Norway to extend proposed under-16 social media ban to games and messaging apps

51 points by geox 4 hours ago on hackernews | 92 comments

gustavus | 4 hours ago

> "Children's safety must come first," said Lene Vågslid, Norway's minister for children and families, adding that the legislation was nearly complete.

> The restrictions aim to protect children from harmful content, addictive features, illegal advertising and unwanted contact from strangers.

I love "harmful content" what is harmful? Why anything that society deems is harmful. For example in the past issues included positive depictions of homosexuality, communism, today it is "racism" and "far right propaganda", who knows what the future will hold for "harmful and illegal content".

I am glad we have managed democracy though to protect us from the bad things in the world.

r_lee | 4 hours ago

don't worry, democracy and European freedom will make sure you are safe by making sure you only see fun and safe EU-approved content

imagine living 16 years just to still be blocked from accessing the internet properly. crazy

4ndrewl | 4 hours ago

Imagine thinking Norway is in the EU...

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

EEA members are subject to basically all EU laws with exceptions for agriculture and fishing...

simion314 | 4 hours ago

Yeah, is like we can't decide what is harmful, fuck even Facebook itself concluded they are doing harm but to protect freedom we should do nothing.

IMO people can gamble after 16. And we can have private protecting ways to prove we are adults if only Big Tech could bother implement a standard.

tosti | 4 hours ago

The Great Iconoclasm strikes again.

LoganDark | 4 hours ago

Unfortunately, democracy is still vulnerable to being torn down.

logicchains | 4 hours ago

European democracy is tearing itself down, and if it doesn't stop voting for anti-natal ideologies that continuously reduce the birthrate then it'll eventually go extinct and be replaced by some other culture where people have above-replacement-level fertility.

nsoam | 4 hours ago

Once you have a high standard of living you don’t want to have children because you have fruitful and fun things to do with your time. It’s got nothing to do with ideology.

logicchains | 4 hours ago

It's absolutely ideology. Israel has a birthrate around 3.0, as do e.g. Saudi and the UAE (among native Arabs, not among temporary migrants). And they have comparable GDP-per-capita to European countries (Israel and the UAE's are actually higher than those of most European countries).

ekianjo | 4 hours ago

of course not. this is clearly ideology

643thespark86 | 4 hours ago

Pray tell, what kind of ideology is so successful as to simultaneously cover the US, Russia, Europe, China, North and South Korea, Australia, India, and most of South America?

SV_BubbleTime | 3 hours ago

I mean… actual answer… globalism.

That you should offshore anything considered menial or undesirable to some poor person somewhere else. That you can have an economy without making anything just by shipping it in from somewhere else, making yourself now dependent on global economics, immigration, and being leveraged by forces that would normally have no effect on you.

rcxdude | 4 hours ago

What anti-natal ideologies do you mean, exactly?

shkkmo | 4 hours ago

Harmful is defined in the announcement linkes in the article.

(Using google translate)

> “The legislation is intended to address the full spectrum of risks children face on social media. This includes everything from exposure to harmful content and addictive features to illegal marketing and unwanted contact from strangers.

I actually think that protecting kids from illegal marketing, addictive features and unwanted contact with strangers is a pretty good idea.

While the censorship isn't great, it is also pretty much par for the course so throwing out (or ignoring as you did) these protections is throwing the baby out with the bath water.

okasaki | 4 hours ago

It just says harmful content again, doesn't define it.

method_capital | 4 hours ago

Don't worry ... just trust 'em.

rowanG077 | 4 hours ago

That's a circular definition. It doesn't actually say what they mean with harmful. they just restate it as harmful.

ajsnigrutin | 4 hours ago

But why not ban marketing to kids, those addictive features and restrict contact to "friends only"?

Like set the age of the account to <18, you get no ads, no infinite scroll etc. and no messages from random bots?

