the work that went into the product. It's the same with say MNT. I'd love to get the Reform Next, but it costs more than a ThinkPad I know I'd use for a decade to come and has truckloads of battery life - or three second hand ones. Just the way she goes. Boutique vs. mainstream.

charcircuit | 22 hours ago

The proposed chip is already 2 years out of date and lacks many security features that are common place and expected for modern devices. And don't forget how poorly the first campaign for the Librem 5 went where they went radio silent for years and refused to process refunds.
Yeah, feels like no lessons were learned. I actually own an L5 from the first time around -- it was similarly out of date at the time of announcement. I was using an already old Note 3 at the time, and remember thinking that the proposed specs were fairly comparable (though I think the Note 3 still won on some factors). If they had actually delivered it around the original planned time it wouldn't have been so bad but it was very late -- covid of course can take some of the blame but not all, and anyway there's another ongoing supply chain shortage right now such that even big companies like Valve can't easily source sufficient components, so why would this time around be any different for Purism.

AFAIK they did start to honor refund requests at some point, but by the time I was forced to upgrade from my Note 3 (due to cell networks) I had already written it off in my mind as an open source donation since at least Purism was doing things more properly than other attempts (Ubuntu, Mozilla) with a lot of upstreaming of changes. The thing eventually arrived and I messed around with it a bit but it's mostly sat in a box for years now. v2 is already way too late... unfortunately for them they won't get more money from me. Also not a fan of the deceptive use of the verb "launched" for a crowdfunding page, nor the emails they spammed me with over the years about some scammy "investment opportunity" or whatever it was, nor the founder's behaviors, nor the mistreatment of former employees...

Disclaimer: I am priced out of being the audience for this phone.

Google and Apple have a monopoly on RCS messaging, and until additional providers can offer interoperability other phone OS’s will only appeal to the small population of people this phone is made for.

> Google and Apple have a monopoly on RCS messaging

Sounds like something the EU should take a closer look at.

Oh wait, it shouldn't, because then prominent US bloggers will keep on raging about EU "overregulation" for months.

627467 | 22 hours ago

> because then prominent US bloggers will keep on raging

The scary US bloggers. That's the problem with the EU

murderfs | 22 hours ago

Lots of text about RISC-V, zero actual details about what actual core they're shipping...

https://forums.puri.sm/t/librem-5-v2-a-risc-v-phone/31563 says they're using a SpacemiT K1, which is around the same ballpark performance as the little cores on a $20 Walmart Android phone from a decade ago.

Hackbraten | 22 hours ago

When comparing single-core performance, which is critical for browsing, your comparison sadly doesn't seem all too far off.

murderfs | 17 hours ago

Oh, when it comes to actual use, it's going to be way worse than the decade old Walmart phone. Browser (and JS JIT) support for RISC-V ranges from bad (firefox) to literally nonexistent (mainline chromium).

warkdarrior | 22 hours ago

Perfect for Gopher/Gemini browsing

guywithahat | 22 hours ago

Well it's more performant than a NXP 8M Quad core Cortex A53, which was in their last phone. I don't think they make any attempt at being the fastest phone, it's more of a developer tool under the guise of a well polished device.

murderfs | 21 hours ago

That's setting the bar so low, I'm not sure it's even possible to not pass it: the A53 was ARM's little core from like 15 years ago, I don't think there are even any purchasable SoCs capable of running Linux that aren't faster than it.

guywithahat | 20 hours ago

I actually purchased a purism 14 years ago and reviewed it and was not impressed, there were large panel gaps I could see through and it had sharp edges, as well as an unusable speaker and other build quality issues. I'm not advising you purchase their products just that it's technically an improvement and on par for their performance goals.

nsoam | 22 hours ago

Launching? They didn't launch anything. It's a crowdfunding website.

neilsimp1 | 22 hours ago

I've had my L5 for 3.5 years and I still think it's the coolest piece of tech that I own.

