I personally believe the world would be a better place if all software was Free and Open-Source Software, regardless of how it was generated. If there's one wish I have with the current "AI" craze is that copyright as we know it goes away or at least is drastically reduced. Copyright terms of less than 20 years and no corporate ownership of copyright, only individuals.
I agree completely. Of all the AI doom scenarios, the deflation of copyright law is the one I welcome. I'd throw in patent law as well. I used to release all my code under the public domain, and only in recent years switched to the MIT license for pragmatic reasons (some countries like Germany don't recognize public domain dedications). The only form of intellectual property I think is reasonable is trademark law, as a prevention of fraud.
I completely agree. