FYI When try and download the needed VirtualBox tool from https://www.virtualbox.org/ it gives a payment error .... Puzzling . Probably has nothing to do with ArchiveTeam ADMIN - if this query , here , not allowed .... please just delete it now Thank You
I cannot speak to why you’re getting a payment error on the virtual box site, I did not receive the same when I attempted to download binaries for windows or mac to test. Its license is free for personal or educational use.
Ironically - i'm running the docker container directly on a mac M1 mini (using colima), and ran into a bit of a problem due to this bug https://github.com/golang/go/issues/77572
Adding `-e GODEBUG=madvdontneed=0` to the docker run command for the warrior should let other apple computers install and run the applediscussions project!
Looks like more items are being found and queued as the jobs are completed and shipped. I cannot say with confidence total work remaining if it hasn’t all yet been captured in the job queue.
I support anyone’s noble attempts to avoid loss of information, and these forums do at least track the long history of reported issues with Apple products, so, good for them.
But if ever there was a more frustrating support forum, this one was it.
Only Apple could pull off something so audacious: hosting a support forum with zero paid representatives present, while still having almost every thread feature one or more responses written in a corporate tone that deliver the Apple talking points (and if necessary, even dismissing the user’s problem as a skill issue or a matter of opinion, rather than an egregious design flaw or bug).
All done by people so devoted to Apple that they perform this labor for decades without any form of compensation. Not even like coupons or something. I’ve been astounded by it since my first visit.
Precisely this. It was ridiculous, beyond audacious, to depend on the public to provide what Apple should have provided all along. Was it ever known whether Apple reviewed the community posts to learn about their product defects? It was as if a million voices screamed into the void and God (Apple) never listened.
It’s usually pretty straightforward to get a human on the phone with Apple. I had a problem with a return the other day and was routed to a human pretty quickly.
Google, on the other hand, I am pretty sure don’t even employ people for phone support
I’ve had good luck going to the Apple store. Even on topics where I’m an expert, they know insane workarounds that just work.
They want you to make an appointment, but I was pretty screwed so they gave me same day service. Problem was fixed on the first try in under an hour; no charge.
I'm quite sure some of those "top commenters" there were the Apple team in charge of that forum itself. Why would anyone post the same stupid solutions again and again as response for each new thread?
I never understood the point of the blind leading the blind within the Apple Support Community. There was quite a bit of misinformation there, but not nearly enough official instruction from Apple itself. Am I wrong about this?
You're not wrong. As much as I deeply respect the mission and accomplishments of Internet Archive, keeping it discoverable by search engines and LLMs is a net-negative IMHO.
"They were full of people asking questions and not getting useful answers, with many responses given by users who were more motivated to gain karma in the forum’s user-ranking system than to help." — Jason Snell (https://sixcolors.com/link/2026/11/ding-dong-the-apple-suppo...)
I agree that unweighted "solutions" from random (and often incorrect) people with good intentions may well lead many down wrong paths... but that having those paths preserved and clearly described is of value in and of itself.
> As much as I deeply respect the mission and accomplishments of Internet Archive, keeping it discoverable by search engines and LLMs is a net-negative IMHO.
But Internet Archive isn't discoverable by search engines? I think it isn't anyway, I've literally never seen a Wayback Machine link in Google so I assume it's on purpose.
There's no robots.txt on web.archive.org and it seems to come up with you use `site:` modifiers, so I think it's just ranked very low. Probably on purpose but probably not on IA's part.
Note that Archive Team is not the same as the Internet Archive. They're related and Archive Team stuff ends up in the IA but they're separate and have different missions.
Are you seriously suggesting that we curate the entire internet for misinformation, just so that the LLMs can indiscriminately crawl it all? Would it not make more sense for LLMs not to be so trusting?
Yes, never had to look at the Apple one too much mercifully, but my heart would sink every time a Microsoft one came up in a search for some problem I was having.
These answers are usually undesirable but in some cases getting a working machine again ASAP is more important than figuring out the actual problem and how to fix it. Like if someone's printer is acting up when they need to print something right before a big meeting, they'd probably appreciate you helping them print elsewhere in the short-term rather than get to work on their printer.
