I recently read another article talking about the fact that a number of older drivers are buying Teslas specifically because of their self driving features, but this is a problem because Tesla is straight up lying about the capabilities of their vehicles. They aren’t full self driving and yet the elderly drivers are treating them as such and putting everyone in danger because they have even less ability to quickly take over and drive when the car inevitably makes an error than younger drivers.
It is really frustrating because autonomous driving is illegal currently in the US as well.
There are several classes of autonomous vehicles (AV), do not quote me on the exact names here.
But basically, the kind that is designed for no human intervention is like class 4. And a dumb car is class zero. Tesla is like class 2. Current Honda civics are about the same, but they have more built in controls to make sure no one goes handsfree.
Teslas are also poorly designed. They only have cameras to manage the car, because Elon Musk hates the proven and effective LIDAR technology. Truly autonomous vehicles use a combo of technologies to have a much more accurate model to make decisions.
There are no consumer grade class 4 AVs, but these are in the works in China and will launch soon, legally.
I'm always reminded of the fact that most people never learn anything. How long have we been having this conversation about old people and driving? 50 years? 70? And the very first story in this piece was about a man haggling with his father, and after negotiation finally relenting. Why?
It should be a no-brainer, by now, after all these thousands upon thousands of stories exactly like these, that there comes a time when you take the keys away. You don't negotiate, you take the keys away. Just take the keys away.
This past election day I was working at a polling place right next to a senior high-rise facility. All day long people came down and waited at the curb for a car, minivan, or little transport bus to pick them up. The car was driven by a child or grandchild, Uber or lyft, or the buses were some sort of Senior Transport company. There are alternatives for seniors.
Taking the keys away is not always so simple. People with dementia fixate on things, you have to be sneaky with them, like toddlers. You can’t just tell them what’s up because they’re willful.
There are lots of strategies: decoy keys, telling them the car is temporarily out of commission, temporarily disabling the car. But when someone else in the house does need to use the car, it’s a bit harder. And when the person taking care of them is also old and might forget about hiding the keys.
I took my mom’s car key and told my dad I had it, but he forgot and spent several hundred dollars having it remade.
We’ve convinced her to stop driving, but it was a gradual process. Whenever she argued, I would remind her that the DOCTOR’s advice was for her not to drive. The next stage was reminding here about the other people on the road, painting a picture of a man on his way home to his family after work and asking her to imagine getting into an accident with him. That was what ultimately convinced her.
If we had just taken her keys, she would have started throwing things at my dad and made his life completely miserable.
One of the biggest issues with people with dementia is their inability to manage their emotions. They can become angry, bitter, and mean. Then they eventually get out into a home that no one can afford and are where they receive substandard care.
My mom is still at home and pretty content. It took work to get her to this state, and hamfisted tactics like “simply taking her keys” would not have gotten her there.
I don’t disagree with your larger point. We’ve got to got these old people to let go of the reins, with driving, politics, and lots of other things.
I also think self-driving cars are dangerous for pedestrians and should not be allowed.
Yes, the key is to play to the elder's particular neurosis. For my dad, it was "if you get in an accident and get sued they could take away your house".
Dad took Grandma's keys away when her vision had deteriorated too much to drive, because the state kept renewing her license without any testing. There was no mechanism in place (at least at the time) that would enable her license to be revoked based on loss of capacity to drive, and frequent minor accidents were not sufficient either.
She called the Cadillac dealership and got them to hand-deliver new keys. Twice.
Dad took the spark plugs and battery next. Grandma had it towed to the dealership and delivered back to her with replacements installed.
Dad lost his shit at the Cadillac dealership's general manager and threatened to sue them. Apparently, the prospect of Grandma's wrath (or of losing the revenue from her constant visits to their body shop) was scarier.
So Dad took the entire car, and Grandma filed a police report. It turned out that the title was still in the name of her deceased husband, whose full name was identical to dad's name except for a suffix. Dad somehow convinced the local police that she was senile (she was blind but 100% cognitively intact) and that as the lawful owner of the car, he was removing the vehicle for safety reasons. I'm not sure if the police actually believed him or chose to look the other way because of her extensive history of fender-benders, but they didn't push the issue.
If that side of the family weren't full of men who used the same fucking name for generations, Dad might have been arrested, and Grandma might have gone on to commit vehicular homicide.
Hahah, that’s great! It’s funny how naming your kid after yourself can create this loophole for your progeny. I didn’t realize what a baller move it was until I saw it play out a few times.
Edit: I hope if you ever have a kid, you name them after either yourself or your dad.
Sure, dementia is a case where my argument doesn't work. 30-some years ago my grandpa knew it was time and the last time I spoke to one of my friends, they told me that their mom just discussed with them that she didn't want to drive any more.
That is: all of us, including a little drivers, know this because we've grown up with it all our lives. Some people never learn.
Unfortunately the options are expensive. The senior transport services are horrible. Basically they only run bankers hours and you need to book 3-5 days ahead. So not very independent feeling. And they tend to be expensive.
I am sure my dad could figure out uber, but there is no availability in the small rural town he lives in. Would be like a 15 minute wait and iffy (low demand but improving). He also can’t afford it. I did a check, and his trip home from Walmart would be $25.
No transit where he is! And moving would be destabilizing.
Yup! It is horrible (I volunteer for a transit focused nonprofit).
I live in a walkable/transit friendly neighborhood and rarely use my car. I wish we could afford the senior home in my siblings neighborhood for dad. It would be perfect for him with easy access to most things. But he likes living in the rural areas and he has community there. I worry about him driving all the time. He was a distracted driver when he was young.
I've seen this in my own family: Grandma had to go to court for her traffic accident at 90, and was very upset about giving up her license to ride the bus, even though she already did live in a retirement town. My great aunt got into a car accident and her biggest concern was recovering the CD's of her culture's folk music out of the player!!! And both of these happened over 10 years ago. Hopefully we can figure out a way to make sure our elderly population is still getting their needs met and keep them safe off the road.
also while unrelated to the main point of aging drivers i thought this note about autonomous traffic was interesting:
>“The most dangerous time in that 15 years is somewhere between Year 3 and Year 7,” he predicts, “because all the big trucks will have changed over, but the resistant people won’t, and so now you have self-driving everything trying to interact with random chaotic people who are driving themselves"
“Random chaotic people driving themselves”? Geez, what’s next? Random chaotic people walking themselves, chewing themselves, thinking themselves, ad nauseam?
I’m 62 and I see enough cognitive changes in myself that I won’t drive on the freeway anymore. I’d quit altogether but I have to work til retirement next year and there is no public transport here. It’s sad bc I loved driving and I love my cute little orange Mini but I don’t want to hurt anyone!
I see this in myself already, how those super-bright headlights bother me, how I prefer to avoid really busy roads. My Brother had to disable my Dad's car to stop him from driving and I hope I have the sense to stop driving before I get to my Dad's point. But public transport is terrible, and Ubering expensive. I feel for people who are rural, even if they wanted to quit driving unless they have family who can take them to the doctor or grocery store, they need to drive to live. Catch 22.
Another consequence of America's car dependence. Self-driving cars are not the solution and we're unfortunately going to need to learn that the hard way.
Just a few months ago an old man pulled out right in front of me and luckily I saw him in time to slam on my brakes and just barely avoid t-boning him. It was at a signalized intersection and I had the green light. It didn't look like he even looked, he just went, even though he had a red light. I leaned on my horn and followed him to confront him. He pulled into a nearby clinic, seems he had a doctor's appointment. I told him what he did and he claimed to have no clue, no memory of almost causing an accident and no memory of hearing the screeching of my tires or my horn. He seemed confused and became defensive, first denying it ever happened, then accusing me of driving too fast (I wasn't). I told him I had a video of it on my dash cam, at which point he retreated and hobbled away to his appointment. I straight up told him he needs to stop driving before he kills someone because he seems to be completely unaware of almost causing an accident not 5 minutes ago. I was so angry, the dude could have killed the both of us, but he seemed completely oblivious to what happened.
Longreads-ModTeam | 2 hours ago
Unfortunately your post has been removed because the article was already posted to the subreddit within the past 90 days.
(Link to the original post: )
SessileRaptor | 3 hours ago
I recently read another article talking about the fact that a number of older drivers are buying Teslas specifically because of their self driving features, but this is a problem because Tesla is straight up lying about the capabilities of their vehicles. They aren’t full self driving and yet the elderly drivers are treating them as such and putting everyone in danger because they have even less ability to quickly take over and drive when the car inevitably makes an error than younger drivers.
PlantedinCA | 2 hours ago
It is really frustrating because autonomous driving is illegal currently in the US as well.
There are several classes of autonomous vehicles (AV), do not quote me on the exact names here.
But basically, the kind that is designed for no human intervention is like class 4. And a dumb car is class zero. Tesla is like class 2. Current Honda civics are about the same, but they have more built in controls to make sure no one goes handsfree.
