I think any book that includes “settler-colonial” is already a biased source. Especially when it frames the Ottoman Empire as a non-colonial enterprise.
These were two colonial empires fighting over a territory and exploiting local populations. Jews served in the Ottoman Army. As a minority population Jews served in all the armies in WWI. 500,000 Jews served in the Russian army, 320,000 in the Austro-Hungarian army, 250,000 Jews served in the American army, 100,000 in the German army, 55,000 in the French army, and 50,000 in the British Empire armies. More than 170,000 Jews fell in battle, 100,000 of them in the Tsar army.
Most teachers and students of the Gymnasium Herzliya High School (in Ottoman Tel Aviv) were pro Ottomanization, from Jewish and national considerations. Most graduates of the Gymnasium and other high schools enlisted in the Ottoman army. In the spring of 1916, more than hundred high school graduates were enlisted in a reserve officer's course in Constantinople, and after graduation were posted to the fronts as junior officers.
This whole post sounds like anti-Zionist history revision. While a small spy group sounds interesting it completely ignores the clearly documented facts that tens of thousands of Jews in Palestine not only support the Ottoman colonialism but served in its army.
I’m struggling to understand how you can accuse this post of ignoring Jewish support for the Ottoman Empire when it explicitly discusses that support.
The original submission states that many Jewish residents remained loyal to the Ottoman authorities, that substantial sections of the Yishuv opposed NILI, and that its activities raised fears of collective reprisals.
These aren’t incidental details. They’re central to the historical argument.
But there’s something else in your response I’d like to examine.
You claim that “tens of thousands” of Jews in Palestine served in the Ottoman army.
Could you provide a source for that figure?
The Jewish Virtual Library’s account of armed Jewish organisations in Palestine states that several thousand Jewish residents were inducted into the Ottoman army during the First World War.
Israel’s Ministry of Defense archives separately records approximately 15,000–18,000 Jewish residents taking Ottoman citizenship. That’s a figure for naturalisation, not military enlistment.
There is a substantial distinction between the two.
Jewish service in the Ottoman army is not disputed. Nor is the broader Yishuv’s opposition to NILI. Both are documented in the academic sources accompanying the submission.
What I’m questioning is your assertion that tens of thousands served, and your insistence that this post ignores something it explicitly acknowledges.
You describe the submission as historical revisionism, yet the historical evidence you’ve presented so far reinforces the distinction the submission was making in the first place.
The activities of NILI and the military service of other Jewish residents are not mutually exclusive historical facts.
I would genuinely welcome a source supporting your enlistment figure, particularly if it distinguishes Jewish residents of Ottoman Palestine from Jewish soldiers serving elsewhere in the Ottoman Empire.
Sources:
Jewish Virtual Library:
https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-evolution-of-armed-jewish-defense-in-palestine
Israel Ministry of Defense Archives:
https://archives.mod.gov.il/sites/English/Exhibitions/The_Jewish_Combatant_Collection/Pages/Questions-and-answers.aspx
Thank you for the detailed response. There are several points on which we agree, although I think you’re addressing a broader question than the one raised in my post.
First, I have no objection to examining Ottoman rule through the lens of imperialism or colonialism. The Ottoman Empire was an imperial power, and its administration of Palestine should not be exempt from historical scrutiny.
Indeed, Jacob Norris’s Land of Progress: Palestine in the Age of Colonial Development, 1905–1948 (Oxford University Press, 2013) examines colonial development across both the Ottoman and British periods.
Second, the term “settler-colonial” is an established analytical framework in historical scholarship. Its application to a particular movement or historical process can certainly be debated, but the presence of the term does not, by itself, establish that a study is biased.
For example, Kristen Alff’s 2023 research in the International Journal of Middle East Studies examines settler-colonial land acquisition in northern Palestine using Ottoman state records, Jewish organisational archives and other contemporary documentation. Importantly, her research also examines Ottoman state coercion and its contribution to Palestinian peasant dispossession.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020743823001290
Third, regarding Jewish military service, the figures and the account of Herzliya Gymnasium graduates you provide correspond closely to material published by Israel’s Ministry of Defense archives.