Why does it always have to be "all adults must show ID" instead?

thinkingtoilet | 4 hours ago

Hey look! Another totally disingenuous comparison made in bad faith! There is already mountains of evidence of how bad social media and phones are for kids. That is what is harmful here. It is obvious to anyone who is looking at this in good faith. Just like 14 year olds shouldn't buy weed and alcohol, they shouldn't have their attention span destroyed by tech billionaires who have armies of the smartest people in the world with no morals working every day to get them more addicted to their phones. This is very simple. And the law is a good one.

rokkamokka | 3 hours ago

It sounds like you're suggesting racism and far right propaganda will become something normal and accepted in the future...

gustavus | 3 hours ago

I'm pointing out that the current boogey man of the day changes pretty regularly and "harmful" is really just code for "ideas the government finds inconvenient or troublesome", which is always then used to crack down on dissent and portray people with unfashionable ideas as "dangerous" and "the enemy".

yalok | 4 hours ago

What about educational games??

Epa095 | 4 hours ago

Its not a general limit on games, but it says that a social network is not exempt just because it has a game on top (read: roblox).

Its also not actually law, this is a proposal.

hochpolitisiert | 4 hours ago

"The adults took away our Videogames."

A little OT, a bit ...but a Week ago, or maybe this week i think there was something about a Videogame, people talking, media, and i heard some elderly, saying that they won't play videogames, even if the graphics are realy good now.

probably satirical content: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3UwcdXSgm8

this video game is from 1991

g-b-r | 3 hours ago

That's so awesome, was the quality really that good in arcades?

I remember trying Mad Dog McCree on my pc, but the quality was pretty aweful there

zoobab | 4 hours ago

Nostr to the rescue.

egorfine | 4 hours ago

I am doing everything in my power to keep my kids online and connected.

notarobot123 | 4 hours ago

and unvaccinated too?
Sorry for your kids!

tarkin2 | 4 hours ago

Things that gets kids socialising and practising their verbal intelligence again are good in my book.

I believe we are past the point where we can assume a laissez-faire approach to what we subject children to will lead to robust, well-rounded societies.

Social division and the decline in verbal intelligence must be addressed for the sake of democracy.

logicchains | 4 hours ago

You need just as much verbal intelligence to type an argument as you do to speak it..

inetknght | 4 hours ago

Not with AI.

Avicebron | 4 hours ago

I think it's the quality, the collective we is moving towards tiktok levels of intelligence..

tarkin2 | 4 hours ago

Written and spoken arguments are learnt differently and exercise different skills. The latter is essential to society and democracy.

logicchains | 4 hours ago

Why is the latter essential? People communicate far more online about politics than they do face-to-face, and have far greater reach.

earthnail | 4 hours ago

It has been discussed at length during covid how much nonverbal communication is lost if you don’t meet in person.

There is a lot of value in meeting in person. Teaching young people how to communicate well in speech, and not just in writing, is thus very important.

card_zero | 2 hours ago

You forgot to say why. You only said:

* Very important

* There is a lot of value in it

* It can be lost

I'm not seeing the "thus".

lotsofpulp | 4 hours ago

If anything, the sound-bite and oral debate nonsense is a scourge on democracy. Try listening to the current US president’s spoken “arguments”.

A website with written justifications for political positions and responses to others’ claims about them and information such as voting history is far more information dense.

But in the end, good information and logical reasoning is not what wins most other humans’ hearts and minds, it’s making them feel what they want to feel.

InsidiousWombat | 4 hours ago

Not letting kids play online games isn't helping on that front
Can't have them kids organizing protests

hello_moto | 4 hours ago

Yep, can’t have Jan6 insurrection and deniability…

BlackRabbit1 | 4 hours ago

We also have to make them stop experimenting with electronics. Otherwise they will build decentralized Bluetooth messengers.

ajsnigrutin | 4 hours ago

EU solved this too.

We had a golden age of electronics coming, you had cheap electronics from aliexpress and AI for programming them...

Now you need a resistor, an LED and a cd2032 battery, all three together 2eur on aliexpress, and you get hit with 18eur of import tarrifs/fees by the EU.

