How to Make the Ink Used to Write Hamlet and the Declaration of Independence

52 points by ohjeez 5 hours ago on hackernews | 22 comments

sevensor | 4 hours ago

TFA is quite clear about this, but don't go putting homemade iron gall ink in a fountain pen. That being said, there are some very nice commercially available iron gall inks that will destroy neither pen nor paper. Another quite nice durable ink, also mentioned, is carbon black. It stays blacker, but it will be much harder to recover your writing if your notebook should happen to be carbonized and buried under pyroclastic flows.

peri-cl | 4 hours ago

I shall endeavor to keep my handwritten notebooks away from incompatible pyroclastic flows.

MonkeyClub | 3 hours ago

Sometimes the volcano just hunts you down; in those cases, iron gall is the way to go.

Otherwise you can go wild with carbon, of course.

Steve44 | 3 hours ago

I get most of my inks from a family business based in Liverpool, UK, called Diamine.

They do an Archival Registrars Ink which I believe is iron gall. Not mentioned on their website, but resellers say :-

> Diamine Registrar`s Ink is a permanent archival blue-black iron gall ink which can be used in fountain pens. > > Do not use in valuable pens and regular flushing out is recommended . It is acidic, which could damage steel nibs. Use with caution, and at your own risk

https://www.diamineinks.co.uk/collections/diamine-archival-r...

Isamu | 2 hours ago

Thank you for this link, I am interested in how this can be an archival ink when it is acidic. That’s a problem with historical inks, which eat away at the paper over time.

Steve44 | an hour ago

Although I bought a bottle of their registrars ink a few years ago I've not actually used it yet and can't comment on the acidity etc. It is a proper registrars ink though and is used throughout the country for official documents.

I regularly use several of their standard inks in various fountain pens. I have one colour which I love and use all the time, I always sign cards & hand write letters in it and it's sort of become Steve44's "signature" colour; the others are just general jotting and playful inks.

I use Diamine as not only do I like their inks, but they are a local family business and I try really hard to support those where I can.

kragen | an hour ago

As I understand it, this is in fact a major problem in archival today, that iron gall ink eats paper. Vellum stands up better under iron gall ink, and I imagine (but have not tested!) that it would destroy acetate but be fine on PET drafting film.

betterunix2 | 3 hours ago

Note that the US government published its iron gall recipe at a time when dip pens were the norm. There was actually a period of time when making your own ink was not so uncommon, but at the time people also cut their own quill pens.

kragen | an hour ago

Isamu | 2 hours ago

>It stays blacker, but it will be much harder to recover your writing if your notebook should happen to be carbonized and buried under pyroclastic flows.

Good tip! Although moving away from the active volcano should maybe be higher on my list of priorities.

AndrewKemendo | 4 hours ago

Making ink from source is incredibly difficult.

I’ve tried over the years and have been able to make some from stone but anything organic is folk chemistry.

Most recently tried with Pokeberries off my property but it turns into an off brown/green pretty quickly.

It’s odd cause most common inks are viscous liquid but when you make your own you almost have to think as though you’re making plaster or concrete, cause there’s multiple phases to ink management:

Particle-liquid Suspension, storage, application, drying

Easy to fail in one of those

AlanYx | 2 hours ago

If you're into inkmaking from local materials, I recommend "Make Ink: A Forager's Guide to Natural Inkmaking" by Jason Logan. He's fairly relaxed about consistency and longevity and treats it more as an art, but he also operates a side business selling his foraged inks, so at least some are reasonably self-stable.

Lots of great pictures of colorful inks in that book.

He also wrote a version of the book aimed at kids, but it's not as good as "Make Ink" IMHO. Blue copper oxide ink does make a good project for kids who are old enough to understand it's toxic and shouldn't be used with fine pens.

AndrewKemendo | 2 hours ago

Very cool recommendation I’ll check it out thanks.

baruz | 2 hours ago

The most difficult part about making iron gall ink is crushing the oak apples enough to where you can extract the acids. The “folk science” of iron gall ink is backed up by later scientific analysis. The original rich black color does fade to a beautiful brown, and should only be used on parchment or vellum, as the gallic and tannic acids are not archival on cellulose paper.

Most botanical dyes are, as you have found, not lightfast and will fade quickly. The simplest and most lightfast organic ink simply uses lampblack (fine soot) and gum arabic which is simple to mix, but making it yourself requires collecting and scraping fine soot. I just use Chinese ink sticks.