This looks like an improvement in every category for the hardware. That's all I really wanted. It will be interesting to see how software support shakes out for the new CPU architecture. 99% of what I use is in the main repos, so that's all I need.

vandyswa | 22 hours ago

A mobile device which can't do realtime notifications from XMPP just won't work for me anymore. The Pinephone's "crust" mode was the only way the device wouldn't cook off the battery in less than half a day. But it disabled the CPU and Wifi, waking only for events from telephony (SMS and calls, specifically).

I'd be very surprised if this RISC-V phone didn't need something like crust.

owathray1 | 22 hours ago

If someone were to pay attention to the 23/24 1099s, they'd find that Todd used company funds, that is your hard earned crowdfunded money, for something he really shouldn't have.

psychoslave | 11 hours ago

What is that even supposed to mean?

kop316 | 22 hours ago

The actual campaign does a better job of showing the specs: https://puri.sm/librem-5-v2-crowdfunding-campaign/

IMHO, I think going with RISC-V is a mistake. It works if you only use PureOS/Mobian/Mura packages, but things like e.g. Signal or Flatpaks are only compiled with X86_64 in mind, so you are already limiting the scope of some apps on there (they mention this in the campaign about ARM64 emulation, but I'd need to be convinced).

There's been a bit of discussion on how performant the RISC-V processor is:

https://floss.social/@okias/117616860986317655

https://browser.geekbench.com/v6/cpu/compare/19472801?baseli...

and from: https://linmob.net/weekly-update-46-2026/

"in case I don't manage to blog about this device later in the week. Now, vector extensions are likely not used, affecting K1 benchmark results negatively, but still: Even if all #MobileLinux remain as lean as they are, the web will surely not, and shipping what seems to be the same real world performance in April 2028 as in a device envisioned ten years earlier and shipped about five years ago is... something (the RAM will definitely help though). One last pun for tonight: Also, when I read freedom, I immediately think of PowerVR graphics."

They are also reusing the Chassis from the Librem 5 v1, which means that if 5G is added, it probably will be sub-optimal.

As someone who backed the Librem 5 and runs mainline Linux as a daily driver since 2021, I'd say I'm very on the fence about this. If I knew that my money was also going to greater community development, I would be much more tempted to get this.

Hackbraten | 21 hours ago

> I'd say I'm very on the fence about this.

Me too. The one single thing that actually makes me even consider the v2 as my next phone (instead of, say, a Fairphone 6) is the smart card reader.

Using a $15 OpenPGP card to SSH into stuff and sign commits and push them right from your phone feels amazing. I’m not sure I’m willing to give that up. But is it worth $1600, plus locking myself into yet another decade of laggy browsing?

kop316 | 20 hours ago

Yep, FWIW Purism does some really cool things that no other manufacturer does with a phone, e.g. the OpenPGP Card and the hardware kill switches, and they do a lot of things I like with a phone, e.g. easily replaceable battery, headphone jack.

If they did a normal evolution in the ARM64 space to have more power and have a better battery life, this would be an easy buy for me.

But it seems that most mobile mainline Linux distros have moved onto Android devices (I use a Oneplus 6 now with Mobian, and I have been tempted to swap to a Fairphone 5). Pinephone straight up does not produce phones anymore. I'd like to see more hardware mainline first phones, but I am not sure this is the right step.

0xbadcafebee | 21 hours ago

$1600? How could it possibly cost that much to make a smartphone today, with China churning out millions of smartphones for 10x less?

The Librem 5 reportedly cost $800 to make in China: https://www.404media.co/how-a-2-000-made-in-the-usa-liberty-...

