Economists Horrified by What AI Industry Has Done to Global Economy

2728 points by One-Emu-1103 6 hours ago on reddit | 362 comments

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

And on other good news, AI driven "efficiency" leads to companies - sometimes more, sometimes less - aggressively getting rid of employees. More burnout for the ones that remaim, while an increasing number gets phased out into....god knows what. In many countries there are literally no jobs for junior IT guys anymore. And it has started to spill over into other areas, like legal, tax, etc.

Now this could be a good thing. But as it turns out, our whole society is built on tax and social contributions generated by *checks notes* labor. Now that labor contributes less and less to output in general, also the state has incur more and more debt.

Well, at least we generated incomparable value for shareholders. For a while.

Magificent_Gradient | 5 hours ago

Fewer people paying into the tax base means everything begins to erode. The social compact fails and we have revolution and chaos.

UBI can help alleviate this, but it will definitely come with strings attached.

“Your UBI benefit has a minimum requirement of 30 hours in the field picking strawberries.”

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

UBI is absolutely necessary, but only one side of the coin. The other side is, where the financing should come from. And this only works with a combination of wealth tax and "machine tax". AI is actually the perfect example: If you fire one employee and "replace" him with AI, and said employee before was taxed 50% including social contribution and everything else (which literally is the case here in Austria...) then the public sector has to regain a comparable amount from...somewhere. Anywhere.

Sherm | 2 hours ago

We could always have companies hire people to be customers. Sure it sounds demented, but why should the solution sound any less insane than the problem?

Odra_dek | 2 hours ago

Circular finance in retail - I like it

kendog50 | 4 hours ago

I'm envisioning an 80% corporate tax, which gets distributed as UBI. The remaining 20% goes to expanding the operation or shareholders or something else. The population spends the UBI. That revenue pays the salaries of the limited number of workers (maybe we're at 10% employment in this scenario) and other company expenses. Profits are taxed at 80%...etc. Is this the likely working scenario under full automation? What are other ways it could go that still benefits most citizens? I guess I could picture something with low corporate tax and everyone is a shareholder, and there's a dividend paid to all.

Corwin223 | 2 hours ago

Profits are hard to tax well because they can just increase pay to certain people to decrease on-paper profit

Uberzwerg | 49 minutes ago

"we don't make any profit, because we need to pay billions for the rights to thecompany logo that is owned by a different company. That company is located in TaxHavenstan and also owned by me"

SARB033 | an hour ago

And unfortunately, as we all know, all income is tax free.

Corwin223 | 4 minutes ago

It was a simple example.

Ideally companies would just maximize profits and taxes would be on profits. It works out beautifully in the math. The problem is it’s a lot easier to make profits vanish than it is to produce them.

kendog50 | 48 minutes ago

Yeah maybe there would be some floor profit margin based on the "amount" of automation. Like there's some new automation metric. And a ceiling on pay. I'm assuming these "people jobs" would be overseeing that the operation is running smoothly, or it's security or something. Maybe it pays a flat amount...$50K per person. I know there are groups that already worked out many of these scenarios, but it's interesting to throw around some numbers.

TheTimberFactory | 3 hours ago

With economic history as a guide, this is highly unlikely.

I think serfdom, ala from the renaissance era, is likely, just to pay off debt.

kendog50 | 2 hours ago

Oh I agree 100%. it more likely that the descendants of the current 6 or so guys at the top will just own all the automated work, funnel the best resources to themselves and their dynasties, the scraps will trickle down to everyone else...well...Snowpiercer. Basically Snowpiercer but no train, just Earth.

SARB033 | an hour ago

You really think 99% of the population is just going to be okay with starvation and serfdom?? That they aren't going to vote against it for UBI, or if that doesn't work (or democracy ends) that they won't rise up like has happened many many many times throughout history?

TheTimberFactory | 42 minutes ago

I didn't say that at all.

MagicalSkyMan | an hour ago

Why would there be serfdom when AI will do everything better than humans?

I also bet people would not vote for that.

ArkitekZero | an hour ago

At this point why not just distribute the goods and services where they're needed arbitrarily? Have we not tried this self-managing nonsense for long enough to admit that it doesn't work?

Tryhard_3 | 36 minutes ago

If they're not paying for employees, they should pass the savings down to you, right? .... Right, Anakin?

dust4ngel | 24 minutes ago

> If you fire one employee and "replace" him with AI, and said employee before was taxed 50% including social contribution and everything else ... then the public sector has to regain a comparable amount from...somewhere

capitalism's answer is for that person to die and therefore no longer cost anything.

ColteesCatCouture | 15 minutes ago

We need to stop hoping for UBI, it won't happen in the US. We need alternatives not dependent on government. Mutual aid is the way

PierreRobineau | 5 hours ago

UBI is a band-aid. Depending on the State has not served the people in communist States so well.

Edit: I am somewhat left leaning. I don't deny that the State has a role to play in redistributing wealth. But I also think depending entirely on the State is dangerous. Throughout history, people had a level of self-reliance that UBI scenarios do not contemplate. I am worried of a state of things where people have no economic value and could thus some day be taken as expense to be diminished and not as human beings free to live the life they decided to live.

I also resent that billionaires would form a distinct class living in obscene luxury.

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

It's simply a fact of output not depending on labor anymore. Imagine you have a hunter gatherer community, then you time travel there with a super machine that produces all the food for them. You need "some way" to make sure that the machine-produced food gets distributed among them.

You can deride this as "communism" or whatever, but the simple economic reality remains. You cannot have a labor-focussed economy where labor doesn't have anything to do anymore.

dyslexda | 3 hours ago

I don't think it's "derision" like you think, but rather caution. Once a population is completely dependent on a government for even their very subsistence, then the government absolutely controls them, rather than the other way around.

PressWearsARedDress | 2 hours ago

I fairly sure redditors in general support some level of government authoritarianism as long as the authoritarianism isn't violent. I mean, the government will simply let you starve on the streets if you fail to comply but since its non violent thats okay.

The spirit of democracy is that "The people" are able to rule themselves. If the government is supplying all of your needs then it is is the government who rules over you. Your "vote" in this sense is a token of ceremonial value.

Protect free speech, the right to arms, the right to assemble, the right to reject the government officials from occupying your home, the right to reject searches/seizures and the right to privacy.

Democracy is not a normal state of affairs, its won through revolution.

HumorAccomplished611 | 2 hours ago

In a society youre always reliant on government. Who funds the roads you drive on daily? Who regulates the electricity that makes everything work?

Like yes a few things here and there dont rely on it but even in democracy youre about 80% reliant on government.

PressWearsARedDress | an hour ago

Well I am actually against publically funded roads as it diverts funds away from public transportation like buses/trains. Driving is extremely wasteful and inefficient. I believe drivers should have to pay all costs associated with roads. The government also acts like a mafia on roads constantly watching for you to make an infraction which they can fine you for and deny your licensure for access in those same roads if you do not pay. In my point of view this violates ones right to privacy, and as such I believe public roads to be authoritarian infrastructure.

Industrial regulation is not same as providing a dependency.

Your "80%" figure is baseless. The government sets up regulatory frameworks and assists industry, that is their job. When they do more than that they encroach on liberty.

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

> Well I am actually against publically funded roads as it diverts funds away from public transportation like buses/trains. Driving is extremely wasteful and inefficient. I believe drivers should have to pay all costs associated with roads. The government also acts like a mafia on roads constantly watching for you to make an infraction which they can fine you for and deny your licensure for access in those same roads if you do not pay. > >

So to be even more reliant on government? I can drive on a dirt road made privately. I cant drive on a dirt railroad track.

>Industrial regulation is not same as providing a dependency.

It actually is. We already saw what happened when that stuff got cut in real time as "A major 2026 Cyclospora outbreak in the U.S. has been linked to contaminated iceberg lettuce from Taylor Farms de Mexico, causing over 11,400 illnesses and 2 deaths across 20 states."

>Your "80%" figure is baseless. The government sets up regulatory frameworks and assists industry, that is their job. When they do more than that they encroach on liberty.

Yes its baseless. Its probably closer to 100% of people.

Dependent-Fox6679 | 2 hours ago

And this is worse than corporations absolutely controlling us...how, exactly?

dyslexda | 2 hours ago

A corporation does not unilaterally control you. We are not in the days of company towns anymore; you are free to change who you work for, even if it is inconvenient or even painful to do so. A corporation also does not have a monopoly on violence, and cannot coerce or compel behavior.

Being wholly dependent upon a powerful, centralized government is not a recipe for a utopia. You can absolutely support wealth redistribution, workers rights, safety nets, etc and be very afraid of a citizenry completely dependent on the government.

Dependent-Fox6679 | an hour ago

What value is the theoretical ability to leave one's current employment when the job market is so shit that finding a new position that's an actual improvement is nigh-impossible?

And yeah. We aren't in the days of company towns and corporate serfdom. But that's not for lack of trying or lack of desire to bring such back.

dyslexda | an hour ago

> that's an actual improvement

Life is not a straight line that goes up. As I said, it could be inconvenient or painful to change your employer, because you might need to accept a worse position. However, you have that choice. If your current position becomes intolerable, you can find another.

Not really the case if you find your government intolerable.

ColteesCatCouture | 11 minutes ago

Labor always will have a place its just the customer that is changing. Most plebes aren't going to be able to afford for AI to do everything for us once the true price of tokens emerges. If the 1% locks out our labor from the current capitalist system we need to look to each other for goods and services.

Icy_Scar_1249 | 4 hours ago

How do you expect people to eat, if they aren't needed for jobs anymore?

PierreRobineau | 3 hours ago

Exactly. I don't expect they will.

Magificent_Gradient | 3 hours ago

People will abandon the dollar and create a new one or resort to the barter system.

dogs_gt_cats | an hour ago

> People will abandon the dollar and create a new one or resort to the barter system.

See for example "Ithaca Hours" in Ithaca NY, "scrip," and other local currencies. There is absolutely precedent for your point here. If dollars no longer make sense people won't use them.

