400 definitely feels like a lot of data centers when just 52 in Alberta would be similar to Michigan.
Google tells me Michigan uses 11–12 GW on average, and summer peaks reach roughly 22–24 GW.
In Alberta, companies have requested ~19.6 GW for only ~52 new datacenter's. O’Leary’s proposed off-grid Wonder Valley campus is pitched at 7.5 GW of generation on its own.
The GDP of Michigan is $734B. The combined cloud computing revenues of Google, AWS, and Microsoft (which make up a large fraction of this datacenter work, though not all of it) are $290B. So yes, we should expect the power usage of these things to be in the same order of magnitude.
No, I wouldn't expect that at all. Google, AWS, and MSFT do not care about helping society. They do not care about making sure children get a good public education. They do not care that workers are treated with dignity. These three can't even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America. They just care about making money.
The state of Michigan provides more value for humanity than those three companies easily.
In fact we should explicitly tax those companies to provide free public school lunches, universal childcare, and universal college/secondary/vocational training programs.
For fun, look at what these three companies are explicitly paying for their data center build out and look at the cost of what it would cost to provide every American school child free lunch.
These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.
Ah, the truth emerges. The smokescreen about taxes, appeal to emotion, etc are all just rooted in that you want to seize and destroy companies you personally disagree of.
we already tax these companies besides that the US spends on average around $17,500 annually per student among the highest in the world. How much more would we have to spend to provide free lunches for everyone? is there any guarantees that if we increased taxes we would actually solve these issues?
> US spends on average around $17,500 annually per student among the highest in the world
Services cost more in the US, so of course it will be more expensive to educate students in America.
> How much more would we have to spend to provide free lunches for everyone?
Nine U.S. states already provide free school lunch (and breakfast) to all public elementary, middle, and high school students regardless of family income. Some quick math shows it would cost Michigan ~$500M/year to provide free lunch to all elementary school students (assuming all students take advantage of the free lunch, so it might be lower).
> is there any guarantees that if we increased taxes we would actually solve these issues?
Nothing in life is ever guaranteed, but the money is definitely there and with the right legislators it could easily be done.
We already tax differently based on tax brackets. I don't see why a few new ones can't be created. I shouldn't be taxed the same as Musk, and Bob's Landscaping shouldn't be taxed the same as Amazon.
Why calculate the cloud computing revenues and not the economic activity facilitated by the existence of cloud computing? You're measuring multiple orders of economic activity by using Michigan GDP but only one order using google, aws, and msft cloud revs.
We're also not counting the petroleum powering the cars everyone is driving and the natural gas used as the primary source of building heat.
Electricity is useful for so many things, but it's not needed in huge amounts in an ordinary Michigander's life today. I wish they'd switch to EVs and heat pumps though, but electric rates make the latter cost more (EVs are cheaper).
Michigan should install heat pumps. However it gets cold enough that a heat pump will not work for several days every winter (and even more nights), so while heat pumps will help they still need something and natural gas ends up our best bet...
Average is useless number for this discussion. One night ever - even it is is one in 100 years - of less than -25F is serious. That will happen at least once in the next 20 years - I don't know when, but it will.
Heat pumps are nearly always backed by resistive heaters for exactly that reason. Resistive heaters are extremely cheap in terms of capital (they're basically just a medium resistance piece of metal) but use more electricity than heat pumps. Which is expensive if you were trying to use them every day, but kind of a shrug if you only have to use them one day out of a decade.
there’s a good reason for this and it relates to ireland and US corporate tax laws. Basically the rules changed for corps to move hqs there , and instead they needed to prove “economic substance” in ireland to establish EU hqs, which for tech companies meant data center builds.
Always good to see more hard data on this topic! I’d be curious to play with their dataset. I toyed around with doing some data center research a couple months ago. My vision was to compare data center counts and population densities near data centers built before and after the dawn of LLMs. And do some other stuff. But I had trouble finding reliable data on where data centers are located (some lists exist, but they’re not perfect, so I was doing manual validation) and when they were built (permitting and whatnot provided decent bounds). In the end, there was too much manual work. I didn’t feel like doing that all weekend for several weekends in a row, and I have a day job to worry about during the week. Though this might be motivation to look back at this and do some automation…
Regarding the actual result, I’m appalled but not surprised (though obviously it’s good to have concrete data). We environmentalists having been raising this concern for at least a year. More people are catching on - this seems to have helped the Blue Wave this election season. But a lot of tech bros still don’t get it, particularly here on HN. Maybe this will help change some minds.