The real deal isn't so different. I worked in tech support a few years ago and it reminded me a lot of hanging out in Freenode/Libera helping people on a whim, though sadly the tools used at that job were a lot more proprietary (Teams, Zoom, some Oracle case management web thing, the product itself that we supported...). I guess the issue with a public forum is that the skill floor is much lower. A bunch of people on the Apple forums probably don't even know how to use IRC.
On one hand I deeply understand the desire to archive the years of human effort which went into asking and answering forum posts.
On the other hand, Apple should have voluntarily done the archiving. Predictably they didn't and wouldn't, because the only single thing these companies care about is profit and everything else can happily go to shit.
In a just world, Apple's refusal to spend the absolutely miniscule amount of effort to archive the forum themselves would earn them a massive reputational stain and they'd face an enormous backlash for effectively spitting on the very people who allow them to exist.
That won't happen, because consumers simply don't care. Corporations have proven time and time again that consumers will tolerate - or even celebrate - being trampled upon as long as their new shiny baubles make them feel superior in some way.
It is a travesty that Apple's support forum was created virtually exclusively by volunteers, and it's a travesty that it's up to other volunteers to ensure its ongoing survival.
Fuck Apple, squarely and truly and wholeheartedly. Fuck Apple.
It has always seemed like a really impoverished place with low quality answers compared to stuff like Stack Exchange. And now they’ll burn it to the ground. Mixed feelings.
The metadata seems likely to be valuable to future historians of this period, even if the answers didn't help anyone at the time they were asked. Archivists assume they don't know what people in the future will need to know and seek to preserve the entire haystack. Obviously their resources are finite so in practice they make some assumptions, but as few as they can.
yes, they can study how people will do anything to feel important. They can study how people will volunteer to do the work for free for one of the biggest companies on the planet. They can study the power dynamics of having a question frozen with a wrong answer and 754 "I have this problem too" marks.
The point is being able to accurately understand the past. The importance of the early internet to later generations cannot be known. Even if it's just some silly "Show HN: The internet 50 years ago" post in a half-century, it would be great if it was accurate.
Could we please stop dealing in absolutes? Alright, you didn’t like it, that doesn’t mean that was true of everyone. Here’s one example of something useful and of value:
> On the other hand, Apple should have voluntarily done the archiving.
We could really use a law forcing them. With books many countries require by law that a copy of every book published is send for archival to the national library. But on the Internet burning decades worth of content, with no archive or backup, is still fair game. It's frustrating how after 30 years we still haven't managed to adopt the rules and regulations we had for paper into the digital world.
i’ve never stumbled across any of these pages and had them be useful in any way shape or form. maybe others have had a different experience, but i think removing them is actually a great idea.
It seemed like most threads were dominated by a handful of people who wrote long mostly copy-pasted responses that typically ended in suggesting you reformat your hard drive and reinstall macOS.
Edit: forgot about resetting PRAM and SMC. Those are classics too!
Probably not a bad start for debugging though. At the very least, plowing through a lot of older blog posts and videos that don't directly map to current software may not be very productive. At the least, you can rule outsome five-year old problem that may not apply and longer.
Mostly, the main way I found the Apple Support Communities vaguely useful was to tell me that this issue I was having wasn't a completely isolated one. However, the various suggested fixes mostly served to send me down useless rabbit holes for an hour or two.
Maybe a corpus like this would be useful if someone spent a lot of time to curate and summarize but I'm unconvinced that just slurping all this content is terribly useful for anyone.
As LLM decompilation and reverse engineering tools get better, the corpus could be useful as a benchmark.
Pin some MacOS binary release. Hand it and the forums to an AI. See how many issues it can address. 1 point for correct forum answer. 2 points for a working bugfix against the binaries.
They were never useful. All of the answers sounded like corporate talking points which was surprising given the answerers were supposedly mostly volunteers. The answers reeked of AI copypasta before LLMs were even a thing.