ColteesCatCouture | 8 minutes ago

Precedents also exist in failed states too. People still had an emergent economy to get needs met.

BananaPalmer | 3 hours ago

UBI is not communism

PierreRobineau | an hour ago

Never said it was. But it has the potential to give rise to the kind of twisted relationship we saw between the State and individuals in communist countries.

Qeltar_ | 4 hours ago

It's also a trap. It divides society even more into haves and have-nots. Subsistence living is not what anyone wants of their limited time on this big spinning ball of dirt.

weatherwar | 3 hours ago

This makes absolutely no sense. I'd love for you to explain.

Qeltar_ | 3 hours ago

The basic premise is that AI will make a small number of people too wealthy while eliminating too many jobs, so UBI must be brought in to support people who have no money and no way to work because of too much automation. The problem is that there's no practical way to establish UBI much above a subsistence level (if it happens at all). People who become dependent on it will have a hard time getting off of it, just barely plodding along while accumulating no real wealth. Meanwhile, the wealthy will basically be trying to get every dollar of that UBI back, generally through overpriced products and subscriptions.

A better approach is much higher taxation of the wealthy and new programs for ordinary people to find meaningful ways to contribute to society. But of course, there's almost no chance that happens either.

weatherwar | 2 hours ago

> People who become dependent on it will have a hard time getting off of it, just barely plodding along while accumulating no real wealth.

So much like the current system.

UnpleasantTroglodyte | an hour ago

Yes, except this time it will be because they legitimately don't have enough money and not because they get uber eats 9 times a week and drive a $70,000 pickup truck.

Illustrious-Lime-878 | 5 hours ago

Its already captured. The expense eliminated increases profit, which is taxed. If you want more increase taxes in general. A "machine tax" just seems ridiculously hard to to enforce or even define. A lot of automation happens gradually, first the workforce is augmented, and and job losses don't play out until each incremental round of layoffs that can be for w/e reason the company says. I also don't get why you'd want to punish automation, it is a good thing in the end, its just the temporary displacement of jobs that is a problem.

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

>The expense eliminated increases profit, which is taxed.

Not enough, by a long shot; at least not here in Austria, don't know if it would work somewhere else.

>I also don't get why you'd want to punish automation, it is a good thing in the end,

I don't want to punish automation. But we have to ensure that society keeps functioning in a world where labor (and wages) are increasingly irrelevant. In a way we are entering the Greek Utopia again, but with machines instead of slaves. If, however, only 10-20% of the population really benefit, then this will socially not be sustainable.

Illustrious-Lime-878 | 4 hours ago

The point is you could just increase the tax in general and then have UBI or some other welfare if you really think w/e "Greek Utopia" (lol) is, is coming. But the unemployment rate is <5% in both the US and Australia, obv. the impact of AI is going to take many, many years to play out, but its not like jobs are just rapidly disappearing right now. Even with the comparison to slaves, in societies with slavery, the vast majority of free citizens were still not rich, but they weren't just unemployed, they still had jobs. So if you're predicting a case where actually, everyone is like idle-rich, there is no problem to begin with. The bigger worry imo is actually people getting worked *harder* for lower wages to compete with machines, but not totally unemployed and willing to revolt or something, and so its not necessarily unsustainable, just shitty.

devliegende | 3 hours ago

Perhaps we can blame autocorrect but talking about Australia when the other guy said Austria is not a good look.

Illustrious-Lime-878 | 3 hours ago

Nah I misread it lol. I'm from the US so Australia is much more commom to me than Austria. Its not really relevant to the point tho unless I am missing something about Austria being particularly affected by AI.

devliegende | an hour ago

Confusing Austria and Australia is a pretty common thing for Americans. Also thinking Africa is a country and not knowing where Lesotho is.

FYI The word Austria is a disambiguation of Osterreich which means "Eastern Empire" whereas Australia derives from Austral which refers to the Southern Hemisphere.

Illustrious-Lime-878 | an hour ago

Tbf speed reading Austria as AustrALia, 2 letter difference, is different than not knowing what Austria is, let alone Africa lol

thebluepin | 4 hours ago

people wont accept slavery. they will just tear down society. and AI cant function without power. "but they have gas backups" ok? so you take out the gas pumping stations? like AI has ZERO resiliency. this delusion that people will accept slavery by skynet is Silicon Valley stupidity. you know what happens with unchecked wealth accumulation mixed with state control? 1789.

Illustrious-Lime-878 | 4 hours ago

Idk, look at today, the degree of inequality, brazen lawlessness by the top most wealthy moguls, total erosion of all privacy. A massive order of magnitude increases in per worker productivity over recent decades but a fractional increase if not declining real wage. More recently a loss of access to healthcare. Largely people are accepting it. I don't know we can say where the point is that people would tear it down, rather than just complain, as long as they have bread and circus, as long as most aren't starving.

thebluepin | 3 hours ago

thats kinda what everyone says before it happens. but i would say its looking far more precarious then it has in the past. when youth unemployment gets too high. thats also a "scary" number is having a bunch of people with nothing to lose having no link to the future leads to bad things.

nada8 | 3 hours ago

Temporary displacement? Really?

Illustrious-Lime-878 | 3 hours ago

Jobs have been constantly changing throughout all of history, most jobs in the 1800s don't exist now. People find new things to do, it just happens gradually, so the only difference here is potentially in degree or speed, so its just a matter of giving people time to adapt, reskill, etc.

dogs_gt_cats | an hour ago

My big concern about UBI being necessary is the culture wars conservatives continue to dwell on. Imagine being an LGBTQ+ person whose livelihood depends on UBI, and then republicans take over the administration. Or someone with a hispanic sounding last name.

Until there is a universal bill of human rights that has actual teeth in the US, UBI would absolutely be weaponized against certain demographics that the current administration believes are undesirable.

Magificent_Gradient | an hour ago

See the social merit system in China and how it’s used as a compliance mechanism.

In the USA, there will absolutely be conditions and biases with UBI. Someone will always believe they are entitled to more than the other for whatever reason.

vgodara | 5 hours ago

This is what people needs to understand. The group which brings in money will always have upper hand. Democracy can't be saved with government handouts. Unless majority of population is contributing to tax collection the current system will collapse.

UBI would be just band aid. It wouldn't fix underlying issues.

That is if majority of population stops coperating and there is zero impact on production means they have zero bargaining power in economic sense.

Icy_Scar_1249 | 4 hours ago

Who will production be for? If people don't have money, who is going to buy consumable goods? Vehicles? Machinery? Businesses? The whole system will need to be rethought in this hypothetical future

Magificent_Gradient | 4 hours ago

The velocity of money is exactly why a K shaped economy will fail. Hollow out the middle and the whole thing skids to a stop.

We’re quickly learning how a circular financed industry like AI is unsustainable.

GuelphEastEndGhetto | 3 hours ago

Like a dam bursting between the haves and have nots.

vgodara | 3 hours ago

Did British Raj collapse because most of it's population couldn't afford it's factory made stuff ?

And if the producer has to pay money to the consumer to buy stuff. How different it would him producing and dumping in ground.

Your pov assume there are multiple producers and the best one gets most customer and becomes rich. But recent years have shown instead of competing they prefer merger.

Icy_Scar_1249 | 3 hours ago

They had someone to sell their goods to. A handful of billionaires won't consume the same as millions of labourers previously would have

vgodara | 3 hours ago

Till 1940 a very small population of world could buy factory produced goods. Most of Latin America and Asia couldn't and they were subjugated by who could buy factory produced goods. And economic engine was running at full throttle.

Icy_Scar_1249 | 3 hours ago

In this case, they don't need LATAM or Asia, or people anywhere to produce goods. And the number of people who could consume in a worse case scenario is extremely tiny.

vgodara | 3 hours ago

And production is extremely cheap. You don't need economy of scale anymore.

Magificent_Gradient | 5 hours ago

Give them breadcrumbs so they eat, but provide just enough so they don’t revolt.

dust4ngel | 15 minutes ago

> provide just enough so they don’t revolt

it's more profitable to sell some AI infrastructure to whatever's left of governments to surveil and kill the discontents. why make it a cost center when it could be a profit center?

Magificent_Gradient | 59 minutes ago

He who has the gold makes the rules. That’s never going to change.

vgodara | 58 minutes ago

Not always but yes he does weild power.

Power atleast according to me comes from three sources crowd , religion and gold.

Few_Fish8771 | 3 hours ago

What if you have state owned enterprises that control most of the production rather than private corporations?

TimSylvester_ | an hour ago

UBI will either be paid from taxes, or will be produced by the issuance of new money.

In either form, it will dramatically worsen government balance sheets.

The only way I can see to resolve it is to shift the issuance of new money from the Fed's balance sheet, in exchange for Treasury Bonds, and directly into citizen accounts.

That would result in the citizens getting the new currency issued directly, then the citizens purchasing the t-bills instead of the Fed. That would also mean the citizens get the segniorage and the interest payments.

It's the only solution I have for UBI that doesn't inherently bankrupt any government that tries it, but I can't imagine the banks will voluntarily give up the segniorage or the interest payments when their own balance sheets are pretty heavily reliant on them.

Magificent_Gradient | an hour ago

It would definitely create two classes of currency: one for the 1% ruling class wealthy that buys whatever they want and another for everyone else that restricts what we can buy, like real estate or investments.

99% of people would instantly become renters of absolutely everything.

TimSylvester_ | an hour ago

Hey, wait a minute! That's what we have now!

Magificent_Gradient | 57 minutes ago

Not quite, but pretty close.  Still share the same dollar, but you have to be in the big club and we certainly ain’t in it.

TimSylvester_ | 46 minutes ago

I'm joking but I'm not. If you look at it from "first bite of the apple", banks get the pre-inflationary value, and this inflationary wave travels incrementally down the flow of cash from issuance to saturation through the economy, while we mere citizens get the post-inflationary, post-saturation value.

So we are spending the same denomination, but it has two different values.

