Doesn't explain what's incorrect or how it should be measured correctly.
The GOP is a confidence scheme
> Confidence schemes rely on psychological manipulation rather than brute force. They exploit human traits such as greed, compassion, naivety, vanity, and the desire to trust.
Americans voted in the most parasitic president this nation has ever seen and when they saw the tax cuts for the parasite billionaires, they said let's do it again
That part is still the most moronic thing that has happened in the lifetime of the USA.
Trump 2016-2020 was an absolute shitshow of a presidency. A complete failure, no matter how you measure. Then you got Biden, who did an admirable job, despite being an old white man looking out for the establishment. But during his time, the government got more done for the US people than any president in living history. (If that sounds crazy you just missed all the useful stuff he did because it was a quiet presidency.)
And then they elected Trump again. It's like they cut themselves while cooking badly enough to go to the hospital, and then four years later they grabbed the knife and stabbed themselves in the stomach, on purpose. Like, what the fuck, guys? WHY?!
And we'll do it again... All the Republican cuts to education make us so vulnerable to the laziest and stupidest cons.
The next president has a hell of a difficult road ahead, not to mention Trump basically emptied the national oil reserves, giving it away almost free, so he "wouldn't look bad about high oil prices", so that's a reckoning coming soon. AI bubble will bust. Trump's "Big Beautiful Bill-ionare giveaway" is just about to start.
When things aren't "perfect" after the next 7 years of fixing this mess, it will be very easy to sell hate and blame again to the uneducated.
They've been told what to think by their 'community leaders' and they don't have the critical reasoning skills to refute any of it. And thinking is such hard work! Will you do it for me plz!? OK thx so much! You wouldn't lie to me, though would you? No! Just checking! Phew! K. Let's go!
Head over to the presidential rankings wiki page. Sienna, C-Span, and APSA all put trump in the bottom 5 for just his first term. They ranked William Henry Harrison higher and he was only president for a month before he died plus James Garfield who was only president for 6 months. Stew on that. Two guys who, combined, were in office less than a year both ranked higher than trump.
Then the nation decided to put him back into office. The man who was already considered one of the worst presidents in our history, and we say "well, let's give him another chance." I'm interested to know what that will do to his rankings.
As I said in other comments: Trump is the worst POTUS in the history of the country, and it's not even close.
When Nixon looks like a good choice in comparison, then you know it's bad. Because at least Nixon did only a little treason, it wasn't a daily occurrence.
Did more for the people than FDR? No way. Social Security, unemployment insurance, minimum wage, taxing the rich and corporations appropriately. Or did you mean more recently, in which case I agree.
The problem with Biden (and most other establishment Democrats for that matter) is that they upheld the status quo, which if you have been paying attention lately, only works out for the top earners of this country. It’s a prime environment for grifters like Trump to take advantage of.
Established $15 minimum wage for Federal workers and contractors
Companies have announced nearly $300 billion in manufacturing investments in the United States
Enacted the Inflation Reduction Act, which lowers costs for families, combats the climate crisis, reduces the deficit, and finally makes the largest corporations pay their fair share
Near record low unemployment rates for the Hispanic and African-American communities
Record low unemployment rate for people with disabilities
Infrastructure
Infrastructure investments in all 50 states, D.C., territories, and throughout Tribal nations, to rebuild or add new highways, bridges, and rail.
Led the world in a historic release of strategic reserves.
Over 16 million households receiving lower cost or free high-speed internet through the Affordable Connectivity Program.
Public Health and Healthcare
Lowered seniors’ health care expenses, including capping out-of-pocket expenses on prescription drugs for seniors at $2,000 per year, ensuring that people enrolled in Medicare will not pay more than $35 for a month’s supply of insulin, and recipients will receive free vaccines.
Hosted the first White House Conference on Hunger, Nutrition, and Health in over 50 years and released a National Strategy to end hunger and reduce diet-related diseases and disparities by 2030.
Four out of five people who sign up for health insurance through the Affordable Care Act can find health care coverage for $10 a month or less, and millions of Americans on Obamacare are saving an average of $800 a year.
Combined 50 percent increase in enrollment in states that use HealthCare.gov and the nation’s uninsured rate is historically low at 8 percent.
Over 16 million Americans signed up for quality, affordable health coverage, the highest number ever produced in an open enrollment period.
Signed the PACT Act, the most significant expansion of benefits and services for toxic exposed veterans in more than 30 years
Defended reproductive rights by signing Executive Orders to protect access to reproductive health care and taking action against state or local officials who attempt to interfere with women exercising their constitutional right to travel out of state for medical care.
International Relations and National Security
Rallied the world to support the people of Ukraine, imposing unprecedented economic costs against Russia and securing bipartisan support at home to deliver critical assistance for Ukraine.
Strengthened America’s alliances and partnerships to advance our interests and values, including strengthening NATO, deepening security and economic partnerships in the Indo-Pacific, and building coalitions to solve shared challenges across the world.
Took key leaders of ISIS and Al Qaeda off the battlefield, defending the American people against terrorism.
Environmental Stewardship
Rejoined the Paris Agreement on day one to reassert the United States global leadership to combat the climate crisis.
Jumpstarted the American offshore wind industry and convened the nation’s first federal-state offshore wind partnership.
Accelerated adoption of electric vehicles by reducing costs for families, jumpstarted the first national EV charging network, and made historic investments into EV batteries and materials.
Set new policies to reduce super pollutants like HFCs and methane to protect communities and reduce emissions fueling climate change.
Restored protections for Bears Ears, Grand Staircase-Escalante, and Northeast Canyons and Seamounts National Monuments and designated Camp Hale-Continental Divide National Monument to conserve our lands and waters, honor our nation’s veterans, protect Tribal cultural resources, and support jobs and America’s outdoor recreation economy.
Awarded more than $1 billion to initiate cleanup and clear the backlog of 49 previously unfunded Superfund sites, over $250 million to clean up hundreds of contaminated brownfield sites and $725 million for abandoned mine lands.
Safety
Signed legislation to put more cops on the beat and invest in community policing.
Signed legislation to reauthorize and strengthen the Violence Against Women Act.
Signed an Executive Order on Improving Public Safety and Criminal Justice for Native Americans and Addressing the Crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous People.
Signed the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, the first major piece of gun safety legislation in three decades.
Signed a landmark executive order on safe, effective, and accountable policing, mandating federal reforms and strengthening public safety and public trust.
Equality and Justice
Invested historic funding for Tribal governments and Native communities.
Signed historic executive orders to advance equity and racial justice, leading to bold action to narrow the racial wealth gap, invest in communities facing persistent poverty, deliver racial justice, and reform criminal justice.
Signed legislation protecting marriage for same-sex and interracial couples and advancing full equality for LGBTQI+ Americans.
Appointed a record number of women and people of color to serve in his Administration.
Nominated and confirmed Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, the first Black woman to serve on the Supreme Court, along with a record number of diverse judicial appointees.
Initiated the process to review how marijuana is scheduled under federal law and pardoned all prior federal offenses of simple marijuana possession.
Education and Debt Relief
Increased the maximum value of Pell Grants by $900.
More than 40 million borrowers stand to benefit from student debt relief.
Announced debt relief for Americans earning less than $125,000 per year who had Pell Grants in college, and up to $10,000 for all other borrowers below that income threshold.
Early 2023, announced a plan to provide millions of borrowers with more affordable monthly student loan payments through changes to income-driven repayment plans.
The problem with Biden is that the right-wing owns the mainstream media and Biden wasn't good at getting around that by using social media to publicize his achievements.
Thats a problem with democrats in general. But that then is linked to a problem with intelligent debate.
The republican party is built on propaganda and lies. The key to this is making everything about fear and one sentence talking points. Repeat ad nauseum. Brain wash the simple folk.
Intelligent people try to refute misinformation and propaganda with hour long TED talks and evidence. The people they are trying to reach however don't like to think deeply. They like to be told what to do and think.
The "American Rescue Plan" expanded the child tax credit and lowered child poverty; it also saved the pensions of two million union workers and retirees.
The "Social Security Fairness Act" expanded Social Security benefits for the first time in two decades.
Raised the minimum wage for federal workers.
Removed medical debt from credit reporting.
Forgave student loans for millions.
Expanded overtime eligibility for salaried workers.
Drove through legislation that invested in infrastructure, clean energy, clean water, etc.
Cracked down on junk and overdraft fees.
The "Respect for Marriage Act" codifies recognition of same-sex marriages into law, prohibiting bigot-run states from refusing to respect the marriage rights of individuals married in other states.
This barely scratches the surface of everything Biden did for regular people. He was the best fucking president we've had since Truman.
To be on the outside looking in was a really weird experience.
Trumps first term basically made a whole lot of us go "okay, thats the last fucking straw, enough is enough, you can fuck right off now!".
Then biden got a term and we were "well, you made your bed now sleep in it".
Then trump fucking got re-elected and within nano-seconds the bed was covered in feces, urine and spiders for some weird reason.
I truly do not think the people of usa understand the politics that has already been set in motion. The divesting from usa is real and its not about not "relying" on usa anymore, its about not "partnering" with usa.
But divesting from usa takes a lot of work and a lot of time. The results will probably not really be felt for another 5 years, but the next couple of decades arent going to be fun for usa.
I have a worry/suspicion that once the divesting starts to really take form, usa will cry foul and insist we are betraying them.
Hate, Ethaniel. White Trump voters hate-voted him in because they wanted him to harm the gays, the hijabwearers, the blacks, the browns, the trans people, etc etc.
And if the price of that was a reduction in their living standards, so be it, they reckoned.
Some 30% of the population has decided that preservation of white supremacy is their number one issue and that the biggest drop in their living standard ever was listening to a black man be their President
Bernie failed to connect with non-white voters over 30 by a staggering margin. He never had a real shot at securing the nomination and when we was mathematically eliminated he still continued his campaign for a time. That’s why we have the phrase “Here’s how Bernie can still win” in our lexicon.
I’m as anti-Trump/pro-boring “let’s just enact good policy” as the next guy, and that was a massive Biden glaze. The guy did OK, the U.S. economy is what performed.
Google what Biden got through. It's really shocking how much he outperformed anyone in the last 50 years. Infrastructure, education, research, health, it's all present. Obama did less in 8 years than Biden in 4.
I thought he would be awful but in hindsight he was great. It's frankly a bit insane how everyone keeps shitting on Biden when he did an objectively good job except for the terrible failed handover.
Edit for visibility: Rank the presidents of the USA in your life time, and be surprised where Biden ends up. Here's mine: Biden, Obama, Clinton, Bush Jr., Bush Senior, [Nixon oops he was way earlier], Reagan, Trump. It's a list of three monsters, three normal people, and two questionable choices in the middle.
I got an auto- warning on my account for what I JUST posted here and I'm appealing it. I am absolutely NOT having my account warned by describing the xeonphobia, bigotry and stupidity I live around!
Can people acknowledge that every election Trump has run in has had very clear criminal interference and outright theft of votes? The only reason Biden won in 2020 was because COVID made mail in voting much easier, allowing the sheer number of voters to cancel out the theft?
That means to express an opinion. You probably meant "pine", but you're a Russian or Israeli bot, so it don't matter too much in the grand scheme of things.
People in this country always vote for tax cuts without understanding these cuts massively favor the rich. The people of North Carolina just voted to amend their constitution, stripping local municipals from setting their own property tax rates, and capping property tax and income tax.
"They'll totally make jobs, and totally pay us competitive wages, and totally not price gouge us. Trust us, bro. Billionaires are philanthropists. I saw one donate to a charity on the news one time."
It took more than 40 years of Republicans decimating education and propagandizing the news to get the deep dumbness they needed to cement their power but make no mistake. They have seriously manipulated events and or outright cheated really hard to get themselves into power going back at least to Nixon.
Nixon: scuttled peace talks that would have ended the Vietnam war in 69, just so he could run as a wartime president
1979 Reagan's team got in touch with the Iranian terrorists that Carter was successfully negotiated a hostage release from and made a deal that if they didn't release them they'd be sold illicit weapons off the books which they did and was the opening move of the Iran Contra scandal and launched Reagan into the Whitehouse.
Not sure what fuckery was done in 88 but there's no way we had an organic election
2000 W Bush who did not win the electoral or popular votes was propelled into office through a series of underhanded judicial steps, a staged riot and was eventually just appointed even though the votes weren't there.
2004 they started heavily using wholesale disenfranchisement techniques, preventing a few million votes from being counted in strategically targeted areas.
This move has been used each election cycle since, with increasing numbers. Dems need to win by a landslide to overcome this shit. Obama did, twice but it worked in 2016 and in 2024 where there was also a huge number of conveniently timed bomb threats at key polling locations plus whatever ratfucking Elon did in every single swing state.
Hillary Clinton and Harris both beat Trump and it wasn't even particularly close the Republican cheat machine is well funded and deeply entrenched at every level of our society from Sheriffs all the way up the chain plus armies of paid influencers and having every news and social media outlet under their complete or near complete control
There was something like 3.5 and 4.2 million votes that were legally/illegally (mostly illegally) challenged and thrown out. That alone was enough to tip the scale but there's also whatever Elon did in swing states where Trump supposedly won hard but downballot voting didn't match at all. Then there was the bomb threats that prevented 10's of thousands (100's of thousands?) from voting in key polling places.
Greg Palast has been documenting the ways Republicans have been stealing elections since 2000. He's a credible investigative journalist. https://www.gregpalast.com/trump-lost-vote-suppression-won/
No, the central claims in Greg Palast’s article “Trump Lost. Vote Suppression Won.” do not hold up against the official 2024 data.
Palast asserts that routine voter-list maintenance, ballot verification, and challenges “wrongly” suppressed millions of votes (disproportionately from voters of color), and that without this Harris would have won the popular vote by ~1.2 million and the Electoral College with 286 votes by carrying Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Georgia. Official U.S. Election Assistance Commission (EAC) Election Administration and Voting Survey (EAVS) figures for 2024, plus certified results, show the specific numbers are inflated or mischaracterized, and the causal leap to a flipped outcome is not supported. 
Official baselines vs. Palast’s figures
Certified popular-vote totals: Trump ~77.3 million (49.8%), Harris ~75.0 million (48.3%), margin ~2.3 million. Electoral votes: Trump 312, Harris 226. Swing-state margins were narrow (Wisconsin ~0.9%/29k votes, Michigan ~1.4%/80k, Pennsylvania ~1.7%/120k, Georgia ~2.2%/115k). 
EAC 2024 EAVS (100% response from states/territories):
• List maintenance/removals (2022–2024 close of registration): 21.3 million records removed. Largest categories: failure to return a confirmation notice and not voting in two consecutive federal elections (~33.5%, roughly 7.1 million); moved out of jurisdiction (~30.8%, roughly 6.5 million); deceased and other reasons make up the rest. States also sent nearly 39–40 million confirmation notices. This is standard NVRA list maintenance, not a secret purge of eligible voters. 
• Palast’s “4,776,706 voters were wrongly purged” is a selective subset of the postcard/inactive category, labeled “wrongly” without evidence that the people removed were eligible and still residing in the jurisdiction. Many such removals are legitimate (moved, deceased, long inactive).
• Mail ballots: ~48 million returned; ~584,000–585,000 rejected (1.2% rate). Most common reasons: non-matching signatures (~41%) and other clerical issues. Palast’s “no less than 2,121,000 mail-in ballots were disqualified” is roughly 3.6× the actual number. He appears to extrapolate from older MIT/NPR figures (including unreturned ballots) rather than 2024 EAVS data. The 1.2% rate was higher than 2020/2016 presidential cycles but lower than recent midterms. 
• Provisional ballots: ~1.74 million issued; ~1.28 million counted (at least in part); ~436,000 rejected. Palast’s “1,216,000 provisional ballots were rejected” is nearly 3× the official figure. The most common rejection reason is the voter was not registered in that jurisdiction. 
• Registration transactions rejected: ~2.84 million (about 3% of transactions processed). Palast’s “3.24 million new registrations were rejected” is in the ballpark but still high. Rejections include incomplete forms, duplicates, ineligibility, and validation failures—not solely suppression.
• “Vigilante” challenges: True the Vote/IV3 claimed ~317,886 challenges submitted by August 2024 (matching their own statements). Election officials across multiple states reported that the large majority were already addressed (inactive status, prior notices), lacked reliability, or were rejected. Courts have previously criticized similar True the Vote lists as “shoddy,” “rife with error,” and lacking reliability. They did not produce the mass removals of eligible voters Palast implies.
Palast’s “at least 585,000 ballots cast in-precinct were also disqualified” aligns numerically with the mail-rejection total, suggesting a labeling or double-counting issue rather than a separate verified category.
The outcome claim
Even granting that ballot rejections, provisional use, and list maintenance can have disparate impacts (some studies, including Brennan Center analyses, document higher rates for certain demographic groups), the scale required to flip the four states plus the popular vote is not shown by the EAC numbers. Palast’s “2.3% suppression factor” and assumption that the net effect would have given Harris another 3.565 million votes (overwhelmingly Democratic) is an extrapolation, not a direct accounting from verified eligible voters prevented from casting countable ballots.
Restrictive voting laws passed after 2020 exist (Brennan Center tracked dozens), and signature-matching, drop-box limits, and challenge processes can create friction. Those are real policy debates. They do not, on the official data, equate to millions of eligible votes discarded in a way that reverses the certified result.
In short: several of Palast’s headline numbers are substantially larger than the corresponding EAC totals, the “wrongly” framing is not supported for the bulk of list-maintenance removals, and the claim that suppression alone produced Trump’s victory is not established by the evidence.
The poorest, stupidest people I know were all saying the same stupid fucking phrase in 2024
“I’d like to unburden what has been” when voting for Trump.
All of them have gotten poorer and probably even more fucking dumb since then and mysteriously none of them have said anything about the economy recently. Or anything at all. It’s almost like these morons don’t pay attention to politics until a meme tells them which way to vote
We didn't. A group of them did and the electoral college stole the rest of our agency. Without the electoral college, the rapist fuck wouldn't have ever been president.
People in general have no fucking clue about the economy. At all.
Even extremely basic and readily available numbers like the fact that the current federal debt's gross interest cost alone (i.e. ~$1.35T which must be paid out every year) not only dwarfs defense spending, it's fully 25% of all federal revenue, or ~20% when looking at net cost.
That's the highest level in the post-WW2 era, eclipsed only by debt service levels immediately after WW1 and WW2, which you'd expect in those circumstances. That's a problem. Not only that, but there's virtually no chance the debt ceiling won't rise again in Q1 2027, even under Democrat control.
This number alone should petrify American voters, but I'll bet anything 90%+ of them have no clue about the above numbers.
Look, I get it. In 2016, if you were a Republican, you weren't going to vote for Clinton, and Trump was your only option. But I can't, and never will, understand how they could watch him flail and fail and then lie to their faces, and still vote for him again in 2020.
We have the ability to get out of this, but not the will. I feel like even if we break the deficit, we won't break the debt. We'll have to put forwards over 1 trillion dollars a year and that amount of political willpower doesn't exist in a divided chamber. Maybe in 28, but by then I really worry our credit rating will be lowered by more than just one agency and our interest rates will look more like 1.25 or 1.5 trillion
Our local elevator wasn't able to move any sorghum this past year, other than some to a local feed lot. They were the only one accepting the crop, and that was for maybe 5 days before they were full.
Anyone that was late had to chop for feed, though honestly this year it'd probably pay better.
High diesel prices, dwindling markets, and full storage will really put a squeeze on the rural economy this upcoming year.
Yeah that deal with China screwed our farmers hard, that one wasn't entirely on us either. They know they have the leverage when it comes to American farmers because they're our largest market. Increasing Russian imports into China lessened their need too, along with expanding farmland and recovering yields after a few bad years since 2021. When the war in Ukraine ends too, that's an additional 17% wheat, rye, etc grains coming back into the market without additional insurance and transportation costs, as well as coming back to the global south easier.
We need to get ahead of the curve and grow something more useful: hemp. We could change the Farm Bill to give incentive to grow it, add addendums to fuel burning plants to allow them to burn compressed waste bricks from stalks, and give an incentive to allow it to be added to concrete. Hempcrete has a lot of benefits and uses a waste product, at scale it's a win for internal circular economics that's better than corn ethanol. We'd have competition from SE Asia, but they don't actively export much at all because there isn't an export market for it yet. Hemp can be used just like cotton, can be compressed into plywood like material that's stronger than plywood, and the already mentioned concrete additive. I don't think there's a market for the leaves really, sort of, because if the interstate regulations behind it. But that's just a regulatory hurdle, not a logistical or demand constricted hurdle.
We have to be concerned about the corn market as well, with ethanol becoming less and less profitable eventually the corn market will have to compensate, as well as corn syrup consumption dropping. I don't know about the animal feed side of things on price, but if we increase herd sizes like we need to then that's at least a relief valve for the market, assuming good weather gives us enough water
Talking to some rural MAGA there's this idea that thry believe the city folk need them more than the other way around. They seem to think if everyone starts to suffer, they'll somehow ride it out because "we're tougher".
Nah, we're all fucked together. Your crops ain't worth shit if the city folk can't package, ship, process, and sell it overseas.
MAGA people in general massively overestimate their "rugged American independence"
All of the Red State economies rely on federal money that is generated by the much more competent, much more successful Blue States. They scream about welfare queens but if the states cut off funding to each other the red states would collapse almost instantly.
It's rural areas supported by cities. It doesn't matter what color your state is. A month ago they said Georgia was red and therefore was red state with red. Now George it is blue with blue state is Blue.
No matter what color you want to ascribe whether it's red or purple or green or whatever, the cities generate the money
It's true, but its more pronounced in traditional heavy red states because republican policy makes it worse. Pick any quality of life metric you want and compare state rankings, the same pattern repeats across all of them
.
Again, pick any ranking of all 50 states in any method you choose, and there's a distinct pattern. I'm sure Atlanta is great, but outliers don't make a trend.
OK. A lot of states just changed which party runs it. I'm not sure how that factors into your statement, because momentarily many red states are about to be blue so the color chart won't work.
>Its more pronounced in traditional heavy red states because republican policy makes it worse.
That's why I said "traditional" heavy red states. These states have had decades of GOP control and it will take a lot of time to undo that damage. Mississippi is not going to contend with Massachusetts for decades because it's going to take that long to un-fuck everything. That doesn't mean it's somehow the Democrats fault that these states aren't successful immediately on the first day they take power.
I mean not really, our consumer market won't go away, our ability to produce will so we'll keep importing like usual. The majority of the world is also divesting out of our Treasury bonds, derisking their own currencies in the event that the dollar changes in value too much. With the bond market being as it is too, more countries are taking bonds with each other and investing in tangible assets like gold with Russians massive selloff flooding the gold market internationally.
The world is trying to insulate us, because they don't trust us. They might not do as badly as you think
20 years ago maybe. BRICS exists. The world has been decoupling from our fading empire since 2016, repatriating gold, rearming, committing to new trade partners. Face it son, this is not the post WWII America anymore.
Ignoring the exceptionalism/centralism in your thinking, yes everyone goes down when a large part of the global economy takes a dump. That is true for every large trading block. the US had to bail out Japan to prevent themselves from chocking on debt increases. So the reverse for even a 'small' market as Japan is just as true. If Japan goes down, so does the US.
But it is likely that the landing will be way softer for the other parties than some historical examples where the US had the benefit. You must not forget that since 2008 many global banks had stricter legislation put onto them. A global banking crisis isn't likely anymore. Moreover, the rich consumption market of the US is not as big (relative) as it used to be. The historical second and third world are becoming consumers too.
What's more, the US is way more dependent on foreign investment than vice versa. A dump in US markets frees up capital for other markets. Eurozone alone dumps €300 billion in the US every year. If that flow stops or even reverses, the eurozone is pretty happy. Not in the first shock, but after a few years. The same for other markets.
This! The interest on the debt is the killer. We spend more on interest than on defense now. The tax cuts didn’t help the spending problem. And there’s enough fingers to point to everyone I Washington on that.
A quarter of the debt thanks to the Bush / Trump tax cuts? Great.
A fun thought experiment I like to do is think about who owns the federal debt. Lots of 401k and institutional investors, sure. But also a lot of rich guys. So not only did they get their taxes cut, now they can use that savings to buy more government debt and siphon even more money off of the working class.
The rich own the lawmakers, so taxing them can't happen.
Eating them requires that a very large number of people are ok with risking their children being parentless and starving homelessly in order to do so. Things are rough, but they're not that rough yet.
We don't even need to tax them that much. 0.14% on the top 1% by wealth could replace income tax on the bottom 50% earners. Hell make it 1% and we could more than eliminate income tax for 90% of American workers.
Stop taking everything out of workers' share of the pie.
Right. People complain "the wealthy can't possibly pay tax on their obscene wealth"... but they already pay for a ton of other shit using that wealth, without crashing the stock market or whatever other boogeyman the bootlickers bring up.
Are there potential macroeconomic flaws I'm not seeing? Sure. But the economy isn't working for most people any more. You can't fix this disaster without a little risk, and taxing the wealthy seems like the smallest risk we can take.
The poorest household in the 1% has $14M, incidentally.
> could replace income tax on the bottom 50% earners
At the federal level the US has one of the most progressive tax systems in the world. The bottom 40% of earners have a negative federal income tax rate.
The bottom 80% of earners pay about 10% of all income taxes. The top 20% pay the rest.
Source: CBO data on taxes here: https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2024-09/60341-supplemental-data.xlsx Look at Tab 12. Use row 266 to see data for the top 20% before Covid.
That workbook I linked also has information just for the top 1% and you can see that they paid 31% of all the income taxes collected by the federal government. They can't have done that if they didn't have income.
Dig into the data a little bit there and tell me where I'm wrong
A lottt of brainwashing has convinced millions of people that they should defend billionaires because they’ve earned it and everyone else is simply lazy trash and that’s why they aren’t rich. The people believing this are usually uneducated and struggling themselves or just ignorant and privileged.
The funny/sad thing is that taxing Americans now at this late stage will do absolutely nothing to stop the downward spiral since the vast majority no longer have anything substantial to tax.
All the cash now resides with the top 1%, and the government doesn't know how to tax it to prevent economic collapse, now pretty much a certainty on this trajectory.
Watch how this allegedly "impossible" task becomes super easy for the divorce lawyer of Jensen Huang's wife in the next few months. Suddenly all his wealth will become accounted for, so she can get her part.
Could they not simply make more money, pay it to the poor people, then immediately hoover it up and give it to the rich people in the form of tax breakages?
Obviously it won't solve anything, but it would probably boost the morale of the poors, knowing that their supreme efforts helped to make their rich lords even more richer.
They would never do that... in 2008, they bailed out the banks that had loaned people money they knew couldn't be paid back instead of giving the people money to pay off the debt that would have gone to the banks anyways.
I mean, move the entire sum of money from "The Economy" to the national debt bank account that is owed money to, such that the owed balance goes to $0.00.
Probably the best time to do it would be right before pay day.
Although I suppose that the money that people would have been paid would also have gone to paying off the national debt.
That already happens, though mostly at the local level. Every entitlement has an industry surrounding it to capture that spent money. Food assistance is functionally a subsidy of grocery stores. Housing vouchers is functionally a subsidy of property management firms.
We're in this hole because Americans want stuff but don't want to pay for it.
Try playing with a federal budget simulator and you'll realize any cuts you make are going to piss off a lot of people, and raising taxes is a losing electoral strategy when voters are children screaming "no tax, only spend.
Even if you max out the tax rate on the top 1% you'll only get about 1/4 of the way to solving the debt. You still need to either raise taxes broadly which won't get you elected, or you need to cut benefits deeply which won't get you elected.
We did unite and vote out the Republicans. Across the country we came together. Now it's the Democrats turn to sell us down the river to the parasite Epstein class. Hooray for Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries.
Bullshit. a simple majority can get rid of the filibuster and tax increases on the wealthy can be put into budget reconciliation. Force trump to veto it, Republicans to vote against the veto override, and then they own the government shutdown.
Republicans still have the presidency, which is a moronic position that includes what are basically the powers of a king, the power to pardon anyone of federal crimes including oneself, and the ability to veto legislation.
You can say "they own the government shutdown" but if you really think Americans are smart enough to process that correctly I don't know what to tell you. Trump will veto shit, Republicans in congress will uphold the veto, and American voters will blame the Democrats for getting nothing done and vote in Republicans again once gas prices are no longer stinging them in the ass or have stayed high long enough to become normalized.
The Democrats winning this election is great, but one election doesn't fix anything. They need to win over, and over, and over again for decades straight to fix what Trump's Republicans have done.
Of course there's no way to fix all this in one election. It won't be fixed in five elections. But at least they can do public investigations of all the Admin and do impeachment hearings to show the public what they put in office like rubbing a dog's nose in its own poop.
How many billionaires are part of that generation? It probably skews their official share a bit. Instead of dividing us by generation, let do it by class
>10's of millions of boomers were never eligible for estate taxes.
The estate tax exemption amount used to be $675,000 in 2001. Now it's over $14 million. So many boomers who would have been subject to it now are excluded cause Republicans raised the exemption so high it barely touches anyone.
I’m all for estate taxes on amounts over a reasonable threshold adjusted for inflation, but that great wealth transfer will mostly not happen. Old people will get sick and lose everything they’ve accumulated over a lifetime to end-of-life care.
Boomer policies have been bad. They’ve directly led to huge debts both for the nation and for their children and grandchildren with cuts to services and failure to get with democratic social ideals that have worked very well throughout Western Europe. Trying to tax the pittance they leave their children and grandkids won’t help much now.
They are leaving $60 to $120 trillion depending on the markets.
Many will get sick, but untold 10's of millions more will drop dead spontaneously with very little medical costs. There is a lot of wealth and homes to go after there.
The potential Reasonable threshold could be $500,000 and their kids would still do well and society would do well.
Ok I'm tired of hearing that phrase so I'm genuinely asking you to define "eat the rich", what exactly are you proposing by that? Taxing is obviously the solution, but politicians are in the pockets of the rich, so how do you implement the second option? Explain how "a rich" is eaten.
The phrase "Eat the rich" originated during the French Revolution.
• The Quote: It is commonly misattributed directly to the philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, but the exact line ("When the people shall have nothing more to eat, they will eat the rich") first appeared in Adolphe Thiers' 1823 History of the French Revolution.
• The Source: It was a paraphrase of a speech delivered on October 14, 1793, by French revolutionary Pierre Gaspard Chaumette during the Paris Commune, reflecting the anger of the Third Estate (commoners) against King Louis XVI and the starving populace.
• Modern Usage: The slogan has resurfaced as a popular expression of protest against modern wealth inequality, appearing in activist movements, political rallies (such as by Elizabeth Warren and the UAW), and social media culture.
In this case, we're not talking about cannibalism but rather dispossession of the excess wealth of the extremely rich.
>In this case, we're not talking about cannibalism but rather dispossession of the excess wealth of the extremely rich.
Err... umm... how come when we actually try to turn it into a billion dollars, we end up with $200 million after accounting for the overhead and market impact?
So, hmm... everything said and done, $150 million out of that billion. Not quite what we expected.
And then repeat the process, because that money was never actually there to begin with.
We have no say. Our government is a corrupt dictatorship but instead of one leader its many, and we have no idea who any of them are. Trump is a puppet and the two party system is in place to keep people divided. Weve had one leader for 250+ years
Not enough people are talking about how the 10 year treasury bond went up 75 points in the last 6 months. It’s above 5% now and not showing any sign of stopping. Driven by AI and the federal government borrowing 1 out of every 3 dollars it spends.
30 year fixed mortgages never go below 1.8% above the 10 year. It’s currently more than 2%.
If this trend continues we’ll have 10% mortgages in 2 years. Higher borrowing costs mean lower prices. The middle class’s largest asset taking a haircut while inflation runs rampant.
Then there’s the whole question of how the debt ceiling gets resolved next year. Trump has played chicken with default before, who knows what he’ll do as a lame duck.
Brother that volatile rise was due to a shift in macro sentiment surrounding the fed funds rate. Everyone was expecting rate cuts and the Iran war shifted the paradigm back towards hikes.
The last time rates were that high was 1989 but it was fairly normal before then. What’s going to stop it rising? As of right now the treasury is borrowing 400b$ per month just to keep the lights on.
Does anyone actually think the Trump administration will strike a fiscally responsible deal with Democrats? Probably not. At best we might avoid defaulting entirely, though that’s very much on the table.
Expectations of the trajectory of the Fed funds rate, which is what all yields are ultimately based on.
>As of right now the treasury is borrowing 400b$ per month just to keep the lights on.
So? Federal government borrowing is nothing like household borrowing. They control the currency. It's effectively all just money printing. Every time the government spends the money supply goes up, while taxation reduces the money supply. The borrowing is then just an asset swap. Yields do not correlate at all with debt and deficit levels.
The war on terror added fourteen trillion dollars — that's $14,000,000,000,000. Ten trillion of which was direct military spending and four trillion was on welfare for the veterans. If the Iran war or even the blockade on Iran continues it'll probably go much higher.
I’ll never forget the fear I had when he was elected the second time. The first I was frustrated but I was like, hey, maybe he’ll cut back spending and get the debt down, let’s see.
He has been a terrible president and is responsible for a quarter to half of our debt which is staggering. Can you imagine what we could have done for the people with that money?
I was always someone who leaned more conservative as fiscally responsible government meant a lot to me, but after Trumps first presidency I no longer believe in a government that will spend less. It can’t really, but even if it does cut back spending they just spend it into bombs. If we are going to spend the money anyways, let’s help the people.
The issue with government spending is similar to the tragedy of the commons. It should be focused towards public goods, and the current accounting in place is woefully ignorant. Think about a poorly designed intersection in a road way, it might cost a million to fix of tax payer money, which seems like a lot, but the cost of the poor intersection is rarely considered in full. A good accounting would consider the cost of the number of times EMS has to roll for every wreck, the cost insurance has to pay out for repairs, the medical costs of any injuries, the cost employers incur from having an injured worker, the cost of time, fuel and wear for every traveler stuck in traffic waiting for the wreck to be cleared, and the commerce impact of business along that section. A weekly or monthly wreck at that intersection can quickly cost more than 250k annually, and on that alone, without considering the benefits a well designed intersection brings outside of fewer wrecks, that 1 million the government spends becomes a cheap investment. Yet, we only focused on the investment cost, and rarely consider the societal costs and benefits in politics.
Tax revenue is mostly from the Middle class, driven by their economic activity. Just like with boom bust cycle inherit in capitalist economies, the only way to stabilize the budget is pull the peaks and raise the valley. Unfortunately for where we are now, it takes time to not just implement those policies, but for the results to bear fruit. It's taken 50 years from Reagan's 'voodoo economics' to get us to this debt level, and like redesigning a intersection, it'll take time and a upfront cost, to stop the economic bleed and see returns. Trump is terrible, but the fiscal issues with the government now are because of privatization, and short-shortsightedness stacking for decades. If you go back to the debates in the 80's they knew their actions would cause the budget issues today. If you want more evidence, Ross Perot, the Texas Oil Tycoon ran for office in the early 90's and laid out some fiscal predictions based on the tax policies being championed, and described exactly what they needed to do to prevent current day, and how Reagan pointed the country to this scenario. His campaign videos included educational infomercials on his polices. He literally did analog power point presentations, trying to educate and warn people of the fiscal issues we're dealing with now.
It's worth noting both Reagan and Trump are Heritage Foundation Candidates, the only two they were able to get into office. They both frontmen, for a larger political group, that includes the Federalist Society he gave Bush Jr. the presidency in 2001, and Citizens United.
They've been setting this up for decades and the average American is too lax/distracted to care. We will get what we deserve and it's gonna really suck. But remember, we deserve it and that helps me sleep better at night.
What most don’t realize, or maybe won’t admit, is that this debt issue gets solved one way or another. All of the options will be hard, it’s a lot of debt. Personally, I prefer solutions where the U.S. controls the timing and methods. They may need to act soon if this is the route they prefer.
State, local and federal debt exceed billionaire wealth so near 5x alone to say nothing of unfunded medicaid, medicare, social security and military and civilian pensions which are another 10x+ multiple. There is no taxing your way out of this.
Bush campaigned on reducing the size of government, then proceeded to make the single largest addition to the government in history.
Trump campaigned on no more wars, gets us into a war (without declaration of war from the congress).
The big thing back in 2004 and in 2016 was right wing slanted people voting "to keep the other person out". People were so much more concerned about keeping John Kerry and Hillary out of the President's seat that it didn't matter much who got in there. Trump was also talking about tearing things apart and saying what people wanted to hear in the moment, that the goldfish-memory kicked in and people didn't seem to remember pictures of Trump WITH Bill and Hillary back when they were buddies. Trump also said stuff like "yeah they were in my pocket back then, I know how this works, but I'm going to change things" when in fact he made them so much worse.
I'd say the voting needs to happen, and people have to just become smarter, but the underlying cultural issues don't look like they're resolving until more people are out on the streets.
Reaganomics has never worked. Maybe we should tax the regard playing space man at 70% like we used to when the country actually was great. if his artistic ass complains he is more than welcome to go back to South Africa
Its like the stupid ass "we dont have the money to pay teachers!!!", but then the president feel his penis is small and goes to war and suddenly its "heres 2 trillion for the military, no problemo!".
The middle class was an accident resulted from a post World War 2 period and a lot of welfare created by FDR, the US rich class wants things back to normal: Very slow quantity of high end jobs and smart people, huge amount of idiots to do manual labor.
Please enlighten me. At which point in American history were the rich paying 50% of their earned income in taxes and 70% of their unearned income in taxes?
(And don’t just give me the marginal tax rates. Marginal tax rates alone are meaningless when you ignore the tax deductions, shelters, and capital gains exclusions that existed at the time which lowered the effective tax rates far below the top marginal tax rates).
Never. People repeat this all the time but do t realize “effective tax rates” were never even close to 70%. Effective tax rate for the rich peaked at 45% in 1945. These days is probably around 30% (give or take).
Would a 40% effective tax rate be good? Yes. But people need to stop spamming the 70-90% tax rate line like they have or will ever happening.
Yep. That tax code was massively complicated and so full of holes that by the time accountants found them all, the effective tax rate was between 12% and 13% for most industries. Among the lowest the US has ever had. Reagan's well meaning restructuring and simplification of the code almost doubled the effective rate to 20-21% and directly caused the economic downturn of the 1990s, which people typically and incorrectly blame entirely on a lowered rate of spending on defense industries due to the end of the Cold War, which is only true if you have a shit-tier Keynesian understanding of economics.
Yes, the US ramped up military and defense spending in 2002 as a reaction to 9/11.
It wasn’t just the wars but that was a huge part of it. You also have to keep in mind that global security changed drastically after 9/11. Airport security, border security, and so on and so forth. Even shipping security that companies had to invest in so they could continue to ship into the US.
The two major years noted, 2009 and 2020, were caused by the massive recession from the 2008 housing market crash, and of course the Covid Pandemic. Both of which had major impacts on the rest of the world and not just the US.
The headline pairing is what stands out: debt now roughly the size of the whole economy, and the claim that tax cuts since 2001 added over 10 trillion dollars to it. The exact attribution depends on how you count, but cutting taxes without a plan to pay for it keeps pushing the bill to later.
Deficit is 6% of GDP. We have republicans who want to cut taxes and increase spending. We have democrats who want to increase spending without really talking about how we are going to pay for it which could lead to larger deficits. Long term interest rates become higher leading to more interest on the debt and making life more costly for Americans. It’s so bad there is no reasonable path to balanced budget that wouldn’t put us into a recession. The best course of action is a 20 year plan to get our deficit to 3% of GDP so it’s no longer outpacing the economy.
In some way it’s a democracy problem. It incentives politicians to give benefits away to certain people (or even everyone) when there’s none to be given. These sections of people may vary depending on the party but the end result is the same. No politician can run a campaign on austerity and win yet that’s the need of the hour.
I mean, if you have to do only things that make the famously short-sighted public happy in the next four-year period or you lose your job, you can't make any long-term sacrifices. In, say, a monarchy, you would be able to make a long-term sacrifice.
You can't run on widespread austerity but you can run on austerity for the top 1% or top 10% who have been compounding the wealth that they've been siphoning from the bottom 90% for the last 50 years.
It only takes 50% to win an election in the U.S., so leaving yourself the 90% who are getting the short end of the stick should be an easy margin to win with.
The question for this generation is whether or not enough voters will be able to smell this shit that the corporate politicians have been shoveling (Trump, Biden, et al.) and vote in a new class of politicians.
And with the next election if a democrat wins they will blame all the economic malfunctions on the democrats and they will vote in another republican idiot 8 years from now who will trash the economy again. I bet they will even blame the democrats for losing the Iran war lol
Almost like providing constant tax cuts to the wealthy and letting them consolidate the majority of wealth at the top, while overspending on wars, military, etc. and then bailing out failed markets instead of letting them collapse weren't great ideas.
> In the absence of significant legislative changes and assuming that the economy follows the path described in this report, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the total surplus will reach $281 billion in 2001. Such surpluses are projected to rise in the future, approaching $889 billion in 2011 and accumulating to $5.6 trillion over the 2002-2011 period.
The GOP is a confidence scheme and they have taken advantage of 1/3 of the population since the late 90s with their constant manipulation and obfuscation of facts and information.
$10T from tax cuts on $35T total added. Which means $25T has been due to excess spending. It’s so frustrating that most people won’t call out the spending growth, even though it is by far the bigger problem.
Thanks for stating what I have said for a long time. Its the spending and the long prevailing attitude of "all the money belongs to the government except what they allow you to keep" that feeds the ever growing debt.
W Bush cut taxes in April of 2001. We've been funding the budget by borrowing since W took office is 2001.
> In the absence of significant legislative changes and assuming that the economy follows the path described in this report, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the total surplus will reach $281 billion in 2001. Such surpluses are projected to rise in the future, approaching $889 billion in 2011 and accumulating to $5.6 trillion over the 2002-2011 period.
6.8 trillion from financial crisis bailouts and covid. 6 trillion from middle east wars. 11 trillion on interest payments and unfunded entitlements like ssn and Medicare. 2 trillion growth in domestic programs. Outside of tax cuts, alot of the deficit is the government fighting or manufacturing crisis without a plan to pay it back.
Don't forget the supplemental appropriations that are not reported in the annual deficit and budget. The cost of the Iraq war was about double the amount allocated to it in the budget, the rest funded by supplements that are not recorded in the deficit but do add to the debt (one of the reasons the deficit does not equal the annual change in debt)
What the tax cuts (and to some extent financial market deregulation) was put us in much worse fiscal situations going into crises, worsening the fiscal impact.
leave it to generations of conservatives & neoliberals to constantly destroy the United States budget with multiple forever wars, multiple tax giveaways and multiple economic downturns
When you spend on welfare it circles back around quite quickly in spending, the velocity of money remains decently high with welfare spending.
When you spend on many of the costs associated with forever wars then at least half of the spending goes straight to contractors.
Contractors will end up spending part of that in a way which cycles back around, but a large portion of the money they recieve will end up in shareholder pockets. The vast majority of money recieved by shareholders goes into safe assets and effectively becomes dead money.
