We Need Smart People Who Give a Shit

95 points by Jackevansevo 7 hours ago on lobsters | 45 comments

arcade | 6 hours ago

Not to self aggrandize by calling myself a “smart person”, but it’s nice to me to see someone pinning down the exact reason I left the industry. I love writing code, and I’m not a manager, so having to hand off the part of my job I love to a robot isnt something I’m willing to do for a long period of time, ie. a job.

pegasus | 4 hours ago

Agree. "Giving a shit" in industry is so very unfulfilling that it emotionally kills you. I tried my best for 16 years and was rewarded with ignorance and contempt. So I moved to academia (academic IT support role) where I can work at my own pace and people are supper happy that anything at all is being done for them.

tomjakubowski | 2 hours ago

As a student I worked a couple IT support roles at my university, supporting biology labs at one, before I switched into software after graduating. Those jobs remain some of the most satisfying, and definitely least stressful, stations in my career. It's a great feeling knowing your work is supporting valuable and interesting research, not to mention getting to rub elbows with smart and highly motivated people who aren't competing with you for promotions.

nickmonad | 4 hours ago

Can I ask what you're doing now?

alexozer | 3 hours ago

Comment removed by its author

icefox | 5 hours ago

Capitalism incenitivizes exporting costs to someone else. So, the "hot stove" metaphor at the end breaks down because the system is run by the children who, when told a stove is hot, coax or force their younger sibling to touch it for them.

travisgriggs | 2 hours ago

Do we have to keep blaming this on capitalism? These same types of behaviors spring up in all kinds of financial/governance systems. Corrupt communism. Free marketism. Capitalism. Asymmetric responsibility/liability and basic human self interest explain this shitty kind of behavior more fundamentally, imo.

tomjakubowski | an hour ago

To misquote a toast from Homer Simpson: "to capitalism: the cause of—and solution to—all of life's problems."

jaculabilis | 37 minutes ago

Most critiques of "capitalism" are not targeted at the concept of privately owning capital. The term seems to function mostly as a synecdoche of the larger economic system we have, of which capitalism is one component but not the sole source of its ills.

zaphar | an hour ago

Capitalism doesn't incentivize that. Greed incentivizes that. In communism greed incentivizes the same thing. In anarchy greed incentivizes that. In socialism greed incentivizes that.

When you've figured out how to solve greed then the problem goes away. Until then free markets with light amounts of regulation seems to limit it in ways that prevent mass starvation and violence more than any other system. But greed is pretty much always going to mess over any system you can come up with.

colonelpanic | 32 minutes ago

What you call "greed" is just laundering capitalist incentives through the language of subjective affect. The reality is, those who don't learn to follow those incentives will be replaced with those who are. Hence, pinning the blame on the defects of individual personality is missing the point.

davepagurek | 6 hours ago

Strong agree with this take. I suspect things humming along smoothly are doing so only because the smart people who give a shit still give a shit despite their job getting harder than ever. I'm kept up at night thinking about how we're sliding backwards like this and feeling increasingly disillusioned about changing people's minds without a big messy example of failure. Feels a little like Y2K and vaccines, it's easy to forget what the consequences are when we've put so much effort already into avoiding them.

gerikson | 5 hours ago

At least with the electrical grid in chaos and networking down globally the big bad scary AI won't be able to take over!

abnercoimbre | an hour ago

without a big messy example of failure

This happens over and over again and with our own folks too (caring programmers.) I was told two years ago to shut up when I would openly discuss non-technical issues: investing in social skills, proper organizing, etc.

Fast forward to today and the tone has shifted so dramatically. From my conversations with newly-apologetic folks, the vast majority of them were laid off recently. Ah, I see.

I’m not gloating: I’m asking why are we like this? Is there a hack we can cook up for humanity to become the kid who listens to warnings rather than always touching stoves?

tclancy | 4 hours ago

I would push back on this in one way, while agreeing with the thesis completely. The world also needs communicators who can talk to multiple groups. This crystallized for me reading Neal Stephenson’s Anaethem, where the smart people who gave a shit wound up as this high priesthood living apart and not having any influence or say (iirc, it’s been a while). Or, as an example, on the first truly large project I ever lead, for the company’s largest client, I went into a status meeting and listed every single thing that wasn’t right. Once my confession was over, my wonderful project manager turned to the client and said, “That’s Tom’s way of saying things are going well and we are still on target.”

