Submission statement: When Emily Smith was 10 weeks old, her father was arrested. According to the police, he had broken both her arms and her collarbone that day, and doctors suspected that she had sustained multiple other broken bones over her short lifespan. The judge set his bail at $3.5 million. Smith’s tale went about as viral as a story could in the ’90s: She was front-page news in papers across Florida for years. She grew up not knowing much about her father or that day. Then, some 30 years later, she realized: She’s a journalist. If she wanted to know the truth, she could find it. In an article for Slate, Smith tracks down every bit of information about her case—her dad’s police file, the detectives on the case, the people who were at the hospital—on an emotional, courageous journey to confront the most infamous day of her life and the person who caused it.
Cleaned link from "https://slate.com/life/2026/09/florida-dad-child-abuse-crime.html?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_content=million_dollar_bones&utm_campaign=&utm_term=&tpcc=reddit-social--million_dollar_bones-":
https://slate.com/life/2026/09/florida-dad-child-abuse-crime.html?tpcc=reddit-social--million_dollar_bones-
Tracking parameters were removed from the original URL(s).
The article mentions that the doctors found on the initial examination that she had evidence of at least 10 broken bones that had healed in addition to these new breaks. That was not an accident.
Don't be too sure. Because multiple fractures at young ages raise immediate red flags for medical staff, physicians sometimes misinterpret the condition as intentional abuse.
However, evidence of past fractures still doesn’t tell investigators who caused them.
Regarding the down votes, only on Reddit do people think that fractured bones come with neat little labels saying who did it. Maybe do all you can to avoid jury duty. /s
As someone who worked in the court system for years with children who had been abused, I would agree that it suggests a pattern.
However without further corroborating information, it’s still just one data point. The article also implicates other relatives. For all we know each fracture represents a separate abuser.
I think it goes without saying that all of us object to child abuse.
Welcome to the pitchfork brigades. If the world actually worked like how most people on reddit think it would be stone-age vigilante justice for everything.
>After doing all this research, revisiting this time with my other family members, and talking to the professionals who were there, I know now there is no one true version of the story
Yeah what a ridiculous nonstory. She didn't learn anything definitive, and goes out of her way to state multiple times that she hears a different story from every person she asks
I’m glad I gave up reading it. Since she had old breaks that had healed, I was wondering if it was going to be about brittle bone disease. There was also an implication it seemed, that the maternal grandmother may have been responsible.
Even the lowest IQ cop can tell you people stories always diverge in someway. People’s memories are not nearly as reliable as they like to think they are. I’m not sure how being human makes this a non-story. It’s clearly important to the author and you have the option of not reading it. Win-win.
The most chilling part is that this story now has three versions: the front page version, the mother's version, and the father's version, and she still doesn't know which one is true.
The worst part is she probably never will. Not only does every person perceive the facts differently, there is always the possibility of sins of omission or lying.
Unless the court sealed it, she does have the option of going back to the court record and reading the discovery on her father as well as court transcripts, assuming that they even had that available. Of course, if anyone lied to the judge, the lawyers, the investigators or the lawyers or investigators, either masterpiece or chose not to consider a piece of evidence worthy of mention that takes her back to the first problem.
When I was 15 my dad bruised 3 of my ribs. How do I know they were bruised? Not because a doctor told me, but because I bruised them again in my late 20’s and a doctor diagnosed me then, and the memory of that exact pain came rushing back. No idea why or how my mom wasn’t forced to take me to a hospital to get checked out..
He was arrested as well. No news story. Not even a CPS interview. I’m a teacher of 14 years, so I now wonder what my mom had to do and to whom in order to orchestrate all of the rug sweeping..
That was very unsatisfying. I get the grey areas in life. I think it would be more interesting to hear how the author feels about all of this. Her dad was 19. 19 year old boys aren't known for impulse control. From the beginning of the article it sounds like he did everything right until he didn't. Does she forgive it because of his youth? Does she not? How does he treat his new children? Did he gloss over it or blame her mom because he's embarrassed or because he can't face what he did?
Just a lot unanswered here and I get that life is like that. But this is an article on Slate. Something would have been better than nothing
[OP] Slate | 13 hours ago
Submission statement: When Emily Smith was 10 weeks old, her father was arrested. According to the police, he had broken both her arms and her collarbone that day, and doctors suspected that she had sustained multiple other broken bones over her short lifespan. The judge set his bail at $3.5 million. Smith’s tale went about as viral as a story could in the ’90s: She was front-page news in papers across Florida for years. She grew up not knowing much about her father or that day. Then, some 30 years later, she realized: She’s a journalist. If she wanted to know the truth, she could find it. In an article for Slate, Smith tracks down every bit of information about her case—her dad’s police file, the detectives on the case, the people who were at the hospital—on an emotional, courageous journey to confront the most infamous day of her life and the person who caused it.