I work in AI, but this is obviously not sustainable unless renewable energy is used.
But according to AI Multiple:
Globally, only about 22% to 27% of the actual electricity consumed by AI and data center facilities comes directly from renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and hydropower.
They recommend the obvious, "Prioritize inference efficiency over training efficiency" since most power is used for inference now.
They reference research that shows that over 80% of AI compute is now used for inference.
Most of those efficiency gains came from shrinking transistors, and we've already hit the physical limits of Moore's Law with atomic-scale transistors.
That's not to say there aren't more efficiency gains to be found, but the low-hanging fruit has been thoroughly picked.
"Work in AI" is one of those vague claims that could mean you work in a field relevant to the topic at hand, infrastructure, or that you simply use AI a lot at work. If your role was the more relevant one, one'd expect you to claim it specifically.
Your point is so basic it requires no expertise to reason about, however, anyways.
Datacenter power consumption wouldn't be an issue if that power came from local renewable sources.
Unfortunately, the gas-fired turbines that are being built now feel like quite a regression. Or the additional load on the public grid, which in some places barely has any spare capacity left.
It's not an unsolvable problem though. A sustainable hyperscale datacenter can be built. There just isn't enough of an incentive as long as buying gas and polluting the air is cheaper (because the cost of both is externalized on society)
>Datacenter power consumption wouldn't be an issue if...
...they didn't use them for AI.
The panic over DC's has nothing to do with DC's. It's entirely about fear around AI and knee-capping AI progress. It's like when conservatives suddenly care about native grasshoppers when they find out a solar farm is gonna be put on the land. You're totally whiffing if you think they actually care about the grasshoppers.
That may be a factor, but there are other, very rational complaints. They are enormous, noisy eyesores. They result in raised electrical rates for anyone living in the region. They are another user of water in areas that may already be stressed for water. They are also setting us up for massive e-waste in 5 years. Those are real problems that you can't just hand-wave away.
You can't hand wave them away, but you can dissolve them with even a modicum of grounded research. All industry is big noisy buildings, DCs aren't particularly loud either (and don't need to be), electric rates come mostly from distribution costs, not generation costs, DCs use about 2 golf courses of water a year, so ask the farmers to water one less day (and save the ag runoff from hitting the streams too), inference is currently being served on 5 year old hardware and 10 year old cards are even hard and expensive to get.
And last of all, it's like 3 datacenters that keep coming up as "DCs are bad" despite their being thousands in the country (and hundreds of hyperscale sized ones).
The whole thing is public panic rather than academic honesty.
You are telling me I'm wrong, not because any of these impacts are wrong, but that they shouldn't count. That's hand-waving.
> All industry is big noisy buildings
But they produce jobs, goods, and social value. If people don't see the value of AI (or even see it as a job risk), then why would they be inclined to put up with the noise and land use?
> electric rates come mostly from distribution costs
Which are costs that result in higher residential rates. Go ask someone who recently looked at their ComEd bill.
> DCs use about 2 golf courses of water a year, so ask the farmers to water one less day
Except you can't ask farmers to do that. We need food, and water is finite. That's not anti-AI panic, it's a cold fact.
Gas has the advantage of being locally available, without having to tax the grid even more, which is not even keeping up a little bit at this point, and has a decade+ build out backlog. Gas is just very convenient, compared to other options. And that is the real problem, because there is no way to fix this quickly.
> A sustainable hyperscale datacenter can be built. There just isn't enough of an incentive as long as buying gas and polluting the air is cheaper (because the cost of both is externalized on society)
This is a misidentification of the problem. Generating power on-site with turbines is an alternative to bidding up the price of grid power that raises the short-term price of electricity for other consumers. If they're doing one they're not doing the other.
Moreover, small gas turbines and converted aircraft engines aren't actually the thing with the lowest long-term operating costs, they're just the thing you can plop out of a truck and turn on right away.
Which means the best thing might be to use turbines temporarily to avoid raising short-term electricity prices for ordinary people, but only for the time it takes to build some new non-carbon generation to replace them.
And the latter is what everybody really wants, because renewable energy isn't just cleaner, it's cheaper. It just takes longer to deploy, not least because the permits cost more and take longer than they ought to. Which means that if you really want to get rid of the turbines and the high electric bills, what you need is to make it faster to build new non-carbon generation.