Being able to see how everything is broken is a skill. Being able to fix the things is a skill. But the art is in having both and managing to talk about the likely outcome. The first by itself is Chicken Little and gets tuned out. The second is rose-colored glasses that break the first time something isn’t fixable. The gift is in explaining that while a shit sandwich is what’s on the menu today, it’s edible and will pass.

zod000 | 4 hours ago

Learning how to still be the person that points out everything that is broken, but can somehow still get any sort of useful dialog with upper management is a hard skill to learn. I have been making progress, because otherwise you get nowhere because you aren't allowed to fix things.

cadey | 4 hours ago

I wish society rewarded people for giving a shit. If you try and do something nice for the world, the world shits on you for it.

chobeat | 3 hours ago

some societies do/did. Just not the current neoliberal West

icefox | 2 hours ago

Fuck society, I love and appreciate you cadey and the world would be emptier without your efforts. <3

mordae | 3 hours ago

I find it incredibly frustrating that we've managed to collectively get ourselves to the point where people don't have kids anymore, because it is incompatible with survival under capitalism for all but a privileged, increasingly shrinking minority...

I mean the actual, very real situation that actually threatens to cause a very real collapse of our collective, global civilization...

We are also actively letting this mode of production destroy the biosphere of the very planet we are living on, by not steering the economy away from greenhouse gas emissions and overuse of agents and approaches that decimate entire species of animalia.

And yet, we here we are, debating nuances of capitalism possibly being detrimental to effectiveness of workers doing their job maintaining certain parts of our infrastructure.

Well, no shit, Sherlock! It makes it increasingly harder to maintain anything! Starting with life!

So what are you going to do about it? Are we striking yet?

This is a much broader problem than our industry. In particular, all our public services are held together by SPWGS who are being treated with extreme disrespect by management who has no idea what they do. The exodus of SPWGS from the federal government in particular is going to have long-lasting repercussions. I recently had a depressing dinner with some ex-CIA folks who related how the SPWGS there and the State Department have left (the ones who weren’t fired, that is) due to the intolerable stress of dealing with current leadership. Same applies to many other fields where reducing everything to money terms and management philosophy from an airport bookstore doesn’t work in the long term.

FRIGN | 3 hours ago

Sorry, I am not a native speaker and googling didn't help: What is SPWGS?

gerikson | 2 hours ago

Initialism for the group in the title.

FRIGN | 2 hours ago

This went right over my head. Thank you for taking your time with the response and clarifying this!

vincent-uden | 5 hours ago

While I agree generally with the take (and with a risk of being really negative), what industry does value their competent people who give a shit? Is this really as unique to the current situation in software development as we'd like to think? Our current economical system has no stated goal to produce well functioning services and products. We hope for it to "on accident" while it optimizes for profit. Does that actually happen?

icefox | 5 hours ago

Industry doesn't value their competent people who give a shit. Individual institutions do. It's based on having competent people at the top who also give a shit.

nickmonad | 4 hours ago

Absolutely. We have definitely crossed a tipping point with this stuff where even if it sucks, it's not going away. It will always come down to individuals making a choice based on values.

I think the creep of managerialism and the rent-extraction-economy is forcing competent people out from the top of institutions as well. I have several older relatives who are doctors and have worked in the health care "industry" their entire lives. Contrary to what you'd expect, their main gripe about the state of the healthcare system in our country today is not related to young people lacking competence, but to an overabundance of administrators with no understanding of how medicine works.

The main thrust of the relatives' argument is: medicine works best when doctors can examine patients and are given leeway to figure out how to help each individual. I.e: things work when people who give a shit are allowed to do so and not prevented from doing so. Instead, doctors nowadays get KPIs, OKRs, demands for "growth of the business", 3 hours of paperwork for each hour of actual work ... sounds a lot like our industry.

tclancy | 4 hours ago

I think that’s why the author mentions capitalism. Whatever it has turned into in the last fifty years or so is a machine that eats goodwill and spits out gold bars to the wealthy. Basically what Marx and Engels said. Try to forget I mentioned it or then you start questioning what the police do and stuff like that or who benefits from wars and people find you strident.

chobeat | 3 hours ago

privately-owned industries do only as long as it benefits the business. Private corporations are designed to extract labor from workers and turn it into profit. Giving a shit matters only as long as it helps the profit, but it's not what they strive for. If they find a way to get profit without giving a shit, they do it. Labor organized through cooperatives, community structures, public institutions tend to do better and serve efficacy over profit.

chobeat | 3 hours ago

I think this is the best repackaging I've seen so far of Marx's concept of General Intellect for a STEM crowd.