So generally, giving money to poor people is a much better use of public money due to how it circulates and ends up supporting businesses that provide necessary goods, whereas spending money on war will inherently suck capital out of the country and end up locking a lot of it up into safe assets for wealthy investors.
There is also the argument that forever wars also decrease the overall economic growth in other sectors. Regional instability in that way is obviously bad for most economic sectors. There are a lot of reasons why war is economically bad. But also, even if you win most of the spoils and subsequent contracts from the newly installed/changed foreign government will also end up being directed towards some of those same wealthy groups which will subsequently lock up the extracted profits into safe assets.
Spending money you don't have isn't a circle - that's creating a spiral of debt, deficit and interest payments.
Again, military and forever war spending is peanuts compared to welfare spending. You could end all military spending and wars and you wouldn't even balance the budget - what does that tell you?
The elephant in the room is Medicare/Medicaid spending which pays fixed prices for services, not determined by the market economy which causes all health care prices to follow suit and be inflated - this is why healthcare is so expensive. Education is similarly expensive because the government backs loans causing schools to charge extraordinary prices - just like healthcare.
Housing has become similarly expensive by the market being crowded out by people with government backed loans.
Prices weren't this insane 30 years ago. And we had forever wars back then too. Bigger ones. The difference now is welfare is out of control. Government involvement in healthcare, education, and housing is out of control, and all of those things have had their prices skyrocket as a result.
The central bank is the creator of the money supply... it's amazing that people aren't taught how this all functions. Through the lens of Modern Monetary Theory, the headline that “U.S. debt now equals the whole economy” mostly misreads what that debt is. MMT holds that a government issuing its own floating currency doesn’t need to borrow in order to spend: it spends by crediting bank accounts, and Treasury securities are simply the record of dollars created but not yet taxed back, effectively interest-bearing savings accounts for the private sector. Because the government’s deficit is the private sector’s surplus by accounting identity, a debt-to-GDP ratio near 100% just means the non-government sector holds financial assets roughly equal to a year of national output, not a bill coming due, since the U.S. can always pay in dollars and faces no solvency constraint. The $10 trillion-plus attributed to tax cuts since 2001 is likewise seen as money left in private hands rather than lost revenue, because taxes exist to create demand for the currency and drain excess spending power, not to fund the government. The real limit is inflation and real resources: if deficits push demand beyond what the economy can produce, prices rise, and that is when tax increases or spending cuts make sense.
That said, the current tax cuts almost exclusively benefited the ultra rich and the corporate sector widening the inequality here in the US.
Now add layers of debt from municipal government, metro, TIF-redirection of taxes toward debt, tax breaks for companies, and everything else that drains actual tax revenues and/or changes tax revenues into debt payments.
Who possibly could have predicted this?! Only anyone with a basic understanding of economics. Arthur Laffer was a buffoon and his nonsense has been thoroughly repudiated by the last 40 years of economic history. Kansas achieved Conservatives’ wet dream of no taxes and went bust. We’re on the fast track to the same end as a country if we don’t change tack.
France has a completely different system to the US. They are a currency user not issuer because they use the euro instead of having control over their own currency (the franc).
Then there is massive hoarding of wealth in France which starves the economy of internal spending that has to be offset by the government because France has a minor trade deficit with the world, also thanks to the euro. You l could some systems be changed? Yes sure. But the fundamental truth is that the debt of someone is the wealth of someone else. Just as spending is income. When I buy food for 10€, I have lost 10€ but they didn't vanish they are now in the pocket of the grocery store.
When the government spend 1 billion that's the money in the economy now being used to do business. Remove that money (budget surplus) and you either have a shrinking economy because now 1 billion is missing or someone else has to go into debt to cover those missing 1 billion.
How did you accidentally stumble onto the economics sub? Where does this idea of "hoarding wealth" even come from? Did you think that billionaires hide their cash under their bed like what do you think they actually do with it? Or even if they did do that, it would somehow starve the economy? How so?
Tax cuts have not added $10,000,000,000,000, not ever cutting spending has added that. When ever "cuts" are discussed, it is usually a cut in the desired increase. Meaning, they wanted to raise a budget 10% but the only got a 6% raise in the budget so the budget was "cut" 4%.
Tax cuts don't add to the debt. Spending adds to the debt. This type of phrasing is so bizarre. It seems to assume that fiscal responsibility by the government is just out of the question.
Thankfully we have Republicans in charge who (ignoring the insane idea that less incoming money doesn't reduce debt) are super good at reducing spending, right?
taking all the money from the billionaires would heavily stop politicians from getting bought out by billionaires to impose toxic economic policies on the rest of us, so yeah, that alone would be worth it
No but taxing them fairly and cutting taxes on the pleabians HELPS with the debt while also giving normal people more money to spend which then generates more tax revenue
It’ll never happen though. Democrats are ok the same team as evidence by monenofn see wealth redistribution bills being repealed when they had congressional power
Tax cuts create a gap in spending that must be filled in order to fund programs already in existence. You’re being intentionally obtuse or have no understanding of how fiscal policy works
Government spending in relation to GDP has gone haywire. The debt has actually passed the entire GDP of the country. It is in no way proportional to the country "expanding in size."
If a minimum wage mcdonalds worker asks you for advice on how to buy a house wouldn't you tell him to get a better job first instead of seeing if he can cancel a Netflix subscription?
You have money coming in and money going out. More money is going out because the elite are being given tax breaks. As a result the debt grows. Hence, tax cuts contribute to growing national debt.
Its not a zero sums game. You can cut taxes and reduce the deficit.
When government reduces taxes, the economy responds positively. In many cases this results in increased revenue to the government compared to the previous higher tax regime.
Can we get some examples please? Not trying to be snarky but I feel like tax cuts in very specific instances would cause this but that’s not what we’ve been doing
There are several historical examples supporting this argument. The economic principle is commonly associated with the Laffer curve.
Two prominent examples (one from a Democrat and one from a Republican):
JFK tax cut (1964):
The top marginal income tax rate was reduced from 91% to 70%. Corporate income tax rates were also reduced. The tax cuts put approximately $11.5 billion back into the private economy. The economy experienced substantial growth. Real GNP grew approximately 5.1% annually from 1964–1967. Unemployment fell to 3.8% by 1967. Federal revenues rebounded substantially following the tax reductions. The 1966 Economic Report of the President reported that federal revenues increased approximately $9 billion between the end of 1963 and the final quarter of 1965, despite $16 billion in tax reductions taking effect during that period.
Reagan tax cut (1981):
The top marginal income tax rate eventually fell from 70% to 28%. Individual income tax rates were reduced across multiple brackets. Businesses received incentives for investment and capital formation. The economy experienced substantial expansion following the 1981–1982 recession. Real GDP grew approximately 4% annually from 1983–1989. Individual income tax receipts increased from approximately $286 billion in 1981 to $446 billion in 1989. After adjusting for inflation, the increase in individual income tax receipts was approximately 14%.
Two prominent examples, one from the 1960s and one from the 1980s.
JFK tax cut (1964):
The top marginal income tax rate was reduced from 91% to 70%. Corporate income tax rates were also reduced. The tax cuts put approximately $11.5 billion back into the private economy. The economy experienced substantial growth. Real GNP grew approximately 5.1% annually from 1964–1967. Unemployment fell to 3.8% by 1967. Federal revenues rebounded substantially following the tax reductions. The 1966 Economic Report of the President reported that federal revenues increased approximately $9 billion between the end of 1963 and the final quarter of 1965, despite $16 billion in tax reductions taking effect during that period.
Reagan tax cut (1981):
The top marginal income tax rate eventually fell from 70% to 28%. Individual income tax rates were reduced across multiple brackets. Businesses received incentives for investment and capital formation. The economy experienced substantial expansion following the 1981–1982 recession. Real GDP grew approximately 4% annually from 1983–1989. Individual income tax receipts increased from approximately $286 billion in 1981 to $446 billion in 1989. After adjusting for inflation, the increase in individual income tax receipts was approximately 14%.
You also seem bizarrely unaware of the idea that the government can reduce its spending. As has been pointed out, no amount of taxation can fix the debt at this point.
We've been cutting for awhile, and it hasn't worked (unless you are willing to admit that inequality and killing the middle class has been the goal). Maybe taxes could go up on people who have more money than can be spent in 100 lifetimes?
I wouldn't say assume. But if you have obligations that were already expected to be paid on, like debt, then yes, cutting taxes is adding to your debt.
Like good luck telling a bank that they have to accept lower mortgage payments cause you decided your job was too much responsibility, and you decided to take a pay cut.
Yes government can stop spending so much. But there's a fucking minimum that the government can cut. Like there's a fucking minimum I can budget, but at a certain point I can't cut anymore spending out of my budget cause it will lead to insane hardships in my life, that might threaten my ability to keep my current level of income. So I have to find another way of making more money.
Yes, but we need things like law enforcement, weapons for defense.
Like I don't fucking understand why people are so against taxes here. It's the social contract. Its what allows you to be on reddit while you shit instead of holding a gun.
Well when the other options for the government are 1) cut medicare, 2) cut social security, 3) stop wars, then this becomes a much more important decision then just stop spending money.
In fact so far with 4 decades in power until now at least, Republicans weren't capable of doing it. So regardless they'll be the ones people will blame when asked who pinned us with all of the extra debt.
I don't care about democrat vs republican. Both parties endorsed the stimulus that devalued the dollar and created the inflation we're seeing now.
Both parties also have continued the military entanglements also. Stopping them is not a difficult decision unless there are special interests involved pushing them to continue.
Retirement is bankrupting us. No program was created to create 20+ year retirement plans. However, that is what they have become, and it's political suicide to correct. So instead, we just yell at each other about the dumbest ideas we can find.
We went into a couple of rando countries after 9/11 and gaslit people into thinking those were the two to invade instead of picking the one where all the terrorists came from. That cost about 6 trillion dollars that will be compounding till I'm dead.
When we are going into wars constantly and extorting other countries for their resources, thinking we can afford it, this becomes a real regret for some people politically.
Though most people in the US are political nihilists. Again the best option was no tax cuts. That's what we could afford at the time.
The post 9/11 wars were massively stupid. Although, that is just a cover anymore for any real discussion The $2 trillion deficit we've had every year since COVID has nothing to do with that. Before people come rushing in, foaming at the mouth because of Iran, $45 billion did not do that either.
Always “wars” as if they’re on scale for entitlements. Defense and war spending has gone from 9% of GDP to 3% of GDP.
Entitlements have ballooned to 14% of GDP. We haven’t spent near that number on wars even in the 60s era where it was more like 9%.
Social security and Medicare spending plus other mandatory and then debt interest is going to be 80% of the budget by 2036. We can’t solve this problem by pointing at war spending, which pretending it serves no purpose, is naive.
I was going to say… thanks for nailing it. We pay a ton of taxes , fees and whatever else. The govt. needs to reign in spending in basically every sector. Like, 5% to 10% cuts across the board until we’re more solvent. Pain will be felt but let’s be honest: A good chunk of spending is pure pork.
Its like a lawyer stopping his law practice and going to work at mcdonalds. The change in income directly impacts the ability to address tax liabilities.
Through fairly simply math you can deteremine how much the loss of income contributed to the increased debt by just looking at what the debt would be if you used the lost income to pay it off.
I agree with your point. Obviously tax cuts will increase the deficit. And obviously increasing spending will increase the deficit.
You're supposed to decrease spending AND decrease taxes or increase both... if your metric is the deficit itself.
Like you imply, the problem is the alternative to decreasing taxes, is to raise taxes. And people only seem to talk about the budget from a standpoint of taxation. And people scoff at the idea of ever ever ever reducing spending.
It's a fair criticism from the left that republicans lower taxes but don't actually decrease spending in any meaningful way, just as it's a fair criticism from the right that the democrats raise taxes, and then use that as justification to increase spending (as they fixed the deficit) which requires raising the taxes again.
Would absolutely love it if we could seriously entertain cutting spending. Yes, got it, the military budget is large and there's obviously savings we could find there... but in order to address the lion's share of the issue and really cut spending you have to start addressing benefits/welfare/etc. Which make up a significantly larger percentage of the budget than the military... and which paradoxically (despite people wanting to balance the budget) is a political death sentance.
The truth is that government spending is pretty responsible. A lot of the spending has a great ROI (in addition to, you know, the human element of it).
One thing that has consistently had terrible ROI, however, has been tax cuts.
Fiscal responsibility should take into account the idea that some spending brings in more than it costs...and the idea that some cuts cost far more than the benefits they provide. But here we are.
lol ah yes, what the government really needs is more money. They just don’t have enough. No other solution, better rob everyone so the government can spend the money. They cant be trusted with it.
There’s a guy who makes $400k/yr and still racks up massive amounts of debt every year. He asks me and some other buddies for money all the time, saying “if I just made more money, I’d be able to get my debt under control. Can you guys please give me some additional money to help me out?” His income has actually gone up pretty significantly over the last several years. It’s just that as his income increases, he just keeps increasing his expenses on top of it. It’s become clear that this guy doesn’t have an income problem. Rather, he actually has a spending problem. The more money he makes, the more he spends.
^ this is exactly what it sounds like when politicians say that we just need to raise taxes. They already bring in an insane amount of tax revenue. The issue is that they spend an even more insane amount. Like the example of the guy above, the government doesn’t have an income problem, they have a spending problem.
When they propose to raise taxes, they never accompany that with proposed reductions in their spending. Rather, they just use it to justify further expenditures on top of our existing ones.
Just giving them more money isn’t going to fix the problem, at least not while they’ve proven to have a terrible spending problem. You must first make them prove they can get their spending under control before agreeing to give them more money.
Or balance the budget. Tell us why you want to raise taxes. Run on the platform. Raise the taxes and actually do what you said you'd do. Its like Green Energy shit. They tax the shit out of gas and all this stuff for Green Energy. You'd think we have Nuclear Power Plants left and fucking right. Nope. Best we can do is a couple of EV charging stations.
Deficit is 6% of GDP. We have republicans who want to cut taxes and increase spending. We have democrats who want to increase spending without really talking about how we are going to pay for it which could lead to larger deficits. Long term interest rates become higher leading to more interest on the debt and making life more costly for Americans. It’s so bad there is no reasonable path to balanced budget that wouldn’t put us into a recession. The best course of action is a 20 year plan to get our deficit to 3% of GDP so it’s no longer outpacing the economy.
I love the sound of this because it’s reasonable and measured, but there’s no way under the current American political system that we can reasonably expect to follow a 20 year plan. The pendulum has swung no more than every 8 years for my entire lifetime. Politicians have several elections in a 20 year window and need to produce results now - often at the expense of the future - to retain their power and their seats. It’s just not feasible when we have this kind of broken system.
Balanced budget alone, achieved in any manner at all would result in a recession.
The deficit funds the private sector economy.
The problem is that the GOP is funneling the deficit to the wealthy and ultra-wealthy. The deficit needs to be reallocated to benefit the middle class by enacting broad benefits like Medicare for all.
True, neither US political party is able to reduce the deficit in any meaningful way...but my point was: that is a good thing.
There is no such thing as "US debt"
We should be talking about forcing Gov spending to benefit more citizens broadly rather than the benefits of deficit spending accruing to a narrow slice of very wealthy people.
Democrats say how we are going to pay for it. Tax the Billionaires like they are supposed to, and not spending on war. It looks like you have not been listening
Brother, nobody in Congress cares about a balanced budget. The game plan should be obvious by now. They're going to infate the debt away with more spending and tax cuts. Doesn't matter what side of the isle you're on. That's exactly what is going on.
Nah this is dumb. You can not tax billionaires enough to make a dent. It is not a serious thought. The US debt is about 40 trillion. All billionaires net worth is 8.4 trillion
Yes, still somehow enough liquidity to spend billions on lobbying and elections, in a midterm year too
The FY 2027 requesting a second doubling of military spending with no increase in taxes though isn't much better than what dems are proposing. I'd argue it's actually worse.
The unfortunate fact is that too much money has been locked up in safe assets, so taxing billionaires isn't enough, you'd need to go after a lot of safe assets. Taxing billionaires would absolutely be 1/3rd of the equation though
And we should all hold our breath for that - right?
Why haven’t Democrats followed this plan in the past when they had several opportunities to do so? Could it be that they are benefitting just like the Republicans under this broken system?
Take every dime from every billionaire and you can’t even fund the government for a year lol. Pretending taxing billionaires will fix this is either a sign of Reddit’s lack of basic economic understanding or deliberate partisanship
That doesn’t cover the bill. Look at all the countries that offer these items. Many have VAT taxes and increase taxes on everyone. You are the one listening to propaganda and being lied to thinking taxing billionaires covers the bill fully. If the country wants these items than fine but let’s be honest about what it’s going to cost and whose paying for it.
Except the Democratic party’s platform isn’t “tax the wealthy so that we can reduce the deficit / match our current spending.” Rather, it’s “tax the wealthy so that we can enact additional spending on top of our already inflated budget (universal healthcare / Medicare for all, free college tuition, student debt forgiveness, UBI, etc.)”
This is why I’m largely opposed to tax increases despite our massive debt. Increasing taxes isn’t going to result in our government reducing the deficit. It’s just going to give them license to spend even more.
In other words, we currently collect $5T in tax revenue and spend $7T in expenditures. If they were to increase taxes so that we now collect $7T in revenue, they’d just use that as justification to increase spending to $10T+. There’s been no actual effort by anyone to curtail spending at all.
When you have a friend that is terrible at managing his money and finds himself in a financial hole, just continually handing him more money won’t solve the problem. You have to first get him to fix his spending habits, otherwise the money you give him will just be wasted as well. Once his budget is under control, then you can start giving him some money to help him out with his financial woes.
Similarly, I will not support any tax increases until the government can show me first that they are willing to cut expenses first.
It’s not just billionaires. There are lots of very wealthy people making less than a billion, the current tax bracket structure stops increasing the rate at 640.6k for single filers and 768.7 for joint filers.
There is an astronomical amount of money to be derived from increasing the rate marginally every few million.
I mean, of course there is government waste that can be streamlined, but I think you are wrong about us not being able to generate enough revenue to ease the burden. With a progressive system, you could easily offset the cost of the military, which IIRC is the third largest budget item in our national spend. That goes a very long way toward lowering the debt, just the money we'd save on interest alone is enormous. I can run the numbers for you if you want.
And (again as I already said below) you haven't even touched cap gains. People are so afraid they are going to lose their standard of living if we raise the taxes on the wealthy. I just don't get where that fear comes from other than a knee jerk reaction to the idea of someone else putting their dirty hands on their precious dollar bills.
The disincentive to tax the wealthy simply doesn't exist. If they want to enjoy the immense wealth of this country, they are simply going to have to kick in. I think it's easy to forget just how much we subsidize the wealthy on their quest for riches. How many people does the Walton family employ that are eating food paid for by tax dollars? Who pays for the upkeep on the roads their trucks drive? I'm sorry but I do not have any sympathy for those whose net worth exceeds the GDP of a small country.
Tax those fuckers until they actually feel it for once, and see how things change.
So wealthy people are already taxed a lot. Saying they aren’t is disingenuous. The problem is increased taxes change behaviors and not always in ways you expect. So just boiling down peoples concerns about downstream effects as wanting to give wealthy people tax breaks; that is nonsensical
You do realize we could take all their wealth from them and it would only lower the debt by 10 trillion or pay for a year of running the country at current asset valuations.
Also the moment mobilization happens their wealth would disintegrate because it’s all bloated wealth based off projected assets that are 40-60x higher than the stocks’ actual revenue.
Realistically we have to raise taxes across the board, massive spending cuts, end all wars or have someone else fund them, go after “missing” funds and prosecute fraud, liquidate any fraud or wasteful resources for revenue, sell off land and resources, steal land and resources, and my favorite; liquidate all assets from the families who allowed this shit show for the past 100 years.
We are in extremely dire straits and anyone who denies this is vastly misinformed and/or moronic. Even at a 500 billion surplus per year which is possible with increased income taxes and spending cuts it would take us OVER 80 FUCKING YEARS OF SUFFERING BECAUSE OF THESE CORRUPT PIECES OF FUCKING SHIT!!!!!
Edit: But don’t worry, we are too big to fail (actual quote from many morons in government and finance) and we have the worlds’ gold hostage, and our currency is directly tied into everyone else’s (except here comes BRICS), and we have the strongest military (true tbh), etc
Pandering has bankrupted us. Anyone who thinks its a collection problem is propagandized beyond belief. Specifically, retirement is killing us. Need to raise the retirement age by 2 years.
At this point, it will take BOTH spending cuts AND tax increases to reign in the debt. Neither alone can save us because we have allowed it to go on for too long.
State, local and federal debt exceed billionaire wealth so near 5x alone to say nothing of unfunded medicaid, medicare, social security and military and civilian pensions which are another 10x+ multiple. There is no taxing your way out of this alone being the solution. You are one one of the few here to grasp that.
At this point it wouldn’t surprise me if the whole goal of Trump’s admin is to have his buddies loot the US for all wealth and then dip to elsewhere, leaving Americans absolutely in poverty with real consequences.
Republican tax cuts by Ronald Reagan and Bush and Trump equal the national debt you can't run a country on air it takes money and if you take away Revenue you get debt and the Republicans are the king at that
No more tax cuts for the wealthy. We've seen the consequences of these foolish policies and there is no counter argument that hasn't already been proven to be a lie. We are driving ourselves into ruin so that people with more money than they can ever use, can save even more money and hoard it like dragons!
Just tax the rich, leave the rest of us alone. Most of us can't survive a tax hike if nothing is else changes. They just won't do what needs to be done.
The political system is bought and paid for by the rich.
So strange how decades of tax cuts for the wealthy haven't given us anything but deeper national debt, cuts to government programs and services, and a gap between the richest 1% vs everyone else that's wider than it has ever been in the modern era.