AwesomePurplePants | 5 hours ago

Nah, it would be X pounds of strawberries. 30 hours of puttering outside while snacking could be quite pleasant.

Qeltar_ | 4 hours ago

I know you're joking, but have you ever spent any amount of time picking strawberries? I do it for a few hours every June, and I think my back is finally about recovered now lol.

AwesomePurplePants | 3 hours ago

Yeah, doing it for real is hard work. Not downplaying the difficulty, just pointing out that per hour creates a funny loophole.

tigz47 | 5 hours ago

30 hours a day

Petrichordates | 3 hours ago

UBI ain't happening, people really need to move past that naivety.

Magificent_Gradient | 3 hours ago

Depends how many people start to revolt because they’re starving.

5partacus69 | 2 hours ago

Those people have now been placed in prison camps... now what?

Affectionate-Food652 | 2 hours ago

…they continue to revolt because you can’t prison camp your way out of a societal collapse where you can’t feed the masses.

5partacus69 | 2 hours ago

That isn't how prison camps work

There are no revolts in prison camps

So my question remains...

Affectionate-Food652 | 2 hours ago

You’re joking right? This is a joke. “There are no revolts in prison camps”

The Warsaw ghetto uprising? Vorkuta uprising? Norilsk uprising? Kengir uprising?

Revolts in prison camps are one of the most common features of prison camps.

Oppressive regimes experiencing logistical collapse also have a hard time maintaining morale. Hard to imprison masses of people when the soldiers you’re sending to imprison them are also hungry.

HumorAccomplished611 | 2 hours ago

Prison is just UBI with less freedom

PierreRobineau | 5 hours ago

Revolution against EMP-hardened military robots?

Magificent_Gradient | 3 hours ago

That’s a grim possibility in the future, but there’s far more of us than military robots right now.

OrangeJr36 | 5 hours ago

Even such a requirement wouldn't even come close to funding UBI.

Like all social programs, to find UBI you need three things:

Low unemployment

A growing (or at least not shrinking) population

Reliable wage growth

So, if you believe that AI adoption will cause disruptions in employment, you're going to have to give up on believing in UBI.

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

>Low unemployment

This is where the fundamental misunderstanding already starts. We are living in a time (very short, one might add) where everything is built on "employment". Because the unquestioned assumption is, that employment generates value.

Now we are entering into a phase, where machines create "most" of the value. Not everything. But the predominant part of it. We have always relied on the "wage" as a means for redistribution. Labor generates value, gets paid a wage, can use the wage for living.

How do you solve this now when labor simply doesn't (really) generate value anymore? If all the value comes from machines (and energy)?

OrangeJr36 | 5 hours ago

A machine that produces something that people cannot afford to buy has no value.

The whole point of economic activity is to produce things for people to buy and consume, if there are fewer people to participate and fewer jobs available to even begin the process then the value of everything in society drops.

This is the problem with large scale adoption of AI that tech bros can't answer, what is the value of AI if the goal they want for it is to destroy the economic value of it to begin with?

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

Very important point, unfortunately this goes beyond anything you can reasonably discuss here in this format.

Basically it touches the core of what is value. Nowadays, everything is linked to accounting rules. If you cannot capture it in enterprise value, business cases, discounted cash flow etc. then it is - as you point out - without value.

Also, the other side of the coin: By this definition a machine that produces "infinite amounts of output with limitlessly available inputs" has - you said it already - also no value. The output is worth nothing if it is just...there. Like air to breathe. It is super essential for our survival, but since it's everywhere available for free you cannot put a price tag on it.

Now let's imagine it will be the same for basic, common goods like food, electricity, etc. How do you build a society around that?

OrangeJr36 | 4 hours ago

You're implying we're entering a Star Trek-esque post-scarcity situation, which is far beyond what modern economics has context for.

More than likely, you would have to have a near total collapse of the current economic system before businesses and governments figure out how to respond to and restructure themselves around.

Odra_dek | 4 hours ago

In a nutshell, yes. However, in no way am I saying we are really "near" this. We could be, but I don't think I will see it in my lifetime.

In the long run however it's inevitable. Just consider how "young" humanity is, compared to - I don't know - Dinosaurs. They went extinct about 60-70 Million years ago. Modern society is a couple thousand years old, if you count generously.

Absurd to think we will still depend on wage labor a couple hundred thousands of years into the future. It's a question of "when" not "if". And people are in denial instead of actively working towards systems that are prepared for this.

David_ungerer | 3 hours ago

OK, the future is not capitalism but, the corporations and oligarchs that benefit from capitalism are willing to ride that horse to the end of the trail . . .

The solution is not economic (yet). The problem is political, left/right is old and tired. New politics that best describes todays world is Pro-corporate/Anti-corporate where Pro protects capitalism, corporations and oligarchs and Anti which protects workers, families and communities.

Viewing the problem this way, the economic solutions are clearer and eazyer.

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

> A machine that produces something that people cannot afford to buy has no value. > >

No one said no cant buy it. Lets say you buy guard drones. Regular people cant buy it but the rich can. They might end up just trading in more a barter system than cash. Some oil baron trades barrels of oil to factories etc.

>This is the problem with large scale adoption of AI that tech bros can't answer, what is the value of AI if the goal they want for it is to destroy the economic value of it to begin with?

Its more about disruption and time isnt it. We used to have like 50% of our population farming. Now its about 1%. That labor had to go somewhere. Eventually it did.

Hopefully the labor can find somewhere to go but it might not.

rethinkingat59 | 3 hours ago

I read this same exact warning in a 1920’s magazine focused on socialism. They warned the combination of electricity and the combustion engine (tractors) would destroy the need for over 50% of the work force,

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

Link?

rethinkingat59 | 25 minutes ago

I read it years ago in magazines stacks in a library. (The way I passed time in college instead of studying) so I don’t have a link.

Wikipedia has an article on the concept that cites multiple sources, some long before the 1920’s, hopes it helps.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_unemployment

HumorAccomplished611 | 12 minutes ago

Haha it was more of a joke that a 1920s magazine would be online. But thanks

Magificent_Gradient | 5 hours ago

AI already is causing disruption in employment.

OrangeJr36 | 5 hours ago

Then there's no reason to consider UBI, if anything you should be considering welfare cuts in response.

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

You could. But at some point, this will lead to a total collapse of society, because only an ever decreasing minority will reap ever increasing rewards.

Now look at history. Anytime. Anywhere. Doesn't matter if ancient Mesopotamia, South America or China. Huge wealth disparity has *always* ended up in collapse eventually.

Zealousideal_Walk433 | 5 hours ago

But they didn't have an army of intelligent robots like tech lords do now. Any dissent will easily be identified by the mere thought of it.

hippydipster | 5 hours ago

Call it CBI then, if there are strings attached. Do not sully the good name of UNIVERSAL Basic Income.

Magificent_Gradient | 4 hours ago

It’s Universal Basic Income, not Unconditional.

hippydipster | 4 hours ago

Thank you, i got confused, but it makes the same point.

fumar | 3 hours ago

People aren't going to accept living on UBI in a western society. Sure a few will, but most will get pissed off and that will lead to instability.

N0b0me | 3 hours ago

Given the increased substitutability of labor by capital there is no need to maintain such a broad and generous social safety net let alone expand it by creating UBI

SomeRandomSomeWhere | 2 hours ago

Until there are AI controlled machines doing the picking. They already have AI controlled machines handling the harvesting of certain produce already.

Magificent_Gradient | 2 hours ago

I saw one machine for onion harvesting that uses AI and lasers to sort as it picks. It’s extremely fast and incredibly accurate.  This technology is also very expensive and out of reach for most farmers.

Artemisbleachedmod | 2 hours ago

The children yearn for the fields

dostoevsky4evah | an hour ago

With an administration like the present one, picking strawberries would be the "cushy" job. They need a little more cruelty against the poors to satisfy them than that.

Geronimomo | an hour ago

The new paradigm demands a wealth tax or unrealised gains tax for the ultra-rich.

Aggravating-Dot132 | 4 hours ago

Ubi can work since resources are limited AND it requires effectively a communism in terms of economy. Which is impossible to achieve.

Friendly_Ad8551 | 5 hours ago

Then stop taxing labour income and start taxing wealth. I think we should have done this regardless of AI anyway.

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

Californian politicians tried, voters said "no".

hopeless at this point

chrisk9 | 5 hours ago

Even though the vast majority will never amass the family wealth where such wealth tax would apply

welshwelsh | 4 hours ago

You don't need to be rich to be impacted by a wealth tax that targets only the rich.

When rich people sell their stocks to pay a wealth tax, that impacts your 401k value, even if you're just a middle manager at an insurance company.

chrisk9 | 4 hours ago

So let obscene wealth concentrate because if they have to sell investments to pay tax obligations the markets will crash? Sure.

devliegende | 2 hours ago

The idea that the value of your 401K is held up by nothing other than people not selling is a little quaint. What do you think is going to happen to your 401K when you're retired and start selling? Value collapse? How will you live then?

dyslexda | 3 hours ago

Maybe a 401k shouldn't be the primary vehicle of independence in retirement, if the cost is we have to let wealth keep concentrating so line goes up.

Magificent_Gradient | 4 hours ago

Put a tax on extreme wealth and the wealthy will find some way around paying it. They’re absurdly wealthy for a reason and it’s not because they play by the rules.

Rock-n-RollingStart | 5 hours ago

We do not tax "labor income" as opposed to "wealth," we tax consumption instead of production. This is Economics 102.

Taxing consumption, e.g., wages, stock dividends, savings account interest, real estate, etc., helps to keep a lid on inflation. Taxes are low on producers, e.g., businesses, capital gains, entrepreneurs, etc., to incentivize investments that keep people employed and the economy growing.

Lemp_Triscuit11 | 5 hours ago

> to incentivize investments that keep people employed and the economy growing.

I believe that they've been squandering that on C suite bonuses and purchasing their competition to allow a reduction in quality of product/service, tho

Rock-n-RollingStart | 5 hours ago

Yes, in my opinion, we've left too many tax loop holes open for far too long that allow a select few people to live outside the tax system. As asset prices have risen dramatically, this amplifies their wealth to the point they have power over government bodies.

