Sandwich Simulator

520 points by subdomain 20 hours ago on hackernews | 184 comments

lantry | 19 hours ago

you can only put butter on the bread. you can't put butter on anything else. 1 star

/s

vzaliva | 18 hours ago

this is a german sandwich! there are rules.

dpangerl | 11 hours ago

its not a sandwich without a top slice... this its just a simple "brot mit ...". I miss my mustard on the egg...

finger | 19 hours ago

I need to put nutella on the cheese but it doesn't let me. And yes, nutella on top is not the same as nutella underneath.

farbklang | 10 hours ago

I feel you - Nutella + Cheese + Salami was one of my favorite childhood "stulle" and I often had to hide it in order to not be ridiculed.

https://stulle.app/21767

Thanks for the inspiration - I might do one of these today for real

ngruhn | 10 hours ago

bruh

ricardobayes | 9 hours ago

Nutella on Cheese ist verboten.

andai | 7 hours ago

This sounds like something you'd find in the Necronomicon... impossible geometry... forbidden sandwich.

skeeter2020 | 5 hours ago

the closest to this I've experienced is my son's short-lived love of ham and jam sandwiches. Cheese + double Nutella is next level though!

hleszek | 18 hours ago

I wish you could make the complete sandwich with bread on top, and then allow you to cut it in two.

Waterluvian | 17 hours ago

And then crash my browser when it rotates the halves to show all the layers. I have more ham in this thing than customer appreciation night at Flock.
More cheese than a Microsoft consumer product demo!

alienbirds | 17 hours ago

There is this site: https://rotatingsandwiches.com/ but they are pre-made

davely | 17 hours ago

Haha. Completely unrelated, really, but for NaNoGenMo [1] a number of years ago (pre-LLM days), I used Markov chains to create a bunch of random sandwich recipes [2] from an old recipe book that was in the public domain.

[1] https://github.com/NaNoGenMo

[2] https://daveschumaker.github.io/Random-Sandwiches/

blululu | 15 hours ago

I wish I could upvote this twice. This just has that pure OG webglitch aesthetic. Something reflective of the old Brian Eno quote: "CD distortion, the jitteriness of digital video, the crap sound of 8-bit - all of these will be cherished and emulated as soon as they can be avoided."

ricardobayes | 9 hours ago

It is emulated, I've seen very modern, hip restaurants/fast food chains now using this aesthetic.

itintheory | 8 hours ago

The aesthetic of rotation?

flimflamm | 11 hours ago

Argh one is faster than others.

analog8374 | 17 hours ago

There's pictures of other sandwiches and some of them have bread on top so I think that's doable but as far as cutting it diagonally I don't see such

em-bee | 17 hours ago

injidup | 10 hours ago

After 20 years in Austria I have a love hate relationship with leberkäse.

Eh oida! A lebekasemmi bitte! Mjammm .... Mit Ketchup!

I have this craving for the stuff. Then almost always I'm about 4/5 through eating the thing, and I get this ick feeling and toss the leftover into a trash can, followed by some lighter fluid and a lit match. And then I don't touch the stuff for ages. And then ..... the craving starts again.

sltkr | 10 hours ago

A Stulle is specifically an open-faced sandwich, similar to the Swedish smörgås (which English speakers may know from the loanword "smorgasbord").

Klappstulle is the version with bread on top too.

bowsamic | 7 hours ago

In Germany we often eat open face sandwiches

anewhnaccount2 | 6 hours ago

Open faced is standard in Nordic-Baltic region including North Germany as well as Basque country.

em-bee | 18 hours ago

one of the few things i miss from austria. some of these toppings are hard to get in china or elsewhere outside of europe.

https://stulle.app/15519

i call this one the four pillars of jenga, with fries: https://stulle.app/15714

cachius | 11 hours ago

Massive

ricardobayes | 9 hours ago

149 Scheiben Salami (!?). You went wild with this one.

em-bee | 8 hours ago

got to make up for the salami deficiency i suffer from in this country.

andai | 7 hours ago

Sandwich of Babel

kylecazar | 18 hours ago

I've created something truly horrible

Akasazh | 9 hours ago

Carte to share?