Read the full article here (no paywall): https://slate.com/life/2026/09/florida-dad-child-abuse-crime.html?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_content=million_dollar_bones&utm_campaign=&utm_term=&tpcc=reddit-social--million_dollar_bones-
clean-links | 13 hours ago
Cleaned link from "https://slate.com/life/2026/09/florida-dad-child-abuse-crime.html?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=social&utm_content=million_dollar_bones&utm_campaign=&utm_term=&tpcc=reddit-social--million_dollar_bones-": https://slate.com/life/2026/09/florida-dad-child-abuse-crime.html?tpcc=reddit-social--million_dollar_bones-
Tracking parameters were removed from the original URL(s).
DethKlokBlok | 13 hours ago
Thought there would be more insights in the story. It basically says it was probably her dad and probably an accident.
libra00 | 12 hours ago
The article mentions that the doctors found on the initial examination that she had evidence of at least 10 broken bones that had healed in addition to these new breaks. That was not an accident.
omnichronos | 3 hours ago
Don't be too sure. Because multiple fractures at young ages raise immediate red flags for medical staff, physicians sometimes misinterpret the condition as intentional abuse.
Miguel Velasquez was falsely charged with child abuse after doctors ignored pleas to test his infant daughter for brittle bones. After a court-ordered test confirmed osteogenesis imperfecta, the charges were dropped, and the family later received a federal settlement of $1 million.
horseradishstalker | 11 hours ago
However, evidence of past fractures still doesn’t tell investigators who caused them.
Regarding the down votes, only on Reddit do people think that fractured bones come with neat little labels saying who did it. Maybe do all you can to avoid jury duty. /s
libra00 | 11 hours ago
No, but it's a fair bet the person we know for a fact broke 3 of her bones probably did the rest. It suggests a pattern of abuse.
horseradishstalker | 11 hours ago
As someone who worked in the court system for years with children who had been abused, I would agree that it suggests a pattern.
However without further corroborating information, it’s still just one data point. The article also implicates other relatives. For all we know each fracture represents a separate abuser.
I think it goes without saying that all of us object to child abuse.
Gastronomicus | 8 hours ago
Welcome to the pitchfork brigades. If the world actually worked like how most people on reddit think it would be stone-age vigilante justice for everything.
sml6174 | 11 hours ago
>After doing all this research, revisiting this time with my other family members, and talking to the professionals who were there, I know now there is no one true version of the story
Yeah what a ridiculous nonstory. She didn't learn anything definitive, and goes out of her way to state multiple times that she hears a different story from every person she asks
DruidHeart | 11 hours ago
I’m glad I gave up reading it. Since she had old breaks that had healed, I was wondering if it was going to be about brittle bone disease. There was also an implication it seemed, that the maternal grandmother may have been responsible.
horseradishstalker | 11 hours ago
Even the lowest IQ cop can tell you people stories always diverge in someway. People’s memories are not nearly as reliable as they like to think they are. I’m not sure how being human makes this a non-story. It’s clearly important to the author and you have the option of not reading it. Win-win.
blonde1swan | 13 hours ago
The most chilling part is that this story now has three versions: the front page version, the mother's version, and the father's version, and she still doesn't know which one is true.
horseradishstalker | 11 hours ago
The worst part is she probably never will. Not only does every person perceive the facts differently, there is always the possibility of sins of omission or lying.
Unless the court sealed it, she does have the option of going back to the court record and reading the discovery on her father as well as court transcripts, assuming that they even had that available. Of course, if anyone lied to the judge, the lawyers, the investigators or the lawyers or investigators, either masterpiece or chose not to consider a piece of evidence worthy of mention that takes her back to the first problem.
kafka_lite | 11 hours ago
This strikes me as it was easier for the author to believe her father wasn't a bad guy (understandably) than it was to face the truth.
Oh and if anyone did that to a baby in my family they had better hightail it to a different state also.
post_button_account | 13 hours ago
Beautiful story. Glad the author could accept her past and move on. Not everyone gets to be so well adjusted in their lives.
jerrrrremy | 6 hours ago
Thank you for being one of the few other people who actually understood this article, sadly.
walking_waterpark | 8 hours ago
When I was 15 my dad bruised 3 of my ribs. How do I know they were bruised? Not because a doctor told me, but because I bruised them again in my late 20’s and a doctor diagnosed me then, and the memory of that exact pain came rushing back. No idea why or how my mom wasn’t forced to take me to a hospital to get checked out..
He was arrested as well. No news story. Not even a CPS interview. I’m a teacher of 14 years, so I now wonder what my mom had to do and to whom in order to orchestrate all of the rug sweeping..
clean-links | 13 hours ago
Cleaned link: https://slate.com/life/2026/09/florida-dad-child-abuse-crime.html?tpcc=reddit-social--million_dollar_bones-
Tracking parameters were removed from the original URL(s).
UnnecessaryDiety | 3 hours ago
That was very unsatisfying. I get the grey areas in life. I think it would be more interesting to hear how the author feels about all of this. Her dad was 19. 19 year old boys aren't known for impulse control. From the beginning of the article it sounds like he did everything right until he didn't. Does she forgive it because of his youth? Does she not? How does he treat his new children? Did he gloss over it or blame her mom because he's embarrassed or because he can't face what he did?
Just a lot unanswered here and I get that life is like that. But this is an article on Slate. Something would have been better than nothing