Skynet will learn and improve SpaceX technology, build an interceptor, go after them and bring them back. Humanity is causing enough trouble on planet Earth, no need for that in other parts of the Universe.
I was surprised to learn a while ago that there apparently aren’t plans to human-rate Starship anymore, at least not before a very large number of cargo launches. Though when you’re escaping Skynet it probably doesn’t matter much whether the government agrees that your vehicle is safe for humans.
Starship was supposed to take a hundred people to Mars in one launch. That was the original point of the entire vehicle. Then at some point Musk pivoted to moon base stuff (presumably after realizing how incredibly far we are from being able to build a self-sufficient Mars base). The original Mars mission was supposed to launch in like 2027 or 29, but of course that was always pure fantasy.
Starship, the subject of the thread, certainly could impact space exploration. Cheaper launch and bigger payload fairings open up all kind of options for telescopes, probes, etc. Plus it was designed to land on Mars, that certainly qualifies as space exploration.
Starship is not about space exploration, it's about monopolizing the launch market and the communication system through Starlink. Also each launch of Starship releases the equivalent carbon emissions of a thousand car-years, so that definitely does not help decarbonization efforts
> Also each launch of Starship releases the equivalent carbon emissions of a thousand car-years
I wonder if you actually believe this is a problem or just want another talking point against something you don't like ? Like all the "AI danta-centers are using up all the water" memes - kinda ruins your point and makes me dismiss any other potentially valid arguments you might have had when you bring up nonsense like that on the same level - what other irrelevant facts are you exaggerating at that point to strengthen your case.
I would even believe these these arguments are brought up intentionally by the people on the other side to make their side easier to defend. But occam's razor.
It's not irrelevant at all if you consider the scale that SpaceX is aiming for, which is 10,000 launches per year by 2030 (at least according to Musk). Assuming 76,000 tons of CO2eq per launch (https://www.space.com/spacex-starship-rocket-launches-enviro...), that's 760 million tons of CO2eq per year, which would be almost 2% of the total global carbon emissions today and similar to current emissions from all aviation worldwide. That's from a single launch vehicle from a single company. While water for data centers is not really a problem (or at least can be solved relatively easily), carbon emissions from space launches are not so easy to avoid
Each launch of Starship is about the equivalent of 3 long haul commercial jet flights. There are 4000 per day. Perhaps Starship isn’t where you should be focused if you actually care about carbon emissions.
Also it is about 600 car years for a Starship launch, not thousands.
Ok but you're ignoring that Elon Musk wants to launch tens of thousands or more starships per year and those will never be clean. Meanwhile aviation can at least in theory be electrified even if that means no more long haul flights.
I didn't say thoudands, but a thousand. The exact number depends entirely on your assumption of how efficient an average car is and how many km are driven per year. 600 cars in America, more like 1000 cars in Europe. My point was to give an order of magnitude
not true, they utilize ultra low orbit unlike other prev gen satellites that are higher, and hence can hang there longer, any starlink satellite decommission much faster.
False. If anything SpaceX is the only player that could develop and launch Kessler syndrome mitigations. Therefore we should wish them all the success that will allow them to continue to be in that position, and even better: let them get ahead of such an event and be ready.
Some of Elon's more ambitious plans will raise global temperatures by 0.5 to 1.5°C degrees through Starship alone if kept up for several decades. This is on top of the business as usual temperature rise.
I'm not saying it will happen, but he is basically advertising human extinction to investors when he promises a terawatt of datacenter capacity launched per year.
If we stop putting CO2 into the atmosphere then at the pre-Industrial Revolution rate of -10ppm/100Ky all photosynthesis on the planet would stop in ~3My. If photosynthesis stops... then all complex animal life on the planet will go extinct. If we raise the temperature of the planet 1.5°C nothing much bad will happen -- the planet will get wetter, not just warmer, if it gets warmer.
Yes, for the past several glacial periods CO2 has been dropping by 10ppm per cycle, and each cycle is about 100,000 years.
The only thing that would interrupt the collapse of atmospheric CO2 would be an otherwise catastrophic Yellowstone caldera eruption event, but that cannot be counted on.
Not sure what we could do? I am not sure what’s stopping others from developing good engines and rockets. I can’t tell if ULA or, say, Blue Origin just have the wrong designs, wrong people, or wrong processes or a mix of the above. I guess we could subsidize some of those companies and help them with r&d but that would seem unfair to spacex…
> I don't know why we should care more about being fair to spacex.
Both of those companies have been around since the early 2000s. Blue Origin is even older than SpaceX, and ULA members have been making space vehicle even before the merger. So it's seems odd to treat them like new startups just getting started and needing "a bit of help".
Nobody is keeping anyone from developing alternatives? Bezos' plaything Blue Origin has been slowly and not so surely trying to get there, several Chinese companies are trying, a bunch of startups are trying different approaches. One has to be the first and that one is currently SpaceX.