tantalor | 18 hours ago

Do I have to subscribe to the enterprise edition to get another piece of bread on top?

shepherdjerred | 18 hours ago

Where is the lettuce?

em-bee | 18 hours ago

we don't put lettuce on our sandwiches :-P

airstrike | 7 hours ago

Any leafy greens will do, really!

climech | an hour ago

Who's "we"?! (I was also taken aback by the lack of lettuce :D)

punkbrwstr | 18 hours ago

And onion!

wolfi1 | 14 hours ago

lettuce? what's that?

pan69 | 18 hours ago

No hagelslag?

em-bee | 18 hours ago

this is a german sandwich, not a dutch one.

that said, granular stuff to spread on top like salt, pepper, chives, etc are missing...

dunham | 18 hours ago

Do Germans use mustard on sandwiches?

em-bee | 17 hours ago

i do, but i have been around the world so much that sometimes i have a hard time differentiating between things that are common back home and things i picked up on the way, or developed out of necessity. but a quick search confirms that mustard is used on bread. not very common i think, but it's there.

yorwba | 7 hours ago

I'm pretty sure Bautz'ner Senf is sold in little cups https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bautz%E2%80%99ner#/media/Datei... precisely because people primarily want to spread the mustard on their Stulle. Might be a regional thing, though. Growing up, it was often paired with Zungenwurst (beef tongue sausage), which I guess also doesn't agree with everyone's palate.

flymasterv | 17 hours ago

wow its almost like those are my dipping mustards and arent meant to go on sandwiches????????? but ok go off

hackernud3s | 18 hours ago

I hope quark is mayo but I'm afraid to confirm.

em-bee | 18 hours ago

nope, it's curd cheese, kind of related to cottage cheese: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quark_(dairy_product)

on bread best with a bit of salt and chives. optionally a slice of cheese on top.

tapland | 17 hours ago

Think of it like cream cheese with the coarse dryness you get from pure cranberry juice

grimoald | 13 hours ago

Only lowfat quark tastes dry. 40% is the way to go.

moobsen | an hour ago

Low fat Quark is actually quite similar to sour cream. Goes surprisingly well with jam/jelly/marmelade.

batperson | 18 hours ago

The butter spreading tech is amazing. The future is now.

freak42 | 11 hours ago

But the liverwurst spreading tech unfortunately is quite bad :(

Aldipower | 10 hours ago

No, it is on point, because I think it should be "Grobkörnige Leberwurst", which is particular hard to smear.

seri4l | 18 hours ago

Looks like a good use case for this that was posted recently.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50341576

reaperducer | 17 hours ago

em-bee | 17 hours ago

reaperducer | 2 hours ago

Not the same.

em-bee | 17 hours ago

an interesting detail is that the person who made this is apparently called weichbrodt as his last name, which means "soft bread"

enoch2090 | 17 hours ago

German last names are truly lovely

em-bee | 17 hours ago

not a common name though. first time i see it. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weichbrodt

enoch2090 | 16 hours ago

bibabaloo | 17 hours ago

rkagerer | 17 hours ago

Well now I Hunger haben!

analog8374 | 17 hours ago

How do I put the bread on top?

tapland | 17 hours ago

Germany and scandinavia don't really do that, but still translate it to sandwich :)

larusso | 13 hours ago

What? I put bread on top and is still a “Stulle“. It’s called a “Klappstulle“. I guess this simulator needs an extension :)

analog8374 | 17 hours ago

Also, I can't seem to get condiments to go on anything but the foundational bread
good move, they can pitch it to potential investors as opportunities for expansion
Get out there, pitch it yourself, 4x your position and become nomnomnomnom
Only a reprobate spreads marmalade on a cheese slice.

You know, with the right cheddar…

analog8374 | 17 hours ago

Where's the kellergewölberäucherkammerwildschweinkräuterknoblauchbratwurst?

tapland | 17 hours ago

Hat off to whoever stacked 87 pickle slices.

