I like the ideology of this: continuing Bram's vision, supporting children in Uganda, not using Microsoft-owned GitHub and not using AI for maintainence.
But! From a technical and user point of view (for users of a VI-like editor), they are probably better of with a ViM clone hosted on GitHub that might be maintained by AI instead, like NeoViM.
I would say the opposite if, like me, you want something that will not change over time and you don’t need new features. (I’m not using plugins at all).
I will happily switch to Vim Classic when it lands in Debian.
I can understand that this may not be for people who like having lot of plugins which evolve through time.
From this latest announcement itself: "For more information about the motivations for this fork, please read this blog post."
From that blog post:
I didn’t know Bram Moolenaar. We never met, nor exchanged correspondence. But, after I moved to the Netherlands, Bram’s home country, in a strange way I felt a little bit closer to him. He passed away a couple of years after I moved here, and his funeral was held not far from where I lived at the time. When that happened, I experienced an odd kind of mourning. He was still young, and he had affected my own life profoundly. He was a stranger, and I never got to thank him.
The people he entrusted Vim to were not strangers, they knew Bram and worked with him often, and he trusted them. It’s not my place to judge their work as disrespectful to his memory, or out of line with what he would have wanted. Even knowing Bram only through Vim, I know he and I disagreed often. However, the most personal thing I know about Bram, and that many people remember about him, was his altruistic commitment to a single cause: providing education and healthcare to Ugandan children in need. So, at the very least, I know that he cared.
I won’t speculate on how he would have felt about generative AI, but I can say that GenAI is something I care about. It causes a lot of problems for a lot of people. It drives rising energy prices in poor communities, disrupts wildlife and fresh water supplies, increases pollution, and stresses global supply chains. It re-enforces the horrible, dangerous working conditions that miners in many African countries are enduring to supply rare metals like Cobalt for the billions of new chips that this boom demands. And at a moment when the climate demands immediate action to reduce our footprint on this planet, the AI boom is driving data centers to consume a full 1.5% of the world’s total energy production in order to eliminate jobs and replace them with a robot that lies.
Meanwhile, this whole circus is enabling the rising tide of fascism around the world, not only by supercharging propaganda but also by directly financially supporting fascist policies and policymakers. All this to enrich the few, centralize power, reduce competition, and underwrite an enormous bubble that, once it bursts, will ruin the lives of millions of the world’s poor and marginalized classes.
I don’t think it’s cute that someone vibe coded “battleship” in VimScript. I think it’s more important that we stop collectively pretending that we don’t understand how awful all of this is. I don’t want to use software which has slop in it. I do what I can to avoid it, and sadly even Vim now comes under scrutiny in that effort as both Vim and NeoVim are relying on LLMs to develop the software.
So this is how, a few years after Bram’s passing, I find myself in another unusual moment of mourning: mourning Vim itself. What an odd feeling.
To keep my conscience clear, and continue to enjoy the relationship I have with this amazing piece of software, I have forked Vim. You can find my fork here: Vim Classic.
I quote this at length because (whether you were sincere or not), you asked why. Other people might also wonder why. Agree or disagree, but Drew made his reasons crystal clear.
I have been using vim-classic since the first release switching from neovim and it works perfectly for what I use it for. I made the decision to not use LSP in vim anymore so I can’t answer to how well that works, my guess is that would potentially be one place where it might be lacking.
gir | 12 hours ago
I'm working on building vim-classic for fedora. WIP spec is at https://girst.fedorapeople.org/vim-classic/ . If anyone is interested in collaborating, hmu!
xyproto | 14 hours ago
I like the ideology of this: continuing Bram's vision, supporting children in Uganda, not using Microsoft-owned GitHub and not using AI for maintainence.
But! From a technical and user point of view (for users of a VI-like editor), they are probably better of with a ViM clone hosted on GitHub that might be maintained by AI instead, like NeoViM.
I feel conflicted.
ploum | 12 hours ago
I would say the opposite if, like me, you want something that will not change over time and you don’t need new features. (I’m not using plugins at all).
I will happily switch to Vim Classic when it lands in Debian.
I can understand that this may not be for people who like having lot of plugins which evolve through time.
dsschnau | 6 hours ago
yeah. soon as i can use Vim Classic from distribution I will migrate from regular vim.
dsr | 10 hours ago
It compiles extremely easily under Trixie, incidentally. Took longer to do the configure-for than the make.
[OP] FedericoSchonborn | 13 hours ago
Okay but why exactly?
There's also a fork of Vim 9 (Vim Classic is Vim 8) hosted on Codeberg: EVi.
telemachus | 9 hours ago
From this latest announcement itself: "For more information about the motivations for this fork, please read this blog post."
From that blog post:
I quote this at length because (whether you were sincere or not), you asked why. Other people might also wonder why. Agree or disagree, but Drew made his reasons crystal clear.
greg_loscombe | 8 hours ago
I totally agree on the AI sentiment.
krig | 10 hours ago
I have been using vim-classic since the first release switching from neovim and it works perfectly for what I use it for. I made the decision to not use LSP in vim anymore so I can’t answer to how well that works, my guess is that would potentially be one place where it might be lacking.
trousers | 2 hours ago