My own reflection was remembering Salon for cavalierly disposing of its brilliant International Issues subforum, then later the whole of TableTalk with no effort to assist preservation.
Somewhere, however far down, on the list of why people feel socially isolated these days is surely the disappearance of internet fora where one could discuss serious issues in a longform-text format with other identifiable regulars who could become chums or friends (albeit of the long-distance sort).
The IMDB boards that brought cinephiles together, the Lonely Planet Thorn Tree forum that was one of the most informed and unspammed places to discuss travel, the music boards on Amazon prior to about 2010 -- all shut down by corporate owners due to the cost of moderation or the inability to strictly control their brand image. Things like Reddit are a pale substitute and full of pathologies.
i think you're right, and now with the proliferation of bots it seems like the only spaces where an actual community can be formed are platforms like discord. it's the only place on the modern web i've ever made any friends.
The thing about the old forums, though, is that they were a welcoming place for older adults. Discord is a young man's game, and how many 40-70 year olds there are going to establish any ties with other people they could conceivably meet up with in real life?
>Discord is a young man's game, and how many 40-70 year olds there are going to establish any ties with other people
numbers wise that's true but then again what's stopping anyone? Young people don't mind talking to older people especially in a hobby centric community. A lot of middle aged people simply don't seem to try.
Reminds me a bit of a decade ago towards the end of my degree I was looking for an internship and people would always say how awful online applications are and how in the olden days you could just walk anywhere and get one. So I just walked to half a dozen places and asked for one and got an internship at the third place. Got some weird stares from a few of them but the worst thing they could do was tell you to shove off
> Young people don't mind talking to older people especially in a hobby centric community. A lot of middle aged people simply don't seem to try.
Exactly, in one of the old forum I used to frequent a lot (focused on point and click adventure games), the age ranged from 20 to 70+ years old. When talking about hobbies, age is completely irrelevant. Thinking too much about age is self defeating.
For me the only thing I dislike about discord is that it's more of a replacement for irc with no permanency. Unlike forums.
The simple fact that Discord is not known to most older people, and even when it is known, it is popularly associated with subcultures like gaming that aren't necessarily theirs. Compare this to the web in the early millennium, which was already known to the broad public, and known as a place one could talk about any particular subject or hobby.
"The simple fact that Discord is not known to most older people"
The olds that game have known about Discord as long as it's been around. The olds that don't game have known about Discord since their kids started hanging out there. You might be confusing the general distribution of individuals actually interested in chatting with strangers online as something age related here.
Please. Firstly, not everyone of older generations has kids of a generation and inclination for which Discord is relevant for the latter. And even of those particular older people, how many people have have had a discussion that revealed Discord as a place relevant to discuss non-gaming issues like music, arts, and travel particularly relevant to a middle-aged or elderly audience?
Discord has its fans here, sure, but it is unrealistic it to depict it as as mainstream as the web in the longform-text age.
You seem anxious to pick a fight that hasn't been offered here. I said olds know about Discord, and they do. Whether they choose to actually engage with it is entirely dependent on how active they are in gaming, same as the rest of the userbase. I find it charming (if unhinged) that you seem to think we mostly sit around discussing posh culture BS.
Discord is live chat with no usable backlog of posts that I can search or go through offline.
I'm too busy working or doing my non-internet hobbies to hang out in a chat room to discuss my hobbies. Forums allow non-live communication and interaction, and long term documentation which is especially critical for hobbies.
It's always fun to watch a new crop of game lobby squeakers have their woldview rocked when the find out their generation didn't invent weed or video games.
Lol what. Olds routinely use Discord for everything from organizing massive in-game alliances (shout to my old EVE corpmates) to hosting weekly tabletop games when party members have become geographically dispersed over the decades.
OK, but what about that great majority of older adults who don't have gaming among their hobbies?
If a platform is associated with gaming, it is inherently going to be associated with younger generations because gaming is more practiced by the latter. The presence of some older people who game doesn't change that. Meanwhile, for older people who want to discuss interests other than gaming, Discord is not a readily appealing platform like the old web was.
Does discord have long form discussions? I never seen it past a IRC/Slack alternative - everything written should be short and pretended it'll be lost. Beyond that, the discussions tend to be unorganized.
Forums were great for overall organization and finding topic discussions is search.
Luckily LLMs are capable of peeling content like that out, but Discord again seems harder to scrape for random discussions on a topic.
The disadvantage of Discord is that it's not discoverable in search.
The advantage of Discord is that it's not discoverable in search. That makes it slightly less susceptible to the "dark forest" effects of the public Internet.