And how much would we expect that number to be? I suspect nearly everyone is sufficiently ignorant about both datacenters and Michigan that they have no clue.
I can't read the article itself (or maybe listen to it? Hard to see what this page actually is). I read Harvard's summary [1] of the article. The preprint is also available [2]
One thing to note is that the framing "Just 400 US Data Centers" makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 "Hyperscale Data Centers" and evaluated them.
The framing is technically correct (since there exist non-hyperscale data centers) but is clearly intended to be deceptive.
There's plenty of other industries that use lots of power as well, it seems some journalist managed to find a state that enough people see as 'big' without enough of those industries to make the comparison look 'fair'.
>The team then modeled these facilities’ energy use in a variety of scenarios and calculated the energy mix of the regional grids to estimate individual facilities’ carbon emissions.
So is it just made up? The facilities energy usage that is?
If the framing were "top 400 datacenters use more electricity than Michigan" would you still call it deceptive?
The point still stands that 400 of the gazillion datacenters in the US use more energy than the entire population and industry of an entire state. That's a ridiculous amount of energy to pour into any number of datacenters.
Okay, what should the number be? If it was the top 800 instead of top 400 would you have no problem with it? Or should the total energy consumption of all data centers always be less than michigan's energy consumption?
No it isn't. Actually, it's way too little energy. See how easy it is to make random claims? Probably a good thing energy allocation isn't based on random reddi- I mean HN user vibes.
> That's a ridiculous amount of energy to pour into any number of datacenters.
Is it? What are you comparing it to? Someone upthread compared it to the top 10 steel plants and it turns out they use more energy than all the data centers.
This is like the water discussion where people discuss absolute values of consumption for huge scale industries and then put that in front of people that have no context to generate outrage.
>"Just 400 US Data Centers" makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 "Hyperscale Data Centers" and evaluated them.
I would assume you wouldn't select the 400 smallest data centers and 400 random data centers would be weird to write an article about, so I defaulted to thinking the 400 largest(with available data). Was this assumption wrong? Where is the deception? Is it Michigan?
Here's how it was misleading to me personally: when I heard "Just 400 Data Centers" I interpreted that initially as there are lots of data centers, say, 1000, but it only takes 400 of them to equal the power of Michigan, so wow! the full set of data centers must use an enormous amount of power!
But now this comment clarified that the initial study looked at all the hyperscalars in the US (403). So it wasn't like it was choosing a subset to equal a known amount of power, it was putting all the power into context. If the headline were instead: "All the Hyperscalar Data Centers in the US equal the power usage of Michigan" it doesn't kind of gesture at a much larger amount of power being used.
Again why would you assume 400 random data centers? The relationship between the data centers and Michigan is power use. So did they pick the data centers without consideration to power usage? Why would you assume that?
No one's talking about a random selection. We're talking about what percentage of total data center power is consumed by that 400, and the percentage is a lot higher than the article with the title "just" indicates. That's the point.
Taking the headline at face value, you might imagine that there are 4,000 data centers and they chose the biggest 400 and said that they consume as much power as Michigan. That would lead you to believe that all the data centers would consume multiple states worth of power because that's only 10% of them.
But that's not the case. This isn't 10% of all data center electrical usage. It's more like 90% of all data center electrical usage (or something). That's the distinction that's being discussed.
>We're talking about what percentage of total data center power is consumed by that 400, and the percentage is a lot higher than the article with the title "just" indicates. That's the point.
When did we start doing that. and what do you mean by a lot higher? Two Michigans? Is that deceptive?
>That would lead you to believe that all the data centers would consume multiple states worth of power because that's only 10% of them.
Why would someone assume that? Cause the 400 data centers are just a random sampling?
> what do you mean by a lot higher? Two Michigans? Is that deceptive?
I said the percentage was a lot higher. I'm measuring percentage using integers between 0 and 100. I'm not sure how you measure percentage in "Michigans". There's a unit error there.
> Why would someone assume that?
They would assume the percentage is small because of the use of the word "just". Again, the 400 was not a random sampling.
> Is it?
Yes, you responded to a comment that was focusing on that.
"One thing to note is that the framing "Just 400 US Data Centers" makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 "Hyperscale Data Centers" and evaluated them."
That's the current topic. You seem to be working pretty hard to not get the point that's being made.