It’s frustrating how these stories are framed so that politicians can spend recklessly while lower marginal rates somehow get the blame. Federal tax revenue has stayed remarkably stable as a share of GDP for decades, regardless of the rates.
Not spending just means someone else had to go in debt and since the US has a trade deficit with the world it has to be private citizens or businesses who both would rather save. Also private debt is way more dangerous because private individuals can't create their own dollars.
This debt scare mongering is truly a litmus test to basic accounting ability
Interest on the debt is a huge line item right now. If you don't pay the interest, you default. If the US economy defaults, it leads to the likely annihilation of the US economy and worldwide depression.
In order to pay increasingly large interest payments, you either print more money (increasing inflation) or reduce spending on everything else.
The US government cannot involuntarily default on is debt. It can just issue more bonds to pay for it.
If anything the issue is the interest in the first place because for some ancient reason the US still issues bonds to a market instead of just doing it directly with the Fed
If nobody buys those bonds, that's another horrific problem besides inflation- increasing borrowing costs for the federal government, which increases borrowing costs for everybody.
And yes, every entity on the planet can default and large nations have defaulted before. The US isn't immune to economic gravity.
Nations that issue their own currency cannot involuntarily go bankrupt. Only if you politically want to like Russia once did or if you have debt in a currency other than your own.
You don't need to sell the bonds. That's a hangover from the gold standard times you can literally just issue the money directly from the Fed without the whole primary market. I'm not saying that whoever is in charge of us monetary economy would do that but it's absolutely an option
Also people will continue to buy them. Japan has 250% debt to gdp ratio with multiple years of 0% interest on them
Yes, a sovereign nation can't involuntarily default, but when the alternative is just as bad or worse (hyperinflation), those semantics don't particularly matter.
You can't print your way out of debt. Ask Zimbabwe why that's true.
It's super rare and only happens in cases where the government was either blocked from trade or had their debt in a foreign currency.
just for you, the big issue that zimbabwe was facing was their collapse in the productive economy. they simply messed up their agricultural economy and then got sanctioned by the rest of the world. had to import food (using foreign currency) and paid every worker in zimbabwe dollar which are worthless because zimbabwe at that point in time had no productive economy
We are dealing with the fallout now. Inflation, and it’s just going to get worse if something isn’t done about the debt. We are looking at 2T per year just to pay interest
(Obviously, MAGA will be perfectly happy to foot this debt, since this is the end result of what their agenda of white-supremacy-at-all-costs has wrought.)
He’s just stealing from citizens until he can’t anymore. We’re just watching and waiting for someone else to stop him. It’s how much longer can he lie… how much more can he steal.
"Independent Fed with dual mandate" is what's not working.
You can't have a 3% inflation target when budget deficit is above 6% of GDP
By artificially lowering inflation, Fed kills growth and creates a massive wealth tax cut for the rich, making those with debts poorer.
Dear young people, your only chance at a prosperous adulthood is to elect nerdy economic types, fiscally responsible is the buzz term. The platform to care about is fiscal responsibility. It’s time to learn hard truths about budgeting.
Oh yes, we saw this coming. Now that Democrats are coming to power, suddenly things like debt deficit and fiscal responsibility matter again. Funny how that works.
The U.S. debt problem is not just a spending problem: repeated tax cuts without offsetting measures have structurally weakened public finances, while rising interest costs leave less room for future policy.
I haven't heard about the debt in 2 years, interesting that people seem to be interested in the debt now. What could have happened to make people want to talk about the debt? An election maybe?
Right now, the only thing that fixes the economy is interest rates back up to 15%, no more tax cuts, & freezing spending.
This is why collapse is certain. Nobody is gonna do these things.
Many are blaming the tax cuts and yes those are a real issue but it's because they weren't combined with meaningful spending cuts. So basically every party spends like drunken sailors but republicans do it while also cutting taxes.
Eventually it's going to blow up in our faces and crash the US economy but neither party has the political will to address it.
It's crazy that at one point we had debates about budget surpluses (1998 to 2001) and what would we do with all of this extra money. And here we are not quite 30 years later over 40 trillion in debt.
I think we should start including the debt in the economy. If a person is in debt they have negative net worth, why not a country? Why do we get to keep saying the economy is good when we are so deep in the hole?
Look, Republicans! Look with your eyes. Does this make sense to you? Do you understand now how youve been lied to and manipulated? Is banning 3 or 4 Trans kids from playing sports over the past 25 years worth 10 Trillion dollars and your children's future?
The US gov't deficit is 6% of GDP, and growing. Without deficit spending the GDP growth you've seen would be negative. It's all a big lie, fueled with debt to say that the US is performing much better than other developed economies.
You could make the same argument for france, and other western economies which have run on deficits since before the pandemic. The difference in the US is that the deficit spending somehow goes to the 1% and not on social programs so the K shaped economy is acutely felt.
Tax cuts NEVER pay for themselves. The Republican supply side myth that wealthy people need to prosper more for anyone to prosper at all is the greatest lie ever told.
Balance the budget, please. It's the only way forward. Just stop with the pork-barrel, stop with the international handouts... START with fixing our own problems.
This isn’t a complex solution. The USA is gonna have to make cuts across the board and gradually and slowly increase taxes. There isn’t a single program that should not recieve cuts.
I for one cannot believe that when we cut funds the federal government collects, the federal government collects less funds. Why didn’t anyone tell me this could happen?!?!
Tax billionaires all tax cuts they have received from Reagan to present. Use the tax revenues to buy down the debt, fund schools, Medicare, social security, & infrastructure maintenance.
Translation: I’m poor because I didn’t steal more of your money. In other words, you are saying that the US debt would be less if the government had taken more of the people’s money.
The idea of DOGE at the time sounded great. The execution however and who ran it was not. I would have loved to see an actual audit on where all our money is going and make meaningful cuts to areas that we don’t need (not the department of education!!). Unfortunately if you believe there is any sort of corruption in the government then the cuts won’t affect all that ghost money lol
Cut spending. Implement budget accountability within the agencies. Audit all agencies for waste/fraud. Stop funding anything outside of our borders. Then we can discuss raising taxes
Pretty sure the only presidents in the last 40 years to reduce the annual budget deficit --which to be clear is not the national debt, ok--have all been Democrats. Clinton, Obama, and Biden.
Budget deficits do not matter for a country the size of the US, so long as GDP is outgrowing debt and deficit.
Biden massively overcooked the economy, and he added about $2 in debt for every $1 of GDP he created. These high borrowing rates also impact the deficit.
Obama also added a lot more debt than he grew the economy by.
The last President that did a good job on the economy was Clinton, but he had the benefit of massive tailwinds for various reasons, and also set the conditions for the GFC at the end of his presidency.
Also tax cuts also need to be looked through the lens of GDP growth. Sure they added $10T in debt but did they create $11T+ in economic activity? If that was the case then they were a success. There is also the Laffer curve to consider, raising taxes becomes pointless after a while and spending needs to be cut instead. The US is probably below the Laffer curve but not as much as people here think.
What is this nonsense of a comment? Deficits don't matter except when Biden and Obama do them, and then you try to argue tax cuts created 11 TRILLION in growth? Anything to back that up other than the ramblings of mental patients?
The person you're replying to was specifically addressing the credit that the person before them was giving to Clinton, Obama, and Biden. They only mentioned those three presidents, thus the response was in turn about those three presidents.
The 10 trillion debt to 11 trillion activity ratio is a hypothetical question, not a claim.
As for the rest, Chat GPT rates most of it as supported but suggests that Biden's ratio was 1 to 1.09, not 1 to 2. So on that one, u/throwawaygoawaynz appears to have made a miscalculation using inflation-adjusted numbers in the wrong place.
This is the most asinine thing I've read on Reddit this month. Tax cuts did not add to the debt, uncontrolled government spending by every administration since 2001 (and before) added over (way over) $10 trillion.
HunterFeeFee | 15 hours ago
No, the US debt equals around 122% of the US economy.
The US measure used in the article, is a domestic consumption number not accepted or recognized anywhere else.
So_HauserAspen | 11 hours ago
"It's not done correctly"
Doesn't explain what's incorrect or how it should be measured correctly.
The GOP is a confidence scheme
> Confidence schemes rely on psychological manipulation rather than brute force. They exploit human traits such as greed, compassion, naivety, vanity, and the desire to trust.
GLAMOROUSFUNK | 12 hours ago
Classic America, using their own units of measurement that no else does
Whole_Fig4068 | 5 hours ago
And we don't even know the whole truth behind all the damage/destruction to overseas bases from this war we're in.
The debt will be much higher than it is right now as repubs will pass the $50 billion the FAA wants too.
Constant_Curve | 9 hours ago
For those unwilling to google
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/gfdegdq188S
eptesicusfuscus | 12 hours ago
It might help...if you're going to contradict it...to provide your definition of what "the IS economy" is best measured by.
Constant_Curve | 9 hours ago
How about the FED? https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/gfdegdq188S
LeastResistancePath | 18 hours ago
Americans voted in the most parasitic president this nation has ever seen and when they saw the tax cuts for the parasite billionaires, they said let's do it again
lana_silver | 15 hours ago
> they said let's do it again
That part is still the most moronic thing that has happened in the lifetime of the USA.
Trump 2016-2020 was an absolute shitshow of a presidency. A complete failure, no matter how you measure. Then you got Biden, who did an admirable job, despite being an old white man looking out for the establishment. But during his time, the government got more done for the US people than any president in living history. (If that sounds crazy you just missed all the useful stuff he did because it was a quiet presidency.)
And then they elected Trump again. It's like they cut themselves while cooking badly enough to go to the hospital, and then four years later they grabbed the knife and stabbed themselves in the stomach, on purpose. Like, what the fuck, guys? WHY?!
Gunzhard22 | 11 hours ago
And we'll do it again... All the Republican cuts to education make us so vulnerable to the laziest and stupidest cons.
The next president has a hell of a difficult road ahead, not to mention Trump basically emptied the national oil reserves, giving it away almost free, so he "wouldn't look bad about high oil prices", so that's a reckoning coming soon. AI bubble will bust. Trump's "Big Beautiful Bill-ionare giveaway" is just about to start.
When things aren't "perfect" after the next 7 years of fixing this mess, it will be very easy to sell hate and blame again to the uneducated.
ChickenChaser5 | 12 hours ago
Purely to spite people they have been told are their enemies. Decades of entertainment style news. Culture war nonsense.
You know, "owning the libs". They will self destruct to achieve that. Zero policy, all feelings. To them, its team sports.
External_Frosting669 | 11 hours ago
Exactly they don’t care they are trapped in a burning sinking ship as long as we are trapped too.
dw82 | 11 hours ago
Many of them don't yet realise that they are also trapped in the burning sinking ship.
Once they realise they'll be shocked that the life rafts have departed without them and only partially full.
Byt3Walk3r | 10 hours ago
Thanks to Reagan for getting rid of real news too
Cumulus_Anarchistica | 8 hours ago
They've been told what to think by their 'community leaders' and they don't have the critical reasoning skills to refute any of it. And thinking is such hard work! Will you do it for me plz!? OK thx so much! You wouldn't lie to me, though would you? No! Just checking! Phew! K. Let's go!
the_other_guy-JK | 7 hours ago
> You know, "owning the libs". They will self destruct to achieve that. Zero policy, all feelings. To them, its team sports.
"I'd shit my pants if it meant a liberal had to smell it." (not my quote, but one version of many similar)
Turgid_Donkey | 7 hours ago
Head over to the presidential rankings wiki page. Sienna, C-Span, and APSA all put trump in the bottom 5 for just his first term. They ranked William Henry Harrison higher and he was only president for a month before he died plus James Garfield who was only president for 6 months. Stew on that. Two guys who, combined, were in office less than a year both ranked higher than trump.
Then the nation decided to put him back into office. The man who was already considered one of the worst presidents in our history, and we say "well, let's give him another chance." I'm interested to know what that will do to his rankings.
lana_silver | 7 hours ago
As I said in other comments: Trump is the worst POTUS in the history of the country, and it's not even close.
When Nixon looks like a good choice in comparison, then you know it's bad. Because at least Nixon did only a little treason, it wasn't a daily occurrence.
UnleavenedTed | 10 hours ago
Did more for the people than FDR? No way. Social Security, unemployment insurance, minimum wage, taxing the rich and corporations appropriately. Or did you mean more recently, in which case I agree.
lana_silver | 10 hours ago
I meant in living memory. Someone we or our parents generation could have voted for.
FDR's presidency was before WW2.
incunabula001 | 11 hours ago
The problem with Biden (and most other establishment Democrats for that matter) is that they upheld the status quo, which if you have been paying attention lately, only works out for the top earners of this country. It’s a prime environment for grifters like Trump to take advantage of.
Far_Future_1982 | 10 hours ago
Totally...
Economic Growth and Job Creation
Infrastructure
Public Health and Healthcare
International Relations and National Security
Environmental Stewardship
Safety
Equality and Justice
Education and Debt Relief
endlesscartwheels | 10 hours ago
The problem with Biden is that the right-wing owns the mainstream media and Biden wasn't good at getting around that by using social media to publicize his achievements.
Technical_Yak1980 | 8 hours ago
Thats a problem with democrats in general. But that then is linked to a problem with intelligent debate.
The republican party is built on propaganda and lies. The key to this is making everything about fear and one sentence talking points. Repeat ad nauseum. Brain wash the simple folk.
Intelligent people try to refute misinformation and propaganda with hour long TED talks and evidence. The people they are trying to reach however don't like to think deeply. They like to be told what to do and think.
Least-Blackberry-848 | 10 hours ago
Except this isn’t true at all. Biden’s presidency was one of the most consequential in the past century.
GlenGaryBoss2024 | 3 hours ago
It wasn't consequential enough to sway the majority of voters...
Least-Blackberry-848 | 3 hours ago
Yes, American voters are very ignorant.
Inner-Medicine5696 | 11 hours ago
> is that they upheld the status quo,
...the main thing Trump voters voted against. They wanted a change - ANY change.
MoonBatsRule | 9 hours ago
> They wanted a change - ANY change. that hurt people who weren't white Christians
Fixed that for you
lana_silver | 7 hours ago
Forgot "cis-male" in that list.
Odd_Telephone3371 | 10 hours ago
This barely scratches the surface of everything Biden did for regular people. He was the best fucking president we've had since Truman.
lana_silver | 7 hours ago
I'm just so confused why non-fascists are against Biden.
xdre | 6 hours ago
The ones who are are really accelerationists.
youdunnyknow | 10 hours ago
GOP moves further right. Dems stop things moving back to the centre.
ReturnOfBane | 8 hours ago
like a ratchet
taylorisntavril | 10 hours ago
To be on the outside looking in was a really weird experience.
Trumps first term basically made a whole lot of us go "okay, thats the last fucking straw, enough is enough, you can fuck right off now!".
Then biden got a term and we were "well, you made your bed now sleep in it".
Then trump fucking got re-elected and within nano-seconds the bed was covered in feces, urine and spiders for some weird reason.
I truly do not think the people of usa understand the politics that has already been set in motion. The divesting from usa is real and its not about not "relying" on usa anymore, its about not "partnering" with usa.
But divesting from usa takes a lot of work and a lot of time. The results will probably not really be felt for another 5 years, but the next couple of decades arent going to be fun for usa.
I have a worry/suspicion that once the divesting starts to really take form, usa will cry foul and insist we are betraying them.
Wuzzupdoc42 | 7 hours ago
But Kamala’s laugh!
EthanielRain | 11 hours ago
2016 can also be explained/excused away...
Hillary was unlikeable, a woman, lifelong politician, people didn't know how awful Trump would really be, didn't believe he'd really win, whatever
...there's nothing that can be said for re-electing
gidimeister | 11 hours ago
Hate, Ethaniel. White Trump voters hate-voted him in because they wanted him to harm the gays, the hijabwearers, the blacks, the browns, the trans people, etc etc.
And if the price of that was a reduction in their living standards, so be it, they reckoned.
Prior_Coyote_4376 | 7 hours ago
Some 30% of the population has decided that preservation of white supremacy is their number one issue and that the biggest drop in their living standard ever was listening to a black man be their President
Gunzhard22 | 11 hours ago
Anyone with half a brain knew how awful he would be and it was widely spoken of.
BotnetSpam | 10 hours ago
She ratfucked Bernie when he had all the momentum. She reaped what she sowed. Then Biden did the same thing in 2020.
ProfessionalOil2014 | 10 hours ago
Bernie was never going to win the nomination. Ever.
germane_switch | 8 hours ago
As much as I wanted him to win, you're right. Much of Gen Z thinks anyone older than 55 is a senile old man.
Janagirl123 | 8 hours ago
Bernie failed to connect with non-white voters over 30 by a staggering margin. He never had a real shot at securing the nomination and when we was mathematically eliminated he still continued his campaign for a time. That’s why we have the phrase “Here’s how Bernie can still win” in our lexicon.
dust4ngel | 4 hours ago
> Like, what the fuck, guys? WHY?!
UsernameNSomeNumbers | 11 hours ago
I’m as anti-Trump/pro-boring “let’s just enact good policy” as the next guy, and that was a massive Biden glaze. The guy did OK, the U.S. economy is what performed.
lana_silver | 11 hours ago
Google what Biden got through. It's really shocking how much he outperformed anyone in the last 50 years. Infrastructure, education, research, health, it's all present. Obama did less in 8 years than Biden in 4.
I thought he would be awful but in hindsight he was great. It's frankly a bit insane how everyone keeps shitting on Biden when he did an objectively good job except for the terrible failed handover.
Edit for visibility: Rank the presidents of the USA in your life time, and be surprised where Biden ends up. Here's mine: Biden, Obama, Clinton, Bush Jr., Bush Senior, [Nixon oops he was way earlier], Reagan, Trump. It's a list of three monsters, three normal people, and two questionable choices in the middle.
Manginaz | 10 hours ago
Because the people of Springfield were eating the dogs AND THE CATS!!!
artisanrox | 8 hours ago
[ Removed by Reddit ]
artisanrox | 8 hours ago
I got an auto- warning on my account for what I JUST posted here and I'm appealing it. I am absolutely NOT having my account warned by describing the xeonphobia, bigotry and stupidity I live around!
lana_silver | 8 hours ago
Yeah I saw a [removed by reddit] reply.
Don't bother, it's just all AI bots being awful, nobody real reads your appeal to begin with. Has happened to me too.
artisanrox | 8 hours ago
💯
Automatoboto | 11 hours ago
Can the idiots in this sub acknowledge that the vast majority of the debt has come under republican rule?
UnleavenedTed | 11 hours ago
And 10 out of the last 11 recessions.
EddieVanzetti | 5 hours ago
Can people acknowledge that every election Trump has run in has had very clear criminal interference and outright theft of votes? The only reason Biden won in 2020 was because COVID made mail in voting much easier, allowing the sheer number of voters to cancel out the theft?
Automatoboto | 4 hours ago
I opine for the days where people this dumb were kept separate from the public
EddieVanzetti | 4 hours ago
> opine
That means to express an opinion. You probably meant "pine", but you're a Russian or Israeli bot, so it don't matter too much in the grand scheme of things.
GiveMeNews | 11 hours ago
People in this country always vote for tax cuts without understanding these cuts massively favor the rich. The people of North Carolina just voted to amend their constitution, stripping local municipals from setting their own property tax rates, and capping property tax and income tax.
galileo34i | 16 hours ago
BuT soMedAy iLL bE a BiLliOnaIrE anD DonT WanT To PaY TAxeS /s
E-2theRescue | 15 hours ago
"They'll totally make jobs, and totally pay us competitive wages, and totally not price gouge us. Trust us, bro. Billionaires are philanthropists. I saw one donate to a charity on the news one time."
whomad1215 | 11 hours ago
One day I might be rich, and then people like me better watch their step
-Futurama Fry during Nixon's head election campaign
dw82 | 11 hours ago
I'd happily pay 99% tax if it was necessary to receive a billion.
kent_eh | 18 hours ago
> Americans voted in the most parasitic president this nation has ever seen
Twice (and many of them voted for him 3 damn times)
cavortingwebeasties | 8 hours ago
> they said let's do it again
It took more than 40 years of Republicans decimating education and propagandizing the news to get the deep dumbness they needed to cement their power but make no mistake. They have seriously manipulated events and or outright cheated really hard to get themselves into power going back at least to Nixon.
Nixon: scuttled peace talks that would have ended the Vietnam war in 69, just so he could run as a wartime president
1979 Reagan's team got in touch with the Iranian terrorists that Carter was successfully negotiated a hostage release from and made a deal that if they didn't release them they'd be sold illicit weapons off the books which they did and was the opening move of the Iran Contra scandal and launched Reagan into the Whitehouse.
Not sure what fuckery was done in 88 but there's no way we had an organic election
2000 W Bush who did not win the electoral or popular votes was propelled into office through a series of underhanded judicial steps, a staged riot and was eventually just appointed even though the votes weren't there.
2004 they started heavily using wholesale disenfranchisement techniques, preventing a few million votes from being counted in strategically targeted areas.
This move has been used each election cycle since, with increasing numbers. Dems need to win by a landslide to overcome this shit. Obama did, twice but it worked in 2016 and in 2024 where there was also a huge number of conveniently timed bomb threats at key polling locations plus whatever ratfucking Elon did in every single swing state.
Hillary Clinton and Harris both beat Trump and it wasn't even particularly close the Republican cheat machine is well funded and deeply entrenched at every level of our society from Sheriffs all the way up the chain plus armies of paid influencers and having every news and social media outlet under their complete or near complete control
charliecarpenter | 6 hours ago
How did Harris beat trump?!
cavortingwebeasties | 6 hours ago
There was something like 3.5 and 4.2 million votes that were legally/illegally (mostly illegally) challenged and thrown out. That alone was enough to tip the scale but there's also whatever Elon did in swing states where Trump supposedly won hard but downballot voting didn't match at all. Then there was the bomb threats that prevented 10's of thousands (100's of thousands?) from voting in key polling places.
