Fusion power is about to start working, says Bob Mumgaard

119 points by AlexandrTheTolerable 9 hours ago on reddit | 76 comments

GeneralCommand4459 | 7 hours ago

Founder of a startup says trust me and throw money at me.

LookOverall | 8 hours ago

The experience of the official Tokamak research indicates that bigger is better because plasma doesn’t have to be bent as much. These startups, on the other hand show us tiny Tokamaks. Now, sure, magnets are better these days but it still looks unlikely.

Party_Like_Its_1949 | 7 hours ago

The Commonwealth Energy design uses high temperature REBCO tape for its magnets. These allow much greater magnetic field strength than ITER for example, allowing them to meet the Lawson Criterion with a much smaller and cheaper design. That is in fact the key advance that might make affordable fusion power feasible.

Compused | 49 minutes ago

> REBCO

A barium laced magnet sounds like a contamination nightmare if the pressure vessel is breached. At least it's not super toxic like beryllium.

Party_Like_Its_1949 | 23 minutes ago

Are you thinking of barium radiocontrast? REBCO magnets don't use a radioactive isotope of barium. I don't think there's really a contamination danger under any circumstances. It's impossible for a fusion reactor to rupture like fission reactors can. Supercriticality isn't a thing in fusion energy.

matman88 | 6 hours ago

Fusion energy in a increases Tokamak increases with 4th power of the magnetic field. Most superconducting magnets like the ones in MRIs made with LTS max out around 3T. ITER's magnets (LTS) will be 11.8T. The HTS magnets in SPARC will be 20T+. This means a Tokamak with magnets this strong produces 8x the fusion power per unit volume so they can be much smaller. ARC will be significantly larger than SPARC to accommodate the breeding blanket but still about half the linear size of ITER which will will make manufacturing significantly cheaper.

Equal_Passenger9791 | 4 hours ago

>that bigger is better

The scaling laws for a plasma suggest that, but the scaling laws for a big multinational project means it takes a lifetime to yield results that smaller projects will provide before the big one.

>
 official Tokamak research

There's inofficial tokamak research? The league of renegade fusion researchers ?

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 8 hours ago

Sounds like you’re not optimistic.

LookOverall | 7 hours ago

I’d be more impressed if the mechanism was something new and untried. Smart people have been building Tokomaks for decades, scaling up every time and barely achieving break even.

f_leaver | 6 hours ago

It's been 5-10 years away for well over 50 years now.

Do the math.

aerojonno | 6 hours ago

Sounds like it's due any day now!

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 5 hours ago

Nah. It’s 5-10 years out.

TheRadiorobot | 5 hours ago

As an engineer this actually check out. Sales says tomorrow at current risk factor. Engineering says in a month at 5x safety factor! These are projects driven by engineers. It’s just going to take 5x longer than sales says so. So 5-10 years from sales 25 years ago puts this on track!

Equal_Passenger9791 | 4 hours ago

Sounds like it's time to ask an AI to solve it and watch it get one-shotted

woah_man | 7 hours ago

Hard to be optimistic about fusion energy when it's been in development for so long.

Caster_of_spells | 5 hours ago

A CEO of a company dependent on whether people believe in their tech says their tech is about to start working… now should we put our trust in that? I doubt it.

Adorable_Ice_2963 | 4 hours ago

"I am once again asking for your financial support"

dingo_xd | 4 hours ago

If you believe him then I have ... a fusion reactor to sell you

AlwaysUpvotesScience | 8 hours ago

Reliable fusion power is always about 10 years away.

godimold | 6 hours ago

It used to be always 20 years away, so that’s progress. :-)

AlwaysUpvotesScience | 3 hours ago

Yes, but it was 20 years away 50 years ago...

14X8000m | an hour ago

Yeah but in 20 years we might have it down to 5 years.

uninhabited | 8 hours ago

moonshot tech wont save the planet. 3 billion raised so far and they might have a 400mw plant in a decade?? 3 billion could get you 2gw of solar with storage we need to electrify now. were out of time

Party_Like_Its_1949 | 7 hours ago

No, this technology won't help with the main part of the transition, but it might be able to help complete the process. A few billion dollars is a drop in the bucket compared to the hundreds of billions a year being poured into renewables these days. Spending some relative pocket change to do this research makes sense among our various priorities.

dm80x86 | 8 hours ago

You do realize the actual moon shot probably did save the planet?

The space programs of the US and USSR diverted huge amounts of money, personal, and resources away from their militaries to a peacefull(ish) goal.

seeker_of_knowledge | 6 hours ago

Sure, but there was no external ticking clock at the time. It was nuke ourselves to death or distract long enough to live.

We are on a clock now, with the fate of humanity hanging in the balance. Not acting wont save us, only massive changes can redirect our course. Pretty much the opposite situation.

jared1259 | 6 hours ago

There was the doomsday clock...