Stone? Do you mean mineral pigments? By my lights, once you start grinding and mulling mineral pigments and mixing them with gum to write with, you’re working with watercolor paints, not inks, and sourcing mineral rocks and grinding pigments from them rather than getting them pre-ground as I do sounds more tedious than making organic lampblack ink.

AndrewKemendo | 2 hours ago

It’s almost silly how simple lamp black is to make, like literally it’s just soot which you can pretty much find everywhere

And yes mineral pigments is what I’m talking about, Finely ground minerals mostly

kragen | an hour ago

In my Japanese class every Thursday was calligraphy day. Calligraphy day began with half an hour of grinding solid India ink on the inkstone. I never made the inkstick myself, but Wikipedia makes it sound pretty easy: it's soot and animal glue, and I accidentally make animal glue regularly by cooking meat too long. Chicken, usually.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inkstick

Admittedly, I didn't kill the chickens myself.

tombert | 4 hours ago

Probably due a combination of some case of undiagnosed autism and the fact that I was kind of forced to use them for school, as a teenager I became kind of obsessed with different types of pens. I bought several fountain pens and inks and had fun playing with them.

This is in spite of the fact that I don't really enjoy using them. My handwriting is roughly comparable to SHA-265 and is write-only, and according to my friends and my wife, I never really learned how to hold a pen correctly and as such physically writing is literally a pretty messy and smudgy endeavor. I think I blame my first grade teacher for the latter problem.

I still have a vestige of interest in different inks like this, just out of historical curiosity, so I might see if I can find some iron gall ink to play with.

JoshTriplett | an hour ago

> My handwriting is roughly comparable to SHA-265 and is write-only

I always joke that my signature is more of a one-time pad.

tombert | 44 minutes ago

Man it gets worse every time I do it too, since now I write by hand so infrequently.

Pretty much as soon my mom bought me my own cheap laser printer to use when I was ~15, I've typed as much as I could because teachers genuinely could not read my handwriting when doing homework. I got pretty good at using the free version of MathType in conjunction with OpenOffice.org to do my math homework (before I eventually learned TeX), all my reports were typed, and teachers were happy because they didn't have to try and decipher what the hell it was that I was writing. This was 20+ years ago or so, so they didn't have to worry about LLMs doing my homework for me.

I have kept this pattern up into adulthood, to a point where I write with my hands so infrequently that it genuinely baffles me at how much my handwriting has degraded every time I am forced to write something by hand (e.g. filling out a form), as I am getting more and more out of practice as I age. I type faster than pretty much anyone I know, and as a result it's rarely been much of a hindrance to me, fortunately.

Amusingly, I remember in fourth grade my teacher (who was a genuinely very kind and nice lady) pulled me aside and said something like "Tom, you're a smart guy, and I think you can do really well when you grow up, but if you don't work on your handwriting then it's going to hold you back in life because no one will be able to read what you write". Even at the time computers were pretty well entrenched into the life of basically everyone in the western world, so I didn't really agree with her. I ended up being right, learning to type was probably the better time investment than penmanship, though I do think her heart was in the right place.

Isamu | 3 hours ago

>When applied, the drying of the ink can be speeded up by dusting your writing paper with a fine powder known as pounce, made from pumice stone or salt, or sometimes grated dried cuttlefish bone.

Note this is really just sopping up extra ink on the surface onto the powder which is blown away from the paper.

They would put the stuff into what looked like salt shakers to use, and to this day I believe one of the houses of congress still keeps these full at each desk.

SoftTalker | 49 minutes ago

And origin of the phrase "done and dusted."

kragen | an hour ago

> To make hynke. Take gall & coporos & or vitrial quartryn & gumme of eueryche a quartryn oþer helf quartryn & a halfe quartryn of gall more & breke þe gall a ij oþer a iij & put ham togedere eueryche one in a pot & stere hyt ofte & wyƷt wythinne ij wykys after Ʒe mow wryte þer wyþ. & yf Ʒe have a quartryn of eueryche take a quarte of watyr yf halfe a quartryn of eueryche þan take half a quartre of watyr.

My paleography is not great, but I think this says, "To make ink. Take [oak] gall & copperas [iron sulfate] or vitriol [sulfate, in case you didn't know what "coporos" was], quarter-pint, & gum; of each, a quarter-pint other half quarter-pint & a half quarter-pint of gall more, & break the gall a 2 other a 3 & and put them [?] together each one in a pot & stir it often & wait. Within 2 weeks after ye [???] write therewith. & if ye have a quarter-pint of every-each, take a quart of water if half a quarter-pint of each, then take half a quarter-pint of water."

"Ʒ" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ezh, the dram symbol) is clearly an error of transcription, and I suspect it's not the only one!