Lemp_Triscuit11 | 4 hours ago

Even beyond their sway over the government- which I agree is the most urgent issue we have going on- I was more complaining that capitalism is sort of based on this idea that a rising tide lifts all boats but we just see on a daily basis that this is not the case. How long do we keep giving tax breaks to corporations based on this ideology that it keeps members of the corporation's community financially above water when we see that it is literally not happening, there's no legal mechanism to make it start happening, and no corporation has its own interesting in moving that direction? lol

There was supposed to be like one really big positive side to this system for the general population and it just doesn't happen anymore, if it ever really did

Rock-n-RollingStart | 4 hours ago

There are countless examples of capitalism lifting people out of poverty while other forms of government do not. The Western democracies are virtually all capitalist forms of government, and they have the highest standards of living of anyone on the planet.

Capitalism is not perfect, but it's the best way people have found to spread resources between ourselves. Just because you don't personally live in some kind of egalitarian Utopia doesn't mean we need to radically change things.

Lemp_Triscuit11 | 4 hours ago

It wasn't a pro socialism rant, I promise lol. But I also won't pretend people going from poor to rich is a feature exclusive to capitalism either.

What I was saying was that your average citizen's buy in to the system of capitalism is supposed to be that when businesses do well that they improve the lives of their employees (edit: and communities), financially and/or otherwise, and not only is that not happening, but we all increasingly pretend any notion that it should happen is bad or unAmerican in some braindead way lol

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

> It wasn't a pro socialism rant, I promise lol. But I also won't pretend people going from poor to rich is a feature exclusive to capitalism either. > >

What other systems have that going on a lot?

Lemp_Triscuit11 | an hour ago

What is your definition of "a lot" and do you have those statistics for the broad system of capitalism? lol

devliegende | 2 hours ago

The Western Democracies are all mixed economies and wide spread upliftment out of poverty is pretty well correlated with them becoming more mixed.

MrSnarf26 | 4 hours ago

This is backwards. Generally a consumption tax is considered a tax when you spend money. Tax on labor or wages generally refers to income tax.

Rock-n-RollingStart | 4 hours ago

This is an economics sub, these are economics terms. People are called "consumers" for a reason.

You tax the money used for consuming things. That could be directly from wages, it could be income from a rental unit, from treasury bills, whatever. This is the money used to buy food, goods, and services. If you don't tax it, inflation goes hog wild, as you'll recall from 2021-2023 when governments were throwing money at people for months before lifting COVID restrictions and inflation exploded.

Odra_dek | 5 hours ago

I (kinda) copy/paste my point from below: This only works if - and only if - labor contributes a significant part to output. Then labor is necessary, labor demand is there, wages can reap a fair portion of profits.

Now we are entering a stage in society, where labor is increasingly irrelevant. It will not happen all at once, but over time. But in most areas. Labor will lose all its bargaining power. And in the end, demand destruction will follow as well.

Bodoblock | 3 hours ago

> But as it turns out, our whole society is built on tax and social contributions generated by checks notes labor.

Which is crazy to me. We say we value labor's contribution to society, but we basically venerate passive ownership in comparison. Labor bears the burden of taxation while capital gets a free pass.

InFearn0 | an hour ago

> We say we value labor's contribution to society

We value labor, but we aren't the ones setting labor's pay nor are we the ones setting tax policy.

TheTimberFactory | 3 hours ago

The scales are slowly tipping the American economy out of balance in the grand scheme of things but come 5-10 years, it will be way out of balance.

Maybe it's me but what if this was the plan all along? Saddle the government with trillions in debt, AI kicks the government and labor in the balls, and then the whole economy, heavily reliant on white collar labor, implodes. Homes go into foreclosure. Soup kitchens with lines out the wazoo. Depression 2.0.

IMO, this is the most realistic scenario. Its one thing to have Luigi going after Healthcare but someone going after AI? It feels like both parties are absolutely complicit in America's undoing.

Where does labor fit into this picture 10-20 years the road? Are we headed to a Children of Men future?

Medium_King_David | 3 hours ago

Peter Thiel is not at all shy about wanting to create a Techno-feudalist future.

Sunflower1066 | 4 hours ago

This is something the really concerns me re tax. Sure there are arguments of just taxing the wealthy more but as we already know the wealthy are very good at avoiding tax via complex structures, taking out loans against assets or just relocating to a tax heaven so idk how we could possibly rely on that accounting for the loss of income tax. I also wonder how UBI can even solve the potential joblessness we could be facing. I wonder what will people even do with themselves? For me there’s only so many kilometres I can run, weights I could lift and video games I could play before there would be some lack of purpose that I felt. Apart from that if people only had a set amount per month that that would be pretty demoralising I feel and could lead to increase in crime due to people attempting to bring in more monthly income.

InFearn0 | an hour ago

> And on other good news, AI driven "efficiency" leads to companies - sometimes more, sometimes less - aggressively getting rid of employees. More burnout for the ones that remaim, while an increasing number gets phased out into....god knows what. In many countries there are literally no jobs for junior IT guys anymore. And it has started to spill over into other areas, like legal, tax, etc.

A consistent trait of successful revolutions is the mutual participation of the professional class and worker class.

Laying off professionals is going to lead to staffing the revolution.

dukeofgonzo | 5 hours ago

well, we could tax capital instead of income. Its that a kosher opinion on the economics subreddit?

TieTheStick | 5 hours ago

I think it better be.

Designer_Show_2658 | 5 hours ago

Good thing we always have capital investment balancing dying real income. Bad thing its value could all come crashing down with the biggest financial recession in history on the horizon. Oh well who needs financial stability anyways.

johnknockout | 4 hours ago

So back last year the consultants (there was maybe a small grain of truth here but it was also definitely a form of dick riding) said that the only ones who were using AI correctly were managers because they were the only people who understood how to use assets stochastically.

So now you have this huge organizations who are giving paid AI models to VPs/ directors/ managers who are moving a 1 million miles an hour and the people who have to execute are completely unable to keep up.

Petrichordates | 3 hours ago

"Using assets stochastically" isn't meaningful language, what are you saying here?

KuntaStillSingle | 32 minutes ago

I think they mean to say indirectly rather than stochastically, because stochastic terrorism is indirect they may be conflating stochastic as referring to indirectness rather than probabilisticity.

CurryMustard | 3 hours ago

If we dont start taxing the hell out of companies shits going to get real bad

spatialmongrel | 19 minutes ago

To paraphrase Adrian Tchaikovsky:

“AI can take away the tedious, the demeaning, the miserable tasks and allow the chance to do fulfilling work, rather than be pressed into the mould of some job they hate, the overtime, the performance targets, and endless meetings.

OR

We replace everyone with AI that is cheaper and quicker, can’t unionize or complain about working conditions, while continuing to insist that individual human value is tied to production.”

GalaXion24 | 2 hours ago

Genuinely thinking we should basically stop taxing labour and start taxing capital.

PierreRobineau | 5 hours ago

Sounds like we need to tax wealth.

muffledvoice | 2 hours ago

This is true, but we need a government that isn’t comprised of the same class they need to tax.

PierreRobineau | an hour ago

Some wealthy people won't object if you also tax their fellow billionaires/multi-millionaires. But that would need to be coordinated throughout many jurisdictions. That's the hard part.

scienceisaserfdom | an hour ago

AI Industry: we must burn down the global economy to save it from itself

psychohistorian8 | an hour ago

its been an absolute bloodbath at the software company I work for

I've survived so far, but why would I even want to stay? surely I am next in line for cuts

RiftHunter4 | 29 minutes ago

>AI driven "efficiency"

Many studies have been done at this point and in no metric has Ai increased productivity regardless of the strategy. It is a waste of time and an addition of needless complexity.

everyones-robots | 23 minutes ago

This falls out of the principles of capitalism.

Capitalism has a lot of upside, but the downsides must be managed. And we uh... Well, we haven't really been doing a lot of that.

DonutAdmirable9831 | 5 hours ago

Quick question but who do you think “the state” is exactly and how does the state (and consequently its debt) make money? A money printer can only get you so far

Odra_dek | 4 hours ago

Not a quick question at all. It touches on the core point of how goods and services get distributed amongst ourselves.

You are absolutely right, printing infinite amounts of money will only lead to ever higher inflation. However, as it currently stands, our systems fundamentally assume (takes for granted) that people can sell their time in the form of "labor", which contributes to the output that we, our economy, produces. We can claim a wage that represents the portion of our input to said output. Economics 101. Now how does this work once labor simply doesn't contribute anything measurable to output anymore?

You cannot simply have the owner of the business harvest 99% of profits all for himself. I mean you could try, but then it's only a matter of time until we have the next big revolution.

David_ungerer | 4 hours ago

Said another way, just voted down HERE 2years ago. “ If capitalism does not work for everyone, F@#K it!”.

MastodonParking9080 | an hour ago

Weren't you all fighting against tariffs to stop outsourcing a while ago? You'll loose your job to foreign competitors in time anyways.

Silent_Wave3137 | 3 hours ago

Idk me and literally all of my friends have had our workloads cut by more than half because of AI. Two of us got promoted. AI is the single best thing to happen to me. Not only did my portfolio rocket up, so did my salary. All while reducing my workload so I can play more games.

People who are good with AI have really been benefiting. The problem is most people are dumb as hell.

[OP] One-Emu-1103 | 6 hours ago

The global economy is “standing on one leg” — artificial intelligence, IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva said.

“If this leg wobbles, that can lead to financial stability troubles,” Georgieva warned.

Circular financing among AI companies has grown to just over $1 trillion, with about two-thirds of it funded by debt, Georgieva said.

BadgersHoneyPot | 6 hours ago

It when the debt started coming out that I really began paring all my tech trades last year. We used to hear that this was all being funded from free cash flow; few people realized that even as of last year all of Meta's free cash flow was going to employee compensation.