Teslas are also poorly designed. They only have cameras to manage the car, because Elon Musk hates the proven and effective LIDAR technology. Truly autonomous vehicles use a combo of technologies to have a much more accurate model to make decisions.
There are no consumer grade class 4 AVs, but these are in the works in China and will launch soon, legally.
DanoPinyon | 3 hours ago
I'm always reminded of the fact that most people never learn anything. How long have we been having this conversation about old people and driving? 50 years? 70? And the very first story in this piece was about a man haggling with his father, and after negotiation finally relenting. Why?
It should be a no-brainer, by now, after all these thousands upon thousands of stories exactly like these, that there comes a time when you take the keys away. You don't negotiate, you take the keys away. Just take the keys away.
This past election day I was working at a polling place right next to a senior high-rise facility. All day long people came down and waited at the curb for a car, minivan, or little transport bus to pick them up. The car was driven by a child or grandchild, Uber or lyft, or the buses were some sort of Senior Transport company. There are alternatives for seniors.
micaflake | 2 hours ago
Taking the keys away is not always so simple. People with dementia fixate on things, you have to be sneaky with them, like toddlers. You can’t just tell them what’s up because they’re willful.
There are lots of strategies: decoy keys, telling them the car is temporarily out of commission, temporarily disabling the car. But when someone else in the house does need to use the car, it’s a bit harder. And when the person taking care of them is also old and might forget about hiding the keys.
I took my mom’s car key and told my dad I had it, but he forgot and spent several hundred dollars having it remade.
We’ve convinced her to stop driving, but it was a gradual process. Whenever she argued, I would remind her that the DOCTOR’s advice was for her not to drive. The next stage was reminding here about the other people on the road, painting a picture of a man on his way home to his family after work and asking her to imagine getting into an accident with him. That was what ultimately convinced her.
If we had just taken her keys, she would have started throwing things at my dad and made his life completely miserable.
One of the biggest issues with people with dementia is their inability to manage their emotions. They can become angry, bitter, and mean. Then they eventually get out into a home that no one can afford and are where they receive substandard care.
My mom is still at home and pretty content. It took work to get her to this state, and hamfisted tactics like “simply taking her keys” would not have gotten her there.
I don’t disagree with your larger point. We’ve got to got these old people to let go of the reins, with driving, politics, and lots of other things.
I also think self-driving cars are dangerous for pedestrians and should not be allowed.
GhostOfGlorp | 2 hours ago
People who haven’t had to deal with this do not understand.
xalupa | 2 hours ago
Yes, the key is to play to the elder's particular neurosis. For my dad, it was "if you get in an accident and get sued they could take away your house".
PurePerfection_ | 2 hours ago
Dad took Grandma's keys away when her vision had deteriorated too much to drive, because the state kept renewing her license without any testing. There was no mechanism in place (at least at the time) that would enable her license to be revoked based on loss of capacity to drive, and frequent minor accidents were not sufficient either.
She called the Cadillac dealership and got them to hand-deliver new keys. Twice.
Dad took the spark plugs and battery next. Grandma had it towed to the dealership and delivered back to her with replacements installed.
Dad lost his shit at the Cadillac dealership's general manager and threatened to sue them. Apparently, the prospect of Grandma's wrath (or of losing the revenue from her constant visits to their body shop) was scarier.
So Dad took the entire car, and Grandma filed a police report. It turned out that the title was still in the name of her deceased husband, whose full name was identical to dad's name except for a suffix. Dad somehow convinced the local police that she was senile (she was blind but 100% cognitively intact) and that as the lawful owner of the car, he was removing the vehicle for safety reasons. I'm not sure if the police actually believed him or chose to look the other way because of her extensive history of fender-benders, but they didn't push the issue.
If that side of the family weren't full of men who used the same fucking name for generations, Dad might have been arrested, and Grandma might have gone on to commit vehicular homicide.
micaflake | an hour ago
Hahah, that’s great! It’s funny how naming your kid after yourself can create this loophole for your progeny. I didn’t realize what a baller move it was until I saw it play out a few times.
Edit: I hope if you ever have a kid, you name them after either yourself or your dad.
[OP] Zen1 | an hour ago
The only thing that stopped my elderly relatives was losing their licenses.
DanoPinyon | 2 hours ago
Sure, dementia is a case where my argument doesn't work. 30-some years ago my grandpa knew it was time and the last time I spoke to one of my friends, they told me that their mom just discussed with them that she didn't want to drive any more.
