How do people with multiple computers handle the passwords?

14 points by everyone_is_butiful 16 hours ago on tildes | 15 comments

Knockout_Mouse | 16 hours ago

For 30 years I never used a password for my computer. Now Windows forced me to start using a four-digit passkey. It feels pointless. If you're in my home, I assume I know you well enough to let you use my PC.

If somebody breaks in, I don't think they're going to haul my gigantic gaming case out. It's unlikely they'd even think it's valuable. They'd be after smaller things that aren't connected to 7 or 8 different peripherals and the wall outlet with a cable salad.

Any other device (like my laptop) shares my four-digit passkey. I just don't feel like the risk level is high enough for me to maintain separate passwords for devices within arm's reach.

preposterous | 11 hours ago

OTOH it’s such a small inconvenience in return for the safety that if someone does steal your computer, they’re unable to poke around. Or your drive ends up being resold or scrapped somewhere, and somebody curious gets all your pictures documents chats etc. Or law enforcement wants to look into your computer (you never know and mistakes do happen). I don’t see a downside to password protecting your devices.

first-must-burn | 6 hours ago

Worth noting that a password by itself doesn't protect your drive, just the running operating system. If you want your stolen hard drive to be unreadable by thieves or LE, you need bitlocker or some other whole disk encryption enabled.

Is my memory bad, or hasn’t Windows been enabling bitlocker since windows 10?

first-must-burn | 3 hours ago

Only if you are using a Microsoft account, or a managed account, to log in.

Isn't Microsoft forcing people to set up Microsoft accounts anyways? They basically hid the capacity in 10, and from what I've been hearing they have been forcing it in 11 unless you're using the enterprise version.

tobii | 6 hours ago

Does windows encrypt user data at rest when you use a login password?

preposterous | an hour ago

I think it does have bitlocker by default now, yes. Haven’t used windows since windows 2000 though so I’m not the most qualified to answer.

tibpoe | 5 hours ago

6 digits would be better but there's no real risk here if microsoft did their job right. The only way pin codes can work is if you limit the number of tries, i.e. it should permanently (or until you provide a more secure auth) lock you out after like 5 incorrect tries.

Macs do this very well, and have their implementation of it backed by a hardware TPM. I hope Windows does the same.

Crespyl | 15 hours ago

The best solution is a synced password manager to a separate device like a phone. I like KeypassXC and Syncthing.

The other thing I do a little too often is use a memorable "algorithm"/pattern to generate passwords per device. I have a base pattern which is a strong password in itself, then I incorporate distinctive features of the system I'm logging into (think hostname, form-factor, etc) into that pattern in a deterministic shuffley manner.

This gives me a unique, strong password for each device, without actually needing to memorize each password individually, just the "algorithm". The problem with this, of course, is that if enough passwords leak, the pattern could in theory be discerned and then all my passwords are up for grabs.

Just use a password manager.

If you don't want to enter passwords all the time, just set a long timeout before it locks.

myrrh | 15 hours ago

...i use a single strong root password + an algorithmic hash based on the domain, machine, + account i'm logging into, so every device or service gets a unique strong password i can reconstruct in my head while logging-in, provided it has a name...

...the only issues i've ever run into are systems with byzantine password restrictions, routine periodic password resets, or multiple/inconsistent names which force me to deviate from my standard hash with passwords i must write down for future reference...

Weldawadyathink | 6 hours ago

1Password. I really like it. It also handles my family share passwords. In this day and age, not using a password manager seems crazy. Especially when you almost certainly have a competent one on your system already for free.

Nihilego | 14 hours ago

I reuse the user password for the computers... But everywhere else, I used KeepassXD or Keepassium, which use a randomized password, for the database, with randomized password for each account.

dreamless_patio | 15 hours ago

This is what I remember by heart:

  1. Full disk encryption (x3, personal laptop and desktop, work laptop)
  2. General password database
  3. Financial password database

All are long, unique diceware passphrases. I wrote them down, stuck the slip of paper in my wallet, and pulled it out a few times a day to commit them to memory before shredding the paper.

My computer account passwords are different but share the same short format. They haven't changed in a long time. These are definitely the weakest link in the chain and I should probably take the time to memorize dicewares for them, but if malware is running on my local machine it's likely exfiltrating everything but these passwords.

Everything else is randomly generated by KeepassXC at the maximum length the website/device accepts. I use syncthing to keep the password databases updated between computers, and LocalSend for my phone since there's weirdness going on with the Android client I used that I don't have time to deal with.

That being said, it's important to develop a threat model (potentially for each system) and find a good middle ground where you're not frustrated but have reasonable defenses. Security can be quite a deep rabbithole and it's easy to start drowning. For home servers I always use long random passwords and SSH certificates for remote access.

Pavouk106 | 5 hours ago

I have one password for my desktop and notebook. We have three desktops at home (one modern and two for kids; these PCs are basically my old PCs) and the all connect to the server, so they all have the same password for each user and the PC logs them in to their profile. PCs are just powerful (for gaming) clients.

I use different password for root (I run Linux everywhere) and I use different passwords on the internet based on say level of criticality - I have top password for internet banking, another top password for my main e-mail, another for sites where real money get used (ie. Amazon) and then lower tier passwords for lower importance sites (ie. Tildes or local eshops etc.).

On top of that I'm the family IT guy so I bave to remember passwords for another ten people...