>the data did not allow them to differentiate between power used for general-purpose versus AI-specialized operations at each HDC
That seems like an important distinction. Many people reading the headline will immediately assume this refers to AIDCs only, especially those who never heard of or rarely thought of data centers until recently.
>HDC electricity demand corresponded to approximately 1.8% of total U.S. electricity consumption
I don't see a problem with this. The only real issue is in cases of added load to local grids increasing costs. It is useful to look at historical electricity production in the US.[0] If anything the period of stagnation starting from 2007 is an anomaly. That stagnation was probably caused by the GFC, de-industrialization, improved energy efficiency and a decreased (but still positive) population growth rate. I don't think anyone protested the 25% increase in electricity production from 1990 to 2000, for example.
By the way, your first link appears to be cut off, full link is this:
At this point I am not even sure why should we continue to read anything from mainstream media. Other than some sort of civil duty to continue correct them or bring it context / communities notes.
I am also wondering why Datecenter and AI is now becoming the new Anti-Christ / Nuclear Reactor.
I think this perspective lacks nuance. If you are so pro-data center you don’t understand why it there is so much fear around them, start there. You don’t need to change your mind, but it is important to understand other perspectives. Otherwise you are going to stay in your own bubble and continue to avoid news that aligns with your perspective.
The demand creates incentive for people to add capacity to the grid. IMO what's really needed is a combination of capital to invest into the grid plus incentives for the public to use less. (Eg: allow DCs to pay marginal bids / $ to those who voluntarily reduce their usage. Allow a DC to pay me, say, $10 to free up $10 worth of marginal electricity usage, they effectively pay double the market rate and I have a benefit from DCs)
These topics are always contentious because you have a huge portion of HN whose livelihood depends on AI slop producing data centers, so they will refuse to recognize any negative externalities, or somehow say our environmental degradation is worth the cost, or simply hand wave it.
Mildly misleading statement, as _some_ of the usage of those datacenters experience _come_ from Michigan, so that should be factored into the calculations.
Why aren't they pushing hard on modular nuclear power plants people have been talking about since basically forever? Or maybe require to have a solar plant next to large data centers?
Wired headline: "Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan"
Wired lede:
> Just 400 hyperscale data centers connected in the US used as much electricity as the state of Michigan in a single year, new Harvard research has found.
Harvard press release [0]:
> The study found that these HDCs, depending on how hard they were running, together used between 68 and 99 terawatt-hours of electricity—with the upper estimate approaching the amount some states, such as Indiana, Michigan, and Tennessee, use in a year.
- Find out how many datacenters are out there and how much electricity they consume
- Find the biggest US state consuming less electricity than that
- Bingo! The headline!
smallerize | 5 hours ago
jakwnd | 5 hours ago
Every google now comes with an AI answer too.
phoronixrly | 4 hours ago
luckydata | 5 hours ago
honeycrispy | 5 hours ago
What do you mean "just"?
rwz | 4 hours ago
qwe----3 | 4 hours ago
galleywest200 | 4 hours ago
Kindlesome | 32 minutes ago
lgunsch | 4 hours ago
Google tells me Michigan uses 11–12 GW on average, and summer peaks reach roughly 22–24 GW.
In Alberta, companies have requested ~19.6 GW for only ~52 new datacenter's. O’Leary’s proposed off-grid Wonder Valley campus is pitched at 7.5 GW of generation on its own.
bradleybuda | 5 hours ago
shimman | 5 hours ago
The state of Michigan provides more value for humanity than those three companies easily.
In fact we should explicitly tax those companies to provide free public school lunches, universal childcare, and universal college/secondary/vocational training programs.
For fun, look at what these three companies are explicitly paying for their data center build out and look at the cost of what it would cost to provide every American school child free lunch.
These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.
richwater | 5 hours ago
Ah, the truth emerges. The smokescreen about taxes, appeal to emotion, etc are all just rooted in that you want to seize and destroy companies you personally disagree of.
bluedino | 5 hours ago
Are you talking about the auto companies?
jayGlow | 4 hours ago
viklove | 2 hours ago
Not enough.
> US spends on average around $17,500 annually per student among the highest in the world
Services cost more in the US, so of course it will be more expensive to educate students in America.
> How much more would we have to spend to provide free lunches for everyone?