Users waited over 4 years to get their phones: https://www.reddit.com/r/Purism/comments/135w4dq/no_refund_f...

fsflover | 21 hours ago

> How could it possibly cost that much to make a smartphone today

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21656355

Hackbraten | 21 hours ago

Because Purism is not going to have millions of customers but thousands while their R&D costs remain in the same ballpark. Plus manufacturing is much cheaper at scale.

twiclo | 21 hours ago

While I won't be buying one of these I'm very happy to see Librem continuing to push the ecosystem forward. They have done an incredible amount of heavy lifting on the software side and were a huge part in kicking off the last wave of enthusiasm around Linux phones.

saulpw | 21 hours ago

Purism is a shady company, I had preordered the original Librem which came with a 'cancel anytime' money-back guarantee (which is why I felt okay preordering). When I wanted to cancel a few years (!) later, they told me I had to wait until the device was released, and then they'd refund me. A few years after that (!) they device was starting to ship, and I asked to cancel again, and was told I had to wait until my spot in the queue before I could cancel. 6 months later when my spot in the queue came up, they told me I couldn't get a refund but they offered me "store credit". In the meantime they had changed the website so that the refund was no longer mentioned (but it's in the Internet Archive still).

And of course the phone itself had major issues, it was overpriced and under-featured and they never made good on many of their technical promises either. The whole experience left such a bad taste in my mouth that my Net Promoter Score for them is below zero. I only regret that I didn't make it to this thread fast enough to tell people to stay away.

fsflover | 21 hours ago

This crowdfunding campaign does not promise 'cancel anytime' money-back guarantee, so this rant is not very relevant. And you got the phone or refund in the end, didn't you? So how is this a scam?

> and they never made good on many of their technical promises either

Which ones?

bpfrh | 20 hours ago

He didn't get a refund he got a store credit, nevermind the "anytime he wanted"

fsflover | 20 hours ago

It seems clear that Purism almost got bankrupted by their original Librem 5 crowdfunding campaign. They likely had no cash to issue refunds. They learned their lesson and do not offer refunds this time. This does not make them a shady company. This is just FUD.

Concerning their technical promises, they all got fulfilled (except the time estimates): https://forums.puri.sm/t/librem-5-promise-delivery-chart/695...

nar001 | 5 hours ago

The shady part is lying to customers about it, offering a warranty that you can't honor and continually telling customers to "wait later" until you just offer them store credit instead. The least you can do is at least being honest with the people who believed in you and gave you money for it.

fsflover | 5 hours ago

I do not deny that this was a problem. It just does not really matter for the current crowdfunding campagn, since the conditions have been explicitly changed. The OP is spreading FUD by exaggerating the problem.

Meanwhile, Lenovo have sold the users' security for money multiple times, and yet the HN crowd is generally positive towards them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superfish#Lenovo_security_inci..., https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150812/11395231925/lenov....

Hackbraten | 20 hours ago

> Which ones?

Purism has promised, and still promises: [0]

> That’s why the Librem 5 will include non-soldered, easily serviceable batteries that you can order.

In reality, they cancel all such orders to e.g. Europe “due to regulations”: [1]

> We will not be able to ship spare batteries outside of the USA, due to regulations. Any such order will be cancelled and refunded.

One might argue that Purism can’t be held accountable for things outside their control. But they’ve been more than happy to sell phones to customers worldwide, so I’d say this is a promise they never kept.

[0]: https://puri.sm/products/librem-5/

[1]: https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5-evergreen-battery/

fsflover | 20 hours ago

Hackbraten | 20 hours ago

Thanks for the pointer!

abrowne | 20 hours ago

I just took delivery of the one I crowd-funded and then sold it – for more than I paid since the price had been raised since then.

asdfqwertzxcv | 20 hours ago

Exactly the same timeline and crap they pulled with me. Never will do business with them.
Did you report Purism to applicable regulatory bodies? If applicable, did you sue them to get your money back? It certainly sucks that you would have to resort to either of those options.

Companies get away with shady behavior for as long as regulators and consumers allow.

christophilus | 20 hours ago

Do you know anything about Furi? https://furilabs.com/

That’s a decent price. I really want a Linux phone. Haven’t pulled the trigger yet, though.