I feel this so much. I was a member of multiple internet forums back in the 2000s and 2010s; and connected with several real people around the world. It was an exciting time, we hung out on the forums, but also connected simultaneously on IRC and Facebook. At random hours of the day I'd get messages from people across the world, and I felt pretty socially engaged. This didn't even cut into my IRL social life, in fact I felt like it improved it.
Many years have passed since.
Recently, after Reddit's user-hostile moves, constantly pushing their app on mobile and making old.reddit.com login-only, I started looking around for alternatives, and haven't found much. The forums I frequented have been shut down, and places like lemmy aren't particularly active.
They still seem to exist for classic cars, engine building, and other niche mechanical pursuits.
Actually a few I find to be growing recently.
But maybe because I don't pay attention reddit/discord I don't notice the proportion of users is still low.
Might be the age of the people involved - those of us in our 50s prefer lists with photos over videos - plus the format being better suited to the content (ie. those lists with photos).
We certainly lost some forums, some due to companies closing or changing strategies, and lost many to spam, but I'd also claim that we lost a lot of them, to people not engaging anymore.
There are still plenty of forums out there, why haven't you (why haven't I) contributed to them since the early 2000s anymore?
For me (here and elsewhere), I tend to over analyze my words. Imposter syndrome sets in sometimes. Other times I feel my words provide little value, or they’ll “feed trolls.”
On HN specifically, not having any sort of discussion engagement (like notifications) makes it extra tough. It’s a double edged sword too. Having that functionality would increase the cost of running the site all while encouraging more low value discussion.
Damn, so true. There’s no substitute for the music forums I belonged to 15-20 years ago, certainly not Reddit. Absolute fanatics combined with minimal moderation lead to the most memorable internet moments I’ll ever have, I’m sure.
If you don't understand why some of us are nostalgic for Salon, this is the best description I've heard of what it was in its heyday:
"left-coast, interactive version of The New Yorker”
Good writing. Good reporting. Interesting topics.
Circa maybe 2006, I got my tech news from Slashdot, my political commentary from Salon.com, my memes from Digg, my celebrity gossip from Gawker and my car nerd discussion from Jalopnik.
True, all of the above were gems compared to all of our options today.
Present company excepted, actually. I appreciate the degree to which HN manages to impose halfway-decent civility onto us (including me at times) with a well-timed “please don’t make posts like this” (thanks dang) :)
In the 70s, people wrote physical letters and journals. We probably know more about that era than we will be able to reliably state about the 2020s in 50 years.
Hell, some of the AIs aren’t even allowed to say who won the 2020 election.
I tested this with Gemini just now and was relieved to see that it can now report the simple facts of the election citing Britanica and Ballotpedia. It took me while to test Copilot as it appears that I didn't have a microsoft account. But anyway it is now accurately reporting the results of the 2020 election.
Are there any other AIs which are still being prevented from saying who won?
I've always disliked Salon, but, even so, this is exactly why archive.org is awesome and deserves massive kudos! They save even the stuff that I don't like :)
wikipedia, archive.org, and youtube. the three are accumulated new library of Alexandria. the latter if it could somehow also be preserved, just not sure how without ton of money and legal.
Is there a way to use Internet Archive to download an entire site snapshot?
I tried to do this for a non-tech person whose blog articles were removed without their permission and without any notice when the blog host was M&Aed. It was a giant PitA for just about 40 article pages and I'm pretty sure I was temp IPbanned for a few hours/days.
Also, there is a lot of bitrot from people who have been working on Kryptos K4 across 30 years.
If they sell the domain or point it somewhere to monetize, then I sort of get it?
I’m sure some literal salon chain or some rich left-leaning person - an Arianna Huffington type - would be willing to spend for it.
But if it goes NXDOMAIN like say, excite.com is… I have no idea how you couldn’t make money with a large original content farm like that. I made a couple hundred a month for a few months with a shitty Wikipedia mirror! (Yes, I got filtered out of Google after a bit, but my site was 100% duplicate). And the hosting, for static files (which is all they need)? It cannot possibly be that expensive.
> I made a couple hundred a month for a few months with a shitty Wikipedia mirror! (Yes, I got filtered out of Google after a bit, but my site was 100% duplicate).
My grand idea was to create a Wikipedia mirror/clone but drive traffic through an ad rev share. Blogs could replace their Wikipedia links with the mirror (or a CMS plugin to do it automatically)… maybe with just subdomain with their Adsense id or their account name+lookup and you’d run their Adsense id x% of the time and the rest with yours.
Use RSS. You can get feeds easily from many more sites than you think. They dont make it obvious but its there if you add /feed or /rss or /index.xml etc to the url. You won't get paywalled but you'll get a lot more than nothing.