Eldrake | 6 hours ago

Yeah but the doomsday clock sat at 2 minutes to midnight for years, it didn't inexorably click forwards. Each choice we made could move it forward or back.

Runaway climate catastrophe is in progress regardless of what we do, now.

athelard | 5 hours ago

I don't agree with this view. I don't think these are comparable expenditures. 3 billion spent on research advances or understanding forever, so long-term investment: the value is infinite. Spending 3 billion on technology we already know is amazing if it is in solar panels but there is no advancement in knowledge.

BackSeatGremlin | 3 hours ago

You're, right, we should probably just give up on these technologies instead

double_dundun_wizard | 6 hours ago

At the end of the day, money is an abstraction for workers and resources . There is an upper limit into how much you can invest short term into things. The USSR wouldn't had been able to build more T-34 if you gave them more money, because they were building as many as their means of production could produce

Synensys | 4 hours ago

But we arent "out of time" in any meaningful sense. If we do nothjng or are slower than ideal, things will get marginally worse. Thats not great, but it also doesnt suggest we should simply give up on making advances in technology because we cant possibly spare a single dollar of green energy money.

K1kobus | an hour ago

There wouldn't be any solar panels if no one had invested in their development.

SignificantCrow | 3 hours ago

Out of time? lol
Don’t fear monger, humanity won’t go extinct because of global warming. Literally no scientist actually believes that

NoRegret1954 | an hour ago

I'm not wandering up the thread to look at the original comment (it's difficult to do on my phone), so apologies if I'm wrong, but I don't recall they said anything about extinction. They said "out of time".

Any talk about "saving the planet" if taken literally is silly. The planet itself has survived much worse.

That said,

>> literally no scientist actually believes that

Literally almost all climate scientists believe this:

According to this peer reviewed study published in Nature, they're projecting 83 million excess deaths by 2100. So that's only 1% of the (current) population.

However, while civilization would probably survive, the world could become a great deal less habitable and poorer. The lives of large swaths of populations would become tenuous and stressful.

That's not a world I want to leave for my grandchildren to live in.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24487-w

Porkenstein | 6 hours ago

Entrepreneur seeking investors says the technology their company depends on will soon be feasible. What a shocker...

2-buck | 6 hours ago

I thought we were moving away from tokamaks to those more complicated stellarators because of the pulsing plasma that damages the chamber. Did they solve that?

Shiningc00 | 4 hours ago

Helical Fusion has a stellarator

ApprehensiveStand456 | 3 hours ago

Cool but I just read we can’t connect what we are generating now to the grid

https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/s/rnFvMBvfDr

vovap_vovap | 3 hours ago

That is the word on the streets for last 60 years.

shaftalope | 3 hours ago

working for who? once the reaction starts and runs magically from seawater do you think our electric bills will get smaller? 'free limitless' power for who?

HorrorMathematician9 | 2 hours ago

Is always 10 years away

ClickLeafChick | 2 hours ago

I'm in my 40s and I've been reading breathless "commercial fusion is just around the corner!" claims since I was a child.

At this point, we're in a Boy Who Cried Wolf situation. I'll wait for optimism until a wolf is actually sighted and reported on by several reputable news orgs.

sickdanman | an hour ago

have we even gotten more power out then we put in yet? Forget about dollar profit, we need to have energy profit first

unknownpoltroon | an hour ago

Whuhu!! Clean fusion power is only 10 years down the road.

crankbait808 | 41 minutes ago

He shouldn’t speak to loudly or often, he may just quietly end up missing

Nathan-Stubblefield | 19 minutes ago

I’ve read that statement many times over the last 60 years.

begaterpillar | 6 hours ago

Okay see you in 10 years !

nderthesycamoretrees | 6 hours ago

On the cusp of fusion again!?! I won’t hold my breath.

ceph2apod | 6 hours ago

You're treating fusion as a solved problem that just needs time, and it isn't. These are experiments, and the people running them will tell you they're still learning why plasmas go unstable. Nobody has produced a design that makes more electricity than the plant consumes, let alone one that's cheap and reliable. Now suppose they succeed anyway. The fuel being free doesn't make the power free, because you still pay to build the plant and to move the electricity through the wires. And even if the power itself cost nothing, it couldn't compete with solar on site. Nobody is going to pay for poles, lines, transmission, and the retail markup when they can generate their own power with solar and storage costs still plummeting. Fusion isn't racing a fixed benchmark, it's racing something that gets cheaper every year.

dingo_xd | 4 hours ago

The issue of capturing 100% of the neutrons with a deuterium blanket around the reactor to convert deuterium to tritium is usually completely omitted. Tritium has to be synthesized since it doesn't exist in nature and even a 90% conversion efficiency is catastrophic for the whole project

Dry_Instruction8254 | 4 hours ago

And almost all versions of these still create steam to turn a turbine.