"Other" seems like it might be intended to give proportions for mixing: a quarter-pint to a half-quarter-pint, or 2 to 3, or whatever. "Everyche" is an old abbreviation for "every-each", meaning "each". It was completely normal to use lowercase Roman numerals like this (j, ij, iij, iv, v, vj, etc.) in recipes up to the 19th century, to the point that Cooley doesn't bother to list them in his list of abbreviations (https://archive.org/details/b28131423/page/n15/mode/1up), although he uses them frequently.

Incidentally, Cooley has several pages of recipes for iron gall ink starting at https://archive.org/details/b28131423/page/776/mode/1up. The version I have handy to quote from is a different edition (cooleyscyclopaed01cool), but, I think, still worth reading, among other things to see how Cooley thought of iron gall ink and its ingredients:

> INK. Syn. Atramentum, L, Coloured liquid employed for writing with a pen. Ink is made of various substances and colours; but at present we shall confine our attention to the tanno-gallic compounds, to which the term, when standing alone, is almost exclusively applied.

> Prep. 1. Aleppo galls (well bruised), 4 oz. ; clean soft water, 1 quart ; macerate in a clean corked bottle for 10 days or a fortnight, or even longer, with frequent agitation, then add of gum Arabic (dissolved in a wine-glassful of water, 1¼ oz. ; lump sugar, ½ oz. ; mix well, and afterwards further add of sulphate of iron (green copperas, crushed small), 1½ oz. ; agi- tate occasionally for 2 or 3 days, when the ink may be decanted for use, but is better if the whole is left to digest together for 2 or 3 weeks. When time is an object, the whole of the ingredients may at once be put into a bottle, and the latter agitated daily until the ink is made ; and boiling water instead of cold water may be employed. Product. 1 quart of excellent ink, writing pale at first, but soon turning intensely black.

I'm guessing that "Aleppo galls" are galls from the Aleppo oak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quercus_infectoria of which Wikipedia says, "The galls from Quercus infectoria contain the highest naturally occurring level of tannin, approximately 50–70%,[6] as well as syringic acid, β-sitosterol, amentoflavone, hexamethyl ether, isocryptomerin, methyl betulate, methyl oleanate, and hexagalloyl glucose.[6][7] They also contain 2–4% each of gallic and ellagic acid that are polymerized to make tannins.[8][9][10]"

Cooley does go on to describe other recipes for iron gall ink using unqualified "Galls (bruised)", and then goes on to explain:

> General Commentary. According to the most accurate experiments on the preparation of black ink, it appears that the quantity of sulphate of iron should not exceed ⅓rd part of that of the galls, by which an excess of astringent vegetable matter, which is necessary for the durability of the colour, is preserved in the liquid. Gum, by shielding the writing from the action of the air, tends to preserve the colour ; but if much is employed, the ink flows languidly from quill pens, and scarcely at all from steel pens. The latter require a very limpid ink. The addition of sugar (especially of moist sugar) increases the flowing property of the liquid, but makes it dry more slowly, and frequently to pass into an acetous state, in which condition it acts injuriously on the pen. Vinegar, for a like reason, is not calculated for the menstruum, as it rapidly softens quill or horn, and corrodes iron and steel.

> To ensure the permanency of the colour of the tanno-gallic inks, the best Aleppo or blue nut-galls must alone be used. No second or inferior quality should be employed. A contrary practice, often adopted for the sake of economy, is nearly always followed by unpleasant results and often by considerable loss.

> The only improvement of importance which has been made in the manufacture of writing ink from the common materials, during the last few years, is the practice of first roasting the gall-nuts, which is now adopted by a few of the houses most celebrated for their copying ink. In this way a portion of pyrogallic acid is formed, which is very soluble in water, and strikes an intense bluish-black colour with the protosulphate or green sulphate of iron. From galls so treated an ink may be made to write black at once. Care must, however, be taken to avoid any loss of materials by volatilisation.

> To prevent any tendency to mouldiness in ink, a few bruised cloves, or a little oil of cloves, or, still better, a few drops of creasote (carbolic acid) may be added. The last two should be previously dissolved in a small quan- tity of strong vinegar, or rectified spirit. With the same intention some of the large makers allow the ink to become covered with a skin of 'mould' in the cask, to render it less liable to undergo the same change when subsequently bottled. Formerly the practice was to add a little spirit for the same purpose.

> Sumach, logwood, and oak-bark are frequently substituted for galls in the preparation of common ink. When such is the case, only about ⅙ or ⅐th of their weight of copperas should be employed. Inks so made possess little durability.