Greg Palast has been documenting the ways Republicans have been stealing elections since 2000. He's a credible investigative journalist. https://www.gregpalast.com/trump-lost-vote-suppression-won/
2024 Election bomb threats https://www.brennancenter.org/sites/default/files/2025-03/bcj-2024-election-bomb-threat-tracker_0.pdf?inline=1
Swing state anomalies https://www.thenumbersarewrong2024.com/across-the-us/swing-states
charliecarpenter | 5 hours ago
No, the central claims in Greg Palast’s article “Trump Lost. Vote Suppression Won.” do not hold up against the official 2024 data.
Palast asserts that routine voter-list maintenance, ballot verification, and challenges “wrongly” suppressed millions of votes (disproportionately from voters of color), and that without this Harris would have won the popular vote by ~1.2 million and the Electoral College with 286 votes by carrying Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Georgia. Official U.S. Election Assistance Commission (EAC) Election Administration and Voting Survey (EAVS) figures for 2024, plus certified results, show the specific numbers are inflated or mischaracterized, and the causal leap to a flipped outcome is not supported. 
Official baselines vs. Palast’s figures
Certified popular-vote totals: Trump ~77.3 million (49.8%), Harris ~75.0 million (48.3%), margin ~2.3 million. Electoral votes: Trump 312, Harris 226. Swing-state margins were narrow (Wisconsin ~0.9%/29k votes, Michigan ~1.4%/80k, Pennsylvania ~1.7%/120k, Georgia ~2.2%/115k). 
EAC 2024 EAVS (100% response from states/territories):
• List maintenance/removals (2022–2024 close of registration): 21.3 million records removed. Largest categories: failure to return a confirmation notice and not voting in two consecutive federal elections (~33.5%, roughly 7.1 million); moved out of jurisdiction (~30.8%, roughly 6.5 million); deceased and other reasons make up the rest. States also sent nearly 39–40 million confirmation notices. This is standard NVRA list maintenance, not a secret purge of eligible voters. 
• Palast’s “4,776,706 voters were wrongly purged” is a selective subset of the postcard/inactive category, labeled “wrongly” without evidence that the people removed were eligible and still residing in the jurisdiction. Many such removals are legitimate (moved, deceased, long inactive).
• Mail ballots: ~48 million returned; ~584,000–585,000 rejected (1.2% rate). Most common reasons: non-matching signatures (~41%) and other clerical issues. Palast’s “no less than 2,121,000 mail-in ballots were disqualified” is roughly 3.6× the actual number. He appears to extrapolate from older MIT/NPR figures (including unreturned ballots) rather than 2024 EAVS data. The 1.2% rate was higher than 2020/2016 presidential cycles but lower than recent midterms. 
• Provisional ballots: ~1.74 million issued; ~1.28 million counted (at least in part); ~436,000 rejected. Palast’s “1,216,000 provisional ballots were rejected” is nearly 3× the official figure. The most common rejection reason is the voter was not registered in that jurisdiction. 
• Registration transactions rejected: ~2.84 million (about 3% of transactions processed). Palast’s “3.24 million new registrations were rejected” is in the ballpark but still high. Rejections include incomplete forms, duplicates, ineligibility, and validation failures—not solely suppression.
• “Vigilante” challenges: True the Vote/IV3 claimed ~317,886 challenges submitted by August 2024 (matching their own statements). Election officials across multiple states reported that the large majority were already addressed (inactive status, prior notices), lacked reliability, or were rejected. Courts have previously criticized similar True the Vote lists as “shoddy,” “rife with error,” and lacking reliability. They did not produce the mass removals of eligible voters Palast implies.
Palast’s “at least 585,000 ballots cast in-precinct were also disqualified” aligns numerically with the mail-rejection total, suggesting a labeling or double-counting issue rather than a separate verified category.
The outcome claim
Even granting that ballot rejections, provisional use, and list maintenance can have disparate impacts (some studies, including Brennan Center analyses, document higher rates for certain demographic groups), the scale required to flip the four states plus the popular vote is not shown by the EAC numbers. Palast’s “2.3% suppression factor” and assumption that the net effect would have given Harris another 3.565 million votes (overwhelmingly Democratic) is an extrapolation, not a direct accounting from verified eligible voters prevented from casting countable ballots.
Restrictive voting laws passed after 2020 exist (Brennan Center tracked dozens), and signature-matching, drop-box limits, and challenge processes can create friction. Those are real policy debates. They do not, on the official data, equate to millions of eligible votes discarded in a way that reverses the certified result.
In short: several of Palast’s headline numbers are substantially larger than the corresponding EAC totals, the “wrongly” framing is not supported for the bulk of list-maintenance removals, and the claim that suppression alone produced Trump’s victory is not established by the evidence.
xOleander | 16 hours ago
The poorest, stupidest people I know were all saying the same stupid fucking phrase in 2024
“I’d like to unburden what has been” when voting for Trump.
All of them have gotten poorer and probably even more fucking dumb since then and mysteriously none of them have said anything about the economy recently. Or anything at all. It’s almost like these morons don’t pay attention to politics until a meme tells them which way to vote
LessInThought | 13 hours ago
People saw the blue wave and thought MAGAs are fed up, truth is their loyalty never wavered, more non voters stepped in.
agent674253 | 17 hours ago
in California, "can we tax the alsdkfjasld class?"
"No, they may leave not pay taxes..."
"umm.. what? they are not paying now? what? you dumb?"
"No, they may move to nashville and pay taxes there if we, if, um, taxes here?"
kennethcocketh | 13 hours ago
We gotta tax the asdhfkso classes slaves though! Somebody think of the slaves!
MsMarvelsProstate | 11 hours ago
Don't forget they said we don't want to tax billionaires, but we do want to increase our own taxes.
BossRedRanger | 12 hours ago
We didn't. A group of them did and the electoral college stole the rest of our agency. Without the electoral college, the rapist fuck wouldn't have ever been president.
Mr_1990s | 11 hours ago
Americans have done this 6 times since 1980.
dirtyitalianguy | 10 hours ago
Apologies for being that guy but you spelled pedophile wrong....
retroencambulator | 10 hours ago
You're going to have to specify which one...
howjon99 | 10 hours ago
He doesn’t give a fuck; no.
blahblah19999 | 9 hours ago
They didn't see the tax cuts for the rich b/c their echo chamber doesn't show them that.
TheVog | 9 hours ago
People in general have no fucking clue about the economy. At all.
Even extremely basic and readily available numbers like the fact that the current federal debt's gross interest cost alone (i.e. ~$1.35T which must be paid out every year) not only dwarfs defense spending, it's fully 25% of all federal revenue, or ~20% when looking at net cost.
That's the highest level in the post-WW2 era, eclipsed only by debt service levels immediately after WW1 and WW2, which you'd expect in those circumstances. That's a problem. Not only that, but there's virtually no chance the debt ceiling won't rise again in Q1 2027, even under Democrat control.
This number alone should petrify American voters, but I'll bet anything 90%+ of them have no clue about the above numbers.
listentomenow | 7 hours ago
Yes, but didn't you hear about the caravan of immigrants that was gonna cross the border or the trans person that wanted to play sports!?!?!?
What was this country supposed to do?
VeteranSergeant | 7 hours ago
> they said let's do it again
Twice.
Look, I get it. In 2016, if you were a Republican, you weren't going to vote for Clinton, and Trump was your only option. But I can't, and never will, understand how they could watch him flail and fail and then lie to their faces, and still vote for him again in 2020.
personman_76 | 20 hours ago
We have the ability to get out of this, but not the will. I feel like even if we break the deficit, we won't break the debt. We'll have to put forwards over 1 trillion dollars a year and that amount of political willpower doesn't exist in a divided chamber. Maybe in 28, but by then I really worry our credit rating will be lowered by more than just one agency and our interest rates will look more like 1.25 or 1.5 trillion
Day_Bow_Bow | 17 hours ago
We have tons of crops with no markets too.
Our local elevator wasn't able to move any sorghum this past year, other than some to a local feed lot. They were the only one accepting the crop, and that was for maybe 5 days before they were full.
Anyone that was late had to chop for feed, though honestly this year it'd probably pay better.
High diesel prices, dwindling markets, and full storage will really put a squeeze on the rural economy this upcoming year.
personman_76 | 13 hours ago
Yeah that deal with China screwed our farmers hard, that one wasn't entirely on us either. They know they have the leverage when it comes to American farmers because they're our largest market. Increasing Russian imports into China lessened their need too, along with expanding farmland and recovering yields after a few bad years since 2021. When the war in Ukraine ends too, that's an additional 17% wheat, rye, etc grains coming back into the market without additional insurance and transportation costs, as well as coming back to the global south easier.
We need to get ahead of the curve and grow something more useful: hemp. We could change the Farm Bill to give incentive to grow it, add addendums to fuel burning plants to allow them to burn compressed waste bricks from stalks, and give an incentive to allow it to be added to concrete. Hempcrete has a lot of benefits and uses a waste product, at scale it's a win for internal circular economics that's better than corn ethanol. We'd have competition from SE Asia, but they don't actively export much at all because there isn't an export market for it yet. Hemp can be used just like cotton, can be compressed into plywood like material that's stronger than plywood, and the already mentioned concrete additive. I don't think there's a market for the leaves really, sort of, because if the interstate regulations behind it. But that's just a regulatory hurdle, not a logistical or demand constricted hurdle.
We have to be concerned about the corn market as well, with ethanol becoming less and less profitable eventually the corn market will have to compensate, as well as corn syrup consumption dropping. I don't know about the animal feed side of things on price, but if we increase herd sizes like we need to then that's at least a relief valve for the market, assuming good weather gives us enough water
FlirtyFluffyFox | 14 hours ago
Talking to some rural MAGA there's this idea that thry believe the city folk need them more than the other way around. They seem to think if everyone starts to suffer, they'll somehow ride it out because "we're tougher".
Nah, we're all fucked together. Your crops ain't worth shit if the city folk can't package, ship, process, and sell it overseas.
Badloss | 10 hours ago
MAGA people in general massively overestimate their "rugged American independence"
All of the Red State economies rely on federal money that is generated by the much more competent, much more successful Blue States. They scream about welfare queens but if the states cut off funding to each other the red states would collapse almost instantly.
meatspace | 10 hours ago
It's rural areas supported by cities. It doesn't matter what color your state is. A month ago they said Georgia was red and therefore was red state with red. Now George it is blue with blue state is Blue.
No matter what color you want to ascribe whether it's red or purple or green or whatever, the cities generate the money
Badloss | 9 hours ago
It's true, but its more pronounced in traditional heavy red states because republican policy makes it worse. Pick any quality of life metric you want and compare state rankings, the same pattern repeats across all of them .
meatspace | 7 hours ago
Georgia is a traditional heavy red state, and Atlanta is the bomb.
Badloss | 5 hours ago
Again, pick any ranking of all 50 states in any method you choose, and there's a distinct pattern. I'm sure Atlanta is great, but outliers don't make a trend.
meatspace | 5 hours ago
OK. A lot of states just changed which party runs it. I'm not sure how that factors into your statement, because momentarily many red states are about to be blue so the color chart won't work.
Badloss | 5 hours ago
>Its more pronounced in traditional heavy red states because republican policy makes it worse.
That's why I said "traditional" heavy red states. These states have had decades of GOP control and it will take a lot of time to undo that damage. Mississippi is not going to contend with Massachusetts for decades because it's going to take that long to un-fuck everything. That doesn't mean it's somehow the Democrats fault that these states aren't successful immediately on the first day they take power.
Accidental-Genius | 18 hours ago
If we go down, everyone is coming down with us.
TheDoomBlade13 | 13 hours ago
Other countries have already started to insulate themselves from the shockwaves. Everyone can see the writing on the wall.
Accidental-Genius | 10 hours ago
I mean yeah, you can also hide under your desk if a nuke is incoming but good luck.
personman_76 | 18 hours ago
I mean not really, our consumer market won't go away, our ability to produce will so we'll keep importing like usual. The majority of the world is also divesting out of our Treasury bonds, derisking their own currencies in the event that the dollar changes in value too much. With the bond market being as it is too, more countries are taking bonds with each other and investing in tangible assets like gold with Russians massive selloff flooding the gold market internationally.
The world is trying to insulate us, because they don't trust us. They might not do as badly as you think
Opening-Cream5448 | 9 hours ago
The consumer market is gone if the dollar fails. Sure people will still want but it doesn’t matter if the means are gone
MyCatLaughsAtMe | 14 hours ago
20 years ago maybe. BRICS exists. The world has been decoupling from our fading empire since 2016, repatriating gold, rearming, committing to new trade partners. Face it son, this is not the post WWII America anymore.
Accidental-Genius | 10 hours ago
BRICS literally, last week, gave up on trying to de-dollarize because China is in the shitter as well.
Repulsive_Peak_8655 | 9 hours ago
BRICS are the ugly girls in high school that somehow always thought they were not ugly and people were drooling for them.
aklordmaximus | 15 hours ago
That isn't as true anymore as you think it is.
Ignoring the exceptionalism/centralism in your thinking, yes everyone goes down when a large part of the global economy takes a dump. That is true for every large trading block. the US had to bail out Japan to prevent themselves from chocking on debt increases. So the reverse for even a 'small' market as Japan is just as true. If Japan goes down, so does the US.
But it is likely that the landing will be way softer for the other parties than some historical examples where the US had the benefit. You must not forget that since 2008 many global banks had stricter legislation put onto them. A global banking crisis isn't likely anymore. Moreover, the rich consumption market of the US is not as big (relative) as it used to be. The historical second and third world are becoming consumers too.
What's more, the US is way more dependent on foreign investment than vice versa. A dump in US markets frees up capital for other markets. Eurozone alone dumps €300 billion in the US every year. If that flow stops or even reverses, the eurozone is pretty happy. Not in the first shock, but after a few years. The same for other markets.
Independent-Water321 | 12 hours ago
Sounds like some death cult shit
Accidental-Genius | 10 hours ago
Welcome to Humanity™️
Jmazoso | 9 hours ago
This! The interest on the debt is the killer. We spend more on interest than on defense now. The tax cuts didn’t help the spending problem. And there’s enough fingers to point to everyone I Washington on that.
nochinzilch | 10 hours ago
A quarter of the debt thanks to the Bush / Trump tax cuts? Great.
A fun thought experiment I like to do is think about who owns the federal debt. Lots of 401k and institutional investors, sure. But also a lot of rich guys. So not only did they get their taxes cut, now they can use that savings to buy more government debt and siphon even more money off of the working class.
dust4ngel | 3 hours ago
> A quarter of the debt thanks to the Bush / Trump tax cuts? Great.
party of fiscal responsibility. know what's better than tax-and-spend liberals? las-vegas-spending-spree-on-the-credit-card republicans.
TieTheStick | 20 hours ago
TAX THE RICH OR EAT THEM
I'm incredibly disappointed in the willingness of average Americans to just continue to allow themselves to be divided and abused like this.
farmallnoobies | 19 hours ago
The rich own the lawmakers, so taxing them can't happen.
Eating them requires that a very large number of people are ok with risking their children being parentless and starving homelessly in order to do so. Things are rough, but they're not that rough yet.
redaemon | 18 hours ago
We don't even need to tax them that much. 0.14% on the top 1% by wealth could replace income tax on the bottom 50% earners. Hell make it 1% and we could more than eliminate income tax for 90% of American workers.
Stop taking everything out of workers' share of the pie.
ElundusCaw | 16 hours ago
They already spend way more on bribing governments than they ever would on paying taxes.
Because it's not about paying taxes, it's not about the money, it's about actively not contributing to society.
The cruelty is the point.
redaemon | 15 hours ago
Right. People complain "the wealthy can't possibly pay tax on their obscene wealth"... but they already pay for a ton of other shit using that wealth, without crashing the stock market or whatever other boogeyman the bootlickers bring up.
Are there potential macroeconomic flaws I'm not seeing? Sure. But the economy isn't working for most people any more. You can't fix this disaster without a little risk, and taxing the wealthy seems like the smallest risk we can take.
The poorest household in the 1% has $14M, incidentally.
MiniTab | 13 hours ago
Elon spent almost 500 million on elections in the last two years alone. It’s insane.
Sammystorm1 | 18 hours ago
That doesn’t fix any deficit…
CasualEcon | 11 hours ago
> could replace income tax on the bottom 50% earners
At the federal level the US has one of the most progressive tax systems in the world. The bottom 40% of earners have a negative federal income tax rate.
The bottom 80% of earners pay about 10% of all income taxes. The top 20% pay the rest.
Source: CBO data on taxes here: https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2024-09/60341-supplemental-data.xlsx Look at Tab 12. Use row 266 to see data for the top 20% before Covid.
KevinGreeneSolar | 11 hours ago
The richest don't earn income. The top 20% of income earners is the upper middle class. Your premise is propaganda.
You already know this, having been told the last 20 times you spammed that link.
CasualEcon | 5 hours ago
That workbook I linked also has information just for the top 1% and you can see that they paid 31% of all the income taxes collected by the federal government. They can't have done that if they didn't have income.
Dig into the data a little bit there and tell me where I'm wrong
ell0bo | 19 hours ago
yup. people have to lose a view of their future to risk their future
TieTheStick | 19 hours ago
Things will get worse until revolution happens.
How bad does it have to get before you're willing to get off your ass? (Not you personally)
For me, I picked an issue and got involved; I built a coalition and we kicked Flock Cameras out of my city.
mookmanthered | 15 hours ago
Reminds me of the old classic, The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress
spook_filled_donuts | 12 hours ago
A lottt of brainwashing has convinced millions of people that they should defend billionaires because they’ve earned it and everyone else is simply lazy trash and that’s why they aren’t rich. The people believing this are usually uneducated and struggling themselves or just ignorant and privileged.
SenseEuphoric5802 | 17 hours ago
The funny/sad thing is that taxing Americans now at this late stage will do absolutely nothing to stop the downward spiral since the vast majority no longer have anything substantial to tax.
All the cash now resides with the top 1%, and the government doesn't know how to tax it to prevent economic collapse, now pretty much a certainty on this trajectory.
ProduceNo1629 | 13 hours ago
> doesn't know how to tax it
Oh yes they do. They just are not willing.
Watch how this allegedly "impossible" task becomes super easy for the divorce lawyer of Jensen Huang's wife in the next few months. Suddenly all his wealth will become accounted for, so she can get her part.
Forkboy2 | 16 hours ago
Most of the wealth is in stocks and real estate, which will lose most of it's value if you try to confiscate it to pay off the debt.
ragequitteroffureh | 16 hours ago
Not American.
Could they not simply make more money, pay it to the poor people, then immediately hoover it up and give it to the rich people in the form of tax breakages?
Obviously it won't solve anything, but it would probably boost the morale of the poors, knowing that their supreme efforts helped to make their rich lords even more richer.
Parking_Chance_1905 | 15 hours ago
They would never do that... in 2008, they bailed out the banks that had loaned people money they knew couldn't be paid back instead of giving the people money to pay off the debt that would have gone to the banks anyways.
Tjam3s | 15 hours ago
I dont condone what they did, but it was the government that started bullying those banks to hand out bad loans to begin with
samhhead2044 | 14 hours ago
They could have even gave them the money to pay off the debt the people owed in totality instead it was no strings attached loan.
ragequitteroffureh | 14 hours ago
Ah, I don't mean a bail out.
I mean, move the entire sum of money from "The Economy" to the national debt bank account that is owed money to, such that the owed balance goes to $0.00.
Probably the best time to do it would be right before pay day.
Although I suppose that the money that people would have been paid would also have gone to paying off the national debt.
Shit.
That debt's never going away, is it :-|
mu_zuh_dell | 11 hours ago
That already happens, though mostly at the local level. Every entitlement has an industry surrounding it to capture that spent money. Food assistance is functionally a subsidy of grocery stores. Housing vouchers is functionally a subsidy of property management firms.
MsMarvelsProstate | 11 hours ago
California is a great example. They voted to keep taxes low on billionaires but to raise taxes on themselves.
Tiny_Dare_5300 | 19 hours ago
But I was told it was the immigrants stealing all our jerbs!
Yevon | 17 hours ago
We're in this hole because Americans want stuff but don't want to pay for it.
Try playing with a federal budget simulator and you'll realize any cuts you make are going to piss off a lot of people, and raising taxes is a losing electoral strategy when voters are children screaming "no tax, only spend.
Even if you max out the tax rate on the top 1% you'll only get about 1/4 of the way to solving the debt. You still need to either raise taxes broadly which won't get you elected, or you need to cut benefits deeply which won't get you elected.
Swagtagonist | 18 hours ago
We did unite and vote out the Republicans. Across the country we came together. Now it's the Democrats turn to sell us down the river to the parasite Epstein class. Hooray for Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries.
angelxeve | 18 hours ago
NO ITS NOT. CALL YOUR SENATOR AND TELL THEM TO VOTE FOR VAN HOLLEN
LockJaw987 | 18 hours ago
It doesn't count as voting out until a 67 seat supermajority in the Senate.
Test-NetConnection | 18 hours ago
Bullshit. a simple majority can get rid of the filibuster and tax increases on the wealthy can be put into budget reconciliation. Force trump to veto it, Republicans to vote against the veto override, and then they own the government shutdown.
oopsydazys | 12 hours ago
Republicans still have the presidency, which is a moronic position that includes what are basically the powers of a king, the power to pardon anyone of federal crimes including oneself, and the ability to veto legislation.