I get it that's a proven technology but damn, when I read about Fusion power I thought there was like a direct energy output and not just another steam powered generator.

I think there is one version that will probably never exist (if any of these are ever actually built) that can create electricity directly, but it's not what most of them run on.

Youpunyhumans | an hour ago

The problem with Direct Energy Conversion is neutrons... you cant stop them with magnetic fields, only with heavy shielding like tungsten or beryillium, which also degrades as it gets hit by more and more neutrons, and becomes radioactive. This shielding basically blocks you from being able to convert the energy directly, which is why turbines are used instead.

However, if we could mine the Helium-3 from the Moon, then we have a fusion fuel that doesnt create neutrons, and so most or all of that heavy shielding can be taken away, and you can efficiently get energy directly to be turned into electricity.

It works by having the charged particles fly away from the reaction, and into a magnetic field, which slows them down, converting their kinetic energy directly to electricity.

banzaizach | 2 hours ago

It's just steam?

🔫always has been.

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 3 hours ago

What’s wrong with that? If you can make heat, you can make steam that can run a turbine.

Jimmy_Fromthepieshop | an hour ago

Soon there will be wars over water supplies.

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 41 minutes ago

Steam turns back into water…

billth93 | 54 minutes ago

I don’t know why that’s an issue, the steam turning a turbine is just a a method to convert heat to electricity, it’s more akin to an adaptor

Big_Bookkeeper1678 | 7 hours ago

They've been telling us this for decades.

Just invest in solar. All those data centers and warehouses could put up enough solar on their brand new shiny roofs to power the entire community that they just invaded.

But these assholes want more money for tech that could potentially destroy an entire region of the planet.

srch4intellegentlife | 6 hours ago

Uhmmmm, no.  Data centers w/ solar aren’t energy positive.  And fusion != fission.  No radioactive waste.

subito_lucres | 6 hours ago

Don't bother arguing rationally with someone who isn't

Mrslinkydragon | 5 hours ago

There absolutely is radioactive waste with fission!

You are slamming very high energy neutrons (from T + D --> ³He + n) and bremsstrahlung xrays (from the changes in direction the particles are making) into the shielding (usually a mix of beryllium and tungsten borides) thats going to cause activation and ionisation of the materials!

Sure the waste is likely to be rendered safe in 50-100 years but it will be extremely radioactive!

mentive | 4 hours ago

Did you and I read different comments? Bcuz the person you're replying to, in context, is stating Fusion has no radioactive waste.

Mrslinkydragon | 4 hours ago

No i was saying to the person that fusion does produce radioactive waste

beerdude26 | 6 hours ago

Solar and large scale batteries (sand, salt, iron)

srch4intellegentlife | 6 hours ago

Sand is for heat/thermal batteries which only work with big mirrors and concentrating solar power.  Grid scale batteries typically use lithium ion.  Salt batteries need the salt to be molten.  Iron/air batteries are in development, but lack the efficiency of lithium.  Flow batteries are less efficient but are catching up quick.  Agree 100% on over+batteries.

beerdude26 | 4 hours ago

Nah sand can work at any scale for heat, there's a bunch of startups. Only retains heat for like a month tho because they're small

srch4intellegentlife | 3 hours ago

Agreed, but none of the PV/battery combos use sand because thermal transfer processes for generating electricity are far less efficient (35% mean).  Sand would be great for a big building with central heat, or even heating whole towns, but it requires significant infrastructure.

beerdude26 | 3 hours ago

Oh yes sorry, the sand batteries aren't for two-way electricity conversion, they're purely used for heating water. Sand can easily hit 600 degrees and stay that way for a month if it's in an insulated enclosure. I can imagine that even in hot summer days, free hot water reduces the power bill a lot.

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 5 hours ago

Fusion reactors wouldn’t blow up. Unlike fission, fusion reactors just shut down if they stop working. The hard part is getting it working, not making it safe.

PromotionOk2443 | 4 hours ago

I think the technology would have been out and in use already if it were not for the fossil fuel industry constantly attacking it and crushing it.  I love all the investments we are getting in it now, but im still very pessimistic that it will be allowed to succeed.  we need it to, but it would upend an industry that has fought violently to protect itself for decades

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 3 hours ago

I think it’s just genuinely hard, not that anyone is trying to stop it from succeeding.

PromotionOk2443 | 2 hours ago

well we can agree to disagree then because I think the evidence is quite clear that the fossil fuel industry has put lots of money and lives on the line to protect its dominance

[OP] AlexandrTheTolerable | 42 minutes ago

Oh they definitely put money into lobbying, but they’re not all powerful either.