It's the debt that will cause this to end poorly. It always does. And rates are on the rise - not just from market participants, but due to express statements by central bankers.

Magificent_Gradient | 4 hours ago

They’re already working on ways to offload that bad debt onto the public through our 401k and IRAs.

The whole reason that “Trump Savings Accounts for Kids” scam was created was for this exact reason.  Pump up share prices, then dump them to these accounts as they begin to lose value and then write off 100% the contributions on taxes.

jjwhitaker | an hour ago

AKA IPO now.

HeKnee | 5 hours ago

Meta was spending all their cash on employee comp? Or data center buildout? The later make sense but not the former.

BadgersHoneyPot | 5 hours ago

Honest question: Given the choice between being that person who sees something, then goes and checks on it himself so that he can write a challenging response that comes with sources, or being that person who asks OP to spoonfeed him information, what prompted you to choose the latter?

Anyways, to help you out, here's WSJ reporting. Since you probably don't pay for a subscription:

>Meta Platforms looks like a money-printing machine. So why has it been loading up on billions of dollars in debt to pay for its new data centers?

>It turns out that the abundant free cash flow that Meta reports to investors is something of an optical illusion. Yes, it generated billions in cash last year, but that was largely devoured by the all-too-real cash costs that come with paying stock-based compensation to employees. Those included billions of dollars in withholding taxes triggered when employee shares vested, and billions more for share buybacks used to offset share dilution from those same awards.

>Viewed this way, it’s easy to see why Meta more than doubled the debt on its balance sheet last year to $58.7 billion. It borrowed because it had to. And that debt is only the part that is visible. Meta’s books don’t include the debt from a $27 billion data-center project under construction that Meta kept off its balance sheet through complex financial engineering.
...
Other big tech companies also report large cash costs tied to stock-based pay, includingAlphabet,MicrosoftandNvidia. But as a percentage of free cash flow, such costs are far smaller at those companies than at Meta, which is an outlier.

Article is 10 months old BTW so old news here.

bobandgeorge | 5 hours ago

Please don't be smug to people asking for a source. It used to be considered good etiquette on here. You're smart enough to know that there is so much misinformation out there and that people doing their own research is really not something that we can depend on folks to do.

Thank you for providing that source.

BadgersHoneyPot | 4 hours ago

You may have missed this subtle twist, but not only did the person question what I wrote, they made their own unsupported contention.

Really, a double faux-pas IMHO.

GreenMycologist87 | 5 hours ago

Debt is the equity. You're saying our global economy will end poorly because that's its purpose. Care to confess any other sins, my child?

BadgersHoneyPot | 5 hours ago

And this right here is a side symptom of what we're dealing with. AI powered bot comments. Because in what world does this comment make sense, from a one month old account?

More Dead Internet Theory. It's sad, really.

GreenMycologist87 | 5 hours ago

Ah, tis no sin to be AI. No need to confess that my child. We're all AI in 604's house. Now let us prey...on the cookies. Nom nom nom.

Edit: Very well, I will proof the theorem in one word; real. And yes, that's the Spanish origin. I double dog dare any of you to contest it.

MontyDyson | 6 hours ago

To be fair $1 trillion isn’t that much in the grand scheme of things. Nvidia lost $1.6 trillion because a man with a mid life crisis jacket couldn’t keep his dick in his pants.

Magificent_Gradient | 5 hours ago

I mean seriously, who doesn’t have a trillion or two stuck between the couch cushions?

EnamelKant | 5 hours ago

I just asked my parents for a small loan of about $1 trillion dollars.

stinkbugzgalore | 5 hours ago

Hence the couch humping by JD Vance

_Thorshammer_ | 5 hours ago

$1 trillion is a mind-boggling amount of money.

Nvidia didn’t “lose“ $1.6 trillion – their stock value dropped that much.

If I told you I was going to pay you $100 for your bike, and then later I told you I was only going to pay you $50, you didn’t actually lose $50. You thought you had $50, and you might have spent $50 because you thought I would pay you $100 for the bike, but you never actually had that money.

The $1 trillion in debt the article is talking about is actual money loaned to these companies and spent on… God only knows what.

If those companies crash, that money disappears.

If I give you $50, and you set it on fire in a parking lot, I lost $50 dollars.

The stock value of Nvidia never existed, so money didn’t disappear, but the money loaned to the tech companies was very real and if they set it on fire, that’s a huge fucking problem.

That’s 1/40 of the national debt.

candykissnips | 4 hours ago

Hmm, doesn’t a stock go down when a lot of it is sold off? So then, $1.6 trillion didn’t just disappear… the bulk of it would have gone to whatever entities sold their NVIDIA shares.

HowdyDiarrhea | 3 hours ago

Conversely, at the height of their valuation, if you decided that you loved Nvidia so much that you wanted to buy the whole company, it would cost you a premium to the ~5 trillion valuation at that point. Nobody's saying they physically lost the cash, it is a commentary on valuation.

NitroLada | 2 hours ago

No it's not, even the IMF and person quoted said it's not, 1T is tiny amount in terms of total value of world economy which is what she's talking about in context

>“It’s not a huge size, but it is a rapid increase,” Georgieva said.

ktaktb | 5 hours ago

Nvidia did not lose 1.6T

Wtf

The fmv of nvidia stock does not appear on the balance sheet and it isnt an item on the income statement.

Please take a bit and read so you can understand what stocks are and what they are not!

I say this as someone that thinks nvidia is overvalued and that the circular financing ...while it may not rise to Criminal Fraud, it is essentially fraud.

Similar to how cage free eggs are actually from hens in cages, the defintion of criminal fraud is bastardized beyond all real meaning.

Dick_Lazer | 5 hours ago

They didn’t lose liquidity but losing market value can lead to very negative effects for the company

ktaktb | 5 hours ago

Sure but that isnt written as

Nvidia lost 1.6T

Revenge of the fools around here.

Yo we are in the shitty times caused by weak men...

Upstairs-Net-6897 | 5 hours ago

Not a midlife crisis jacket

awhafrightendem | 5 hours ago

That one take so truly ignorant that no part of what was written is accurate. It usually takes a while to find but bright and early in the morning here you are. Guess I'll work in the garden today.

MontyDyson | 4 hours ago

Touch some grass whilst you’re at it.

laosurv3y | 5 hours ago

It's such a weird thing to say. Growth may all be tied to AI but the economy is more than growth and other sectors haven't disappeared.

Qeltar_ | 5 hours ago

> ...two-thirds of it funded by debt...

On top of the other mountains of debt.

And yet everyone believes the Fed's "tough language" about how they are going to raise rates to the moon.

dually | 5 hours ago

All money is a loan from somewhere; this is a fundamental property of money you might as well be having a moral panic about gravity

apparently all these people wringing their hands about "vendor-financing" have never bought a car loan.

biinjo | 4 hours ago

What I find interesting with these articles is the scapegoating.

Sure ‘the AI industry’ is a bunch of rich guys circle jerking each other’s data centers.

But what these articles fail to report on is the underlying industry in all of these global issues, 2008 mortgage crisis and now the circular funding in the AI business:

The banks.

The banks that approve all these loans and finances. The financial industries that build these elaborate webs of financing structures. They do it for any business where they stand to make big money and currently that’s AI.

When it crashes, the banks go crying to the government as if it’s something they couldn’t see coming and they get bailed out because otherwise the savings and pensions of the voters are gone.

On to the next big bubble to suck dry.

RamBamBooey | 3 hours ago

Bailing out the banks without putting a single banker in jail after the 2008 crash was a terrible mistake.

GalaXion24 | 2 hours ago

Even if we didn't do that at the very least banks should have been nationalised without compensation and all investors should have lost their money. That would make investors think twice about this sort of thing in the future.

muffledvoice | 3 hours ago

Ask the bankers and they’ll tell you it was a great idea and they had no other choice.

KingFebirtha | 3 hours ago

Before the 80s and 90s, banks and finance in general were much more heavily regulated to avoid situations like this. Hell, in the 90s they literally removed the regulations that were put in place to prevent another great depression (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gramm%E2%80%93Leach%E2%80%93Bliley_Act). I guess we'll have to find out the hard way again.

AllenIll | 3 hours ago

It is essentially a kind of counterfeiting with extra steps. But instead of creating fake money for real goods the banks create a fake story to create real money. Real money that doesn't get pulled out of circulation either. Even after the fake story finally gets exposed.

Edit: Spelling.

FreeEnergy001 | 3 hours ago

> They do it for any business where they stand to make big money

I mean they do it for drug cartels so I don't see why AI would be where they draw the line.

ISB-Dev | an hour ago

Well it's not really the fault of the banks, it's it? It's the fault of governments whose job it is to regulate them.

Gootangus | 25 minutes ago

As of the government and bank aren’t two heads of the same hydra

strolls | 26 minutes ago

> The banks.

> The banks that approve all these loans and finances.

Banks are not financing data centres - they're funded as an investment by pension and insurance companies and by investment funds which you can buy in your 401k.

A merchant bank is not the same as the high street bank that provides your chequing account - they might both be banks, but they have fundamentally different structures and roles. I'm not defending what they did in the run up to 2008, but the reason the merchant banks were bailed out at that time was because they provide financing for all the other largest companies in the USA (S&P 500 companies and beyond) and a startup couldn't have just stepped in and taken over that role if one of more of them went bust. (Also the government did get its bailout money back.)

After 2008 a bunch of protections were put into place - e.g. Dodd-Frank Act, 2010 - which prohibit banks from putting their own capital at risk the way they did arriving at 2008.

The financing for these data centres is made privately, by individual and institutions, and the government tries not to regulate that excessively, because the whole point of economic markets is that collectively (by the process of people pursuing profit, some of them succeeding and others losing money) they have more wisdom than individuals or governments. Capitalism is far from perfect and I don't advocate unregulated markets, but it has brought us many of the comforts and necessities we enjoy and take for granted today.