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

This was mostly lobbied by Lidl/Kaufland so their Chinese trash aisles are more competetive BTW. Nothing to do with actual EU manufacturing (Which nicely got hit with bigger costs for ensuring proper cardboard disposal in every county you ship to. A static $XX000 cost to ensure only big companies can play)

maxrev17 | 4 hours ago

How’s about just protect them from advertising which makes their attention the value at any cost?

tyleo | 4 hours ago

I don’t get what you mean. Many of the social game platforms don’t make much revenue from advertising while also being a source of harm.

InsidiousWombat | 4 hours ago

That when there is no money there, there won't be so much push to hook children on it.

Remove gambling (whether lootboxes or more traditional ways) and ads and most of the predatory business models won't be interested with kids and teenagers

tyleo | 3 hours ago

The article isn’t just about predatory business models. Did you read the restrictions? This also covers harmful content and unwanted contact with strangers.

> The restrictions aim to protect children from harmful content, addictive features, illegal advertising and unwanted contact from strangers.

maxrev17 | 3 hours ago

Not to be at all dismissive but those feel like parenting issues for the most part. You can’t always protect from strangers nor harmful content. I get that some restriction is good but rotten.com and randoms online was a huge part of my childhood!

tyleo | 3 hours ago

So digital products have free rein to put harmful content in front of kids and it’s always “parenting issues” when they do?

This doesn’t seem true for anything else: guns, drugs, pornography. Why is it okay for digital spaces but not physical ones?

conception | 46 minutes ago

People forget, at least in the US, it used to be illegal to advertise to children until Reagan - the explosion of toys and shows that were just toy ads continues to this day.

tancop | 4 hours ago

I hope they start burning schools like France if the law passes.
In France they are burning more fire engines and people's shops and smashing public infrastructure.

That's not a protest.

Neither is burning schools.

lesspassiveobse | 4 hours ago

They don't care about the children whatsoever (except the Epstein gang). This is about having ADULTS verify to tie their identity to what they do online to crack down on anti-government opinions.

poly2it | 4 hours ago

Why is the solution to bad parenting always authoritarian control over the youth?

SV_BubbleTime | 4 hours ago

How about the textbook definition of slippery slope here?

You’re right, but the overall theme of authoritarians gonna authoritarian just shouldn’t be surprising. Only rarely are laws considered for their off paper consequences.

vincnetas | 4 hours ago

because you can be a good patent, but your kids go to school with kids of "bad" parents and you have no direct control of how they are raised. im speaking here in context of social media and phone use at school.

bartread | 3 hours ago

You don’t necessarily need it: phones are banned at the schools our kids attend by the schools themselves. Bad and irresponsible parents will still be bad and irresponsible but it does very much limit the impact on our kids. School leadership sometimes needs to take more initiative than they do instead of waiting on government to ham-fistedly spoonfeed them legislation.

bartread | 3 hours ago

Don’t forget: whilst offloading externalities onto ordinary citizens and small businesses rather than the large corporations and the elites in control of them who are actually the source of the problems.

ajsnigrutin | 4 hours ago

> The restrictions aim to protect children from harmful content, addictive features, illegal advertising and unwanted contact from strangers.

What is harmful content? Who defines this?

What not ban addictive features in general, not just for kids?

Why not ban illegal advertising (hey, it has "illegal" in it!)?

And how will they regulate who's a stranger and who isn't?

Let's be fair, 95% of kids social actitivies is on one of the few large social networks and a few messaging apps, maybe 20 in total. Just regulate those, ban all the dark patterns, and the world will be a much nicer place. (and I mean that for everyone, not just for kids).

Return social networks with content from people you follow, not random influences, return youtube with videos you want to watch, return search doing the actual search and not giving me anti-trump videos when i'm searching for super mario speedruns (yes, youtube), ban advertising alltogether on minor accounts, ban gambling (lootboxes, etc.), ban pay-to-win mechanics for minors (eg. games shouldn't offer any paid features to under 18 accounts at all.. hell, even i'll set my in-game age to 1yo if needed), etc.

With current regulation, the "protect the children" is turning into "adults, show your ID for everything".

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

Harmful content = disapproval of the Elite.

zkmon | 4 hours ago

Irrespective of how far this can be effectively enforced, I completely support this, because the direction, intent and willingness to do something about this - are all good. Children deserve to get their childhood back. It is better than not having any regulatory action.