The numbers are quite different when you only count commercial launch services which at this point are only ~20% of SpaceX’s all-time payload tonnage. The rest is all Starlink. That said, SpaceX does still have a rather dominating market position.
I'm not sure that's how it works. At least some of SpaceX's success can be attributed to governmental incentives and contracts. It's everyone's interest (except Elon's?) that we find ways to tunnel such incentives and contracts to new companies.
The (US) government deliberately channels NSSL launches to multiple companies. In fact, current contracts include Blue Origin, ULA, Rocket Lab and some other small companies.
Many other companies in the US also have those incentives but few actually delivered (Rocket Lab did, but it's a small launch provider). Same thing in Europe.
Their success is because they developed a reusable booster and changed the economics of commercial launches. They deserve to profit from doing what no incumbent could be bothered to do first.
I'm not arguing with their success and accomplishments. I'm arguing that we want more companies to be able to do that, and that it isn't a godly miracle that SpaceX managed to do it - there are things that society can do to foster this kind of innovation.
It's funny you say this, because everyone thought giving SpaceX a chance at the NSSL contract. Every single launch company has a chance at these incentives and contracts, SpaceX just happens to actually be able to fulfill them.
The current situation is the result of competition. SpaceX is a newcomer in the commercial launch business, and they blew all their competitors out of the water. Europe has pretty much disappeared because left so far behind.
SpaceX has actually saved customers when their competition failed multiple times. Ariane, Vulcan, New Glenn, European Soyuz, Starliner, and Antares were all not available, late, blew up, had political problems, etc and SpaceX launched their payloads. Starlink launches so often it doesn't really effect anything to just bump one of them a couple months from now and substitute a customer payload in.
If anything, SpaceX undercharges, even though they've already forced their competition to lower their prices. Their timeliness is something none of the competition can remotely match at any cost.
SpaceX is of course going to be far ahead since they are their own customer with Starlink launches. By the time the constellation reaches it's target 40,000 satellite size, SpaceX will need to be replacing 8000 end-of-life satellites (target 5-year lifetime) per year, obviously a lot of tonnage.
They need less satellites for the same network capacity with V3, but constellation size is ultimately demand-stopped. SpaceX would want to keep growing the constellation for as long as they can serve more users with that extra capacity.
V3 sats are also rumored to have significantly better longevity, via a mix of improvements to frontal aerodynamic cross-section (more mass per area) and larger fuel tanks, but that is yet to be confirmed in any official sources.
> SpaceX is of course going to be far ahead since they are their own customer
Lots of non-SpaceX Starlink aspirants. Starlink per se doesn't explain this gap. Launch cadence does. (Which is dependent on Starlink, but not uniquely so.)
Question: Are these numbers mass "to orbit" or mass "to, and staying, in orbit"? The article says "payload carried to orbit" which is vague.
It might seem pedantic but going forward a significant part of SpaceX will be stuff put into orbit and then brought back (starship). And looking backwards, many modern sat launches involve delivery vehicles that enter orbit to deliver payloads but almost immediately de-orbit themselves.
The number I am interested in, from an environmental point of view, is how much mass (titanium/aluminum) is being burned up in the upper atmosphere. That a complex question.
The launch industry defines payload as customer mass delivered to a target orbit. This does not include the mass of the launcher.
Kick stages are uncommon; most satellites raise their own orbits slowly, with onboard thrusters. When they are used, they are usually disposed of in a high parking orbit.
Exactly. So customer mass to orbit does not include whatever stage did the orbital insertion burn, released the payloads, and then immediately returned. So these numbers are not the full story to the questions surrounding the amount of metal being burnt/vaporized into the upper atmosphere.
Well, the upper stage of the launch vehicle, the bit that achieves orbital velocity. The lower stages are dropped/returned at lower altitudes/speeds and generally do not burn up. But starship achieves orbit and returns unburnt, like shuttle.
If 77% of spacex launch weight is starlink, that’s 59% of all launch weight? Assuming spacex is basically doing that at cost then doesn’t this imply there simply isn’t much demand for capacity?
What would we put in space if there was double as many launches, for example? The only thing I can think of is an alternative constellation to starlink (hopefully nicer to Ukraine) which would need non-spacex launch capacity or subsidy to be competitive?
There's a chart in the piece, which shows the "other" category at a decent pace, albeit slightly slower than starlink.
I think a big part of SpaceX's model is induced demand. Falcon 9 has bought about far more than there was previously, but despite being very cheap compared to most launch providers, it remains prohibitively expensive for a lot of applications which might otherwise exist.
So - Starship is a pretty core gambit for their business, as by having full reusability they can vastly improve the economics, to the point where the cost of the vehicle and launch equipment is amortised over a large number of flights, rather than being a one-off, and the consumables end up being your principle fixed cost.