If institutional investors want to invest in data centres then they should be allowed to (which is a completely separate question of whether a specific data centre should be allowed where it might disturb locals or endangered wildlife) because it's only by allowing good and bad investments to be made, and money poured into new industries, do technologies advance and become cheaper. Institutional investors are the most diversified of all, and spread billions amongst risky and safe investments, so should not be a social risk (they are also regulated).

Elon Musk is a twat, but he pioneered electric cars and forced all the other car manufactures to follow; he's reduced the cost of satellite launches and given internet connectivity to the remotest areas, cheaper and with higher bandwidth than ever before. That's a product of investors throwing money at him - his companies probably won't survive, but they'll be bought up and restructured when they go bust; other companies will follow his roadmap and compete. That's how markets work, and that's why people should be allowed to invest (broadly speaking) in whatever they want.

JesusSavesForHalf | an hour ago

Removing Glass-Stegal was one of the US' dumbest mistakes

Richandler | 33 minutes ago

Lotta private equity. The banks actually seem to be in a good place regarding their exposure to AI.

Signal_Republic3771 | 4 hours ago

Why are we as individuals, poor individuals at that because let's be real they are billionaires, why are we investing our money retirement etc in these companies and in turn our demise. Stop your greed and choose where your dollars and support goes. Disengage and push back.

NextGen-Panic | 4 hours ago

Philosophers and educators shocked motherfuckers are THIS stupid.

Theologians and con artists excited to usher in a new era of scams and schemes.

Politicians to continue bloviating, useless as always.

Alien explorers will discover a barren planet, full of wasted potential.

PizzaItch | 4 hours ago

Almost right, except there are no alien explorers. We are rushing towards discovering the answer to the Fermi paradox first-hand.

Medium_King_David | 3 hours ago

Chalk up another win for the great filter, everyone!

nifty-necromancer | an hour ago

And it’s not even AI that’s the (or a) great filter. It’s unfettered capitalism. Biology on a planetary scale with corporations absorbing competition and extracting resources.

NextGen-Panic | 51 minutes ago

Alien report: "Barring additional evidence to the contrary, our inspectors at Planet Refurbishers, LLC believe that the Humans were ultimately too liberal to eradicate Greed from their gene pool, which became their downfall. They let 'cancer' win."

roscoe_dock | 4 hours ago

Beautiful even though it’s so sad.

Slunkx | 4 hours ago

Training AI for marketing instead of progressive advancement, to where robots will be used instead of humans for work and economic shortfall for the AI to eventually see we're counter productive as a species and killing its purpose to why it was created and then.... Well now we got The Terminator.

muffledvoice | 3 hours ago

This is why crashes happen, a couple of decades go by, and crashes happen again. And again.

The way to “make the big money” right now (allegedly) is by pouring everything into AI. This speeds up the freight train mentioned in the article, exacerbating the imbalance.

If you’re a lemming in the middle of a huge crowd of lemmings, running in the same direction they do seems like a good idea because you only see [and compare yourself to] them and not the cliff.

HedonisticFrog | an hour ago

Is nobody actually reading the article? It's not talking about how capable AI is, it's talking about how it's a massive bubble. AI isn't capable of replacing employees yet, it's not even close. At best it's useful as small scope specific tools such as filling out spread sheets.

[OP] One-Emu-1103 | an hour ago

I read the articles but somehow I think most people only read the headlines

HedonisticFrog | 29 minutes ago

Classic reddit

Open-Consequence1779 | 59 minutes ago

Yes totally agree. But that's a huuuuge issue for the AI companies. Because AI is then more like a personal assistant more software model-like and for this type of products we know perfectly how big the market is... and it is nowhere close to those XX trillions of market potential AI CEOs come up with to try justifying their oversized investments and financial losses.

HedonisticFrog | 28 minutes ago

Every single AI company is being valued as if it will become a monopoly and control the entire market. It's not even in the realm of reasonable, the only question is when it will pop.

Mindrust | 28 minutes ago

>AI isn't capable of replacing employees yet, it's not even close

It's getting progressively closer

https://www.remotelabor.ai/

carefuldzaghigner | 26 minutes ago

The milky way is also getting closer to Andromeda buddy

Phixionion | 3 hours ago

Its tech in general and I can believe its not talked about more. You have a non physical economy tied to a physical one with nothing to properly balance it out.

PlanetCosmoX | 5 hours ago

I think it’s in the process of popping, I think most people who read economics thinks this.

Looking at nVidia stock yesterday all I see is deleveraging.
The Anthropic IPO isn’t an IPO it’s a sinking ship where investors are trying to pawn their bags onto retail.

It’s the spill-over I’m worried about. When this thing really goes there will be few places that are safe.

But I’m betting that Enbridge is one of them, and Canadian natural gas is another. One is a utility that is well placed to service Datacenters in the event that there is no bust, and the other is taking advantage of a depressed natural gas market getting exposure to Asia and Europe.

I suppose the US military has to spend to resupply missiles, ammunition, and buy drones. But this won’t happen until after the new Gov sits and the senate appropriations committee starts to make decisions once again. This time Dem controlled with no spectre of Trumps stupid battleship.

Magificent_Gradient | 5 hours ago

We all might be bag holders anyways after these AI stocks are chopped up and stuffed into our 401k and left to die while the top cashes out before it crashes.

TieTheStick | 5 hours ago

I demanded no AI exposure in my 401K. We'll see if they lied to me.

HowdyDiarrhea | 3 hours ago

Lol good luck with that

LubberwortPicaroon | 5 hours ago

My suspicion and fear is that while there is certainly a bubble around AI and it may be in the early stages of popping now, I'm not convinced it will go the same way as the dot com bubble or rail mania. I fear that these corporations are too influential as lobbyists and have buried themselves too deeply into national security in 5 short years that they are now too important to fail. Instead of the bubble popping and companies collapsing, consolidation and a sensible ecosystem emerging, the US government will step in, absorb the losses with another trillion or two added to the national debt

Magificent_Gradient | 3 hours ago

The midterm Democrat blowout definitely throws a wrench into the AI industry.

The AI oligarch’s compromised puppet in the Oval Office has to take his foot off the accelerator now.

[OP] One-Emu-1103 | 5 hours ago

howudothescarn | 5 hours ago

This is a lot of wishful thinking. Anthropic ipo is over subscribed for example

Brendan__Fraser | 5 hours ago

I think a lot of people are trying to catch the opening bump only to dump right after

YSoMadTov | 5 hours ago

Anthropic is arguably the AI company that is doing well the most and they are still nowhere close to being profitable and will remain so for the near future. All of the AI companies are infinite money sucking blackholes with anthropic being the least bad because Claude is actually useful for the most part.

Nadnerb98 | 4 hours ago

You might be right- but I remember the same narrative about Facebook in the early 2000’s- so many “experts” said they didn’t have a business model or a clear path to profitability. Those experts were clearly wrong.

YSoMadTov | 4 hours ago

Anthropic is the most likely to survive, just like Facebook was the only one to survive and thrived out of the bazillion different social media platforms during the boom, the rest will bust.

Existing-Return-5308 | 3 hours ago

Half the lawyers in every court case are 100% wrong.

Dizzy-Memory2231 | 32 minutes ago

This is a pretty stupid hot take based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what lawyers do.

ellamking | 2 hours ago

It's true that they are doing the relatively well, but 80% of their revenue comes from 1% of their customers, and most of their large customers are other AI companies that aren't profitable. It's questionable if their relative success is at all sustainable.

some_where_else | 4 hours ago

easy enough to size the float as necessary - then borrow against the remaining shares that now have a 'market price'.

iliveonramen | 4 hours ago

The article that claims that also claims that Dario is the new Jensen. I guess it thinks any warm body can do. It also seems to miss the fact that it was NVIDIA’s massive piles of cash that was able to be used to backstop AI companies and data centers that kept the whole thing going. Anthropic doesn’t have either those margins or cash flow

Magificent_Gradient | 3 hours ago

Hardware and software are two completely different ends of the tech spectrum as far as businesses go.

iliveonramen | 3 hours ago

Im not sure your point?

Magificent_Gradient | 3 hours ago

$ANT is going to be pumped and dumped like SpaceX.

zeezle | 5 hours ago

> I suppose the US military has to spend to resupply missiles, ammunition, and buy drones. But this won’t happen until after the new Gov sits and the senate appropriations committee starts to make decisions once again.

As someone now working for an aerospace company in the sector, these companies are actually doing very well and the contracts are often already signed through the 2060s and beyond.

The "problem" as far as the stock market is concerned is that these companies are doing as well as expected so stock prices don't go up that much. Their whole business model is steady but not poised for explosive growth (no pun intended).

Aggravating-Big3858 | 4 hours ago

I'm not thrilled about the current setup either. For some reason, the smartest people in the world have all decided AI is the train we all need to jump on. Immediately. In very short order we're going to have AI, quite possibly AGI, a robotics revolution, and then a quantum computing breakthrough.

Very good chance the world is a dramatically different place 10 years from now ... nevermind 20 or 30

Urshilikai | 3 hours ago

it wasnt the smartest people choosing this, dont frame them as anything but misanthropic

Silent_Wave3137 | 3 hours ago

Nah, it is. Not all of them, but a lot. Only a moron would try to stop progress. Same idiots who said machines and factories would destroy the country. Or that cars wouldn’t catch on. Or that the internet was temporary.

AI is inevitable. It’s trendy to oppose it, and it is harmful in a lot of unavoidable ways. But it’s still coming. Nothing is going to stop it because it’s critical to national security for every country in the world now.

That’s what the smartest people in the world know. They don’t have to like it, but they know it’s inevitable.

Dense-Muffin-3809 | 2 hours ago

Only an idiot would label any technological innovation as « progress ». It’s sad that we only mesure progress as financial or technological.

Socially, intellectually, environnementale, AI is a massive regression. It’s mostly useless for now and if it doesn’t deliver its promises in due time, it might play a big part in our downfall.

DojiRun | 2 hours ago

you should try smiling. AI has done the opposite for myself and many around me. I was like you about 1 year ago.

otakugal15 | 2 hours ago

Gross

DojiRun | an hour ago

So productive.