That source is worth reading in full because it also acknowledges that Palestinian Jews served with British forces against the Ottomans, including through the Zion Mule Corps and later Jewish battalions.
But more importantly, none of this contradicts my original post.
I specifically explained that NILI did not represent the wider Jewish community in Palestine, that many Jewish residents remained loyal to the Ottoman authorities, and that NILI’s activities were opposed by substantial sections of the Yishuv.
This is also explicitly discussed in Selim Tezcan’s 2019 study in Belleten, particularly the sections concerning NILI’s establishment and the Yishuv’s opposition to its activities.
Tezcan documents how Israeli history textbooks acknowledge that most of the Yishuv supported the Ottoman Empire, while a smaller pro-British group established the NILI intelligence network.
https://belleten.gov.tr/eng/full-text/390/eng
So I think we’re in agreement that Jewish political and military loyalties during the First World War were considerably more diverse than a simple binary division would suggest.
The subject of my post, however, is the specific intelligence cooperation between NILI and the British military during 1915–1917, and the historical significance of that cooperation.
Acknowledging that Jewish soldiers served in the Ottoman army does not negate the documented activities of a separate Jewish espionage organisation working for Britain.
Nor does recognising Ottoman imperialism prevent historians from examining settler-colonial practices associated with particular Zionist organisations.
These are distinct historical questions, and they can be examined simultaneously.
If there are particular findings in the cited research that you believe are unsupported or inaccurate, I’d welcome a discussion of those findings.
That’s precisely why I included the original academic sources.
Applying the settler-colonial framework to Israel is a discriminatory analysis because it forces a complex, diverse indigenous people into a rigid, racialized caricature to deny them the right to self-determination.
The argument rests on four direct points: It erases non-white Jews: Settler-colonial theory requires a binary of "white European invaders" versus "indigenous people of color." To fit Israel into this box, the framework fixates exclusively on Ashkenazi Jews and erases the roughly half of Israeli Jews who are Mizrahi and Sephardi—Middle Eastern and North African Jews who never left the region and were expelled from Arab lands after 1948. It validates past imperial subjugation: Jews maintained a continuous presence in the land for 3,000 years. Their population remained a minority only because conquering empires—most notably the Ottoman (Turkish) Empire—restricted Jewish immigration, banned land purchases, and enforced second-class (dhimmi) status. Calling Jews "foreigners" because they finally overcame centuries of colonial population control legitimizes Ottoman oppression. It criminalizes refugees: Colonialism is driven by an imperial mother-country extracting wealth. Zionism had no mother-country; the vast majority of Jewish immigrants were destitute refugees fleeing Russian pogroms, the Holocaust, and Middle Eastern expulsions. Labeling stateless genocide survivors as "colonizers" treats Jewish survival itself as an act of aggression. It applies a racist double standard to indigeneity: Jews originated in the Levant, speak a native Canaanite language (Hebrew), and maintain unbroken cultural and religious ties to the land. Denying them indigenous status because their diaspora spent centuries in exile—or because some acquired lighter skin—imposes a racialized expiration date on human rights that is applied to no other displaced people on earth.
We’ve now reached an interesting point in this discussion.
You began by dismissing the sources as questionable, accused the submission of ignoring Jewish service in the Ottoman army despite its explicit acknowledgment of that history, and then questioned my posting history and writing style.
Now you’ve presented a four-part argument about Jewish indigeneity, racial identity, refugees and self-determination.
But none of those arguments establishes that NILI did not cooperate with British intelligence, that the historical documents cited are inaccurate, or that the 2026 study’s interpretation of its activities is unsupported.
You appear to be treating historical examination of Zionist institutions as an attack on Jewish identity itself.
Those are not interchangeable propositions.
The historical experiences of Jewish communities deserve accurate representation. So do the activities of particular Zionist organisations, including their relationships with imperial authorities.
You can recognise both without contradiction.
The question I’ve been asking throughout is straightforward: which specific historical claims in the cited research are incorrect, and what evidence contradicts them?
You’ve had several opportunities to answer that question.