As to the "what would we put up there" - its the same information horizon as we're facing with AI, as we once faced with electricity, and with the steam engine - we just don't know what the applications of sufficiently cheap new technological capability are, as we've never had them before. Like... people moving their factories from steam just didn't even think of making smaller motors and putting them in the individual machines, rather than having an enormous belt-driven system, for nearly 50 years.
We can guess, though - things like space based manufacturing, resource extraction, compute, energy generation, and even tourism, become far more economically attractive once the cost drops sufficiently - this is Jevon's paradox.
It's the airliner model, essentially. Prop planes were a hideously expensive way to cross the atlantic, and only the super rich could afford it. Now, almost anyone can, as the technical development and marginal cost of utility has absolutely hammered the price.
I’m unsure why GP is being downvoted. It’s not unreasonable to be skeptical of space-based economic development output. Moving from pure human labor to machine-based automation on land was comparatively an easy sell; the supply/demand curve was pre-existing, and the supply/demand chain didn’t need immediate infusion of capex to support the new automation-produced products. I understand net new use cases (resource extraction via, say, asteroid mining) but space-based compute and manufacturing seem currently like a solution without a real problem to solve.
I guess there is potentially supplies for a moon base, but given the scale of it, and NASA's funding, it's hard to see that ever rivalling satellites (esp. Starlink replacements) in terms of yearly mass.
It's hard to see datacenters in space ever being cost effective, even with free electricity and cooling. Most of the lifetime cost of buying/running a datacenter GPU is the cost of the GPU itself.
I would assume fuel choice would dominate. The Space Shuttle's main engine used hydrogen and achieved an ISP of 366 at sea level. Compare that the F9's 282 at sea level from using kerosene.
ISP isn’t what matters at sea level. Launching more efficiently requires more thrust and kerosene greatly beats hydrogen because of its much higher density.
Focusing on ISP is how NASA got into a situation where they need SRBs for human rated rockets.
One thing we will all have to realise one day is that in a well lubricated free market with developed private capital, meritocracy almost always results in a monopoly. Which isn't good not it is bad. It's just how it is: something to accept if we want to maximise progress.
dan_grec | 8 hours ago
If they can pull it off, what they’re aiming for by about 2030 is difficult to comprehend.
ReptileMan | 7 hours ago
koolba | 7 hours ago
mihaaly | 6 hours ago
Sharlin | 6 hours ago
ReptileMan | 5 hours ago
Probably because it is overkill. It is meant to lift a space station not its inhabitants.
PR will be disastrous if something happens.
Sharlin | 4 hours ago
Noaidi | 6 hours ago
Sad to comprehend.
maxdo | 6 hours ago
Noaidi | 6 hours ago
thinkcontext | 6 hours ago
estearum | 4 hours ago
thinkcontext | 4 hours ago
fanwood | 5 hours ago
rafaelmn | 5 hours ago
I wonder if you actually believe this is a problem or just want another talking point against something you don't like ? Like all the "AI danta-centers are using up all the water" memes - kinda ruins your point and makes me dismiss any other potentially valid arguments you might have had when you bring up nonsense like that on the same level - what other irrelevant facts are you exaggerating at that point to strengthen your case.
I would even believe these these arguments are brought up intentionally by the people on the other side to make their side easier to defend. But occam's razor.
fanwood | 3 hours ago
NetMageSCW | 5 hours ago
Also it is about 600 car years for a Starship launch, not thousands.
imtringued | 5 hours ago
gus_massa | 5 hours ago
The objective should be to use the equivalent of biodiesel that can be carbon neutral.
(Would you be happy if SpaceX uses Liquid Hydrogen instead?)
fanwood | 3 hours ago
aja12 | 5 hours ago
maxdo | 4 hours ago
cryptonector | 21 minutes ago
imtringued | 5 hours ago
I'm not saying it will happen, but he is basically advertising human extinction to investors when he promises a terawatt of datacenter capacity launched per year.
Aarostotle | 4 hours ago
cryptonector | 23 minutes ago
Yes, for the past several glacial periods CO2 has been dropping by 10ppm per cycle, and each cycle is about 100,000 years.
The only thing that would interrupt the collapse of atmospheric CO2 would be an otherwise catastrophic Yellowstone caldera eruption event, but that cannot be counted on.
lgleason | 7 hours ago
mcjenkisns | 7 hours ago
rdtsc | 7 hours ago
HWR_14 | 6 hours ago
Also, spacex got a lot of r&d contracts when they were starting out, so it hardly seems unfair.
petcat | 6 hours ago
maxdo | 6 hours ago
rdtsc | an hour ago
Both of those companies have been around since the early 2000s. Blue Origin is even older than SpaceX, and ULA members have been making space vehicle even before the merger. So it's seems odd to treat them like new startups just getting started and needing "a bit of help".
efromvt | 6 hours ago
hagbard_c | 7 hours ago
mihaaly | 6 hours ago
Sharlin | 6 hours ago
world2vec | 6 hours ago
yoavm | 5 hours ago
NetMageSCW | 5 hours ago
It isn’t SpaceX’s fault none of them can deliver.