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

I see you are preparing already for the future where they make you tie your real identity to your ycombinator account. I also fully support the government and the way the Epstein-adjacent politicians think about children all the time. No need to arrest me for wrongspeak.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

This is an acceptable future, if more of you had your real identity tied to your account you wouldn't act like antisocial psychopaths all the time, or at least there'd be some consequences for it.

SV_BubbleTime | 3 hours ago

You have no idea the censorship and information silo you are begging for. Your “goals” lead to effectively slavery in a generation.

Looking at people in dictatorships and cults… the number one limit is placed on information.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

Yes I do, I've been observing the same arguments for over 10 years now. I've seen every argument for and against censorship, and I've seen empirically how the countries with least of it have all but destroyed their social fabric, and I've made an evidence-based conclusion to support it (and obviously there are nuances in my opinion that aren't appropriate for a casual forum discussion). Cheers.

kakacik | 3 hours ago

One can't expect even smart folks to understand / have empathy in topics when their fat paychecks and feeling of accomplishment and self-worth are directly depending on such behavior (when talking about anonymous users like SV_BubbleTime ). Parents of small kids have often vastly different opinion in this.

I wish strongly we could have this anarchy with absolutely free information and somehow it would work out for the better. I believe we did have it for some time but here we are. Then I talk to many folks with sub-standard IQ and they literally need their opinions to be served to them on plate, in very simplistic manners, the more emotions the better.

The surface for abuse is simply massive as trump and similar folks have showed. I lost my faith this would lead to better future for us all, not with current version of mankind out there. Impossible IMHO.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

This is exactly it, I really wanted total anonymity before, I don't know who wouldn't want a world like that pre-2016, but the evidence of exploitable loopholes as well as the magnitude of their effects is just too overwhelming and grows by the day. A more balanced approach is needed at least.

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

Why not just require a licence/CS degree to sign an ISP contract :)

Asraelite | 3 hours ago

The effects of loss of privacy on democracy take several decades to play out fully.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

I never even said there would be no consequences to a loss of privacy, nor did I advocate for East German style repression, I really just made a soft argument for de-anonymisation of social media being net positive and that's it.

Asraelite | 3 hours ago

I'm saying 10 years isn't nearly enough time to see why that isn't actually a net positive.

dreambuffer | 2 hours ago

Ok I get you but I would disagree with the implied premise, I was operating from the premise that the internet's problems are largely a result of too much anonymisation, not too little. I guess it depends where you look.

g-b-r | 3 hours ago

Sure, that's exactly how it went on Facebook (that has required real identities since the beginning).

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

Are you suggesting that society isn't perfect and there exist antisocial elements!?!? A police squad will show up shortly to escort you to the meat grinder.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

"Isn't perfect" is just a dampening phrase you've conveniently chosen in a self-serving way. A proper accounting of all evidence suggests that society is increasingly miserable because of antisocial elements. The second and third order effects are way worse than just "isn't perfect".

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

The statement was a satire on how a government may want to dispose of you for any sort of criticism. For example, you mentioning antisocial people may be interpreted as an attack on their authority/control. (The government is perfect and the society under its control is also perfect, so stating that bad elements exist means saying that the government isn't perfect) This may seem far fetched for you but people died for looking at officials the wrong way in some countries.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

Yes even most children aged 11 and up understand the concept of officials repressing their populations, which is why it's such an effective thought-terminating propaganda device. Regardless, the truth is a lot more nuanced and warrants proper discussion, I don't think it falls to cheap gotchas which I've seen repeated over and over again on this site.

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

Standard "Shades-of-grey" reply from people who think denying the existence of good and evil makes them sound smart. Have fun getting made into soylent, or getting executed with an AA-cannon like in North Korea. Even if you plan to be a good little citizen, you will make a misstep sooner or later.

dreambuffer | 2 hours ago

Are you... coming out against the concept of nuance, gradients, and tentative thought in general?