Instead, the discussion has progressively moved further away from NILI and towards defending Zionism against arguments the original submission never made.
I have no intention of disputing Jewish historical connections to Palestine. Nor do I need to do so to examine the documented activities of an espionage organisation during the First World War.
If you want to challenge the historical research, challenge the historical research.
But please stop substituting an argument about Jewish identity for an examination of the evidence.
That’s a fair observation, and I agree the Armenian genocide deserves greater attention in this discussion.
The Ottoman government’s systematic deportation and mass killing of Armenians from 1915 onwards had a profound impact on perceptions of security among other minority communities, including the Jewish Yishuv in Palestine.
There’s a particularly relevant connection to NILI.
Sarah Aaronsohn returned from Constantinople in early 1916 with accounts of atrocities committed against Armenians. Her experiences intensified fears within the Aaronsohn family and their associates that Jewish communities might face similar persecution.
These fears also help explain the divided response to NILI. While its members regarded cooperation with Britain as a means of escaping Ottoman rule, many other Jewish residents feared that discovery of the espionage network would provoke collective punishment.
Yuval Ben-Bassat’s research into Ottoman wartime correspondence examines these fears, including allegations that an Ottoman official threatened Jewish residents with treatment resembling that inflicted upon Armenians.
The chronological distinction is important, however. NILI’s early attempts to establish British contacts began in 1915, before Sarah’s return, so the Armenian genocide should be understood as an important influence on its development rather than its sole founding motivation.
Kate Dannies’ 2016 study, which is included in the original post’s sources, explores this relationship in some detail.
I agree that this context deserves greater prominence. It helps explain both the motivations of NILI’s members and the opposition they encountered within the wider Yishuv.
Thank you for raising it.
Sources:
Kate Dannies (2016), NILI and the Issue of Divided Loyalties in the Jewish Yishuv of Ottoman Palestine:
https://www.palestine-studies.org/sites/default/files/jq-articles/Pages_from_JQ_68_-_Kate_Dannies_0.pdf
National Library of Israel, The Diaries That Document the NILI Organization:
https://blog.nli.org.il/en/nili/
This is a curated account focusing on Palestinian cinema, archival material and related historical research. Its posting history naturally reflects those interests.
And for the record, this submission hasn’t been crossposted anywhere, so your claim about spamming it across multiple communities is simply incorrect.
You describe the sources as questionable, yet haven’t identified a single factual error in the submission or explained which academic source you consider unreliable.
You also claim the post contains terminology used incorrectly, but haven’t provided an example.
And now we’re discussing whether the prose sounds like AI rather than whether the history is accurate.
You’re welcome to challenge the research. That’s precisely why I’ve included the sources.
But if you want to question the historical record, you’ll need to engage with the historical evidence.
My Reddit posting history isn’t a counterargument.
The post explicitly distinguishes the activities of NILI from those of the wider Jewish population in Ottoman Palestine.
NILI was a relatively small espionage network operating under Aaron Aaronsohn and his associates. Its cooperation with British intelligence is historically documented, as is the opposition it encountered from substantial sections of the Jewish Yishuv.
Many Jewish residents remained loyal to the Ottoman authorities, while others feared that NILI’s activities would bring reprisals against the entire community.
This distinction is examined in Kate Dannies’ 2016 study, NILI and the Issue of Divided Loyalties in the Jewish Yishuv of Ottoman Palestine, published in Jerusalem Quarterly.
It is also discussed in Selim Tezcan’s 2019 research in Belleten, which examines how Israeli history textbooks portray these competing loyalties.
The existence of a particular espionage organisation does not establish collective responsibility, nor does it justify characterising an entire Jewish population as disloyal.
That would be precisely the kind of historical generalisation the original post takes care to avoid.
The subject here is NILI’s documented activities between 1915 and 1917, not the collective loyalty of Jewish communities throughout the Central Powers.
I would encourage reading the original post before attributing an argument to it that it explicitly rejects.