That is: all of us, including a little drivers, know this because we've grown up with it all our lives. Some people never learn.
PlantedinCA | 2 hours ago
Unfortunately the options are expensive. The senior transport services are horrible. Basically they only run bankers hours and you need to book 3-5 days ahead. So not very independent feeling. And they tend to be expensive.
I am sure my dad could figure out uber, but there is no availability in the small rural town he lives in. Would be like a 15 minute wait and iffy (low demand but improving). He also can’t afford it. I did a check, and his trip home from Walmart would be $25.
No transit where he is! And moving would be destabilizing.
SaintOrJannikSinner | 2 hours ago
All this to say that the chickens are coming home to roost in regards to centering our society around motor vehicles.
PlantedinCA | an hour ago
Yup! It is horrible (I volunteer for a transit focused nonprofit).
I live in a walkable/transit friendly neighborhood and rarely use my car. I wish we could afford the senior home in my siblings neighborhood for dad. It would be perfect for him with easy access to most things. But he likes living in the rural areas and he has community there. I worry about him driving all the time. He was a distracted driver when he was young.
[OP] Zen1 | 3 hours ago
I've seen this in my own family: Grandma had to go to court for her traffic accident at 90, and was very upset about giving up her license to ride the bus, even though she already did live in a retirement town. My great aunt got into a car accident and her biggest concern was recovering the CD's of her culture's folk music out of the player!!! And both of these happened over 10 years ago. Hopefully we can figure out a way to make sure our elderly population is still getting their needs met and keep them safe off the road.
also while unrelated to the main point of aging drivers i thought this note about autonomous traffic was interesting:
>“The most dangerous time in that 15 years is somewhere between Year 3 and Year 7,” he predicts, “because all the big trucks will have changed over, but the resistant people won’t, and so now you have self-driving everything trying to interact with random chaotic people who are driving themselves"
aqqalachia | 3 hours ago
i'm nosy about the music.
[OP] Zen1 | 2 hours ago
Japanese oldies basically https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL2-5Y-K-KOJDXRWwLe0jiLRa4eL8gppMc&si=ZTLbmZdiARSR21Gz
Odd_School_8833 | 2 hours ago
“Random chaotic people driving themselves”? Geez, what’s next? Random chaotic people walking themselves, chewing themselves, thinking themselves, ad nauseam?
[OP] Zen1 | an hour ago
“I know where I came from but how about all you zombies?”
Situation-Emergency | 2 hours ago
I’m 62 and I see enough cognitive changes in myself that I won’t drive on the freeway anymore. I’d quit altogether but I have to work til retirement next year and there is no public transport here. It’s sad bc I loved driving and I love my cute little orange Mini but I don’t want to hurt anyone!
DyllCallihan3333 | 2 hours ago
I see this in myself already, how those super-bright headlights bother me, how I prefer to avoid really busy roads. My Brother had to disable my Dad's car to stop him from driving and I hope I have the sense to stop driving before I get to my Dad's point. But public transport is terrible, and Ubering expensive. I feel for people who are rural, even if they wanted to quit driving unless they have family who can take them to the doctor or grocery store, they need to drive to live. Catch 22.
WrigglyGizka | 2 hours ago
Another consequence of America's car dependence. Self-driving cars are not the solution and we're unfortunately going to need to learn that the hard way.
Human0id77 | 2 hours ago
Just a few months ago an old man pulled out right in front of me and luckily I saw him in time to slam on my brakes and just barely avoid t-boning him. It was at a signalized intersection and I had the green light. It didn't look like he even looked, he just went, even though he had a red light. I leaned on my horn and followed him to confront him. He pulled into a nearby clinic, seems he had a doctor's appointment. I told him what he did and he claimed to have no clue, no memory of almost causing an accident and no memory of hearing the screeching of my tires or my horn. He seemed confused and became defensive, first denying it ever happened, then accusing me of driving too fast (I wasn't). I told him I had a video of it on my dash cam, at which point he retreated and hobbled away to his appointment. I straight up told him he needs to stop driving before he kills someone because he seems to be completely unaware of almost causing an accident not 5 minutes ago. I was so angry, the dude could have killed the both of us, but he seemed completely oblivious to what happened.
Bright_Ices | 2 hours ago
Sounds like he really was oblivious. If you had gotten the license plate number, you could have called the DMV to report him for a driving checkup.
TheGreatRandomio | 2 hours ago
https://archive.is/cMtGo in case anybody's caught by the paywall.