JumpCrisscross | 5 hours ago
Nitpick: this is an ATM machine.
world2vec | 5 hours ago
kevin_thibedeau | 5 hours ago
yoavm | 2 hours ago
tekla | 4 hours ago
tempfile | 6 hours ago
mytailorisrich | 6 hours ago
thinkcontext | 5 hours ago
If anything, SpaceX undercharges, even though they've already forced their competition to lower their prices. Their timeliness is something none of the competition can remotely match at any cost.
HarHarVeryFunny | 7 hours ago
mlindner | 7 hours ago
TMWNN | 7 hours ago
ACCount39 | 4 hours ago
V3 sats are also rumored to have significantly better longevity, via a mix of improvements to frontal aerodynamic cross-section (more mass per area) and larger fuel tanks, but that is yet to be confirmed in any official sources.
JumpCrisscross | 5 hours ago
Lots of non-SpaceX Starlink aspirants. Starlink per se doesn't explain this gap. Launch cadence does. (Which is dependent on Starlink, but not uniquely so.)
seizethecheese | 4 hours ago
> 77% of the mass SpaceX launched this year is its own Starlink satellites
sandworm101 | 7 hours ago
It might seem pedantic but going forward a significant part of SpaceX will be stuff put into orbit and then brought back (starship). And looking backwards, many modern sat launches involve delivery vehicles that enter orbit to deliver payloads but almost immediately de-orbit themselves.
The number I am interested in, from an environmental point of view, is how much mass (titanium/aluminum) is being burned up in the upper atmosphere. That a complex question.
thaeli | 6 hours ago
Kick stages are uncommon; most satellites raise their own orbits slowly, with onboard thrusters. When they are used, they are usually disposed of in a high parking orbit.
sandworm101 | 5 hours ago
Sharlin | 6 hours ago
cdot2 | 6 hours ago
Sharlin | 6 hours ago
sandworm101 | 5 hours ago
HarHarVeryFunny | 6 hours ago
All LEO satellites will de-orbit and burn up, which is going to be ~8000 Starlinks per year or roughly 5000 tons per year.
spwa4 | 7 hours ago
Sharlin | 6 hours ago
spwa4 | 4 hours ago
world2vec | 6 hours ago
wood_spirit | 6 hours ago
What would we put in space if there was double as many launches, for example? The only thing I can think of is an alternative constellation to starlink (hopefully nicer to Ukraine) which would need non-spacex launch capacity or subsidy to be competitive?
madaxe_again | 6 hours ago
I think a big part of SpaceX's model is induced demand. Falcon 9 has bought about far more than there was previously, but despite being very cheap compared to most launch providers, it remains prohibitively expensive for a lot of applications which might otherwise exist.
So - Starship is a pretty core gambit for their business, as by having full reusability they can vastly improve the economics, to the point where the cost of the vehicle and launch equipment is amortised over a large number of flights, rather than being a one-off, and the consumables end up being your principle fixed cost.
As to the "what would we put up there" - its the same information horizon as we're facing with AI, as we once faced with electricity, and with the steam engine - we just don't know what the applications of sufficiently cheap new technological capability are, as we've never had them before. Like... people moving their factories from steam just didn't even think of making smaller motors and putting them in the individual machines, rather than having an enormous belt-driven system, for nearly 50 years.
We can guess, though - things like space based manufacturing, resource extraction, compute, energy generation, and even tourism, become far more economically attractive once the cost drops sufficiently - this is Jevon's paradox.
It's the airliner model, essentially. Prop planes were a hideously expensive way to cross the atlantic, and only the super rich could afford it. Now, almost anyone can, as the technical development and marginal cost of utility has absolutely hammered the price.
mjamil | 3 hours ago
HarHarVeryFunny | 5 hours ago
It's hard to see datacenters in space ever being cost effective, even with free electricity and cooling. Most of the lifetime cost of buying/running a datacenter GPU is the cost of the GPU itself.
Whitespace | 6 hours ago
thinkcontext | 6 hours ago
NetMageSCW | 5 hours ago
Focusing on ISP is how NASA got into a situation where they need SRBs for human rated rockets.
dmix | 6 hours ago
stetrain | 6 hours ago
A_Duck | 5 hours ago
ApolloFortyNine | 4 hours ago
The EU has a GDP 10x Russia, but launches a quarter of the tonnage of even this current state of Russia.
anovikov | 4 hours ago