I mean, okay. On the free internet, you're allowed to say whatever you want even if it isn't true, I guess.

gustavus | 3 hours ago

What's funny is that almost all of the problems brought about by the Internet only came to pass after people started tying their real identities to their online personas.

dreambuffer | 3 hours ago

Can you name what you think the problems with the internet are? In my accounting of things, most of the problems with the internet come from bot farms, which only exist because no one has to prove they are who they say they are. The problem would be even worse under a maximal anti-censorship regime because you wouldn't even be allowed to track bot behaviour because it might reveal PII or something.

iamnothere | 31 minutes ago

Or the “antisocial psychopaths” will start leaving a flaming bag of dog shit on your porch instead of replying to you, once they have your real identity.

Freedom of speech, not freedom from consequences, amiright?

It’s insane that you think this would be an improvement.

g-b-r | 3 hours ago

If you instead stopped to think of how this has to be enforced, you'd have probably realized that the negative consequences (outlawing of anonymous communication for everyone) are going to outweigh by far any positive outcome for the children.
I'm fine if they ban network connected games. I honestly don't mind them blowing the crap out of demons and pulling people's spines out of their bodies but the popular ones among those age groups are almost universally a problem for society, pushing microtransactions, grinding, gambling and their own corporate scrip. There is zero motor or skill development in such things, just mindless servitude and building addiction.

Messaging is a disaster as well until they have some maturity. I've seen and had to get involved in some awful crap including bullying, organising fights and trying to get other kids in trouble by reporting them to the police for stuff they didn't do. The schools and the parents have to get involved all the time.

And yes I have three kids who have been through that age transition, one before the rise of this mess and two after. The before was much better for the kids. Way better.

I'm not sure we can go back but we should give them a chance to learn these things without the machine being in the mediator of everything. It makes them better people in the long-run.

tyleo | 3 hours ago

I’ve done work on the moderation side and I agree. We’re basically asking random mods to be the arbitrators of harms to children.

As it stands it feels like less safe games can get more users. I feel like that’s a bad incentive. It’s the sort of tragedy of commons which I think governments are most equipped to solve.

jonathanstrange | 3 hours ago

I wouldn't mind any of this if the respective countries offered an entirely free and running age verification service with zero knowledge proof structure so developers don't have to pay a single cent out of their own pocket for it and no personal information is leaked.

What I'm worried about is when countries come up with Draconian regulations with zero intentions of providing the means to comply with them, so that in the end only megacorporations can do it.

lesspassiveobse | 3 hours ago

There is no way to make this kind of system anonymous. Otherwise one bad actor can set up Age-Verification-As-a-Service API and sign requests for everyone including children. This should be rejected at every level. Privacy of electronic messaging needs to be protected at least as much as paper-mail is, not less.
There is something incredibly paternalistic about the government not trusting parents with making choices for the kids, to the point of not even allowing them to choose the games their kids play, or how they communicate with their friends and family. Using a murky legal definition of what's allowed and what isn't.

On top of that, the fact that it essentially require age verification from everyone using these platform, creates an additional big privacy risk.

I'm also surprised by how old this law applies. One of the "purposes" of childhood is to make mistakes and learn in a safe environment so that you grow into a responsible adult. If you are so sheltered, when would you make the mistakes? When no one has the authority to help you anymore?

tyleo | 3 hours ago

Governments make other choices for kids like not letting them get jobs, drink, or smoke and requiring school. Why are some choices for kids okay but this one isn’t? Or do you think they are all bad?

I don’t personally know how to draw this line but I do feel like one exists.

kakacik | 3 hours ago

There are mistakes that have high chances of permanent damage. Would you argue that kids having fun with fentanyl under adult supervision is much better life experience than having no such exposure during childhood?

There are many fentanyls these days for bodies and minds and kid's minds are very a) fragile, b) get into addictive self/reinforcing patterns very quickly. Just look at how average teen's life looks like now compared to say 30 years ago. Higher (or even equal) happiness ain't there.

The best path is, as always, somewhere in the middle. Having no fentanyl and no social networks till say 15-16 is the middle path. Not something corporations like to see of course and they push and lobby against this intensively, but they position themselves directly against humanity's greater good, having their own profit as the only goal.