It is worth noting that Aaron Aaronsohn was given free access because there was a huge famine that was caused by a locust swarm and purposely exacerbated by the British and French. They hoped to cause a revolt by starving the population. He was one of the senior people devising a plan to deal with the locust swarm, and worked directly with Djemal Pasha, the Ottoman military governor.
The Jews of the province also had good reason to fear reprisal. The Djemal Pasha had gone completely off the deep end after finding French documents detailing their attempts to organize a resistance movement with various groups (most notably Syrian Arabs). His reign of terror ironically was one of the main motivations when an Arab revolt began.
Unfortunately the subsequent revolt meant that Djemal Pasha's crackdown got worse. Neighbors were encouraged to rat out neighbors; the military tribunals all hanging judges.
So, you had possibly the most prominent Jewish person in the orbit of the mass murdering Djemal Pasha exposed as a spy, during a period bordering on mass hysteria. Even separate from motivations in the circumstances of WWI greater Syrian/Palestine that was very much cause for concern.
Thank you for adding this context. It’s an important part of the story, particularly in understanding why the discovery of NILI provoked such alarm within the wider Yishuv.
You’re right about Aaron Aaronsohn’s relationship with Cemal Pasha. His appointment to oversee the response to the 1915 locust plague gave him access and freedom of movement that subsequently proved valuable to NILI’s intelligence operations.
Yuval Ben-Bassat examines precisely this relationship in his 2015 study, Enciphered Ottoman Telegrams from the First World War Concerning the Yishuv in Palestine, drawing on Ottoman archival correspondence. It’s particularly revealing that Cemal Pasha’s own administration had facilitated the movements of someone who would later work against it.
Your point about the famine also deserves attention. The Anglo-French naval blockade contributed significantly to the catastrophe, and historians have examined evidence that food deprivation was regarded by Allied officials as a means of weakening Ottoman authority and encouraging rebellion. The locust devastation, Ottoman military requisitioning, conscription and administrative failures compounded the crisis.
There is one chronological distinction worth making concerning Cemal Pasha’s repression.
His campaign against Arab political figures was already underway before the Arab Revolt of June 1916. Eleven were executed in Beirut in August 1915, followed by another major round of executions in Damascus and Beirut in May 1916.
M. Talha Çiçek examines this in Martyrs/Separatists, Syrian and Lebanese, published by the International Encyclopedia of the First World War.
That chronology matters because Cemal’s repression was not simply a reaction to an established rebellion. It was also part of the Ottoman authorities’ efforts to suppress perceived separatism and consolidate control over the Arab provinces.
And this brings us back to NILI.
The prospect of a clandestine British intelligence network being uncovered within an already deeply suspicious and increasingly repressive wartime administration helps explain why so many Jewish residents feared collective reprisals.
It also reinforces the importance of distinguishing NILI’s activities from the political loyalties of the wider Jewish population.
Thanks again for contributing this perspective. It’s precisely the kind of additional historical context that makes these discussions worthwhile.
Sources:
Yuval Ben-Bassat (2015), Enciphered Ottoman Telegrams from the First World War Concerning the Yishuv in Palestine, Turcica:
https://cris.haifa.ac.il/en/publications/enciphered-ottoman-telegrams-from-the-first-world-war-concerning-/
M. Talha Çiçek, Martyrs/Separatists, Syrian and Lebanese, International Encyclopedia of the First World War:
https://doi.org/10.15463/ie1418.10609
Library of Congress, The Locust Plague:
https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/americancolony/amcolony-locust.html
csick | 7 hours ago
I think any book that includes “settler-colonial” is already a biased source. Especially when it frames the Ottoman Empire as a non-colonial enterprise.
These were two colonial empires fighting over a territory and exploiting local populations. Jews served in the Ottoman Army. As a minority population Jews served in all the armies in WWI. 500,000 Jews served in the Russian army, 320,000 in the Austro-Hungarian army, 250,000 Jews served in the American army, 100,000 in the German army, 55,000 in the French army, and 50,000 in the British Empire armies. More than 170,000 Jews fell in battle, 100,000 of them in the Tsar army.