Same. I appreciate the commitment to the bit, but would be ok with these going to the great /dev/null in the sky unless you find (like every big hardware company with a support forum) comments like “as a Level # support paladin, I would be happy to point you to six threads that sound a bit like your problem but aren’t. On the plus side, they also don’t have conclusive answers!”
I found a helpful one yesterday. I had to look at something on an iBook G3. When I turned on the laptop, the trackpad wasn't working. A post on the support forum said that it was because the settings on the trackpad management IC got hosed, and you could fix it by holding down the power button until you heard a beep. Sure enough, this got the trackpad working.
The last time I looked at the support forum (a few months ago when I was trying to force an iTunes Match sync) I also got a useful solution.
Whew. I thought I would really miss searching about some age-old glitchy problem in iOS or why I lost all my contacts in a software update, finding out that hundreds of other people have been dealing with the same problems, not finding any answer and just shrugging my shoulders. Now, Apple says "just shrug your shoulders."
I think people underestimate the value of finding those pages though. Even if there's no solution, it's better than realizing it's you, it's only you.
For example, just yesterday I downloaded an app with the promise of a discount. Surprise surprise, the app gave an error claiming the coupon. A quick search later I find out it's not just me, someone reported it months ago.
So it was just false advertising and did not waste time reporting the "bug"
Frankly nothing worth saving on that site. It has the same energy as Google or Microsoft product forums, helmed by unpaid “community leaders” copy pasting template answers that does not address the question at all.
We will be telling our grandkids about how before there was AI slop we all had to huddle around the Apple support forums and “use our imaginations” to “pretend” there was a benevolent but incompetent intelligence
The Apple Support Community has always been horrible. It was a way for Apple to not actually give support and just ignore issues. Never once did I ever find out any actual solution. All I saw was an unofficial answer, often wrong, and 25 to 700 "me too" and no actual movement from Apple. It's one of their worst feature and arguably inconsistent with their supposed image of support.
Don't forget the "Level 10" or whatever users who fancied themselves to be some kind of privileged Apple support employee despite being an unpaid volunteer with no real way to solve problems or escalate.
That's because Apple typically does not actually have a fix. Apple is very often slow to feedback and changes. They just don't listen much unless it makes it to the media.
I've hated the lock screen change wallpaper long press functionality since the start. It's way too easy to accidentally trigger it. I don't change wallpapers for years.
It would be trivial for Apple to add a toggle to disable this feature for people like me.
Countless threads have been started on this topic and every single time, someone gives a non-answer or incorrect one until eventually people figure out that you can't disable it.
Yes, I think my biggest fear about Apple is 1. Consumer reliance on them having the best product, 2. Their culture around secrecy makes an unhealthy tension where feedback is not acknowledged and actions too slow to keep up.
There’s nothing more demoralizing than having a niche issue with an Apple product and finding the support forums top of your Google search results. If there were actually a fix, there would be blogspam sites trying to claw their way out of the SEO crab bucket to sell it to you, but if all you find is the support community, you are truly doomed. One post, 4 years ago, a trickle of me-toos, and no resolution.
I suspect the only engineers capable of diagnosing the problem are those who are not allowed to admit there is a problem.
At least it’s not as bad as M$ ”support” forum where threat actors distribute malware ”helpers” in the form of links to exe files on russian web sites. But yes, Apple is not far from that level of miserable support.
Sounds on par with the Microsoft support community. I'm glad it seems to have been downranked in search results, because whenever I happened upon it while researching an issue, it was inevitably an honest question followed by an MVP replying with an unhelpful answer in there (often looking like they barely read the question), resolving it, then a bunch of comments/consternation from other people throughout years(!) asking the same question because the solution didn't work or wasn't even relevant.
Many years of “i understand you are having trouble with [regurgitated question], restart it, delete your preferences and make sure it has the latest software update”
is archiving the whole community really worthwhile? i mean, preservation is good, but they're gonna preserve a bunch of junk. i just focused on the confirmed answers and the unanswered questions.
The difference is that Apple Support Community has always been actively and objectively bad, rife with incorrect and outdated information. Anything mining it for answers will provide worse answers.