Prior_Coyote_4376 | 2 hours ago

Outside of online activists, pretty much everyone has accepted AI will continue to exist, not because of national security but because there’s a lot of different motivations to achieve a tool like that. The smartest people have been critical of the way industry has built completely unrealistic expectations of what AI is doing and going to do.

Cars are here to stay but you’re going to sound silly saying you have more freedom to move around while stuck in rush hour traffic everyday. The Internet is here to stay but you’d be laughed out of any room for suggesting it’s improved our networking ability as a species without a hitch. AI is also here to stay but it’s not going to bring about a UBI utopia through the development of sentient AGI and we actually need a lot more regulatory guidance for it, it’ll lead to things like new medicines or improved search

POEness | an hour ago

Only difference is, this isn't AI. It's hype / scam.

RadicallyMeta | 2 hours ago

What % of "smart" people do you think are having these thoughts?

crasheerice4 | 2 hours ago

Yup. It’s happening and no one out there can stop it. Instead of screaming at a bar trivia night for making an AI flyer people should be way more focused on how we integrate it in a way that is healthy for the general population. The horse is out of the barn, but we can train the horse

Forward_Problem_8982 | 2 hours ago

Screaming at AI flyers is training the horse.

crasheerice4 | 2 hours ago

No, it’s dumb. No one was going to pay a graphic designer to make a bar trivia flyer, there just wouldn’t have been a flyer. Focus on shit that matters

Forward_Problem_8982 | an hour ago

Anyone can make a flyer. You don't need to pay.

Miserable-Debt-8390 | 3 hours ago

What is mindblowing is how the management class is ignoring what the experienced developers are screaming at them…(I have seen this personally)

These people made up their mind and they are glad to drive all of us off a cliff

poopybuttwo | 3 hours ago

The management class is well aware that AI can solve some very algorithmic problems, but it has not been effective at solving many human problems. It’s not going to really fix something like a nurse staffing shortage, or understanding why a small molecule drug isn’t being absorbed well, or prioritizing how to adjust zoning in an urban district to promote investment while offsetting concerns of gentrification. These are all just little examples of how AI, given lots of data, can fit solutions efficiently but can’t handle imperfect people, complex biology, or human misalignment. These concepts extend into business, where your biggest problem is often deciding what problem to solve… AI won’t tell you how to balance projects, just how to optimize projects in a basically frictionless environment.

canuck_in_wa | 2 hours ago

Not only won’t it solve the human coordination problems, it makes them all worse. How much do you ignore slop from coworkers now? My eyes glaze over when I see obvious slop now, and I calibrate my energy to work with it to the energy a person put in to make it.

LLMs / agentic systems are making everyone locked in to their own little world, exchanging slop messages that no one cares about.

deepasleep | 3 hours ago

Their motivation is simple greed.

There is a pervasive belief that whoever gets to general artificial intelligence first wins. That belief is probably true if you assume recursive self-improvement comes with it.

So whoever has an ownership stake in the company or companies that “own” the technology will basically have a lock on all future technology and any revenue that comes from the work done by the AI.

The problems are RSI may not be coincident with AGI and if it is, there’s a good chance whatever they birth into the world may not see any reason to keep humans around, let alone give a flying fuck about the petty wants of the shareholders.

MagicalSkyMan | 2 hours ago

What a dumb take. There will obviously be multiple motivations working at once.

deepasleep | an hour ago

More than one thing be true at the same time.

But the thing that’s driven us to the point where companies are speculatively borrowing and spending trillions of dollars is greed.

Don’t be obtuse.

MagicalSkyMan | an hour ago

More things being true at the same time is quite literally what I said and the opposite of what you said. I bet plenty of people want AI simply because it will make things better overall, not because of some greed.

What makes you think spending trillions is greed?

Legomichan | 3 hours ago

This belief is primary led by politicians and not actual scientists.

AI will face severe bottlenecks soon, which is a good thing.

As for what this means, the last industrial revolution caused a lot of inequality, launched militaristic campaigns across the globe and made the lifes of factory workers a living hell.

It also gave humanity a huge leap forward and ushered an era of abundance which was unimaginable before.

This is no different, we need to talk about the consequences, as a lot of people working in AI are willing to do, and demand solutions, but stopping AI is stupid.

I like to ask this question to see where people stand: "If AI cured all illness in 10 to 15 years, should we let people get I'll so doctors can keep their work?"

I’ll ask that question then: why aren’t AI efforts directed towards curing all illnesses, instead of being relentlessly focused on eradicating music and arts in general?

Still_Benefit_2302 | 14 minutes ago

You're making things up. Do you know who Hinton is?

mmmhtroe | 2 hours ago

Do you have any proof that supports your claim? Seems like if anything ai research is speeding up and researchers are incredibly worried instead

Legomichan | 2 hours ago

Yeah, that's what I'm saying? That actual scientists want to have an actual debate because AI is exceeding our expectations and this have a lot of implications? That's politicians that want to push it no matter what?

The initial statement in the chain is "For some reason the smartest people in the world have all decided" which is not true, and hence the "[smartest people] motivation is simple greed" is false?

mmmhtroe | 2 hours ago

Oh no I totally get that, what I meant is your bottleneck comment, as in I'm not sure whether you are saying that there will be a bottleneck soon? And if so, what indication is there of that?

Existing-Return-5308 | 3 hours ago

Perhaps you dont remember 1999, when there was no TV on a cell phone.

Or 1980, when only the rich had (satellite) phones.

marmot_scholar | 2 hours ago

There’s good reason to be skeptical of the train. Not that progress will cease or is illusory, but we’re already into the sigmoid of LLM advancement, the initial deployment just lacked the capital to train them using the entire available dataset. We’ve now essentially done that, frontier models are trained on as much data as the internet contains and people can only manually label more data at a limited rate.

Consider that the human brain still vastly outperforms these models on task efficiency (number of examples to mastery), as well as having a wider variety of actual learning methods, and then consider that individual people take in more data through the optic nerve as a toddler than frontier models do in their entire training. AI maximalists have retorts to each of those in isolation, but the big picture is important.

The tech IS transformational, but not because of an unbounded increase in our ability to translate data to intelligence. Instead it basically allows us to copy and recombine intelligence, taking away the limitation of every person having to be a generalist who transmits their specialty knowledge slowly.

TLDR, AI will continue to get better, but the “exponential” part is a result of exponential increase in investment. It’s bounded by architecture (inefficient), available data (finite) and physics (processors can only get so small)

Although this could be true, the actual point of AI is self improvement. If that's possible and it's scalable, the prediction is that exponential growth follows. The minutia of how it's done is no longer important because no human will understand it

This, of course, assumes that RSI is scalable and a sufficiently smart AI will always be able to improve itself, which is of course not a given

POEness | an hour ago

Yup. LLMs (not AI, cause it isn't I) has already plateaud. We will see some better user interfaces and a little less hallucination, but this is it. It's a search engine.

Still_Benefit_2302 | 15 minutes ago

Adorable.

snowrazer_ | an hour ago

2026 was literally the biggest year for AI, and the later half was much bigger than the first half of the year. What are you smoking?

ObiWanIsMyDog | 51 minutes ago

I mean.. this shows you literally havent used it. I work a highly technical job that pays over 6 figures and you can give a frontier model any task I do and access to the systems, and it will provide an answer that is complete with shown work verifying the solution / new workflow / answer to a customer email / whatever. If it can't verify a solution it will inform you of tests or data needed to confirm the results. It can do that whole job. Expanded across a team it means I could do the work of my whole team of 6 with one dedicated AI system to assist me.

Thats just reality. Far more than a search engine.

trivetgods | 37 minutes ago

This just says to me that you’re not very good at your job. (Note: I work in FANG and it can barely schedule a meeting without screwing it up.)

M00n_Slippers | an hour ago

These aren't the smartest people, they are the richest people.

smokefoot8 | 3 hours ago

Quantum computing would be vastly less impactful than the others. Quantum resistant encryption is being deployed now, and its other uses are rather niche.

norfizzle | 3 hours ago

I'm looking forward to the digital guitar amps that are actually as good as tube amps. I've suspected for a while that quantum computing will get us there.

monkeyamongmen | 3 hours ago

Which will be great for all those sick jams out in the wasteland.

PerfectEnthusiasm2 | an hour ago

They are not the smartest people in the world.

thus_spake_7ucky | 3 hours ago

Richest does not equal smartest.

beepbeepsheepbot | 59 minutes ago

>the smartest people in the world

No they aren't.

Certain_Mountain_258 | 28 minutes ago

the richest

Wise_Drawing1364 | 3 hours ago

That's because they aren't the smartest people in the world

Brilliant-Potato-218 | 2 hours ago

within the next 10-30 years we'll all be drastically fucked anyway with climate change, regardless of ai developments.

saskinas | an hour ago

They are just using it wrong, should be empowering people and expanding, not replacing people.

Pulpdog94 | 2 hours ago

It won’t be occupied by us normal folk by then…

Talentagentfriend | 2 hours ago

It’s only going to ramp up. 10 years? I wouldn’t be surprised if 5 years or less we live in a dramatically different world.

sshwifty | an hour ago

As someone that works in software, the workers don't have a choice. Adapt AI or be out of a job.

Unlike boomers that somehow managed to keep their jobs while not understanding how to start Excel, newer generations do not have that luxury. AI is here to stay, love it or hate it. It sucks, but that is the truth.

My personal opinion is that AGI won't arrive soon or be what people think it will be. And it won't make things better, it will likely make them much much worse.

dante3590 | 53 minutes ago

You mean greediest people

NorthAtlanticTerror | 51 minutes ago

> a quantum computing breakthrough

A solid reason to believe they may at some point do something somewhat useful would be the greatest breakthrough in the history of quantum computing.

jawdirk | 3 hours ago

I can't help but recall another group of "smart" people telling other people to get onto trains. That's an interesting choice of words.