Nine U.S. states already provide free school lunch (and breakfast) to all public elementary, middle, and high school students regardless of family income. Some quick math shows it would cost Michigan ~$500M/year to provide free lunch to all elementary school students (assuming all students take advantage of the free lunch, so it might be lower).
> is there any guarantees that if we increased taxes we would actually solve these issues?
Nothing in life is ever guaranteed, but the money is definitely there and with the right legislators it could easily be done.
fooqux | an hour ago
qeternity | an hour ago
Oh, this again. Why should we tax these companies differently to any other?
fooqux | an hour ago
qeternity | an hour ago
They are some of the biggest employers in the US...what are you on about?
>They just care about making money.
Yes, that is literally the purpose of a company. It's like saying "employees only care about their paycheck".
>These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.
Ah right. Having a normal one today are we?
missedthecue | 5 hours ago
coryrc | 4 hours ago
Electricity is useful for so many things, but it's not needed in huge amounts in an ordinary Michigander's life today. I wish they'd switch to EVs and heat pumps though, but electric rates make the latter cost more (EVs are cheaper).
bluGill | 4 hours ago
keybrd-intrrpt | 3 hours ago
This says they are still viable:
https://michiganhvacauthority.com/michigan-heat-pump-conside...
Modern residential cold-climate air-source heat pumps can operate down to roughly −15°F to −25°F, depending on the model.
Michigan had an average of 4.6 nights per year reaching 0°F or below during 2020–2024
bluGill | 3 hours ago
AnthonyMouse | 2 hours ago
djeastm | 5 hours ago
https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-dcmec/dat...
cjaackie | 5 hours ago
Silamoth | 5 hours ago
Regarding the actual result, I’m appalled but not surprised (though obviously it’s good to have concrete data). We environmentalists having been raising this concern for at least a year. More people are catching on - this seems to have helped the Blue Wave this election season. But a lot of tech bros still don’t get it, particularly here on HN. Maybe this will help change some minds.
Goodliff | 5 hours ago
But according to AI Multiple:
Globally, only about 22% to 27% of the actual electricity consumed by AI and data center facilities comes directly from renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and hydropower.
They recommend the obvious, "Prioritize inference efficiency over training efficiency" since most power is used for inference now.
They reference research that shows that over 80% of AI compute is now used for inference.
https://aimultiple.com/ai-energy-consumption
j45 | 5 hours ago
I don't see that referenced anywhere often enough in the AI datacenter swirling.
It's like saying mobile phones from the 1990's would never become more efficient, nor software, nor chips.
scottLobster | 5 hours ago
That's not to say there aren't more efficiency gains to be found, but the low-hanging fruit has been thoroughly picked.
mw888 | 5 hours ago
Your point is so basic it requires no expertise to reason about, however, anyways.
nsoam | 4 hours ago
j45 | 5 hours ago
AuthAuth | 5 hours ago
renehsz | 5 hours ago
Unfortunately, the gas-fired turbines that are being built now feel like quite a regression. Or the additional load on the public grid, which in some places barely has any spare capacity left.
It's not an unsolvable problem though. A sustainable hyperscale datacenter can be built. There just isn't enough of an incentive as long as buying gas and polluting the air is cheaper (because the cost of both is externalized on society)
WarmWash | 4 hours ago
...they didn't use them for AI.
The panic over DC's has nothing to do with DC's. It's entirely about fear around AI and knee-capping AI progress. It's like when conservatives suddenly care about native grasshoppers when they find out a solar farm is gonna be put on the land. You're totally whiffing if you think they actually care about the grasshoppers.
dweinus | 3 hours ago
WarmWash | 2 hours ago
And last of all, it's like 3 datacenters that keep coming up as "DCs are bad" despite their being thousands in the country (and hundreds of hyperscale sized ones).
The whole thing is public panic rather than academic honesty.
dweinus | an hour ago
> All industry is big noisy buildings
But they produce jobs, goods, and social value. If people don't see the value of AI (or even see it as a job risk), then why would they be inclined to put up with the noise and land use?
> electric rates come mostly from distribution costs
Which are costs that result in higher residential rates. Go ask someone who recently looked at their ComEd bill.
> DCs use about 2 golf courses of water a year, so ask the farmers to water one less day
Except you can't ask farmers to do that. We need food, and water is finite. That's not anti-AI panic, it's a cold fact.
WarmWash | 39 minutes ago
DCs aren't distribution networks. They pay for their own grid connection.