Really glad this is being preserved. There’s so much internet history in those archives. Whatever people may think of Salon, keeping an online publication going for 31 years is an achievement in itself, and it’s good to know people will still be able to explore what it left behind.
I can't imagine why a big website that's totally shutting down wouldn't at least transfer data to the IA
I'm imagining this kind of like the Organization for Transformative Works, which through their Open Doors program, they take ownership of fandom-related projects when the project owners don't want to maintain it anymore. So like a 2012 archive of Sailor Moon fanfics, they'll take over the website rather than it disappearing.
Few may remember this, but there was thing called Salon Personals, which for a fleeting moment, was one the best online dating communities that ever was.
OTOH, the Archive has been slaughtered. Material they scanned is just not available except for peep shows (it's the new porn?) and even so, the scans they did are so blah.
Books were apparently scanned with some compromise setting that lets halftones look reasonable, but the text is almost universally blackish on a dishwater gray background. I use Preview.app to threshold and later stitch the color and grayscale pages back in. This doesn't work for books with a lot of illustrations, unless they are line drawings.
Of course, material saved from the internet is in its original quality.
mellosouls | a day ago
Goodbye from Salon (658 points, 288 comments)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50383739
My own reflection was remembering Salon for cavalierly disposing of its brilliant International Issues subforum, then later the whole of TableTalk with no effort to assist preservation.
[OP] CharlesW | a day ago
TFNA | a day ago
The IMDB boards that brought cinephiles together, the Lonely Planet Thorn Tree forum that was one of the most informed and unspammed places to discuss travel, the music boards on Amazon prior to about 2010 -- all shut down by corporate owners due to the cost of moderation or the inability to strictly control their brand image. Things like Reddit are a pale substitute and full of pathologies.
slopinthebag | a day ago
TFNA | a day ago
slopinthebag | 23 hours ago
Barrin92 | 22 hours ago
numbers wise that's true but then again what's stopping anyone? Young people don't mind talking to older people especially in a hobby centric community. A lot of middle aged people simply don't seem to try.
Reminds me a bit of a decade ago towards the end of my degree I was looking for an internship and people would always say how awful online applications are and how in the olden days you could just walk anywhere and get one. So I just walked to half a dozen places and asked for one and got an internship at the third place. Got some weird stares from a few of them but the worst thing they could do was tell you to shove off
sersi | 21 hours ago
Exactly, in one of the old forum I used to frequent a lot (focused on point and click adventure games), the age ranged from 20 to 70+ years old. When talking about hobbies, age is completely irrelevant. Thinking too much about age is self defeating.
For me the only thing I dislike about discord is that it's more of a replacement for irc with no permanency. Unlike forums.
TFNA | 21 hours ago
The simple fact that Discord is not known to most older people, and even when it is known, it is popularly associated with subcultures like gaming that aren't necessarily theirs. Compare this to the web in the early millennium, which was already known to the broad public, and known as a place one could talk about any particular subject or hobby.
forgetfreeman | 10 hours ago
The olds that game have known about Discord as long as it's been around. The olds that don't game have known about Discord since their kids started hanging out there. You might be confusing the general distribution of individuals actually interested in chatting with strangers online as something age related here.
TFNA | 9 hours ago
Discord has its fans here, sure, but it is unrealistic it to depict it as as mainstream as the web in the longform-text age.
forgetfreeman | an hour ago
nasalgoat | 7 hours ago
I'm too busy working or doing my non-internet hobbies to hang out in a chat room to discuss my hobbies. Forums allow non-live communication and interaction, and long term documentation which is especially critical for hobbies.
senderista | 22 hours ago
forgetfreeman | 10 hours ago
VeryFinePrint | 21 hours ago
forgetfreeman | 10 hours ago
Lol what. Olds routinely use Discord for everything from organizing massive in-game alliances (shout to my old EVE corpmates) to hosting weekly tabletop games when party members have become geographically dispersed over the decades.
TFNA | 9 hours ago
If a platform is associated with gaming, it is inherently going to be associated with younger generations because gaming is more practiced by the latter. The presence of some older people who game doesn't change that. Meanwhile, for older people who want to discuss interests other than gaming, Discord is not a readily appealing platform like the old web was.
ThunderSizzle | 21 hours ago
Forums were great for overall organization and finding topic discussions is search.
Luckily LLMs are capable of peeling content like that out, but Discord again seems harder to scrape for random discussions on a topic.
pjc50 | 14 hours ago
The advantage of Discord is that it's not discoverable in search. That makes it slightly less susceptible to the "dark forest" effects of the public Internet.
quadrifoliate | 23 hours ago
Many years have passed since.