Most teachers and students of the Gymnasium Herzliya High School (in Ottoman Tel Aviv) were pro Ottomanization, from Jewish and national considerations. Most graduates of the Gymnasium and other high schools enlisted in the Ottoman army. In the spring of 1916, more than hundred high school graduates were enlisted in a reserve officer's course in Constantinople, and after graduation were posted to the fronts as junior officers.
csick | 7 hours ago
This whole post sounds like anti-Zionist history revision. While a small spy group sounds interesting it completely ignores the clearly documented facts that tens of thousands of Jews in Palestine not only support the Ottoman colonialism but served in its army.
[OP] stammerton | 5 hours ago
I’m struggling to understand how you can accuse this post of ignoring Jewish support for the Ottoman Empire when it explicitly discusses that support.
The original submission states that many Jewish residents remained loyal to the Ottoman authorities, that substantial sections of the Yishuv opposed NILI, and that its activities raised fears of collective reprisals.
These aren’t incidental details. They’re central to the historical argument.
But there’s something else in your response I’d like to examine.
You claim that “tens of thousands” of Jews in Palestine served in the Ottoman army.
Could you provide a source for that figure?
The Jewish Virtual Library’s account of armed Jewish organisations in Palestine states that several thousand Jewish residents were inducted into the Ottoman army during the First World War.
Israel’s Ministry of Defense archives separately records approximately 15,000–18,000 Jewish residents taking Ottoman citizenship. That’s a figure for naturalisation, not military enlistment.
There is a substantial distinction between the two.
Jewish service in the Ottoman army is not disputed. Nor is the broader Yishuv’s opposition to NILI. Both are documented in the academic sources accompanying the submission.
What I’m questioning is your assertion that tens of thousands served, and your insistence that this post ignores something it explicitly acknowledges.
You describe the submission as historical revisionism, yet the historical evidence you’ve presented so far reinforces the distinction the submission was making in the first place.
The activities of NILI and the military service of other Jewish residents are not mutually exclusive historical facts.
I would genuinely welcome a source supporting your enlistment figure, particularly if it distinguishes Jewish residents of Ottoman Palestine from Jewish soldiers serving elsewhere in the Ottoman Empire.
Sources:
Jewish Virtual Library:
https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-evolution-of-armed-jewish-defense-in-palestine
Israel Ministry of Defense Archives:
https://archives.mod.gov.il/sites/English/Exhibitions/The_Jewish_Combatant_Collection/Pages/Questions-and-answers.aspx
[OP] stammerton | 7 hours ago
Thank you for the detailed response. There are several points on which we agree, although I think you’re addressing a broader question than the one raised in my post.
First, I have no objection to examining Ottoman rule through the lens of imperialism or colonialism. The Ottoman Empire was an imperial power, and its administration of Palestine should not be exempt from historical scrutiny.
Indeed, Jacob Norris’s Land of Progress: Palestine in the Age of Colonial Development, 1905–1948 (Oxford University Press, 2013) examines colonial development across both the Ottoman and British periods.
https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199669363.001.0001
Second, the term “settler-colonial” is an established analytical framework in historical scholarship. Its application to a particular movement or historical process can certainly be debated, but the presence of the term does not, by itself, establish that a study is biased.
For example, Kristen Alff’s 2023 research in the International Journal of Middle East Studies examines settler-colonial land acquisition in northern Palestine using Ottoman state records, Jewish organisational archives and other contemporary documentation. Importantly, her research also examines Ottoman state coercion and its contribution to Palestinian peasant dispossession.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020743823001290
Third, regarding Jewish military service, the figures and the account of Herzliya Gymnasium graduates you provide correspond closely to material published by Israel’s Ministry of Defense archives.
That source is worth reading in full because it also acknowledges that Palestinian Jews served with British forces against the Ottomans, including through the Zion Mule Corps and later Jewish battalions.
https://archives.mod.gov.il/sites/English/Exhibitions/The_Jewish_Combatant_Collection/Pages/Questions-and-answers.aspx
But more importantly, none of this contradicts my original post.
I specifically explained that NILI did not represent the wider Jewish community in Palestine, that many Jewish residents remained loyal to the Ottoman authorities, and that NILI’s activities were opposed by substantial sections of the Yishuv.