Hackbraten | 20 hours ago

Before you do, make sure you understand the trade-offs. [0]

[0]: https://social.librem.one/@dos/112686932765355105

owathray1 | 20 hours ago

Todd also used significant company money for an ongoing non-company expense. Given that that the company was started using crowd funded money, this beyond shady. There is proof in the 2024 1099s if anyone there cares to check.

renehsz | 19 hours ago

Yeah, that's very shady behavior. The fact that they silently removed the refund language from the website clearly shows their intentions.

But here’s a hypothetical question I’d love to hear yall's opinions on: If a small hardware company couldn't survive paying out all refunds as promised, which of the following two scenarios is worse?

1. The company tries to honor refund promises and goes bankrupt. Nobody receives new hardware or ongoing support anymore. Customers who preordered might still go home empty-handed depending on how much the company owes to other creditors.

2. The company offers store credit instead of the promised cash refunds and stays in business. They can keep producing devices and provide support to customers. But preorder customers cannot get their cash back, only stuff from the store.

To be clear, I'm not saying that Purism is/was in this situation. Obviously, R&D of a phone is very expensive and they don't sell huge volumes, so they have to jack up prices to stay afloat. But I don't what financial situation they're in, maybe they're doing perfectly fine, maybe not.

Regardless, I'm curious what people would prefer them to do in the hypothetical scenario that they were extremely short on cash.

In that scenario, the hardware company is insolvent, unless the buyers agreed to a kickstarter-like "best effort" contract in advance. Not declaring your insolvency and continuing to trade is a criminal offence, in many jurisdictions. If they agreed to a best effort contract, then there's not really an issue, the option was agreed in advance. Probably not legally valid unless it was explicitly flagged up, like Kickstarter do, of course.

So my answer is - they don't get to decide that unilaterally after the fact. If your commitments make you insolvent, you might be able to persuade your creditors to change the deal, but only by agreement. Not by just saying "oopsie, here's some store credit". That makes you a crook.

Incidentally, at least in the UK, one creditor (that you can't pay) can force your company to be wound up. The cost of the legal fees make it such that it would require a few phone-sized creditors to get together before it was worth it for them, but in principle it only takes one.

That's why the option taken by companies in this situation is usually to say that they will convert to credit, but refund any who ask. If enough people don't ask, the company is solvent again, by the consent of their creditors. Otherwise they aren't.

excannuk | 17 hours ago

Number 2 is fraud. Just because you're insolvent doesn't mean you can unilaterally discharge your obligations. Thats literally what bankruptcy court is about

metalman | 21 hours ago

almost sold, but I need the full current capabilities and more than 2k Canadian, which will force a full audit of any competition. the "bigme, hibreak" has my attention as a colour eink phone, but the software is older android, and they are cagey about what is pre loaded and locked when asked. got interested in eink after a customer showed me his teeny tiny black and white eink phone that only does calls and texts, barely bigger than like 5 standard bank/id cards stacked, said it was hand made in batches in NY, somewhere. dont know if the eink drivers are proprietary, but the combo of eink and a full open source os + hardware stack would be nice

conradev | 20 hours ago

You’re better off ordering a Fairphone 6+ if you want a usable product in the space.

Has great Android support of course, but also good Nura/postmarketOS support

It’s still a few years behind the flagships, but likely more powerful and cheaper than whatever this ends up becoming.

dxxvi | 5 hours ago

Does the phone run Android apps or iOS apps? If not, that phone is for fun only as I need to install an authenticator (only available in Google/Apple store) for work.

phasephantasm | 21 minutes ago

Purism hasn't launched anything, this is just an idea that you can buy which may not convert into a product at any point in time, as history has shown with them.

They didn't even have an idea of a Librem 5 v2 before seemingly November 13th or so. I guess they saw Motorola unveiled the Signature 27 with GrapheneOS support costing $1600 USD or so November 5th, and they decided: "yeah, we deserve that money, let's rip off some more and move into THAT big league".