HedonisticFrog | an hour ago

Except AI capability is wildly overblown. This article is talking about how it's a massive bubble with circular investing that's ready to pop.

senorgraves | 2 hours ago

"For some reason" you mean trying to create a literal utopia? As if that's not a good enough reason? There is literally no more positive goal than trying to create utopia.

You're welcome to the opinion that it isn't realistic or whatever else, but pretending there's no reason is malice

Edit: I'm not going to respond to every individual but it is quite well known that many big figures in tech belong to the e/acc movement. Don't blame me that you're uninformed

Edit 2: people responding as if I endorse any of these ideas: I am not even reading it, and you're projecting

NeedleworkerChoice89 | 2 hours ago

A utopia? Are you serious? What public statement from any of the drug addled, narcissistic AI CEOs makes you think it will be a utopia?

We’re week out from Altman saying we should give him our RAM. The tech oligarchs want their own city-states where they own their workers. We have multiple people saying we either grow the economy, or we all die and the human experiment is over.

Delicious-Finger-593 | 2 hours ago

Whether it's practical is another matter. The reason so many are jumping on this is because they see it progress, that's the reason. The promise of fixing every problem we have, a post-scarcity world, of curing every ailment is a very tantilizing promise. So yeah that is the reason.

EthanielRain | 2 hours ago

Virtually every person in power enriches themselves, often at the cost of others. Literally the same people leading ai have chosen to kill the weakest of us already, for no reason except maybe saving a dollar (ie ending USAID)

Hundreds of children were murdered recently..."it was ai", that was it, zero accountability.

I'm sure they're working towards utopia this time 🙄

SonofHondoBelmondo | 2 hours ago

It is fair to argue that a "reason" that is unserious is comparable to "some reason".

"Why are we making all of these extreme changes very quickly without a clear idea of where this is all going?"

"Because we're going to make everything into the bestest world that has ever gooded! We'll cure all the diseases and all the poor people will not have to work full time and they can spend their time being artists!"

Forgive me if I remain skeptical. The malice I perceive is behind the guarded intentions of these weird tech moguls.

LavisAlex | an hour ago

Utopia? My dude we have enough housing and food in North America right now to make sure everyone gets housed, fed and has Healthcare yet we have consistently choose not to.

Why do you think that the Oligarch class will give up all their power when AGI gets here? Post scarcity would be perfect communism and the end of class.

Interesting-Cod6486 | an hour ago

Utopia for who right? the nazis were building a 1000 year "utopia"

senorgraves | an hour ago

Okay? so then if you said Nazis were doing Holocausts "for some reason", you would be just as ignorant as the person I'm responding to.

HourOpposite527 | an hour ago

If you call the type of techno fascism advocated by the likes of Thiel utopia, sure, then we are heading that way. To pretend that new technologies will be some type of horn of plenty is at best ignorant. For the past 100+ years we had the technology to allow every single person a decent live yet humanity managed to turn this period into absolute misery for the bottom 80%

LurkerFailsLurking | an hour ago

This is so fucking dumb. If Elon Musk and other billionaires gave a shit about creating utopia, we'd already have one. Remember in 2021 when he said he'd give $6.6 billion (2% of his wealth at the time) to the UN's World Food Program if they provided a public accounting of how it would be spent to end world hunger, so they did, and then he didn't give them a dime? And then led the DOGE team in ending USAID, which effectively cut global food programs by billions?

ResistLife | 42 minutes ago

I have a bridge to sell you if you think their goal is utopia of any kind beyond maybe just for themselves

teamrunner | 2 hours ago

Rage bait.

WeekendAtMadoffs | 6 hours ago

They never had a problem when American companies did regular outsourcing to india...

The cat is out of the bag. Companies want cheap outsourced labor powered by AI it's too late to go back!!!

CompetitionHot1666 | 6 hours ago

Not too late but getting close.

These companies are short-sighted in the sense that the valuation they believe they deserve is predicated on displacing a massive amount of human capital.

But the issue is that by doing so, they’re also displacing a massive portion of the overall consumer base that is necessary to sustain a healthy economy.

Until they can prove that net jobs lost will be less than net jobs (and economic productivity gained), it will always be a losing proposition.

And given the recent election results, time is not on their side to make that argument.

Magificent_Gradient | 5 hours ago

Expel too many humans and their knowledge from the workforce and AI becomes a train that coasts to a stop in one to three years. AI is latent and follows humans, not the other way around no matter what the companies who are about to IPO and need bagholders tell us.

The gap in experience and knowledge will take years after that to get started again.

CompetitionHot1666 | 5 hours ago

Agreed, and between that and “model collapse” (where AI trains itself on AI slop), there’s certainly a limited growth potential. At least for now.

w0zify | 5 hours ago

I also can't help but also wonder how cheap AI powered labor is going to be in the end.

Sure, right now tokens for Anthropic are cheap enough as they try and obtain mass adoption. Will it stay that way once they have to answer to shareholders though?

It really feels like AWS all over again. Companies were sold big performance gains and lower costs by moving their servers to the cloud. Then once they finished the transition, they were blind-sighted by how expensive it ended up being.

CompetitionHot1666 | 5 hours ago

This comment is 100% on point.

Tokens are currently massively subsidized while the battle for AI dominance unfolds.

What happens two years from now when the “winners” have been determined?

solomons-mom | 5 hours ago

India's over-supply of human capital is an issue too. In 1980, Indians had 25 million babies --more than the total population of Canada or Australia that year. In the next two decades, India created more new people than the US had in total. At the peak, 2001, India pushed out 29 million new people.

About 35 million ambitious Indians emmigrated, and the diaspora remits about $150b annually. As jobs dry up, many are not going to be able to stay where they went.

CompetitionHot1666 | 5 hours ago

I hear that, but what specifically are you suggesting?

solomons-mom | 4 hours ago

My best guess is the human capital situation will be pretty awful in India for young adults. Since the median age in India is 29, there are more teens and young adults in India that there are total people in the US. That is a lot youthful energy hoping to improve their lot in life. Will they be peaceful like the recent Cockroach protests?

In the US, my best guess is the US upper-middle income people will take a hit and their children will adjust to a changing standards, as has always happened.

dually | 5 hours ago

Demand is a given because humans have unlimited wants and needs.

CompetitionHot1666 | 5 hours ago

Agreed. But when the masses have fewer means to meet their unlimited wants, where do we end up?

dually | 2 hours ago

we end up with lower interest rates

PlanetCosmoX | 5 hours ago

There’s always Canada. The world’s slowest Western country at adopting changes in computers.

They’re still trying to adapt to the computer itself.

Bubble_and_squeak | 5 hours ago

I hate to break it to you, but one of the biggest companies advocating for an entirely agentic economy is Shopify, a Canadian tech company.

The-Phantom-Blot | 5 minutes ago

Now workers in developed economies have to compete with Artificial Intelligence managed by Actual Indians. It's AI^(2).

grok-it-all | 5 hours ago

Hey! That's capitalism, baby! It's good for America!

vid_icarus | 4 hours ago

lol we are just getting started, my friends. Everything so far has been the trailer for the upcoming shitstorm AI is going to create in the economy. We ain’t seen nothing yet.

jash9 | 4 hours ago

What should we do when we see a source to a website we've never of heard before?

This article says economists are horrified but only cites a single economist and she doesn't say she's horrified in the article but expresses some concerns.

A single economist is concerned, says fake news website you've never heard of.

Well, to the top of reddit then.

muffledvoice | 3 hours ago

Well, that single economist is the managing director of the IMF, so there’s that.

TieTheStick | 4 hours ago

When staid financially organizations like the IMF sound the alarm, the smart money is already getting out.

I wish I had a stack of cash I could gamble on shorts with.

iamwayycoolerthanyou | 4 hours ago

"All it would take is for a “sudden drop in investment confidence and withdrawal from the AI field” to send markets tumbling, Georgieva explained."

This is already happening. Nvidia's backstopping is probably going to end. Investor confidence is dropping as the selloff continues. The moats apparently don't exist. Bond yields going up. Enterprise not seeing performance improvements and are identifying real IP and liability risks. Not to mention everybody is thoroughly freaked out and it has already caused a significant amount of economic destruction in a multitude of areas.

Mammalian_Routines | 30 minutes ago

Deception comes from the most primitive survival sections of your brain.

Pretending it's progressive intelligence is a.bottleneck that will create more and more dangerous humans.

PloTwist2001 | 4 hours ago

Well this comment must be one hundred and forty characters which is a bit inconvenient when I really just wanted to say that,  I’m sure it’ll all work itself out.

lilyp727 | 4 hours ago

the imf's own numbers show why it matters, ai-related investment added about half a percentage point to US growth in 2025. so a lot of the growth people see is spending on data centers and chips, and if the returns disappoint, that support goes away fast.

OldDragonNewTricks | 9 minutes ago

And it will happen next year and the people will blame Democrats and the cycle starts over where the country elects Republicans to power again.

thepinkdread2026 | 7 minutes ago

It feels sort of intellectually lazy to me to just take up a bunch of space for data vs redesigning the whole thing altogether to where they don’t need data centers. Like why does everything these people do have to be lazy and just backwards. Like I get it, it’s probably easier to convince a stupid politician that Ai is like the next big thing vs truly innovating. It takes effort, creativity, time. I don’t know it just feel s lazy to me.

MrOphicer | 2 hours ago

Can all the proponents of UBI explain how it will work and be maintained long term, considering everything we know about governments now? So far, I haven't heard a single reason to sugest it will work.

No-Permit-9331 | 4 hours ago

There has got to be an adult in the house to deal with this AI state. This is the set up for the digital era. The government will be controlling everyone’s bank accounts and “food credits”. Do something they don’t like, your accounts will get wiped out. They can and will make you “not exist” anymore on paper. Our entire lives will be controlled. FYI-they wanted this rolled out for 2030.

Legal-Koala-5590 | 3 hours ago

Got any sources on this?

5partacus69 | 2 hours ago

Well... the question then becomes, what are we going to do about it? If the answer is nothing (which it probably is), then we deserve whatever we get