We don't need to farm in water stricken areas to feed people. Protests against this long predate DCs.
Again, don't fall for the hysteria.
hrncn | 3 hours ago
AnthonyMouse | 2 hours ago
This is a misidentification of the problem. Generating power on-site with turbines is an alternative to bidding up the price of grid power that raises the short-term price of electricity for other consumers. If they're doing one they're not doing the other.
Moreover, small gas turbines and converted aircraft engines aren't actually the thing with the lowest long-term operating costs, they're just the thing you can plop out of a truck and turn on right away.
Which means the best thing might be to use turbines temporarily to avoid raising short-term electricity prices for ordinary people, but only for the time it takes to build some new non-carbon generation to replace them.
And the latter is what everybody really wants, because renewable energy isn't just cleaner, it's cheaper. It just takes longer to deploy, not least because the permits cost more and take longer than they ought to. Which means that if you really want to get rid of the turbines and the high electric bills, what you need is to make it faster to build new non-carbon generation.
spicyusername | 4 hours ago
Useless rage baiting.
andrewla | 4 hours ago
One thing to note is that the framing "Just 400 US Data Centers" makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 "Hyperscale Data Centers" and evaluated them.
The framing is technically correct (since there exist non-hyperscale data centers) but is clearly intended to be deceptive.
[1] https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/hyperscale-data-centers-energy...
[2] https://arxiv.org/pdf/2606.05420
qwe----3 | 4 hours ago
peterabbitcook | 4 hours ago
Step 2: find “thing 2” with property x closest to (result of Step 1) && x <= (result of Step 1)
Step 3: Write clickbait.
Optional: Publish some permutations - resample list of “thing 1” to yield min(number of “thing 1”) matching “thing 2” for each “thing 2” in list
ApolloFortyNine | 4 hours ago
>The team then modeled these facilities’ energy use in a variety of scenarios and calculated the energy mix of the regional grids to estimate individual facilities’ carbon emissions.
So is it just made up? The facilities energy usage that is?
peterabbitcook | 3 hours ago
Downstream re-reporting (Wired, NYT, etc) mixes these interchangeably, or picks 1 and treats it the same as the other.
jeff_carr | 3 hours ago
Total Primary Energy (Coal + Gas + Grid) ~1,050 – 1,150 TWh/yr (~120–130 GW avg)
Electrical Power Only ~105 – 150 TWh/yr (~12–17 GW avg)
Top ~400 Hyperscale Data Centers
Electrical Power Only ~68 – 99 TWh/yr (~7.8–11.3 GW avg)
whateveracct | an hour ago
AI on the other hand..
unrented7977 | 4 hours ago
The point still stands that 400 of the gazillion datacenters in the US use more energy than the entire population and industry of an entire state. That's a ridiculous amount of energy to pour into any number of datacenters.
Jtarii | 3 hours ago
wwwtyro | 3 hours ago
Why? Your objection sounds arbitrary.
ion_trapper | 3 hours ago
dpoloncsak | 3 hours ago
Its citing Hyperscaler Data Centers as 1.8% of the US's power usage, right? Sounds like Michigan just doesn't use that much power.
rpdillon | 2 hours ago
Is it? What are you comparing it to? Someone upthread compared it to the top 10 steel plants and it turns out they use more energy than all the data centers.
This is like the water discussion where people discuss absolute values of consumption for huge scale industries and then put that in front of people that have no context to generate outrage.
undersuit | 4 hours ago
I would assume you wouldn't select the 400 smallest data centers and 400 random data centers would be weird to write an article about, so I defaulted to thinking the 400 largest(with available data). Was this assumption wrong? Where is the deception? Is it Michigan?
losvedir | 3 hours ago
Here's how it was misleading to me personally: when I heard "Just 400 Data Centers" I interpreted that initially as there are lots of data centers, say, 1000, but it only takes 400 of them to equal the power of Michigan, so wow! the full set of data centers must use an enormous amount of power!
But now this comment clarified that the initial study looked at all the hyperscalars in the US (403). So it wasn't like it was choosing a subset to equal a known amount of power, it was putting all the power into context. If the headline were instead: "All the Hyperscalar Data Centers in the US equal the power usage of Michigan" it doesn't kind of gesture at a much larger amount of power being used.
undersuit | 2 hours ago
rpdillon | 2 hours ago
Taking the headline at face value, you might imagine that there are 4,000 data centers and they chose the biggest 400 and said that they consume as much power as Michigan. That would lead you to believe that all the data centers would consume multiple states worth of power because that's only 10% of them.
