Math students fear AI will take their jobs—they’re using it anyway

143 points by scientificamerican 9 hours ago on reddit | 28 comments

[OP] scientificamerican | 9 hours ago

Everyone has heard what the giants of mathematics think about artificial intelligence—the open letters, the op-eds, the predictions from laureates who have already cemented their reputation. Almost no one has asked the people whose future is less secure—the graduate students and postdoctoral researchers left to pick up the pieces after AI continues to plough through the field of math. To take the field’s pulse, three math Ph.D. students—Anna Brandenberger, Hanna Mularczyk and Dora Woodruff—launched an online Google Forms survey in the wake of AI cracking problems that mathematicians had chased for decades. The survey quickly spread through word of mouth and department mailing lists: “We needed something that features the voices of grad students and postdocs as well,” Woodruff says.

Described in a preprint paper, the 268 responses from nearly 60 institutions paint a stark picture of a community in limbo: largely frustrated and anxious that AI is taking this field for a ride yet divided on what to do about it.

cyndaquilled | 5 hours ago

I mean, the lack of info on how to proceed with this seems like it would be intense af. Like, imagine a full field just going away

ThatGodDamnXmasTree | 6 hours ago

I think that now that the cat is out of the bag, society is now going to have to learn how to work with AI, there's really no going back.

I explained it like this to my nephew who got busted for using Chat for Math problems, that while the tool exists, there's a huge difference in being able to confirm the answer is correct and assuming it's correct.

Without experts who can confirm a result is correct, the answers are useless. We are still going to need people who can do math and things like that.

tossawayheyday | 2 hours ago

This is going to be a huge job market I expect. Because SOMEONE is liable for what AI produces and will need to validate it.

MagicJourneyCYOA | an hour ago

No, this is going to be an extremely small market. These people will be needed, but you're fooling yourself if you think that it will be a huge market.

HotwheelsSisyphus | an hour ago

The problem is that to be good at validation you need the knowledge to properly understand the subject and a lot of that comes from experience, trying things out for yourself, making mistakes, figuring out solutions on your own.

Puzzleheaded_Fold466 | an hour ago

Math degrees holders have among the lowest unemployment and underemployment rate.

They’re very employable with a lot of different options. Only a small minority end up in Academia.

Top_Border1060 | 7 hours ago

Honestly, AI helps me a lot to learn stuff. It can rewrite my handwritten course (and my handwritting is very horrible to read), write the intuitions of some statements, put hints on exercises and proofs so I can try to do them myself, reorganize the course like I want (for example putting the exercises inside the course instead of on a separated section), etc. It can also correct typos or things like that. And I'm using only the free version of Claude, which is quite crazy.

Master-Event-1643 | 7 hours ago

Honestly don’t get why you’re downvoted, and ill probably be downvoted as well for speaking out about this.

I do the exact same for my learning in university and managed to score extremely well in written examinations. AI should not be used to replace cognition but rather be used to challenge and build on it. Any question or bullet point in slides i’m uncertain, i just screenshot and ask, keep asking till i understand the content. Insert the entire deck of slides and create quizzes, create knowledge checks, etc… Such an insanely useful tool and there has never been a more exciting period for learning.

The people hating on AI, have this narrow take and closed view, that everyone just outsources their thinking to AI when reality is, they should be a tool and not a replacement. The tool itself should not be blamed when used in the hands of the wrong people, just like how knifes are in the hands of a chef vs a murderer.

_ECMO_ | 7 hours ago

Does someone know a single mathematician who either lost his or her job to AI or is sitting whole day doing nothing?

hattusili-the-third | 5 hours ago

I know multiple mathematicians who have had their entire research program vanish overnight. You aren't likely to see mass layoffs yet since we just started an academic year, but I would strongly expect to see funding cuts next year and possible layoffs.

_ECMO_ | 4 hours ago

I do expect funding cuts, but I sincerely don't think those will happen because there wouldn't be enough for mathematicians to do but because people deciding the funding were bombarded by the "AI solved math" message.

NewAgent5986 | 2 hours ago

I think math is cool, but besides being a professor, what are the job opportunities for mathematicians? It feels like a job that requires a lot of study and intelligence but doesn’t provide much in any tangible thing that makes money. I’m sorry I just don’t know how that degree results in a job where someone pays you to do it, besides niche cases, or a teacher.

Top_Border1060 | 2 hours ago

Data science and AI-related stuff, finance, research, statistician.

leftonred_b | an hour ago

Honestly everything.

Math is a degree in problem solving, people that major in math are really good at everything that requires critical thinking.

I've worked with them in fields from avionics to HVAC, and they were better than anyone else in troubleshooting.

Actual_Western3953 | 2 hours ago

“Accountants worried excel will take their jobs, they continue to use it anyways” written in the 90’s probably

Sun_Remarkable44 | an hour ago

This is true but incomplete. There were about 2 million bookkeepers employed in the US in the peak of the late 80s. Now it’s about 1.1 million.

Excel was a tool to do the work faster. AI could (theoretically) do projects start to finish.

Apples and oranges. Either way the trees are getting cut

tossawayheyday | an hour ago

Yeah, I’m saying that I think there is very much still a place for a traditional mathematics education for that reason

BLT_Trade_r | 6 hours ago

If you understand life you understand you have no choice in many matters, AI is just just such an example, you have to use it in order to stay competitive. There are probably hundreds of thousands of people in the US right now that are training AI to replace them because they need the money.

quickdraw9 | 4 hours ago

It's going to be important moving forward that we continue educating students even though AI will be the primary mode of computation. At some point we will come to an impasse if the general population loses the knowledge we have developed because it's easier and faster for a computer to solve the problems we face.

Sanchez_U-SOB | 9 hours ago

I dont think the net effect will be bad. Just like the loss of actual human computers as a job, Ai will change some careers but science as a whole will not shift too much. Science funding itself, or lack thereof, is having a much greater impact.

Also, what's the limit of how much Ai ie data centers do we actually need? Theres a point where its just overkill.

betabot | 8 hours ago

If trends continue this is a dramatic understatement. AI is going to completely upend the pace and scale of science, and it’s not clear if there will be much of a role for humans left at all.

The net effect will be profound discovery (if you can call it discovery since humans might not even understand it) at unprecedented speed, though, so maybe still a net positive.

EnvironmentalCook520 | 7 hours ago

I think jobs like doctors and lawyers will get replaced by AI. Probably all white collar jobs will eventually get replaced. I have been in IT, currently a sysadmin, for over a decade now but I'm still young enough for a career change and I've been debating on becoming an electrician lol.

betabot | 7 hours ago

I’m in software engineering and know my days are numbered as well.

AI has me asking deep and uncomfortable questions about purpose and the future almost every day now. We might eventually reach a good outcome, but we’re definitely in for some very turbulent years. I’m saving money like crazy. 😣

Clicking_Around | 3 hours ago

Money will be irrelevant post-singularity.

betabot | 3 hours ago

Then awesome. I’m not taking that risk.

Reddt-iz-cancer | 4 hours ago

AI is already outperforming doctors now.

CKingDDS | 4 hours ago

Drug addicts fear that drugs are ruining their lives— they’re using them anyways.