You can say "they own the government shutdown" but if you really think Americans are smart enough to process that correctly I don't know what to tell you. Trump will veto shit, Republicans in congress will uphold the veto, and American voters will blame the Democrats for getting nothing done and vote in Republicans again once gas prices are no longer stinging them in the ass or have stayed high long enough to become normalized.
The Democrats winning this election is great, but one election doesn't fix anything. They need to win over, and over, and over again for decades straight to fix what Trump's Republicans have done.
artisanrox | 8 hours ago
Of course there's no way to fix all this in one election. It won't be fixed in five elections. But at least they can do public investigations of all the Admin and do impeachment hearings to show the public what they put in office like rubbing a dog's nose in its own poop.
Dreadsin | 18 hours ago
Some people are so easily duped that it’s almost infuriating
becauseiloveyou | 18 hours ago
See: the election results in California on the proposition for a one-time tax to billionaires…
spankpaddle | 13 hours ago
And comments like these where you know absolutly the person gaslighting hasnt left their house in 3 days.
WeekendAtMadoffs | 19 hours ago
"The Rich"
what about the 10's of millions of boomers who are not paying an estate tax?
They should pay for their iraq wars, afghanistan wars, WTC attacks due to poor immigration policies, bailouts of wall street, mortgage debacles, etc.
The boomers $120 trillion bag should be taxed at 50% to pay off our debts.
Jzmu | 19 hours ago
How many billionaires are part of that generation? It probably skews their official share a bit. Instead of dividing us by generation, let do it by class
ryanv09 | 18 hours ago
No war but class war
First_Stat | 19 hours ago
10's of millions of boomers were never eligible for estate taxes.
Stop pitting the old against the young
Savings_Pie_8470 | 19 hours ago
>10's of millions of boomers were never eligible for estate taxes.
The estate tax exemption amount used to be $675,000 in 2001. Now it's over $14 million. So many boomers who would have been subject to it now are excluded cause Republicans raised the exemption so high it barely touches anyone.
taylorisntavril | 10 hours ago
Hey, at least they are good at voting in their own self-interest. Maybe a little TOO good at it, actually.
SmootherWorm | 18 hours ago
I’m all for estate taxes on amounts over a reasonable threshold adjusted for inflation, but that great wealth transfer will mostly not happen. Old people will get sick and lose everything they’ve accumulated over a lifetime to end-of-life care.
Boomer policies have been bad. They’ve directly led to huge debts both for the nation and for their children and grandchildren with cuts to services and failure to get with democratic social ideals that have worked very well throughout Western Europe. Trying to tax the pittance they leave their children and grandkids won’t help much now.
WeekendAtMadoffs | 18 hours ago
They are not leaving a pittance.
They are leaving $60 to $120 trillion depending on the markets.
Many will get sick, but untold 10's of millions more will drop dead spontaneously with very little medical costs. There is a lot of wealth and homes to go after there.
The potential Reasonable threshold could be $500,000 and their kids would still do well and society would do well.
taylorisntavril | 10 hours ago
Ive never understood how those people can cry that people just want "other peoples money" and that people just want "something for nothing".
Their children didnt earn that money.
Inheritance should be taxed the exact same way a direct gift would be, because thats what it is.
per54 | 18 hours ago
I’m not sure I want to eat people…
TieTheStick | 17 hours ago
https://youtu.be/iuiSo9wz5kI?feature=shared
Solenkata | 17 hours ago
Ok I'm tired of hearing that phrase so I'm genuinely asking you to define "eat the rich", what exactly are you proposing by that? Taxing is obviously the solution, but politicians are in the pockets of the rich, so how do you implement the second option? Explain how "a rich" is eaten.
TieTheStick | 17 hours ago
"Eat the Rich"
The phrase "Eat the rich" originated during the French Revolution.
• The Quote: It is commonly misattributed directly to the philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, but the exact line ("When the people shall have nothing more to eat, they will eat the rich") first appeared in Adolphe Thiers' 1823 History of the French Revolution.
• The Source: It was a paraphrase of a speech delivered on October 14, 1793, by French revolutionary Pierre Gaspard Chaumette during the Paris Commune, reflecting the anger of the Third Estate (commoners) against King Louis XVI and the starving populace.
• Modern Usage: The slogan has resurfaced as a popular expression of protest against modern wealth inequality, appearing in activist movements, political rallies (such as by Elizabeth Warren and the UAW), and social media culture.
In this case, we're not talking about cannibalism but rather dispossession of the excess wealth of the extremely rich.
DustyRacoonDad | 9 hours ago
>In this case, we're not talking about cannibalism but rather dispossession of the excess wealth of the extremely rich.
Err... umm... how come when we actually try to turn it into a billion dollars, we end up with $200 million after accounting for the overhead and market impact?
So, hmm... everything said and done, $150 million out of that billion. Not quite what we expected.
And then repeat the process, because that money was never actually there to begin with.
Porn0323 | 17 hours ago
[ Removed by Reddit ]
Academic-Bench-8828 | 13 hours ago
With a fork
Bigfreakingtits | 13 hours ago
Yep. Morons let the real culprits, the politicians, turn them against each other and hate rich people instead of the politicians. Fucking imbeciles.
sphinxofblackquartzj | 12 hours ago
Hate is a strong emotion, that's why
Decloudo | 11 hours ago
How about we stop making them rich?
Oh wait, that would mean people cant consume blindly for short term comfort...
KeeganDoomFire | 10 hours ago
Yep, no reason less people than fit on a bus should own more than 1/2 the entire US.
(I did not do the math but it can't be that far off)
TwiggNBerryz | 10 hours ago
We have no say. Our government is a corrupt dictatorship but instead of one leader its many, and we have no idea who any of them are. Trump is a puppet and the two party system is in place to keep people divided. Weve had one leader for 250+ years
ParamedicNervous2731 | 9 hours ago
start with the 50% of congress that are multi millionare and have been in office for decades
pinkflirtyy | 8 hours ago
its so frustrating how they keep pitting us against each other instead of fixing the real mess
Motor-Cranberry-1092 | 19 hours ago
What are you doing about it?
TieTheStick | 19 hours ago
I'm glad you asked; I built a coalition of like minded people and together we kicked Flock Cameras out of my city!
KnotSoSalty | 19 hours ago
Not enough people are talking about how the 10 year treasury bond went up 75 points in the last 6 months. It’s above 5% now and not showing any sign of stopping. Driven by AI and the federal government borrowing 1 out of every 3 dollars it spends.
30 year fixed mortgages never go below 1.8% above the 10 year. It’s currently more than 2%.
If this trend continues we’ll have 10% mortgages in 2 years. Higher borrowing costs mean lower prices. The middle class’s largest asset taking a haircut while inflation runs rampant.
Then there’s the whole question of how the debt ceiling gets resolved next year. Trump has played chicken with default before, who knows what he’ll do as a lame duck.
Mountain_Snow3613 | 18 hours ago
Brother that volatile rise was due to a shift in macro sentiment surrounding the fed funds rate. Everyone was expecting rate cuts and the Iran war shifted the paradigm back towards hikes.
We're not having 10% mortgage rates
KnotSoSalty | 16 hours ago
The last time rates were that high was 1989 but it was fairly normal before then. What’s going to stop it rising? As of right now the treasury is borrowing 400b$ per month just to keep the lights on.
Does anyone actually think the Trump administration will strike a fiscally responsible deal with Democrats? Probably not. At best we might avoid defaulting entirely, though that’s very much on the table.
ParamedicNervous2731 | 9 hours ago
yes thank you jimmy carter
AnUnmetPlayer | 3 hours ago
> What’s going to stop it rising?
Expectations of the trajectory of the Fed funds rate, which is what all yields are ultimately based on.
>As of right now the treasury is borrowing 400b$ per month just to keep the lights on.
So? Federal government borrowing is nothing like household borrowing. They control the currency. It's effectively all just money printing. Every time the government spends the money supply goes up, while taxation reduces the money supply. The borrowing is then just an asset swap. Yields do not correlate at all with debt and deficit levels.
dust4ngel | 3 hours ago
> Higher borrowing costs mean lower prices
is this why housing prices have not dropped when rates went up by 3x?
AdhesivenessHot57 | 9 hours ago
The war on terror added fourteen trillion dollars — that's $14,000,000,000,000. Ten trillion of which was direct military spending and four trillion was on welfare for the veterans. If the Iran war or even the blockade on Iran continues it'll probably go much higher.
sendgoodmemes | 11 hours ago
I’ll never forget the fear I had when he was elected the second time. The first I was frustrated but I was like, hey, maybe he’ll cut back spending and get the debt down, let’s see.
He has been a terrible president and is responsible for a quarter to half of our debt which is staggering. Can you imagine what we could have done for the people with that money?
I was always someone who leaned more conservative as fiscally responsible government meant a lot to me, but after Trumps first presidency I no longer believe in a government that will spend less. It can’t really, but even if it does cut back spending they just spend it into bombs. If we are going to spend the money anyways, let’s help the people.
Rodot | 9 hours ago
Did Bush II not turn you off to the myth of the "fiscally responsible conservative"?
evilJaze | 7 hours ago
Or any of the other many, many examples of other nations worldwide who have had conservative governments?
1776FreeAmerica | 9 hours ago
The issue with government spending is similar to the tragedy of the commons. It should be focused towards public goods, and the current accounting in place is woefully ignorant. Think about a poorly designed intersection in a road way, it might cost a million to fix of tax payer money, which seems like a lot, but the cost of the poor intersection is rarely considered in full. A good accounting would consider the cost of the number of times EMS has to roll for every wreck, the cost insurance has to pay out for repairs, the medical costs of any injuries, the cost employers incur from having an injured worker, the cost of time, fuel and wear for every traveler stuck in traffic waiting for the wreck to be cleared, and the commerce impact of business along that section. A weekly or monthly wreck at that intersection can quickly cost more than 250k annually, and on that alone, without considering the benefits a well designed intersection brings outside of fewer wrecks, that 1 million the government spends becomes a cheap investment. Yet, we only focused on the investment cost, and rarely consider the societal costs and benefits in politics.
Tax revenue is mostly from the Middle class, driven by their economic activity. Just like with boom bust cycle inherit in capitalist economies, the only way to stabilize the budget is pull the peaks and raise the valley. Unfortunately for where we are now, it takes time to not just implement those policies, but for the results to bear fruit. It's taken 50 years from Reagan's 'voodoo economics' to get us to this debt level, and like redesigning a intersection, it'll take time and a upfront cost, to stop the economic bleed and see returns. Trump is terrible, but the fiscal issues with the government now are because of privatization, and short-shortsightedness stacking for decades. If you go back to the debates in the 80's they knew their actions would cause the budget issues today. If you want more evidence, Ross Perot, the Texas Oil Tycoon ran for office in the early 90's and laid out some fiscal predictions based on the tax policies being championed, and described exactly what they needed to do to prevent current day, and how Reagan pointed the country to this scenario. His campaign videos included educational infomercials on his polices. He literally did analog power point presentations, trying to educate and warn people of the fiscal issues we're dealing with now.
It's worth noting both Reagan and Trump are Heritage Foundation Candidates, the only two they were able to get into office. They both frontmen, for a larger political group, that includes the Federalist Society he gave Bush Jr. the presidency in 2001, and Citizens United.
maxbaconism | 6 hours ago
You guys you could have elected Bernie Sanders, but you smeared him as a communist.
TitanicChurro | 11 hours ago
They've been setting this up for decades and the average American is too lax/distracted to care. We will get what we deserve and it's gonna really suck. But remember, we deserve it and that helps me sleep better at night.
IntellectAndEnergy | 9 hours ago
What most don’t realize, or maybe won’t admit, is that this debt issue gets solved one way or another. All of the options will be hard, it’s a lot of debt. Personally, I prefer solutions where the U.S. controls the timing and methods. They may need to act soon if this is the route they prefer.
AffectionatePlate804 | 7 hours ago
And the US has a history of doing it. Did it after the revolutionary war. Did it in 1933.
Debt restructuring will happen and some people are going to get screwed
ExistentialCrisis227 | 7 hours ago
State, local and federal debt exceed billionaire wealth so near 5x alone to say nothing of unfunded medicaid, medicare, social security and military and civilian pensions which are another 10x+ multiple. There is no taxing your way out of this.
AllDataIsMyIP | 6 hours ago
Homeowners live with mortgages several times their salary and work things out carefully.
flyingasian2 | 4 hours ago
Taxes will have to go up for all income brackets, not just billionaires.
Hyperion1144 | 10 hours ago
REPUBLICAN tax cuts.
REPUBLICANS made those tax cuts.
Don't even speak about the "fiscal conservatism" of the republican party. Not ever again.
Advanced-Patient-161 | 8 hours ago
Bush campaigned on reducing the size of government, then proceeded to make the single largest addition to the government in history.
Trump campaigned on no more wars, gets us into a war (without declaration of war from the congress).
The big thing back in 2004 and in 2016 was right wing slanted people voting "to keep the other person out". People were so much more concerned about keeping John Kerry and Hillary out of the President's seat that it didn't matter much who got in there. Trump was also talking about tearing things apart and saying what people wanted to hear in the moment, that the goldfish-memory kicked in and people didn't seem to remember pictures of Trump WITH Bill and Hillary back when they were buddies. Trump also said stuff like "yeah they were in my pocket back then, I know how this works, but I'm going to change things" when in fact he made them so much worse.
I'd say the voting needs to happen, and people have to just become smarter, but the underlying cultural issues don't look like they're resolving until more people are out on the streets.
KaijuFan1967 | 9 hours ago
And yet people keep voting for them. The only time they ever vote for Dems is when the bill finally comes due for the GOP mismanagement.
dwightpower420 | 20 hours ago
Reaganomics has never worked. Maybe we should tax the regard playing space man at 70% like we used to when the country actually was great. if his artistic ass complains he is more than welcome to go back to South Africa
Cudi_buddy | 20 hours ago
If you can donate 500 million of your own cash for a fuckin midterm you should be paying an assload more in taxes. Plain and simple.
BOOTY_POPPN_THIZZLES | 18 hours ago
and it blows a huge fucking hole in all those morons arguments “Ohhh all of his wealth is in stocks!! He can’t just withdraw it!”
Mother fucker, Elon almost conjured up a billion dollars to just throw at ads and marketing.
I never want to hear that stupid fucking argument again
taylorisntavril | 10 hours ago
Its like the stupid ass "we dont have the money to pay teachers!!!", but then the president feel his penis is small and goes to war and suddenly its "heres 2 trillion for the military, no problemo!".
Gildian | 16 hours ago
For the average American, that would've been like donating 30 dollars.
Less than a fucking tank of gas
Chronochrome | 19 hours ago
And it's a drop in the bucket compared to his net worth. He could have given billions and it still wouldn't have mattered to him.
codacoda74 | 20 hours ago
So many people don't know this fact. 50% for earned, 70% for unearned. We made great things and created the middle class.
40_Thousand_Hammers | 20 hours ago
The middle class was an accident resulted from a post World War 2 period and a lot of welfare created by FDR, the US rich class wants things back to normal: Very slow quantity of high end jobs and smart people, huge amount of idiots to do manual labor.
emoney_gotnomoney | 18 hours ago
“Fact.”
Please enlighten me. At which point in American history were the rich paying 50% of their earned income in taxes and 70% of their unearned income in taxes?
(And don’t just give me the marginal tax rates. Marginal tax rates alone are meaningless when you ignore the tax deductions, shelters, and capital gains exclusions that existed at the time which lowered the effective tax rates far below the top marginal tax rates).
TheeAntelope | 18 hours ago
Never. People repeat this all the time but do t realize “effective tax rates” were never even close to 70%. Effective tax rate for the rich peaked at 45% in 1945. These days is probably around 30% (give or take).
Would a 40% effective tax rate be good? Yes. But people need to stop spamming the 70-90% tax rate line like they have or will ever happening.
WodenoftheGays | 19 hours ago
So I hate Elon, but what do you mean by "regard?"
f1rehead | 19 hours ago
/g/t/
TheeAntelope | 18 hours ago
We never taxed anyone at a 70% effective tax rate.
Beneficial-Office978 | 16 hours ago
Yep. That tax code was massively complicated and so full of holes that by the time accountants found them all, the effective tax rate was between 12% and 13% for most industries. Among the lowest the US has ever had. Reagan's well meaning restructuring and simplification of the code almost doubled the effective rate to 20-21% and directly caused the economic downturn of the 1990s, which people typically and incorrectly blame entirely on a lowered rate of spending on defense industries due to the end of the Cold War, which is only true if you have a shit-tier Keynesian understanding of economics.
TheeAntelope | 9 hours ago
But all you ever hear on Reddit is “Reagan bad, Regan give tax brek!”
Neat_Let923 | 17 hours ago
You can literally see in 2002 the amount the US started adding to it’s national debt every year skyrocketed…
(All numbers were calculated in 2026 USD using each years CPI)
From 1968 to 2001 the average national debt added was about $469 billion each year.
From 2002 to 2026 the average was $1.7 trillion
The two biggest years of course were 2009 at $3 trillion and 2020 at $5.4 trillion
Mk6mec | 13 hours ago
What was the debt used for? Bush Middle East wars?
Neat_Let923 | 3 hours ago
Yes, the US ramped up military and defense spending in 2002 as a reaction to 9/11.
It wasn’t just the wars but that was a huge part of it. You also have to keep in mind that global security changed drastically after 9/11. Airport security, border security, and so on and so forth. Even shipping security that companies had to invest in so they could continue to ship into the US.
The two major years noted, 2009 and 2020, were caused by the massive recession from the 2008 housing market crash, and of course the Covid Pandemic. Both of which had major impacts on the rest of the world and not just the US.
Lilasky136 | 19 hours ago
The headline pairing is what stands out: debt now roughly the size of the whole economy, and the claim that tax cuts since 2001 added over 10 trillion dollars to it. The exact attribution depends on how you count, but cutting taxes without a plan to pay for it keeps pushing the bill to later.
statix85 | 16 hours ago
Sounds like a democrat problem to me. (/s just to be sure)
CappedReserveDays | 10 hours ago
Just to state the facts, Obama collectively added 70% to the national debt, whereas Trump has only collectively added ~45%.
https://www.investopedia.com/us-debt-by-president-dollar-and-percentage-7371225
Deficit is 6% of GDP. We have republicans who want to cut taxes and increase spending. We have democrats who want to increase spending without really talking about how we are going to pay for it which could lead to larger deficits. Long term interest rates become higher leading to more interest on the debt and making life more costly for Americans. It’s so bad there is no reasonable path to balanced budget that wouldn’t put us into a recession. The best course of action is a 20 year plan to get our deficit to 3% of GDP so it’s no longer outpacing the economy.
TheReal4thBrother | 17 hours ago
Boomers sold out their kids. Absolutely time to rise up and seize their wealth 🤷♂️
xXxPussyWrecker69xXx | 16 hours ago
Bruh boomers are dying and we're inheriting it
NonGNonM | 14 hours ago
lol they're going to squeeze out the boomers for all they have before they have a chance to pass it down to us.
Little-Maximum1290 | 13 hours ago
Thanks Claude
Randomdumpling | 20 hours ago
In some way it’s a democracy problem. It incentives politicians to give benefits away to certain people (or even everyone) when there’s none to be given. These sections of people may vary depending on the party but the end result is the same. No politician can run a campaign on austerity and win yet that’s the need of the hour.
MakinBaconOnTheBeach | 12 hours ago
I could see Thomas Massie doing it. Dude has a debt clock on his desk and is still super popular
skurvecchio | 19 hours ago
That's not a problem with democracy. That's a problem with every form of government.
LegOfLambda | 12 hours ago
I mean, if you have to do only things that make the famously short-sighted public happy in the next four-year period or you lose your job, you can't make any long-term sacrifices. In, say, a monarchy, you would be able to make a long-term sacrifice.
skurvecchio | 8 hours ago
In a monarchy, you still need the support of constituents, it's just that they're different people. Aristocracy/Oligarchy.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_law_of_oligarchy?wprov=sfla1
Mountain_Snow3613 | 18 hours ago
You can't run on widespread austerity but you can run on austerity for the top 1% or top 10% who have been compounding the wealth that they've been siphoning from the bottom 90% for the last 50 years.
It only takes 50% to win an election in the U.S., so leaving yourself the 90% who are getting the short end of the stick should be an easy margin to win with.
The question for this generation is whether or not enough voters will be able to smell this shit that the corporate politicians have been shoveling (Trump, Biden, et al.) and vote in a new class of politicians.
ric2b | 12 hours ago
> No politician can run a campaign on austerity and win yet that’s the need of the hour.
Maybe not in the US but it has happened multiple times in other countries, most recently with Milei in Argentina.
Cartographihi | 16 hours ago
And with the next election if a democrat wins they will blame all the economic malfunctions on the democrats and they will vote in another republican idiot 8 years from now who will trash the economy again. I bet they will even blame the democrats for losing the Iran war lol
The spiral of the two-party American downfall.
HuTaosTwinTails | 10 hours ago
Almost like providing constant tax cuts to the wealthy and letting them consolidate the majority of wealth at the top, while overspending on wars, military, etc. and then bailing out failed markets instead of letting them collapse weren't great ideas.
So_HauserAspen | 11 hours ago
> In the absence of significant legislative changes and assuming that the economy follows the path described in this report, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the total surplus will reach $281 billion in 2001. Such surpluses are projected to rise in the future, approaching $889 billion in 2011 and accumulating to $5.6 trillion over the 2002-2011 period.
https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/107th-congress-2001-2002/reports/entire-report.pdf
The GOP is a confidence scheme and they have taken advantage of 1/3 of the population since the late 90s with their constant manipulation and obfuscation of facts and information.
ironteddybear | 14 hours ago
$10T from tax cuts on $35T total added. Which means $25T has been due to excess spending. It’s so frustrating that most people won’t call out the spending growth, even though it is by far the bigger problem.
jakefromstatefire | 13 hours ago
Thanks for stating what I have said for a long time. Its the spending and the long prevailing attitude of "all the money belongs to the government except what they allow you to keep" that feeds the ever growing debt.