This was really fun.

olelele | 4 hours ago

Thanks! I did two, the first one got 92 :)

olelele | 4 hours ago

A friend just posted nr 28.237 where he stacked 102 pickles

danjl | 16 hours ago

Internationalization is clearly non-trivial

ivanjermakov | 10 hours ago

It might've reached wider audience by mistake.

Aldipower | 10 hours ago

True, internationalisation is clearly non-trivial. SCNR

Tajnymag | 4 hours ago

True. That's why most of the usual stuff on Hacker News is only in English

b800h | 16 hours ago

Yikes, no Marmite, nor grated cheddar to go with it.

ideasphere | 16 hours ago

Toast Bär-Kiwi: https://stulle.app/16617

In honor of my favourite Wikipedia photo: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toast_Hawaii

lencastre | 11 hours ago

Wow,… needs caviar

Semaphor | 9 hours ago

Interesting, never heard of the cherry. The German wikipedia only lists it as common addition. I guess it might be regional

x______________ | 6 hours ago

Learned about this 10 months ago![0]

0 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46870739

rendx | 5 hours ago

In my family, we typically put a little cranberry jam in the middle.

wowczarek | 6 hours ago

As seen in the hit song by Alexander Marcus:

https://youtu.be/DHHAR1S_eKA

...well he exclusively makes hit songs. Kind of a modern, disco version of Helge Schneider. Less jazz, but even more quiet insanity.

geraneum | 5 hours ago

Lol one of the top comments under that video:

“Fun Fact: Es wurde dir nicht vorgeschlagen...du hast nach diesem Song gesucht !”

With enough condiments you can create a hole in the geometry: https://stulle.app/16862

modinfo | 13 hours ago

eosis | 11 hours ago

Why does that happen? Hmmmm...

adlotsof | 15 hours ago

Very dissappointed i cant cut the cheese in pieces to have exactly one layer of chese cover the complete bread

hb4ch | 15 hours ago

peak german cuisine

SeanAnderson | 15 hours ago

No hotdog bun? :(

ZYZ64738 | 14 hours ago

Missing most vegan options. maybe add a filter? (vegan, vegetarian, allergies, kosher, halal, martian, 40 Eridani A b)

https://stulle.app/17440

freak42 | 11 hours ago

Well, luckily everything you see is meat free! Ceci n'est pas un sandwich.

x3haloed | 14 hours ago

The tomato is so unnerving. Watching it slide over things before eventually vacuum-sealing itself to whatever is underneath. I think it's the slimey, bumpy testure and the pliability.

kenferry | 13 hours ago

I feel like I've learned something about Germany if gummy bears and potato chips are more normal sandwich toppings than lettuce.

em-bee | 8 hours ago

meat culture

jrrc_dev | 13 hours ago

I'd like to print it and eat it- maybe one day...

kepair | 13 hours ago

otherayden | 5 hours ago

:-)

gsoff | 13 hours ago

nice. i liked the gallery

ody4242 | 13 hours ago

please add carbohydrates/sugar/protein/calories/fat calculation :)

necovek | 12 hours ago

I know this is German Sandwich simulator, but with so many Balkan people in Germany, it needs "ajvar" as a topping too.

minmax2020 | 12 hours ago

wait do you guys actually put gummy bears in the sandwich

freak42 | 12 hours ago

The liverwurst is difficult to spread.
I feel like this might be Frog Fractions 3 somehow

the_wolo | 11 hours ago

A day in school: https://stulle.app/21003
If the author is reading this: please add guacamole, camembert and sriracha.

morsch | 8 hours ago

Mayo

Cockbrand | 7 hours ago

Also Fleischsalat, so we can recreate Stulli, das Pausenbrot.

neuroelectron | 11 hours ago

Certainly, they must put mustard on sandwiches in Germany

sevenzero | 10 hours ago

We do! It's great

rayoleary | an hour ago

They have a wonderful selection of mustards in Germany but Colman’s English if there is ham involved is a must

looperhacks | 11 hours ago

Spreading Nutella on butter doesn't make a horrible mess, totally unrealistic. 4/10

/s

dpangerl | 11 hours ago

There is no such thing as Nutella an butter! Never has been and never will be.