This is also explicitly discussed in Selim Tezcan’s 2019 study in Belleten, particularly the sections concerning NILI’s establishment and the Yishuv’s opposition to its activities.
Tezcan documents how Israeli history textbooks acknowledge that most of the Yishuv supported the Ottoman Empire, while a smaller pro-British group established the NILI intelligence network.
https://belleten.gov.tr/eng/full-text/390/eng
So I think we’re in agreement that Jewish political and military loyalties during the First World War were considerably more diverse than a simple binary division would suggest.
The subject of my post, however, is the specific intelligence cooperation between NILI and the British military during 1915–1917, and the historical significance of that cooperation.
Acknowledging that Jewish soldiers served in the Ottoman army does not negate the documented activities of a separate Jewish espionage organisation working for Britain.
Nor does recognising Ottoman imperialism prevent historians from examining settler-colonial practices associated with particular Zionist organisations.
These are distinct historical questions, and they can be examined simultaneously.
If there are particular findings in the cited research that you believe are unsupported or inaccurate, I’d welcome a discussion of those findings.
That’s precisely why I included the original academic sources.
csick | 4 hours ago
Applying the settler-colonial framework to Israel is a discriminatory analysis because it forces a complex, diverse indigenous people into a rigid, racialized caricature to deny them the right to self-determination.
The argument rests on four direct points:
It erases non-white Jews: Settler-colonial theory requires a binary of "white European invaders" versus "indigenous people of color." To fit Israel into this box, the framework fixates exclusively on Ashkenazi Jews and erases the roughly half of Israeli Jews who are Mizrahi and Sephardi—Middle Eastern and North African Jews who never left the region and were expelled from Arab lands after 1948.
It validates past imperial subjugation: Jews maintained a continuous presence in the land for 3,000 years. Their population remained a minority only because conquering empires—most notably the Ottoman (Turkish) Empire—restricted Jewish immigration, banned land purchases, and enforced second-class (dhimmi) status. Calling Jews "foreigners" because they finally overcame centuries of colonial population control legitimizes Ottoman oppression.
It criminalizes refugees: Colonialism is driven by an imperial mother-country extracting wealth. Zionism had no mother-country; the vast majority of Jewish immigrants were destitute refugees fleeing Russian pogroms, the Holocaust, and Middle Eastern expulsions. Labeling stateless genocide survivors as "colonizers" treats Jewish survival itself as an act of aggression.
It applies a racist double standard to indigeneity: Jews originated in the Levant, speak a native Canaanite language (Hebrew), and maintain unbroken cultural and religious ties to the land. Denying them indigenous status because their diaspora spent centuries in exile—or because some acquired lighter skin—imposes a racialized expiration date on human rights that is applied to no other displaced people on earth.
[OP] stammerton | 4 hours ago
We’ve now reached an interesting point in this discussion.
You began by dismissing the sources as questionable, accused the submission of ignoring Jewish service in the Ottoman army despite its explicit acknowledgment of that history, and then questioned my posting history and writing style.
Now you’ve presented a four-part argument about Jewish indigeneity, racial identity, refugees and self-determination.
But none of those arguments establishes that NILI did not cooperate with British intelligence, that the historical documents cited are inaccurate, or that the 2026 study’s interpretation of its activities is unsupported.
You appear to be treating historical examination of Zionist institutions as an attack on Jewish identity itself.
Those are not interchangeable propositions.
The historical experiences of Jewish communities deserve accurate representation. So do the activities of particular Zionist organisations, including their relationships with imperial authorities.
You can recognise both without contradiction.
The question I’ve been asking throughout is straightforward: which specific historical claims in the cited research are incorrect, and what evidence contradicts them?
You’ve had several opportunities to answer that question.
Instead, the discussion has progressively moved further away from NILI and towards defending Zionism against arguments the original submission never made.
I have no intention of disputing Jewish historical connections to Palestine. Nor do I need to do so to examine the documented activities of an espionage organisation during the First World War.
If you want to challenge the historical research, challenge the historical research.