So_HauserAspen | 11 hours ago
W Bush cut taxes in April of 2001. We've been funding the budget by borrowing since W took office is 2001.
> In the absence of significant legislative changes and assuming that the economy follows the path described in this report, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that the total surplus will reach $281 billion in 2001. Such surpluses are projected to rise in the future, approaching $889 billion in 2011 and accumulating to $5.6 trillion over the 2002-2011 period.
https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/107th-congress-2001-2002/reports/entire-report.pdf
Mk6mec | 13 hours ago
Can you explain this better? Are the ultra wealthy overspending 25T or US gov?
ImprovementLow1474 | 13 hours ago
6.8 trillion from financial crisis bailouts and covid. 6 trillion from middle east wars. 11 trillion on interest payments and unfunded entitlements like ssn and Medicare. 2 trillion growth in domestic programs. Outside of tax cuts, alot of the deficit is the government fighting or manufacturing crisis without a plan to pay it back.
Rodot | 9 hours ago
Don't forget the supplemental appropriations that are not reported in the annual deficit and budget. The cost of the Iraq war was about double the amount allocated to it in the budget, the rest funded by supplements that are not recorded in the deficit but do add to the debt (one of the reasons the deficit does not equal the annual change in debt)
gmb92 | 6 hours ago
What the tax cuts (and to some extent financial market deregulation) was put us in much worse fiscal situations going into crises, worsening the fiscal impact.
UseApprehensive2025 | 20 hours ago
leave it to generations of conservatives & neoliberals to constantly destroy the United States budget with multiple forever wars, multiple tax giveaways and multiple economic downturns
snowrazer_ | 16 hours ago
60% of spending is welfare. Forever wars is nothing compared to welfare costs.
poonslyr69 | 12 hours ago
When you spend on welfare it circles back around quite quickly in spending, the velocity of money remains decently high with welfare spending.
When you spend on many of the costs associated with forever wars then at least half of the spending goes straight to contractors.
Contractors will end up spending part of that in a way which cycles back around, but a large portion of the money they recieve will end up in shareholder pockets. The vast majority of money recieved by shareholders goes into safe assets and effectively becomes dead money.
So generally, giving money to poor people is a much better use of public money due to how it circulates and ends up supporting businesses that provide necessary goods, whereas spending money on war will inherently suck capital out of the country and end up locking a lot of it up into safe assets for wealthy investors.
There is also the argument that forever wars also decrease the overall economic growth in other sectors. Regional instability in that way is obviously bad for most economic sectors. There are a lot of reasons why war is economically bad. But also, even if you win most of the spoils and subsequent contracts from the newly installed/changed foreign government will also end up being directed towards some of those same wealthy groups which will subsequently lock up the extracted profits into safe assets.
snowrazer_ | 6 hours ago
Spending money you don't have isn't a circle - that's creating a spiral of debt, deficit and interest payments.
Again, military and forever war spending is peanuts compared to welfare spending. You could end all military spending and wars and you wouldn't even balance the budget - what does that tell you?
The elephant in the room is Medicare/Medicaid spending which pays fixed prices for services, not determined by the market economy which causes all health care prices to follow suit and be inflated - this is why healthcare is so expensive. Education is similarly expensive because the government backs loans causing schools to charge extraordinary prices - just like healthcare.
Housing has become similarly expensive by the market being crowded out by people with government backed loans.
Prices weren't this insane 30 years ago. And we had forever wars back then too. Bigger ones. The difference now is welfare is out of control. Government involvement in healthcare, education, and housing is out of control, and all of those things have had their prices skyrocket as a result.
dingsh-lowcone | 14 hours ago
60% is false. It’s closer to 15% of our national spending. About the same as the military.
BallsOutKrunked | 13 hours ago
Ss is 20%, Medicare 15%, Medicaid 10%. Roughly 45%.
Military spending is 12%
dingsh-lowcone | 10 hours ago
I forgot about Medicaid so fair point, but to include SS is disingenuous. It’s not welfare, it’s an earned benefit insurance program.
Amazing_Statement357 | 8 hours ago
The central bank is the creator of the money supply... it's amazing that people aren't taught how this all functions. Through the lens of Modern Monetary Theory, the headline that “U.S. debt now equals the whole economy” mostly misreads what that debt is. MMT holds that a government issuing its own floating currency doesn’t need to borrow in order to spend: it spends by crediting bank accounts, and Treasury securities are simply the record of dollars created but not yet taxed back, effectively interest-bearing savings accounts for the private sector. Because the government’s deficit is the private sector’s surplus by accounting identity, a debt-to-GDP ratio near 100% just means the non-government sector holds financial assets roughly equal to a year of national output, not a bill coming due, since the U.S. can always pay in dollars and faces no solvency constraint. The $10 trillion-plus attributed to tax cuts since 2001 is likewise seen as money left in private hands rather than lost revenue, because taxes exist to create demand for the currency and drain excess spending power, not to fund the government. The real limit is inflation and real resources: if deficits push demand beyond what the economy can produce, prices rise, and that is when tax increases or spending cuts make sense.
That said, the current tax cuts almost exclusively benefited the ultra rich and the corporate sector widening the inequality here in the US.
Aware_Twist7124 | 10 hours ago
Now add layers of debt from municipal government, metro, TIF-redirection of taxes toward debt, tax breaks for companies, and everything else that drains actual tax revenues and/or changes tax revenues into debt payments.
Least-Blackberry-848 | 10 hours ago
Who possibly could have predicted this?! Only anyone with a basic understanding of economics. Arthur Laffer was a buffoon and his nonsense has been thoroughly repudiated by the last 40 years of economic history. Kansas achieved Conservatives’ wet dream of no taxes and went bust. We’re on the fast track to the same end as a country if we don’t change tack.
cyberdude419 | 19 hours ago
Trickle down works for the 1%, not the rest of the 99%.
I hope my fellow Americans can learn something from France’s demonstrations when they are being attacked by the billionaires and government
Individual-Pattern26 | 19 hours ago
Yes France is famously thriving economically
Pocchoni | 11 hours ago
France has a completely different system to the US. They are a currency user not issuer because they use the euro instead of having control over their own currency (the franc).
Then there is massive hoarding of wealth in France which starves the economy of internal spending that has to be offset by the government because France has a minor trade deficit with the world, also thanks to the euro. You l could some systems be changed? Yes sure. But the fundamental truth is that the debt of someone is the wealth of someone else. Just as spending is income. When I buy food for 10€, I have lost 10€ but they didn't vanish they are now in the pocket of the grocery store.
When the government spend 1 billion that's the money in the economy now being used to do business. Remove that money (budget surplus) and you either have a shrinking economy because now 1 billion is missing or someone else has to go into debt to cover those missing 1 billion.
Individual-Pattern26 | 8 hours ago
How did you accidentally stumble onto the economics sub? Where does this idea of "hoarding wealth" even come from? Did you think that billionaires hide their cash under their bed like what do you think they actually do with it? Or even if they did do that, it would somehow starve the economy? How so?
Double_Wall3207 | 16 hours ago
Tax cuts have not added $10,000,000,000,000, not ever cutting spending has added that. When ever "cuts" are discussed, it is usually a cut in the desired increase. Meaning, they wanted to raise a budget 10% but the only got a 6% raise in the budget so the budget was "cut" 4%.
EGarrett28 | 14 hours ago
Tax cuts don't add to the debt. Spending adds to the debt. This type of phrasing is so bizarre. It seems to assume that fiscal responsibility by the government is just out of the question.
whoeve | 12 hours ago
Thankfully we have Republicans in charge who (ignoring the insane idea that less incoming money doesn't reduce debt) are super good at reducing spending, right?
Whiskey_Bear | 12 hours ago
I lose my job... The loss of income isn't adding to my debt; the 6 video streaming services I left running are adding to my debt.
Taxes are the government's income. Lack of income == spending.
No-Designer-6533 | 11 hours ago
You’re right, billionaires did need that 10 trillion in tax breaks more than the nation did
EGarrett28 | 11 hours ago
Taking all the money from all the billionaires will not pay off the debt. Hating or attacking wealthy people is just completely irrelevant.
PaulyglotTV | 11 hours ago
taking all the money from the billionaires would heavily stop politicians from getting bought out by billionaires to impose toxic economic policies on the rest of us, so yeah, that alone would be worth it
jkman61494 | 11 hours ago
No but taxing them fairly and cutting taxes on the pleabians HELPS with the debt while also giving normal people more money to spend which then generates more tax revenue
It’ll never happen though. Democrats are ok the same team as evidence by monenofn see wealth redistribution bills being repealed when they had congressional power
propergreased | 11 hours ago
Tax cuts without spending reduction will increase the deficit. Government isn’t a business.
burritoace | 11 hours ago
This is just a straight up lie
hehehennig | 11 hours ago
Tax cuts create a gap in spending that must be filled in order to fund programs already in existence. You’re being intentionally obtuse or have no understanding of how fiscal policy works
TechnologyEither | 12 hours ago
Damn thats crazy it’s almost like the money you have equals income minus spending.
EGarrett28 | 12 hours ago
To some people the idea that you could spend less is crazy.
TechnologyEither | 12 hours ago
It’s both. We need to spend less and tax more
Jaegersmann | 12 hours ago
Yes… spend less on a country that has expanded & expanded in size… genius, you are an absolute genius.
EGarrett28 | 12 hours ago
Government spending in relation to GDP has gone haywire. The debt has actually passed the entire GDP of the country. It is in no way proportional to the country "expanding in size."
duesenjeffepic | 12 hours ago
If a minimum wage mcdonalds worker asks you for advice on how to buy a house wouldn't you tell him to get a better job first instead of seeing if he can cancel a Netflix subscription?
AK_Panda | 12 hours ago
If the government is running a budget deficit, then tax cuts are adding to the debt.
thewittman | 12 hours ago
No it's not adding anything it's removing potential income. Anytime you spend more than you make it's just a matter of time before things go belly up.
AK_Panda | 5 hours ago
Yes, and when you remove income and are already surplus, that lost income is replaced by debt.
RandyRandallsson | 14 hours ago
You have money coming in and money going out. More money is going out because the elite are being given tax breaks. As a result the debt grows. Hence, tax cuts contribute to growing national debt.
Schlieren1 | 13 hours ago
Its not a zero sums game. You can cut taxes and reduce the deficit.
When government reduces taxes, the economy responds positively. In many cases this results in increased revenue to the government compared to the previous higher tax regime.
BigHoneyisBestCenter | 11 hours ago
Can we get some examples please? Not trying to be snarky but I feel like tax cuts in very specific instances would cause this but that’s not what we’ve been doing
Schlieren1 | 4 hours ago
There are several historical examples supporting this argument. The economic principle is commonly associated with the Laffer curve.
Two prominent examples (one from a Democrat and one from a Republican):
JFK tax cut (1964):
The top marginal income tax rate was reduced from 91% to 70%. Corporate income tax rates were also reduced. The tax cuts put approximately $11.5 billion back into the private economy. The economy experienced substantial growth. Real GNP grew approximately 5.1% annually from 1964–1967. Unemployment fell to 3.8% by 1967. Federal revenues rebounded substantially following the tax reductions. The 1966 Economic Report of the President reported that federal revenues increased approximately $9 billion between the end of 1963 and the final quarter of 1965, despite $16 billion in tax reductions taking effect during that period.
Reagan tax cut (1981):
The top marginal income tax rate eventually fell from 70% to 28%. Individual income tax rates were reduced across multiple brackets. Businesses received incentives for investment and capital formation. The economy experienced substantial expansion following the 1981–1982 recession. Real GDP grew approximately 4% annually from 1983–1989. Individual income tax receipts increased from approximately $286 billion in 1981 to $446 billion in 1989. After adjusting for inflation, the increase in individual income tax receipts was approximately 14%.
chumbawumbaprinciple | 10 hours ago
Has this happened in the US over the last 50 years?
Schlieren1 | 4 hours ago
Two prominent examples, one from the 1960s and one from the 1980s.
JFK tax cut (1964):
The top marginal income tax rate was reduced from 91% to 70%. Corporate income tax rates were also reduced. The tax cuts put approximately $11.5 billion back into the private economy. The economy experienced substantial growth. Real GNP grew approximately 5.1% annually from 1964–1967. Unemployment fell to 3.8% by 1967. Federal revenues rebounded substantially following the tax reductions. The 1966 Economic Report of the President reported that federal revenues increased approximately $9 billion between the end of 1963 and the final quarter of 1965, despite $16 billion in tax reductions taking effect during that period.
Reagan tax cut (1981):
The top marginal income tax rate eventually fell from 70% to 28%. Individual income tax rates were reduced across multiple brackets. Businesses received incentives for investment and capital formation. The economy experienced substantial expansion following the 1981–1982 recession. Real GDP grew approximately 4% annually from 1983–1989. Individual income tax receipts increased from approximately $286 billion in 1981 to $446 billion in 1989. After adjusting for inflation, the increase in individual income tax receipts was approximately 14%.
Puzzleheaded-Wait785 | 9 hours ago
It's not a game at all, it's an accounting identity.
Malik617 | 13 hours ago
compare the rates of increase/decrease of tax revenue to government spending. the spending is the problem.
RandyRandallsson | 9 hours ago
Sure, but tax breaks are not helping!
EGarrett28 | 13 hours ago
You also seem bizarrely unaware of the idea that the government can reduce its spending. As has been pointed out, no amount of taxation can fix the debt at this point.
guzzti | 13 hours ago
How big of a ratio was the first house loan you took out, when compared to your annual income?
chumbawumbaprinciple | 10 hours ago
We've been cutting for awhile, and it hasn't worked (unless you are willing to admit that inequality and killing the middle class has been the goal). Maybe taxes could go up on people who have more money than can be spent in 100 lifetimes?
Wrenchinspokesby | 5 hours ago
And yet somehow we will settle on W2 earners making 300k
chumbawumbaprinciple | 5 hours ago
Oh no! Surely they are on the verge of starvation!
External_Birthday691 | 11 hours ago
I wouldn't say assume. But if you have obligations that were already expected to be paid on, like debt, then yes, cutting taxes is adding to your debt.
Like good luck telling a bank that they have to accept lower mortgage payments cause you decided your job was too much responsibility, and you decided to take a pay cut.
Yes government can stop spending so much. But there's a fucking minimum that the government can cut. Like there's a fucking minimum I can budget, but at a certain point I can't cut anymore spending out of my budget cause it will lead to insane hardships in my life, that might threaten my ability to keep my current level of income. So I have to find another way of making more money.
EGarrett28 | 11 hours ago
The US government continues taking on more debt. It's not just paying what they're already obligated to pay.
There is literally no other solution to this besides cutting spending or causing an economic disaster. Taxing is not going to do it.
Shiddin_myself_woo | 10 hours ago
Bro, spending money creates debt no matter how you look at it
godswewerestrong | 9 hours ago
Say that again
External_Birthday691 | 3 hours ago
Yes, but we need things like law enforcement, weapons for defense.
Like I don't fucking understand why people are so against taxes here. It's the social contract. Its what allows you to be on reddit while you shit instead of holding a gun.
Idk why the people in this sub are so tax-hating.
Virtual_Magazine_860 | 13 hours ago
Well when the other options for the government are 1) cut medicare, 2) cut social security, 3) stop wars, then this becomes a much more important decision then just stop spending money.
In fact so far with 4 decades in power until now at least, Republicans weren't capable of doing it. So regardless they'll be the ones people will blame when asked who pinned us with all of the extra debt.
EGarrett28 | 13 hours ago
I don't care about democrat vs republican. Both parties endorsed the stimulus that devalued the dollar and created the inflation we're seeing now.
Both parties also have continued the military entanglements also. Stopping them is not a difficult decision unless there are special interests involved pushing them to continue.
Super_Mario_Luigi | 12 hours ago
Retirement is bankrupting us. No program was created to create 20+ year retirement plans. However, that is what they have become, and it's political suicide to correct. So instead, we just yell at each other about the dumbest ideas we can find.
Virtual_Magazine_860 | 12 hours ago
We went into a couple of rando countries after 9/11 and gaslit people into thinking those were the two to invade instead of picking the one where all the terrorists came from. That cost about 6 trillion dollars that will be compounding till I'm dead.
When we are going into wars constantly and extorting other countries for their resources, thinking we can afford it, this becomes a real regret for some people politically.
Though most people in the US are political nihilists. Again the best option was no tax cuts. That's what we could afford at the time.
Super_Mario_Luigi | 9 hours ago
The post 9/11 wars were massively stupid. Although, that is just a cover anymore for any real discussion The $2 trillion deficit we've had every year since COVID has nothing to do with that. Before people come rushing in, foaming at the mouth because of Iran, $45 billion did not do that either.
doubagilga | 8 hours ago
Always “wars” as if they’re on scale for entitlements. Defense and war spending has gone from 9% of GDP to 3% of GDP.
Entitlements have ballooned to 14% of GDP. We haven’t spent near that number on wars even in the 60s era where it was more like 9%.
Social security and Medicare spending plus other mandatory and then debt interest is going to be 80% of the budget by 2036. We can’t solve this problem by pointing at war spending, which pretending it serves no purpose, is naive.
G42driver | 13 hours ago
I was going to say… thanks for nailing it. We pay a ton of taxes , fees and whatever else. The govt. needs to reign in spending in basically every sector. Like, 5% to 10% cuts across the board until we’re more solvent. Pain will be felt but let’s be honest: A good chunk of spending is pure pork.
preferred-til-newops | 11 hours ago
Plus tax revenue has continued to go up even after tax cuts, there's definitely a spending problem!
The_White_Ram | 8 hours ago
I think you are reading it too literally.
Its like a lawyer stopping his law practice and going to work at mcdonalds. The change in income directly impacts the ability to address tax liabilities.
Through fairly simply math you can deteremine how much the loss of income contributed to the increased debt by just looking at what the debt would be if you used the lost income to pay it off.
The_Susmariner | 6 hours ago
I agree with your point. Obviously tax cuts will increase the deficit. And obviously increasing spending will increase the deficit.
You're supposed to decrease spending AND decrease taxes or increase both... if your metric is the deficit itself.
Like you imply, the problem is the alternative to decreasing taxes, is to raise taxes. And people only seem to talk about the budget from a standpoint of taxation. And people scoff at the idea of ever ever ever reducing spending.
It's a fair criticism from the left that republicans lower taxes but don't actually decrease spending in any meaningful way, just as it's a fair criticism from the right that the democrats raise taxes, and then use that as justification to increase spending (as they fixed the deficit) which requires raising the taxes again.
Would absolutely love it if we could seriously entertain cutting spending. Yes, got it, the military budget is large and there's obviously savings we could find there... but in order to address the lion's share of the issue and really cut spending you have to start addressing benefits/welfare/etc. Which make up a significantly larger percentage of the budget than the military... and which paradoxically (despite people wanting to balance the budget) is a political death sentance.
So here we are.
5minArgument | 5 hours ago
Sigh. A ledger is comprised of revenue and spending. Tax cuts are revenue cuts.
Vast_Telephone_9988 | 4 hours ago
Spending that exceeds revenue adds to debt to be accurate
Weird_Ad7634 | 11 hours ago
The truth is that government spending is pretty responsible. A lot of the spending has a great ROI (in addition to, you know, the human element of it).
One thing that has consistently had terrible ROI, however, has been tax cuts.
Fiscal responsibility should take into account the idea that some spending brings in more than it costs...and the idea that some cuts cost far more than the benefits they provide. But here we are.
EGarrett28 | 11 hours ago
So you're fine with the national debt now being greater than the country's GDP? You think that's responsible and sustainable?
Praetor72 | 19 hours ago
lol ah yes, what the government really needs is more money. They just don’t have enough. No other solution, better rob everyone so the government can spend the money. They cant be trusted with it.
emoney_gotnomoney | 18 hours ago
There’s a guy who makes $400k/yr and still racks up massive amounts of debt every year. He asks me and some other buddies for money all the time, saying “if I just made more money, I’d be able to get my debt under control. Can you guys please give me some additional money to help me out?” His income has actually gone up pretty significantly over the last several years. It’s just that as his income increases, he just keeps increasing his expenses on top of it. It’s become clear that this guy doesn’t have an income problem. Rather, he actually has a spending problem. The more money he makes, the more he spends.
^ this is exactly what it sounds like when politicians say that we just need to raise taxes. They already bring in an insane amount of tax revenue. The issue is that they spend an even more insane amount. Like the example of the guy above, the government doesn’t have an income problem, they have a spending problem.
When they propose to raise taxes, they never accompany that with proposed reductions in their spending. Rather, they just use it to justify further expenditures on top of our existing ones.
Just giving them more money isn’t going to fix the problem, at least not while they’ve proven to have a terrible spending problem. You must first make them prove they can get their spending under control before agreeing to give them more money.
Financial_Profit377 | 12 hours ago
Or balance the budget. Tell us why you want to raise taxes. Run on the platform. Raise the taxes and actually do what you said you'd do. Its like Green Energy shit. They tax the shit out of gas and all this stuff for Green Energy. You'd think we have Nuclear Power Plants left and fucking right. Nope. Best we can do is a couple of EV charging stations.
perilous_times | 20 hours ago
Deficit is 6% of GDP. We have republicans who want to cut taxes and increase spending. We have democrats who want to increase spending without really talking about how we are going to pay for it which could lead to larger deficits. Long term interest rates become higher leading to more interest on the debt and making life more costly for Americans. It’s so bad there is no reasonable path to balanced budget that wouldn’t put us into a recession. The best course of action is a 20 year plan to get our deficit to 3% of GDP so it’s no longer outpacing the economy.