But that's not the case. This isn't 10% of all data center electrical usage. It's more like 90% of all data center electrical usage (or something). That's the distinction that's being discussed.
undersuit | 2 hours ago
When did we start doing that. and what do you mean by a lot higher? Two Michigans? Is that deceptive?
>That would lead you to believe that all the data centers would consume multiple states worth of power because that's only 10% of them.
Why would someone assume that? Cause the 400 data centers are just a random sampling?
>That's the distinction that's being discussed.
Is it?
rpdillon | an hour ago
I said the percentage was a lot higher. I'm measuring percentage using integers between 0 and 100. I'm not sure how you measure percentage in "Michigans". There's a unit error there.
> Why would someone assume that?
They would assume the percentage is small because of the use of the word "just". Again, the 400 was not a random sampling.
> Is it?
Yes, you responded to a comment that was focusing on that.
"One thing to note is that the framing "Just 400 US Data Centers" makes it seem like 400 out of the gazillion data centers use this much electricity, but the original research seems to be that they found exactly 403 "Hyperscale Data Centers" and evaluated them."
That's the current topic. You seem to be working pretty hard to not get the point that's being made.
undersuit | an hour ago
I replied to them because they said it was deceptive and no one can give me a concrete example of this deception.
kingcauchy | 3 hours ago
[OP] Betelbuddy | 3 hours ago
fngjdflmdflg | 3 hours ago
>the data did not allow them to differentiate between power used for general-purpose versus AI-specialized operations at each HDC
That seems like an important distinction. Many people reading the headline will immediately assume this refers to AIDCs only, especially those who never heard of or rarely thought of data centers until recently.
>HDC electricity demand corresponded to approximately 1.8% of total U.S. electricity consumption
I don't see a problem with this. The only real issue is in cases of added load to local grids increasing costs. It is useful to look at historical electricity production in the US.[0] If anything the period of stagnation starting from 2007 is an anomaly. That stagnation was probably caused by the GFC, de-industrialization, improved energy efficiency and a decreased (but still positive) population growth rate. I don't think anyone protested the 25% increase in electricity production from 1990 to 2000, for example.
By the way, your first link appears to be cut off, full link is this:
Hyperscale data centers’ energy consumption, carbon emissions newly estimated by researchers https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/hyperscale-data-centers-energy...
[0] https://www.eia.gov/totalenergy/data/browser/?tbl=T07.01#/?f...
ksec | 2 hours ago
At this point I am not even sure why should we continue to read anything from mainstream media. Other than some sort of civil duty to continue correct them or bring it context / communities notes.
I am also wondering why Datecenter and AI is now becoming the new Anti-Christ / Nuclear Reactor.
wyre | 2 hours ago
maerF0x0 | 4 hours ago
ck2 | 4 hours ago
even the expensive hardware has to be replaced every few years
mvkel | 4 hours ago
"Just the McDonaldses in New York City use more electricity than North Dakota"
barbazoo | 3 hours ago
sciencesama | 4 hours ago
MOARDONGZPLZ | 4 hours ago
mannyv | 4 hours ago
Why Michigan instead of Maryland, Delaware, or Connecticut? Give the smaller states a chance!
EcommerceFlow | 4 hours ago
djha-skin | 3 hours ago
Jach | 3 hours ago
vjvjvjvjghv | 3 hours ago
boothby | 3 hours ago
teamonkey | 3 hours ago
Lots of brochures have been printed though.
ibn_khaldun | 3 hours ago
Wired lede:
> Just 400 hyperscale data centers connected in the US used as much electricity as the state of Michigan in a single year, new Harvard research has found.
Harvard press release [0]:
> The study found that these HDCs, depending on how hard they were running, together used between 68 and 99 terawatt-hours of electricity—with the upper estimate approaching the amount some states, such as Indiana, Michigan, and Tennessee, use in a year.
Wired is playing in your faces.
[0] https://hsph.harvard.edu/news/hyperscale-data-centers-energy...
dpoloncsak | 3 hours ago
> HDC electricity demand was approximately 82 TWh, corresponding to about 1.8% of total US electricity consumption
(https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-026-01985-7)
Sounds like Michigan just doesn't use much power...
ibn_khaldun | 2 hours ago
regnull | 2 hours ago