If you're a smart person who gives a shit at a company who's amenable to it (big if), you can always give a shit about the manner in which LLMs are used and adopted at that company, and deploy your smartness in service of trying to make things better. The conversation, unfortunately, isn't black and white. Using your "smartness" here probably doesn't mean being right the loudest about how LLMs are bad and should never be used. Rather, you need to employ empathy in order to listen effectively. But if your goal is to retain a modicum of humanity in our profession, I suspect this is one of the best ways you can make an impact.

gcupc | 2 hours ago

I'm not that smart, but I do give a shit, which is why I'm in the public sector.

travisgriggs | 2 hours ago

Why is this an article that gets boosted on something like lobste.rs? I mean, it’s cool, it’s a pat on the back for us seasoned trench workers. But we knew we and our peers were necessary already. But this message would seem much better lofte upon the ears and eyes of decision makes and check writers. Though, if history be any evidence, it’s an uncomfortable truth that their brains will just route around.

tclancy | 2 hours ago

Because it really, really matters to know other people see the same things you do.

jrandomhacker | 10 minutes ago

I've been job hunting lately and I really wish that a) there was a good way to put "I give a shit" on my resume, and b) that that would actually get rewarded

quindarius | 5 hours ago

Reminds me of the book Atlas Shrugged, and the qoute:

Where is John Galt

tclancy | 4 hours ago

Can you expand on why this made you think of a work by Ayn Rand? Generally curious. Also, one of the clothes brands that’s not with my daughter’s cohort right now (Brandy Melville maybe) has a sub brand named after him and it is so confusing to me.

mtlynch | 4 hours ago

Not GP, but Atlas Shrugged is about smart people who give a shit withdrawing from society because they feel that society doesn't properly value their contributions.

I suspect your confusion is that Atlas Shrugged is very pro-capitalism, whereas the linked article is staunchly anti-capitalist. The linked article thinks the world has too much capitalism, whereas Atlas Shrugged felt the US wasn't capitalist enough and needed less government intervention in the economy.

chobeat | 3 hours ago

Atlas Shrugged sells to outcasts the idea they are smart because they are outcasts. Being an outcast doesn't make you smart.

quindarius | an hour ago

totally!

Ayn Rand, is such an interesting writer. But she truly stands on the shoulders of giants of thought even tho she doesn't present it that way.

Both her major titles Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged have a central theme. What happens when you take shortcuts and don't do things in accordance to her moral philosophy that she tries to layout through monologues in the books. In Fountainhead, it is depicted in a individuals. In Atlas Shrugged its societies.

She loves the concept of primary movers and that few people are the catalyst for actually getting shit done in this world. And to be clear she portrays the ideal man or society. As something to strive for as she said in forward in Atlas Shrugged. The ideal is typically not achievable but in the pursuit you can do some good things.

Thats why I thought of it for this article.

Disclaimer: After being a reader of Ayn Rand for a long time I still think her Philosophy is not as well thought out as she likes to claim. I think that Adam Smith Theory of Moral Sentiments BLOW her out of the water without being a prick about it. Highly rec reading that book and following it Wealth of Nations. So much more can be said but I will hold here.

mtlynch | 4 hours ago

It's actually, "Who is John Galt?"

gcupc | 2 hours ago

No one ever asks "How is John Galt?".

tclancy | 2 hours ago

Which is how he wound up a man-o-sphere influencer.

essen | 2 hours ago

"What does that even mean?"

quindarius | an hour ago

There is a couple quotes in the book when he left the factory like

“Don’t despair! We will get John Galt!” said official broadcasts in the daytime — but at night, every hour on the hour, by a secret, official order, an appeal was sent from short-wave transmitters into the empty reaches of space: “Calling John Galt! . . . Calling John Galt! . . . Are you listening, John Galt? . . . We wish to negotiate We wish to confer with you, Give us foward on where you can be reached. ... Do you hear us, John Galt?” There was no answer.

not verbatim tho so I appreciate the callout