If Windows, Linux and MACOS integrated AI like Omarchy has, you wouldn't need a support forum in the first place. Mostly these support forums are filled with wrong answers or toxic members. Honestly AI has made support forums obsolete.
The last time I tried (laptop
wifi was busted), qwen 3.0 or something was able to one shot a better answer than anything I’d ever seen on the Apple support forums. I happened to have it on that mac, and no other internet access.
I was back online in a minute or two. The fix was obscure.
[OP] digitaldragon | 19 hours ago
Related: The Apple Support Community will permanently close on November 20, 2026 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50449440
toomuchtodo | 19 hours ago
https://wiki.archiveteam.org/index.php/ArchiveTeam_Warrior
consumer451 | 18 hours ago
toomuchtodo | 18 hours ago
consumer451 | 18 hours ago
asdefghyk | 18 hours ago
toomuchtodo | 17 hours ago
amar1729 | 16 hours ago
Adding `-e GODEBUG=madvdontneed=0` to the docker run command for the warrior should let other apple computers install and run the applediscussions project!
saagarjha | 11 hours ago
toomuchtodo | 11 hours ago
Hamuko | 11 hours ago
knotimpressed | 16 hours ago
drum55 | 16 hours ago
rafram | 5 hours ago
But yes, Archive-It is the Archive.org affiliate with a similar distributed model.
rovr138 | 15 hours ago
Some may have more than 1 instance running.
ArchiveTeam != Archive.org
xp84 | 18 hours ago
But if ever there was a more frustrating support forum, this one was it.
Only Apple could pull off something so audacious: hosting a support forum with zero paid representatives present, while still having almost every thread feature one or more responses written in a corporate tone that deliver the Apple talking points (and if necessary, even dismissing the user’s problem as a skill issue or a matter of opinion, rather than an egregious design flaw or bug).
All done by people so devoted to Apple that they perform this labor for decades without any form of compensation. Not even like coupons or something. I’ve been astounded by it since my first visit.
EarthAmbassador | 18 hours ago
wackget | 17 hours ago
matsemann | 17 hours ago
Had a minor issue once, tried all the things on forums, didn't work. Sent a request, and the next day someone actually called me and helped fix it.
While Google and Apple I've never even been able to reach a human. Which was quite stressful when my Gmail got accidentally locked for a week..
SOLAR_FIELDS | 16 hours ago
Google, on the other hand, I am pretty sure don’t even employ people for phone support
jamesfinlayson | 16 hours ago
hedora | 3 hours ago
They want you to make an appointment, but I was pretty screwed so they gave me same day service. Problem was fixed on the first try in under an hour; no charge.
montag | 17 hours ago
binaryturtle | 12 hours ago
wildrhythms | 7 hours ago
EarthAmbassador | 18 hours ago
ryandrake | 18 hours ago
c-hendricks | 17 hours ago
montag | 17 hours ago
CharlesW | 17 hours ago
"They were full of people asking questions and not getting useful answers, with many responses given by users who were more motivated to gain karma in the forum’s user-ranking system than to help." — Jason Snell (https://sixcolors.com/link/2026/11/ding-dong-the-apple-suppo...)
"Good riddance." — John Gruber (https://daringfireball.net/linked/2026/11/11/apple-support-c...)
markjgraham | 17 hours ago
I agree that unweighted "solutions" from random (and often incorrect) people with good intentions may well lead many down wrong paths... but that having those paths preserved and clearly described is of value in and of itself.
Wowfunhappy | 17 hours ago
But Internet Archive isn't discoverable by search engines? I think it isn't anyway, I've literally never seen a Wayback Machine link in Google so I assume it's on purpose.
jamesfinlayson | 16 hours ago
maxbond | 15 hours ago
rafram | 5 hours ago
maxbond | 15 hours ago
CharlesW | 15 hours ago
opan | 10 hours ago
teddyh | 3 hours ago
xnx | 17 hours ago
jamesfinlayson | 16 hours ago
wpm | 13 hours ago
"Format your C: drive and reinstall Windows"
The only two solutions ever posted there
opan | 10 hours ago
hurfdurf | 8 hours ago
opan | 10 hours ago
tclancy | 15 hours ago
wackget | 17 hours ago
On the other hand, Apple should have voluntarily done the archiving. Predictably they didn't and wouldn't, because the only single thing these companies care about is profit and everything else can happily go to shit.