Recently, after Reddit's user-hostile moves, constantly pushing their app on mobile and making old.reddit.com login-only, I started looking around for alternatives, and haven't found much. The forums I frequented have been shut down, and places like lemmy aren't particularly active.
jubilee33 | 19 hours ago
Scoundreller | 18 hours ago
Fortunately or unfortunately, a lot are owned by a small handful of players.
And forums with their threading work a lot better than Reddit does where it’s a new topic for the same problem every week…
nasalgoat | 8 hours ago
eXpl0it3r | 11 hours ago
There are still plenty of forums out there, why haven't you (why haven't I) contributed to them since the early 2000s anymore?
c0wb0yc0d3r | 10 hours ago
On HN specifically, not having any sort of discussion engagement (like notifications) makes it extra tough. It’s a double edged sword too. Having that functionality would increase the cost of running the site all while encouraging more low value discussion.
samudrijan | 7 hours ago
cgh | 9 hours ago
atourgates | 20 hours ago
"left-coast, interactive version of The New Yorker”
Good writing. Good reporting. Interesting topics.
Circa maybe 2006, I got my tech news from Slashdot, my political commentary from Salon.com, my memes from Digg, my celebrity gossip from Gawker and my car nerd discussion from Jalopnik.
Those were good days.
xp84 | 20 hours ago
Present company excepted, actually. I appreciate the degree to which HN manages to impose halfway-decent civility onto us (including me at times) with a well-timed “please don’t make posts like this” (thanks dang) :)
pessimizer | a day ago
vkgcr | 23 hours ago
Moving forward we can expect having a quasi-exact record of what happened because it's cheap and easy to record stuff.
I often wonder how it _really_ was in the past. For instance, California in the 70s.
ceejayoz | 21 hours ago
Hell, some of the AIs aren’t even allowed to say who won the 2020 election.
giglamesh | 7 hours ago
I tested this with Gemini just now and was relieved to see that it can now report the simple facts of the election citing Britanica and Ballotpedia. It took me while to test Copilot as it appears that I didn't have a microsoft account. But anyway it is now accurately reporting the results of the 2020 election.
Are there any other AIs which are still being prevented from saying who won?
_hyn3 | 23 hours ago
It's not too late to donate! https://archive.org/donate
userbinator | 20 hours ago
Keyframe | 16 hours ago
voxleone | 10 hours ago
https://arcticworldarchive.org/
thephyber | 23 hours ago
I tried to do this for a non-tech person whose blog articles were removed without their permission and without any notice when the blog host was M&Aed. It was a giant PitA for just about 40 article pages and I'm pretty sure I was temp IPbanned for a few hours/days.
Also, there is a lot of bitrot from people who have been working on Kryptos K4 across 30 years.
simonw | 22 hours ago
That was in 2017 though so maybe they block that kind of traffic today.
nextaccountic | 22 hours ago
Marsymars | 20 hours ago
xp84 | 20 hours ago
If they sell the domain or point it somewhere to monetize, then I sort of get it?
I’m sure some literal salon chain or some rich left-leaning person - an Arianna Huffington type - would be willing to spend for it.
But if it goes NXDOMAIN like say, excite.com is… I have no idea how you couldn’t make money with a large original content farm like that. I made a couple hundred a month for a few months with a shitty Wikipedia mirror! (Yes, I got filtered out of Google after a bit, but my site was 100% duplicate). And the hosting, for static files (which is all they need)? It cannot possibly be that expensive.
Scoundreller | 18 hours ago
My grand idea was to create a Wikipedia mirror/clone but drive traffic through an ad rev share. Blogs could replace their Wikipedia links with the mirror (or a CMS plugin to do it automatically)… maybe with just subdomain with their Adsense id or their account name+lookup and you’d run their Adsense id x% of the time and the rest with yours.
rr808 | 22 hours ago
xp84 | 20 hours ago
OnlineTux | 19 hours ago
Bedlow | 17 hours ago
arjie | 22 hours ago
snasan | 21 hours ago
xp84 | 20 hours ago
KPGv2 | 18 hours ago
I'm imagining this kind of like the Organization for Transformative Works, which through their Open Doors program, they take ownership of fandom-related projects when the project owners don't want to maintain it anymore. So like a 2012 archive of Sailor Moon fanfics, they'll take over the website rather than it disappearing.
tpurves | 18 hours ago
anonthrownaway | 7 hours ago
jamesnorden | 11 hours ago
k310 | 7 hours ago
Books were apparently scanned with some compromise setting that lets halftones look reasonable, but the text is almost universally blackish on a dishwater gray background. I use Preview.app to threshold and later stitch the color and grayscale pages back in. This doesn't work for books with a lot of illustrations, unless they are line drawings.
Of course, material saved from the internet is in its original quality.
philipallstar | 4 hours ago