HartyInBroward | 19 hours ago
I love the sound of this because it’s reasonable and measured, but there’s no way under the current American political system that we can reasonably expect to follow a 20 year plan. The pendulum has swung no more than every 8 years for my entire lifetime. Politicians have several elections in a 20 year window and need to produce results now - often at the expense of the future - to retain their power and their seats. It’s just not feasible when we have this kind of broken system.
wthhappenwithmyoldid | 16 hours ago
There is a saying among some politicians that they can fix the debt problem but that means they won’t get re-elected. Hence, they won’t fix it.
liegelord | 18 hours ago
Balanced budget alone, achieved in any manner at all would result in a recession.
The deficit funds the private sector economy.
The problem is that the GOP is funneling the deficit to the wealthy and ultra-wealthy. The deficit needs to be reallocated to benefit the middle class by enacting broad benefits like Medicare for all.
Smart-Fox5634 | 18 hours ago
The policy of this administration is to infate the debt away with more spending and tax cuts for the elites. They don't care about a balanced budget.
liegelord | 4 hours ago
True, neither US political party is able to reduce the deficit in any meaningful way...but my point was: that is a good thing.
There is no such thing as "US debt"
We should be talking about forcing Gov spending to benefit more citizens broadly rather than the benefits of deficit spending accruing to a narrow slice of very wealthy people.
Wannabe__geek | 20 hours ago
Democrats say how we are going to pay for it. Tax the Billionaires like they are supposed to, and not spending on war. It looks like you have not been listening
Smart-Fox5634 | 18 hours ago
Brother, nobody in Congress cares about a balanced budget. The game plan should be obvious by now. They're going to infate the debt away with more spending and tax cuts. Doesn't matter what side of the isle you're on. That's exactly what is going on.
Sammystorm1 | 18 hours ago
Nah this is dumb. You can not tax billionaires enough to make a dent. It is not a serious thought. The US debt is about 40 trillion. All billionaires net worth is 8.4 trillion
Agreeable_Garlic_912 | 16 hours ago
And most of it isn't liquid.
Rodot | 9 hours ago
Yes, still somehow enough liquidity to spend billions on lobbying and elections, in a midterm year too
The FY 2027 requesting a second doubling of military spending with no increase in taxes though isn't much better than what dems are proposing. I'd argue it's actually worse.
poonslyr69 | 12 hours ago
The unfortunate fact is that too much money has been locked up in safe assets, so taxing billionaires isn't enough, you'd need to go after a lot of safe assets. Taxing billionaires would absolutely be 1/3rd of the equation though
BallsOutKrunked | 13 hours ago
You can tell how dumb a redditor is by the amount of times they say "tax the billionares" as a solution to our problems.
HartyInBroward | 19 hours ago
And we should all hold our breath for that - right?
Why haven’t Democrats followed this plan in the past when they had several opportunities to do so? Could it be that they are benefitting just like the Republicans under this broken system?
MrVacuous | 11 hours ago
Take every dime from every billionaire and you can’t even fund the government for a year lol. Pretending taxing billionaires will fix this is either a sign of Reddit’s lack of basic economic understanding or deliberate partisanship
perilous_times | 18 hours ago
That doesn’t cover the bill. Look at all the countries that offer these items. Many have VAT taxes and increase taxes on everyone. You are the one listening to propaganda and being lied to thinking taxing billionaires covers the bill fully. If the country wants these items than fine but let’s be honest about what it’s going to cost and whose paying for it.
emoney_gotnomoney | 18 hours ago
Except the Democratic party’s platform isn’t “tax the wealthy so that we can reduce the deficit / match our current spending.” Rather, it’s “tax the wealthy so that we can enact additional spending on top of our already inflated budget (universal healthcare / Medicare for all, free college tuition, student debt forgiveness, UBI, etc.)”
This is why I’m largely opposed to tax increases despite our massive debt. Increasing taxes isn’t going to result in our government reducing the deficit. It’s just going to give them license to spend even more.
In other words, we currently collect $5T in tax revenue and spend $7T in expenditures. If they were to increase taxes so that we now collect $7T in revenue, they’d just use that as justification to increase spending to $10T+. There’s been no actual effort by anyone to curtail spending at all.
When you have a friend that is terrible at managing his money and finds himself in a financial hole, just continually handing him more money won’t solve the problem. You have to first get him to fix his spending habits, otherwise the money you give him will just be wasted as well. Once his budget is under control, then you can start giving him some money to help him out with his financial woes.
Similarly, I will not support any tax increases until the government can show me first that they are willing to cut expenses first.
SoonerEsq | 14 hours ago
Universal healthcare is estimated to save the US economy $1 trillion per year.
Complete tuition forgiveness for everyone would cost less than the Iraq war alone (maybe half as much).
Free college tuition (with stricter controls over enrollment and which degrees are needed) is a direct investment in the economy.
kingdom_of_1 | 19 hours ago
It’s not just billionaires. There are lots of very wealthy people making less than a billion, the current tax bracket structure stops increasing the rate at 640.6k for single filers and 768.7 for joint filers.
There is an astronomical amount of money to be derived from increasing the rate marginally every few million.
That is the best practical way forward.
Sammystorm1 | 18 hours ago
You can’t tax your way out of this. Not unless you tax everyone more.
kingdom_of_1 | 17 hours ago
I mean, of course there is government waste that can be streamlined, but I think you are wrong about us not being able to generate enough revenue to ease the burden. With a progressive system, you could easily offset the cost of the military, which IIRC is the third largest budget item in our national spend. That goes a very long way toward lowering the debt, just the money we'd save on interest alone is enormous. I can run the numbers for you if you want.
And (again as I already said below) you haven't even touched cap gains. People are so afraid they are going to lose their standard of living if we raise the taxes on the wealthy. I just don't get where that fear comes from other than a knee jerk reaction to the idea of someone else putting their dirty hands on their precious dollar bills.
The disincentive to tax the wealthy simply doesn't exist. If they want to enjoy the immense wealth of this country, they are simply going to have to kick in. I think it's easy to forget just how much we subsidize the wealthy on their quest for riches. How many people does the Walton family employ that are eating food paid for by tax dollars? Who pays for the upkeep on the roads their trucks drive? I'm sorry but I do not have any sympathy for those whose net worth exceeds the GDP of a small country.
Tax those fuckers until they actually feel it for once, and see how things change.
Sammystorm1 | 10 hours ago
So wealthy people are already taxed a lot. Saying they aren’t is disingenuous. The problem is increased taxes change behaviors and not always in ways you expect. So just boiling down peoples concerns about downstream effects as wanting to give wealthy people tax breaks; that is nonsensical
AlternativeNorth6613 | 18 hours ago
shh this is Reddit, where we post feel good things that have no backing in reality
JDCam47 | 17 hours ago
You do realize we could take all their wealth from them and it would only lower the debt by 10 trillion or pay for a year of running the country at current asset valuations.
Also the moment mobilization happens their wealth would disintegrate because it’s all bloated wealth based off projected assets that are 40-60x higher than the stocks’ actual revenue.
Realistically we have to raise taxes across the board, massive spending cuts, end all wars or have someone else fund them, go after “missing” funds and prosecute fraud, liquidate any fraud or wasteful resources for revenue, sell off land and resources, steal land and resources, and my favorite; liquidate all assets from the families who allowed this shit show for the past 100 years.
We are in extremely dire straits and anyone who denies this is vastly misinformed and/or moronic. Even at a 500 billion surplus per year which is possible with increased income taxes and spending cuts it would take us OVER 80 FUCKING YEARS OF SUFFERING BECAUSE OF THESE CORRUPT PIECES OF FUCKING SHIT!!!!!
Edit: But don’t worry, we are too big to fail (actual quote from many morons in government and finance) and we have the worlds’ gold hostage, and our currency is directly tied into everyone else’s (except here comes BRICS), and we have the strongest military (true tbh), etc
Super_Mario_Luigi | 11 hours ago
Pandering has bankrupted us. Anyone who thinks its a collection problem is propagandized beyond belief. Specifically, retirement is killing us. Need to raise the retirement age by 2 years.
fitandhealthyguy | 11 hours ago
At this point, it will take BOTH spending cuts AND tax increases to reign in the debt. Neither alone can save us because we have allowed it to go on for too long.
DrTommyNotMD | 10 hours ago
Tax cuts being less than a quarter of the problem might be the real headline here.
This really is a spending problem not a taxing problem. Our entire economy is a pyramid scheme where each generation has to double or it topples.
ExistentialCrisis227 | 7 hours ago
State, local and federal debt exceed billionaire wealth so near 5x alone to say nothing of unfunded medicaid, medicare, social security and military and civilian pensions which are another 10x+ multiple. There is no taxing your way out of this alone being the solution. You are one one of the few here to grasp that.
Bennely | 10 hours ago
At this point it wouldn’t surprise me if the whole goal of Trump’s admin is to have his buddies loot the US for all wealth and then dip to elsewhere, leaving Americans absolutely in poverty with real consequences.
Unusual_Annual_5776 | 10 hours ago
Republican tax cuts by Ronald Reagan and Bush and Trump equal the national debt you can't run a country on air it takes money and if you take away Revenue you get debt and the Republicans are the king at that
RobinGoodfell | 10 hours ago
No more tax cuts for the wealthy. We've seen the consequences of these foolish policies and there is no counter argument that hasn't already been proven to be a lie. We are driving ourselves into ruin so that people with more money than they can ever use, can save even more money and hoard it like dragons!
RyCo1234 | 9 hours ago
Just tax the rich, leave the rest of us alone. Most of us can't survive a tax hike if nothing is else changes. They just won't do what needs to be done.
The political system is bought and paid for by the rich.
Ok-Wealth-7322 | 5 hours ago
So strange how decades of tax cuts for the wealthy haven't given us anything but deeper national debt, cuts to government programs and services, and a gap between the richest 1% vs everyone else that's wider than it has ever been in the modern era.
Opening-Restaurant83 | 17 hours ago
Tax cuts don’t increase the debt—spending does.
It’s frustrating how these stories are framed so that politicians can spend recklessly while lower marginal rates somehow get the blame. Federal tax revenue has stayed remarkably stable as a share of GDP for decades, regardless of the rates.
Pocchoni | 11 hours ago
Not spending just means someone else had to go in debt and since the US has a trade deficit with the world it has to be private citizens or businesses who both would rather save. Also private debt is way more dangerous because private individuals can't create their own dollars.
This debt scare mongering is truly a litmus test to basic accounting ability
alrighty66 | 12 hours ago
I feel for the younger ones who are going to have to deal with debt. Politicians are great at spending with no thought of how to reduce debt
-JustJoel- | 11 hours ago
Over a third of the national debt is due to taxes. It’s right there in the headline, you could at least try reading that far.
GreaterMetro | 11 hours ago
When did government revenue decrease from the previous year?
Pocchoni | 11 hours ago
What do they have to deal with. Can you explain
EthanielRain | 11 hours ago
Repaying it with interest
Octogenarian politicians are racking up an unimaginable (literally unimaginable amounts) of debt that doesn't just go away when they die
Pocchoni | 11 hours ago
What do you mean repaying it?
The debt is not paid off.
MooseIsLoose90 | 8 hours ago
Interest on the debt is a huge line item right now. If you don't pay the interest, you default. If the US economy defaults, it leads to the likely annihilation of the US economy and worldwide depression.
In order to pay increasingly large interest payments, you either print more money (increasing inflation) or reduce spending on everything else.
Pocchoni | 8 hours ago
The US government cannot involuntarily default on is debt. It can just issue more bonds to pay for it.
If anything the issue is the interest in the first place because for some ancient reason the US still issues bonds to a market instead of just doing it directly with the Fed
MooseIsLoose90 | 8 hours ago
If nobody buys those bonds, that's another horrific problem besides inflation- increasing borrowing costs for the federal government, which increases borrowing costs for everybody.
And yes, every entity on the planet can default and large nations have defaulted before. The US isn't immune to economic gravity.
Pocchoni | 8 hours ago
Nations that issue their own currency cannot involuntarily go bankrupt. Only if you politically want to like Russia once did or if you have debt in a currency other than your own.
You don't need to sell the bonds. That's a hangover from the gold standard times you can literally just issue the money directly from the Fed without the whole primary market. I'm not saying that whoever is in charge of us monetary economy would do that but it's absolutely an option
Also people will continue to buy them. Japan has 250% debt to gdp ratio with multiple years of 0% interest on them
MooseIsLoose90 | 6 hours ago
Yes, a sovereign nation can't involuntarily default, but when the alternative is just as bad or worse (hyperinflation), those semantics don't particularly matter.
You can't print your way out of debt. Ask Zimbabwe why that's true.
Pocchoni | 5 hours ago
There is not gonna be any hyperinflation.
It's super rare and only happens in cases where the government was either blocked from trade or had their debt in a foreign currency.
just for you, the big issue that zimbabwe was facing was their collapse in the productive economy. they simply messed up their agricultural economy and then got sanctioned by the rest of the world. had to import food (using foreign currency) and paid every worker in zimbabwe dollar which are worthless because zimbabwe at that point in time had no productive economy
America is not zimbabwe
cavershamox | 8 hours ago
No country with a sovereign currency needs to default, the country can just create more money to pay its debts.
US government spending works in the same way, taxes are just deleted, they don’t pay for anything and it’s newly created money that is spent.
Tax just acts to eliminate demand to prevent inflation.
It’s why France is extra screwed by using the Euro
tqlla3k | 10 hours ago
We are dealing with the fallout now. Inflation, and it’s just going to get worse if something isn’t done about the debt. We are looking at 2T per year just to pay interest
Pocchoni | 10 hours ago
You would have to change the system then. The interest based bond system is causing issues
NextGen-Panic | 19 hours ago
Nah, everything's fine!
Ask Former Fed Chair Jerome Powell!
https://reddit.com/link/19speh6cjjisg/video/o3kwr4mufw1i1/player
(Obviously, MAGA will be perfectly happy to foot this debt, since this is the end result of what their agenda of white-supremacy-at-all-costs has wrought.)
PDessi | 19 hours ago
He’s just stealing from citizens until he can’t anymore. We’re just watching and waiting for someone else to stop him. It’s how much longer can he lie… how much more can he steal.
bigolchimneypipe | 12 hours ago
Who?
Ateist | 18 hours ago
"Independent Fed with dual mandate" is what's not working.
You can't have a 3% inflation target when budget deficit is above 6% of GDP
By artificially lowering inflation, Fed kills growth and creates a massive wealth tax cut for the rich, making those with debts poorer.
EffectiveTop842 | 15 hours ago
Dear young people, your only chance at a prosperous adulthood is to elect nerdy economic types, fiscally responsible is the buzz term. The platform to care about is fiscal responsibility. It’s time to learn hard truths about budgeting.
Mrkvica16 | 6 hours ago
Oh yes, we saw this coming. Now that Democrats are coming to power, suddenly things like debt deficit and fiscal responsibility matter again. Funny how that works.
Low_Ability4450 | 14 hours ago
The U.S. debt problem is not just a spending problem: repeated tax cuts without offsetting measures have structurally weakened public finances, while rising interest costs leave less room for future policy.
WTFHELP | 12 hours ago
I haven't heard about the debt in 2 years, interesting that people seem to be interested in the debt now. What could have happened to make people want to talk about the debt? An election maybe?
Mrkvica16 | 6 hours ago
Yep. Isn’t it funny how that works, like a clockwork. Which depths of Heritage foundation did this commentators come from?
happytree23 | 18 hours ago
Remember this scene when it comes time to vote in 2028
Ill-Astronaut4652 | 14 hours ago
The democrats have a tall order challenge Trump and his minions will pull down the us economy and the global order if not managed
No check and balance for the past two years
Minimum_Raccoon_1501 | 11 hours ago
Right now, the only thing that fixes the economy is interest rates back up to 15%, no more tax cuts, & freezing spending.
This is why collapse is certain. Nobody is gonna do these things.
saltlampshade | 10 hours ago
Many are blaming the tax cuts and yes those are a real issue but it's because they weren't combined with meaningful spending cuts. So basically every party spends like drunken sailors but republicans do it while also cutting taxes.
Eventually it's going to blow up in our faces and crash the US economy but neither party has the political will to address it.
ansiz | 9 hours ago
It's crazy that at one point we had debates about budget surpluses (1998 to 2001) and what would we do with all of this extra money. And here we are not quite 30 years later over 40 trillion in debt.
A2Rhombus | 9 hours ago
I think we should start including the debt in the economy. If a person is in debt they have negative net worth, why not a country? Why do we get to keep saying the economy is good when we are so deep in the hole?
D4db0d0hye4h | 9 hours ago
Look, Republicans! Look with your eyes. Does this make sense to you? Do you understand now how youve been lied to and manipulated? Is banning 3 or 4 Trans kids from playing sports over the past 25 years worth 10 Trillion dollars and your children's future?
Constant_Curve | 9 hours ago
The US gov't deficit is 6% of GDP, and growing. Without deficit spending the GDP growth you've seen would be negative. It's all a big lie, fueled with debt to say that the US is performing much better than other developed economies.
You could make the same argument for france, and other western economies which have run on deficits since before the pandemic. The difference in the US is that the deficit spending somehow goes to the 1% and not on social programs so the K shaped economy is acutely felt.
Mish61 | 9 hours ago
Tax cuts NEVER pay for themselves. The Republican supply side myth that wealthy people need to prosper more for anyone to prosper at all is the greatest lie ever told.
Extreme_Whole5892 | 7 hours ago
Balance the budget, please. It's the only way forward. Just stop with the pork-barrel, stop with the international handouts... START with fixing our own problems.
charliecarpenter | 7 hours ago
This isn’t a complex solution. The USA is gonna have to make cuts across the board and gradually and slowly increase taxes. There isn’t a single program that should not recieve cuts.
Plzlaw4me | 6 hours ago
I for one cannot believe that when we cut funds the federal government collects, the federal government collects less funds. Why didn’t anyone tell me this could happen?!?!
obwanabe | 6 hours ago
Tax billionaires all tax cuts they have received from Reagan to present. Use the tax revenues to buy down the debt, fund schools, Medicare, social security, & infrastructure maintenance.
ANMorton | 4 hours ago
Translation: I’m poor because I didn’t steal more of your money. In other words, you are saying that the US debt would be less if the government had taken more of the people’s money.
poopmee | 4 hours ago
The idea of DOGE at the time sounded great. The execution however and who ran it was not. I would have loved to see an actual audit on where all our money is going and make meaningful cuts to areas that we don’t need (not the department of education!!). Unfortunately if you believe there is any sort of corruption in the government then the cuts won’t affect all that ghost money lol
GXP_2009 | 3 hours ago
Cut spending. Implement budget accountability within the agencies. Audit all agencies for waste/fraud. Stop funding anything outside of our borders. Then we can discuss raising taxes
radiodmr | 18 hours ago
Pretty sure the only presidents in the last 40 years to reduce the annual budget deficit --which to be clear is not the national debt, ok--have all been Democrats. Clinton, Obama, and Biden.
PIK_Toggle | 12 hours ago
Interesting, since congress controls spending.
throwawaygoawaynz | 17 hours ago
Budget deficits do not matter for a country the size of the US, so long as GDP is outgrowing debt and deficit.
Biden massively overcooked the economy, and he added about $2 in debt for every $1 of GDP he created. These high borrowing rates also impact the deficit.
Obama also added a lot more debt than he grew the economy by.
The last President that did a good job on the economy was Clinton, but he had the benefit of massive tailwinds for various reasons, and also set the conditions for the GFC at the end of his presidency.
Also tax cuts also need to be looked through the lens of GDP growth. Sure they added $10T in debt but did they create $11T+ in economic activity? If that was the case then they were a success. There is also the Laffer curve to consider, raising taxes becomes pointless after a while and spending needs to be cut instead. The US is probably below the Laffer curve but not as much as people here think.
Impossible_Cover_978 | 15 hours ago
What is this nonsense of a comment? Deficits don't matter except when Biden and Obama do them, and then you try to argue tax cuts created 11 TRILLION in growth? Anything to back that up other than the ramblings of mental patients?
Murdreed_Brotaids | 14 hours ago
The person you're replying to was specifically addressing the credit that the person before them was giving to Clinton, Obama, and Biden. They only mentioned those three presidents, thus the response was in turn about those three presidents.
The 10 trillion debt to 11 trillion activity ratio is a hypothetical question, not a claim.
As for the rest, Chat GPT rates most of it as supported but suggests that Biden's ratio was 1 to 1.09, not 1 to 2. So on that one, u/throwawaygoawaynz appears to have made a miscalculation using inflation-adjusted numbers in the wrong place.
Beneficial-Mine7741 | 17 hours ago
The debt isn't the problem; the problem is that we need other countries, companies in America, and billionaires to buy us debt.
It helps U.S. companies with their taxes if they do this.
Putrid_Leg_1474 | 12 hours ago
This US does not have a tx income problem. We have a spending problem.
You could tax everyone 75% and the government would still find a way to overspend it.
Apprehensive-Read989 | 9 hours ago
>and tax cuts since 2001 added over $10 trillion
This is the most asinine thing I've read on Reddit this month. Tax cuts did not add to the debt, uncontrolled government spending by every administration since 2001 (and before) added over (way over) $10 trillion.
CoffeePotProphet | 9 hours ago
Sure you can say uncontrolled spending, but any business that cuts its revenue, is a bad business
TheHyperboley | 9 hours ago
True, but if we didn't do the tax cuts, the debt would be $10b less right now