olelele | 3 hours ago

Oh you don’t know what you’re missing. Especially on hot toast so the butter melded first… the salt of the butter really adds something. OTOH I used to love dipping French from vanilla milkshake…

rayoleary | an hour ago

You sir are correct

siva7 | 10 hours ago

Could you please add asap an rss feed to the sandwich? My customer needs urgently this feature

TheTxT | 10 hours ago

Two ham slices, mirrored, a couple of structural pickles and a stabilizing piece of cheese per level can get you quite far:

https://stulle.app/22656

... but at a certain height it start to lag and the iPad gets very hot, eating through 1% of battery per minute.

srcoder | 9 hours ago

Just more cheese https://stulle.app/22707

dzogchen | 9 hours ago

That is not how jam spreads. Took me out of the immersion.

JassanSanjay | 9 hours ago

That was fun.

yukaka | 9 hours ago

Deutsche Qualität

thatslast | 9 hours ago

i want to spread on other ingredients

cheapcheerful | 9 hours ago

A distinct lack of dick sandwitches in the archive.

I can only conclude that we have already passed the first Age of Penii, and are merely awaiting the next.

Edit: needs vegemite! Edit 2: Yessssss it has BEGUN! Edit 3: Bit of a cockroach problem it seems, you need any help over there Germany?

worthless-trash | 9 hours ago

I also wanted vegemite.

Ylpertnodi | 4 hours ago

Marmite. Just thing of all the usa-people that have never had the [dis]pleasure. It's a love it, or hate it thing.

em-bee | 8 hours ago

i saw one :-|

movedx | 8 hours ago

Better than GTA 6.

momojo | 8 hours ago

This is good

getwiththeprog | 8 hours ago

After a dozen slices of cheese, things really began to hot up

matthiaskoller | 8 hours ago

Thanks for this. The kids had a lot of fun with it. Greetings from https://stulle.app/24698

tezza | 8 hours ago

If you like this offbeat humour, I humbly recommend https://vole.wtf/

This site has a plethora (nice word that) of curios

They even have a sandwich themed micro-site dedicated to crisp sandwiches: https://vole.wtf/crisp-sandwich-day/

andai | 7 hours ago

https://vole.wtf/glasses-cleaning/

lol. Reminds me of Wishy Washy Windows for the PS2 (a game you'd play with the webcam) except infuriating instead of satisfying.

wowczarek | 6 hours ago

Thank you for this link, kind Sir, this is perhaps what I've been looking for ever since rathergood.com stopped making their classic flash videos.

gwerbin | 6 hours ago

Linked on that site: https://datacenter.fm/

gitowiec | 8 hours ago

A lot of glitches on Firefox Android. Wonder why people developing web apps omit web standards, or broader compatibility?

greggsy | 7 hours ago

I agree. Web standards should always be front and centre of any developer, especially those developing sandwich simulators.

skeeter2020 | 5 hours ago

Yes why didn't the developer, who obviously is looking to maximize the commercial value of their _Sandwich Simulator_ not test extensively against a browser with < 1% global market share? Unacceptable!

diydsp | 2 hours ago

You're off by a factor of more than 3. [0]

And the answer is because privacy matters. Instead of being a follower, chasing everyone off of a cliff, be intentional. Give a damn.

[0] https://technologychecker.io/blog/firefox-market-share

moobsen | an hour ago

Works great on Fairphone 5 with e/OS and Fennec.

Maybe you just need a little beefier phone to fully enjoy this marvel of the bread sim genre?

:)

This is the most European thing I’ve ever seen on hacker news ever

czemuja | 8 hours ago

nice, should be in every digital menu for composing before ordering <3

andai | 7 hours ago

Delightful!

On mobile it doesn't let me rotate the cheese with 2 fingers? Aww!

(Also would be even cooler if cheese had ragdoll physics or what you call it. Cheese simulator...)

danecek099 | 7 hours ago

There is no onion!! What the hell

porori | 7 hours ago

I really wish I could make a 1kg marmalade sandwich.

doctor_radium | 6 hours ago

sandinmyjoints | 6 hours ago

Be sure to unmute, it compliments the experience nicely

derbOac | 6 hours ago

I know this is German but seeing the jam without an ability to add peanut butter was frustrating.