But please stop substituting an argument about Jewish identity for an examination of the evidence.
schuylkilladelphia | 5 hours ago
This is missing a lot of context with the Armenian genocide by the Ottomans here
[OP] stammerton | 5 hours ago
That’s a fair observation, and I agree the Armenian genocide deserves greater attention in this discussion.
The Ottoman government’s systematic deportation and mass killing of Armenians from 1915 onwards had a profound impact on perceptions of security among other minority communities, including the Jewish Yishuv in Palestine.
There’s a particularly relevant connection to NILI.
Sarah Aaronsohn returned from Constantinople in early 1916 with accounts of atrocities committed against Armenians. Her experiences intensified fears within the Aaronsohn family and their associates that Jewish communities might face similar persecution.
These fears also help explain the divided response to NILI. While its members regarded cooperation with Britain as a means of escaping Ottoman rule, many other Jewish residents feared that discovery of the espionage network would provoke collective punishment.
Yuval Ben-Bassat’s research into Ottoman wartime correspondence examines these fears, including allegations that an Ottoman official threatened Jewish residents with treatment resembling that inflicted upon Armenians.
The chronological distinction is important, however. NILI’s early attempts to establish British contacts began in 1915, before Sarah’s return, so the Armenian genocide should be understood as an important influence on its development rather than its sole founding motivation.
Kate Dannies’ 2016 study, which is included in the original post’s sources, explores this relationship in some detail.
I agree that this context deserves greater prominence. It helps explain both the motivations of NILI’s members and the opposition they encountered within the wider Yishuv.
Thank you for raising it.
Sources:
Kate Dannies (2016), NILI and the Issue of Divided Loyalties in the Jewish Yishuv of Ottoman Palestine:
https://www.palestine-studies.org/sites/default/files/jq-articles/Pages_from_JQ_68_-_Kate_Dannies_0.pdf
National Library of Israel, The Diaries That Document the NILI Organization:
https://blog.nli.org.il/en/nili/
apathetic_revolution | 6 hours ago
At the risk of being cancelled for this hot take, I don’t much care for the Ottoman Empire.
GoRangers5 | 6 hours ago
So in other words, the Jewish population of the Central Powers had "stabbed them in the back," is that what you are getting at?
csick | 6 hours ago
If you look at the OP post history it’s a wall of questionably sourced pro-Palestine propaganda spammed across every board they can think of.
I think this post is also AI generated because if you actually read it, it’s clearly forcing buzz words into places that don’t make sense.
[OP] stammerton | 5 hours ago
I’m somewhat puzzled by your objections.
This is a curated account focusing on Palestinian cinema, archival material and related historical research. Its posting history naturally reflects those interests.
And for the record, this submission hasn’t been crossposted anywhere, so your claim about spamming it across multiple communities is simply incorrect.
You describe the sources as questionable, yet haven’t identified a single factual error in the submission or explained which academic source you consider unreliable.
You also claim the post contains terminology used incorrectly, but haven’t provided an example.
And now we’re discussing whether the prose sounds like AI rather than whether the history is accurate.
You’re welcome to challenge the research. That’s precisely why I’ve included the sources.
But if you want to question the historical record, you’ll need to engage with the historical evidence.
My Reddit posting history isn’t a counterargument.
[OP] stammerton | 5 hours ago
No. Quite the opposite, in fact.
The post explicitly distinguishes the activities of NILI from those of the wider Jewish population in Ottoman Palestine.
NILI was a relatively small espionage network operating under Aaron Aaronsohn and his associates. Its cooperation with British intelligence is historically documented, as is the opposition it encountered from substantial sections of the Jewish Yishuv.
Many Jewish residents remained loyal to the Ottoman authorities, while others feared that NILI’s activities would bring reprisals against the entire community.
This distinction is examined in Kate Dannies’ 2016 study, NILI and the Issue of Divided Loyalties in the Jewish Yishuv of Ottoman Palestine, published in Jerusalem Quarterly.
It is also discussed in Selim Tezcan’s 2019 research in Belleten, which examines how Israeli history textbooks portray these competing loyalties.