In a just world, Apple's refusal to spend the absolutely miniscule amount of effort to archive the forum themselves would earn them a massive reputational stain and they'd face an enormous backlash for effectively spitting on the very people who allow them to exist.
That won't happen, because consumers simply don't care. Corporations have proven time and time again that consumers will tolerate - or even celebrate - being trampled upon as long as their new shiny baubles make them feel superior in some way.
It is a travesty that Apple's support forum was created virtually exclusively by volunteers, and it's a travesty that it's up to other volunteers to ensure its ongoing survival.
Fuck Apple, squarely and truly and wholeheartedly. Fuck Apple.
montag | 17 hours ago
ostensible | 17 hours ago
maxbond | 15 hours ago
socalgal2 | 9 hours ago
soulofmischief | 8 hours ago
latexr | 9 hours ago
https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-250012366
tclancy | 15 hours ago
How is babby formed.
opan | 10 hours ago
grumbel | 8 hours ago
We could really use a law forcing them. With books many countries require by law that a copy of every book published is send for archival to the national library. But on the Internet burning decades worth of content, with no archive or backup, is still fair game. It's frustrating how after 30 years we still haven't managed to adopt the rules and regulations we had for paper into the digital world.
notnmeyer | 17 hours ago
sitzkrieg | 17 hours ago
willseth | 17 hours ago
Edit: forgot about resetting PRAM and SMC. Those are classics too!
greazy | 11 hours ago
MS has taken this approach to every problem.
ghaff | 6 hours ago
xattt | 7 hours ago
ghaff | 6 hours ago
Maybe a corpus like this would be useful if someone spent a lot of time to curate and summarize but I'm unconvinced that just slurping all this content is terribly useful for anyone.
hedora | 3 hours ago
Pin some MacOS binary release. Hand it and the forums to an AI. See how many issues it can address. 1 point for correct forum answer. 2 points for a working bugfix against the binaries.
asaddhamani | 16 hours ago
tclancy | 15 hours ago
ndiddy | 3 hours ago
The last time I looked at the support forum (a few months ago when I was trying to force an iTunes Match sync) I also got a useful solution.
awepofiwaop | 17 hours ago
caned | 16 hours ago
etatester | 4 hours ago
For example, just yesterday I downloaded an app with the promise of a discount. Surprise surprise, the app gave an error claiming the coupon. A quick search later I find out it's not just me, someone reported it months ago.
So it was just false advertising and did not waste time reporting the "bug"
vachina | 14 hours ago
rusk | 10 hours ago
socalgal2 | 9 hours ago
wildrhythms | 7 hours ago
aurareturn | 6 hours ago
I've hated the lock screen change wallpaper long press functionality since the start. It's way too easy to accidentally trigger it. I don't change wallpapers for years.
It would be trivial for Apple to add a toggle to disable this feature for people like me.
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/254801624?sortBy=rank
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/254748139?sortBy=rank
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/254581677?sortBy=rank
Countless threads have been started on this topic and every single time, someone gives a non-answer or incorrect one until eventually people figure out that you can't disable it.
kphorn | 6 hours ago
jl6 | 6 hours ago
I suspect the only engineers capable of diagnosing the problem are those who are not allowed to admit there is a problem.
SilverElfin | 4 hours ago
malfist | 2 hours ago
lwowowx | an hour ago
orange_man_bad | 3 hours ago
RankingMember | 3 hours ago
mung | 7 hours ago
cowlevel | 6 hours ago
teddyh | 3 hours ago
0gs | 6 hours ago
etatester | 4 hours ago
CharlesW | 2 hours ago
thrownaway561 | 4 hours ago
hedora | 3 hours ago
I was back online in a minute or two. The fix was obscure.