A lot of potential with this site.

staticBr | 6 hours ago

ah yes, peak german humor.

zach_moore | 6 hours ago

Whoever made this can you share the source code with me so i can modify it to return json?

kozar | 6 hours ago

I really should share my work more often. I have a similar experience named “World’s Best Sandwich”:

https://www.coreykozarski.com/sandwich/

huhtenberg | 5 hours ago

It is extremely laggy after adding two slices of bread and a dozen slices of prosciutto. 20 seconds later and they were still in the process of falling down.

kozar | 4 hours ago

Sorry about that! Are you on mobile by chance?

I do need to optimise it further for heavy toppings more, thank you for the reminder.

pumnikol | 4 hours ago

It's great! While not as photorealistic, yours has more options. Thank you so much!

kozar | 4 hours ago

TY! Any toppings that you wish you had available?

reaperducer | 3 hours ago

Weck.

mulhoon | 3 hours ago

The slicing is a nice touch. I'm hungry.
Thanks. I love sandwiches, so naturally I worked on this while I was hungry for a sandwich each day.

re slicing: It took a lot of self-control to not add a diagonal cross slice vs centre.

thefourthchime | 3 hours ago

I for one appreciate that you can have a bottom and top piece of bread.

metadat | 2 hours ago

Very cool, but also quickly becomes laggy as ingredients stack.
Sorry! A small fix has been released; should be a bit more responsive now.

goosejuice | an hour ago

The options for both reveal some interesting opinions on sandwiches!

rglover | an hour ago

Honestly prefer this version to OP. Shared it with some friends.
Enjoy! Friend with the highest stack should get their next sandwich covered for free :P
The simulator is nice, but the human creativity of those using it is amazing! I looked at sandwiches created by others and had many laughs.

beej71 | 4 hours ago

I wrote the Internet Pizza Server in 1994, and I'm truly impressed by the improvements in web-based simulated food technology that have taken place over the last three decades.

MPSimmons | 4 hours ago

The way the ham moves as you drag it disturbs me

olelele | 3 hours ago

There are a lot of comments here about stuff missing, but what about mettwurst!? (and sliced yellow onion of course)

baconbkr | 3 hours ago

This is eggcelent https://stulle.app/30921

rayoleary | an hour ago

Tolle
Needs more pineapple. I cannot make a Toast Hawaii.

ixxie | 3 hours ago

Its technically not a sandwich because you CANNOT PUT A SECOND SLICE OF BREAD ON TOP.

Also what the hell, no mayo!

[OP] subdomain | 3 hours ago

The sheet music for the theme is posted here: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/90xwh57kqrabh9wu6zg89/Stullen...

SamBam | 2 hours ago

This is excellent, and now I'm hungry for my liverwurst, butter, cheese, salami and pickle sandwich.

However, unfortunately there probably ought to be some moderation for the public photos. Currently on the first three pages there are swastikas, multiple hitler drawings, and a penis.

greg0r | an hour ago

Thanks! It is moderated: swastikas and Hitler drawings get removed, usually within the hour, and "Melden" at the bottom of each sandwich page reports one. The penises stay.

(I’m the creator of stulle.app)

an3223 | an hour ago

The attention to detail is fascinating, for instance the camera zooming out when the ingredients are stacked high enough!
came here to say the same... i stacked cucumbers until the camera zoomed out and then they started falling off on to the cutting board. very cool!

Druyf | an hour ago

I present to you: None Sandwich with Left Beef https://stulle.app/32681

As inspired by one of my favourite Tumblr posts of all time, None Pizza with Left Beef

maffyoo | an hour ago

WastedCucumber | 59 minutes ago

Another example of the central German sandwich paradox - this country has fantastic mustard, but will never put any of it on a sandwich, insisting istead on boring Brötchen

throwrioawfo | 40 minutes ago

https://stulle.app/34020 there's always one...

rayoleary | 34 minutes ago

It’s incomprehensible to me that butter works not be added to a sandwich

rayoleary | 33 minutes ago

* would