The existence of a particular espionage organisation does not establish collective responsibility, nor does it justify characterising an entire Jewish population as disloyal.
That would be precisely the kind of historical generalisation the original post takes care to avoid.
The subject here is NILI’s documented activities between 1915 and 1917, not the collective loyalty of Jewish communities throughout the Central Powers.
I would encourage reading the original post before attributing an argument to it that it explicitly rejects.
Source:
https://belleten.gov.tr/eng/full-text/390/eng
McGillis_is_a_Char | 6 hours ago
It is worth noting that Aaron Aaronsohn was given free access because there was a huge famine that was caused by a locust swarm and purposely exacerbated by the British and French. They hoped to cause a revolt by starving the population. He was one of the senior people devising a plan to deal with the locust swarm, and worked directly with Djemal Pasha, the Ottoman military governor.
The Jews of the province also had good reason to fear reprisal. The Djemal Pasha had gone completely off the deep end after finding French documents detailing their attempts to organize a resistance movement with various groups (most notably Syrian Arabs). His reign of terror ironically was one of the main motivations when an Arab revolt began.
Unfortunately the subsequent revolt meant that Djemal Pasha's crackdown got worse. Neighbors were encouraged to rat out neighbors; the military tribunals all hanging judges.
So, you had possibly the most prominent Jewish person in the orbit of the mass murdering Djemal Pasha exposed as a spy, during a period bordering on mass hysteria. Even separate from motivations in the circumstances of WWI greater Syrian/Palestine that was very much cause for concern.
[OP] stammerton | 5 hours ago
Thank you for adding this context. It’s an important part of the story, particularly in understanding why the discovery of NILI provoked such alarm within the wider Yishuv.
You’re right about Aaron Aaronsohn’s relationship with Cemal Pasha. His appointment to oversee the response to the 1915 locust plague gave him access and freedom of movement that subsequently proved valuable to NILI’s intelligence operations.
Yuval Ben-Bassat examines precisely this relationship in his 2015 study, Enciphered Ottoman Telegrams from the First World War Concerning the Yishuv in Palestine, drawing on Ottoman archival correspondence. It’s particularly revealing that Cemal Pasha’s own administration had facilitated the movements of someone who would later work against it.
Your point about the famine also deserves attention. The Anglo-French naval blockade contributed significantly to the catastrophe, and historians have examined evidence that food deprivation was regarded by Allied officials as a means of weakening Ottoman authority and encouraging rebellion. The locust devastation, Ottoman military requisitioning, conscription and administrative failures compounded the crisis.
There is one chronological distinction worth making concerning Cemal Pasha’s repression.
His campaign against Arab political figures was already underway before the Arab Revolt of June 1916. Eleven were executed in Beirut in August 1915, followed by another major round of executions in Damascus and Beirut in May 1916.
M. Talha Çiçek examines this in Martyrs/Separatists, Syrian and Lebanese, published by the International Encyclopedia of the First World War.
That chronology matters because Cemal’s repression was not simply a reaction to an established rebellion. It was also part of the Ottoman authorities’ efforts to suppress perceived separatism and consolidate control over the Arab provinces.
And this brings us back to NILI.
The prospect of a clandestine British intelligence network being uncovered within an already deeply suspicious and increasingly repressive wartime administration helps explain why so many Jewish residents feared collective reprisals.
It also reinforces the importance of distinguishing NILI’s activities from the political loyalties of the wider Jewish population.
Thanks again for contributing this perspective. It’s precisely the kind of additional historical context that makes these discussions worthwhile.
Sources:
Yuval Ben-Bassat (2015), Enciphered Ottoman Telegrams from the First World War Concerning the Yishuv in Palestine, Turcica:
https://cris.haifa.ac.il/en/publications/enciphered-ottoman-telegrams-from-the-first-world-war-concerning-/
M. Talha Çiçek, Martyrs/Separatists, Syrian and Lebanese, International Encyclopedia of the First World War:
https://doi.org/10.15463/ie1418.10609
Library of Congress, The Locust Plague:
https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/americancolony/amcolony-locust.html