Two things: They allow creating eula non compliant mods. And they need to decompile minecraft itself to work, which is why it has to happen on your PC individually (distributing modified .jars that already perform mod loading isn't allowed). Also people make money with their mods via ad links. All of this would not surprise me to make them start suing projects, especially if using full IP scans to find badly named servers is already normal for them.
Mojang was distributing source code mappings for a long time. Now they're not even obfuscating the minecraft jars anymore. The decompiling argument doesn't stand.
Yeah, it's surprising to me that not only is the java edition still getting feature parity (-ish) with Bedrock, they're making it easier to mod compared to the prior state of the world. I'm not used to bigcorps being friendly to these kinds of projects.
One thing to keep in mind there is how they keep hiring prominent modders to work on the Java team. Not sure what the chicken or egg is here but certainly is an indicator of attitude
Assetto Corsa is another great example: it was built from the ground up to be easily extensible, and while it was popular at release in 2014, thanks to community mods (such as CSP which is largely the effort of one person(!)) it's still seeing new peak player counts this year despite receiving no significant first-party updates since 2017.
It's also surprising to me that game companies advocate modding, but it shouldn't be surprising. You'd think it's a good business decision to let modders carry the burden of developing the game and adding free content for you and shaping it the way the community wants it to be.
I always wondered what kind of internal conversations the FFXIV devs have about the mod scene; subscription fees from modders spends just as well as anyone else, and there's a general understanding among the cosmetic modders to not do anything involving cash shop assets that would give Square a direct incentive to crack down. But when it comes to gameplay mods, the quasi-competitive nature of ultimate raids (and the actual competitive nature of PvP), plus the question of how you should let mods affect raid design, makes it all pretty tricky.
The official statements have always been flavors on "no, don't mod, it's against ToS" but it's impossible to tell how much of that is just "we don't actually care but we want to be able to pull the plug".
I really thought the story was going to end at the part where mojang sends a one-liner documentation link without even asking for something (assuming the screenshots are really the messages they sent). That said, I think there should be a point where surprise over the author not asking for compensation should turn into surprise over mojang not offering compensation..
proctrap | 15 hours ago
I am honestly surprised that mojang hasn't yet removed the java edition and DMCA'd all java mod loaders yet since they got bought my microsoft.
iggle | 11 hours ago
I'm not sure in what world mod loaders are infringing copyright.
proctrap | 7 hours ago
Two things: They allow creating eula non compliant mods. And they need to decompile minecraft itself to work, which is why it has to happen on your PC individually (distributing modified .jars that already perform mod loading isn't allowed). Also people make money with their mods via ad links. All of this would not surprise me to make them start suing projects, especially if using full IP scans to find badly named servers is already normal for them.
kiwec | 5 hours ago
Mojang was distributing source code mappings for a long time. Now they're not even obfuscating the minecraft jars anymore. The decompiling argument doesn't stand.
quasi_qua_quasi | 2 hours ago
Yeah, it's surprising to me that not only is the java edition still getting feature parity (-ish) with Bedrock, they're making it easier to mod compared to the prior state of the world. I'm not used to bigcorps being friendly to these kinds of projects.
darleaf | 2 hours ago
One thing to keep in mind there is how they keep hiring prominent modders to work on the Java team. Not sure what the chicken or egg is here but certainly is an indicator of attitude
fleebee | an hour ago
Modding keeps games alive for a long, long time.
Assetto Corsa is another great example: it was built from the ground up to be easily extensible, and while it was popular at release in 2014, thanks to community mods (such as CSP which is largely the effort of one person(!)) it's still seeing new peak player counts this year despite receiving no significant first-party updates since 2017.
It's also surprising to me that game companies advocate modding, but it shouldn't be surprising. You'd think it's a good business decision to let modders carry the burden of developing the game and adding free content for you and shaping it the way the community wants it to be.
quasi_qua_quasi | 25 minutes ago
I always wondered what kind of internal conversations the FFXIV devs have about the mod scene; subscription fees from modders spends just as well as anyone else, and there's a general understanding among the cosmetic modders to not do anything involving cash shop assets that would give Square a direct incentive to crack down. But when it comes to gameplay mods, the quasi-competitive nature of ultimate raids (and the actual competitive nature of PvP), plus the question of how you should let mods affect raid design, makes it all pretty tricky.
The official statements have always been flavors on "no, don't mod, it's against ToS" but it's impossible to tell how much of that is just "we don't actually care but we want to be able to pull the plug".
ema-pe | 2 hours ago
I think they didn't because the Java Edition community is pretty large and they would lose a lot of players
lonjil | an hour ago
A pretty big source of popularity for Minecraft is Youtube, and that scene is pretty much all Java Minecraft, and most of them use mods too.
keldu | 10 hours ago
I'm primarily confused by the author offering their service for free to a company, especially one as large as mojang
steef | 10 hours ago
I really thought the story was going to end at the part where mojang sends a one-liner documentation link without even asking for something (assuming the screenshots are really the messages they sent). That said, I think there should be a point where surprise over the author not asking for compensation should turn into surprise over mojang not offering compensation..
quasi_qua_quasi | 2 hours ago
Well, the flip side is that if Mojang did offer compensation, then shutting it down becomes a thornier problem.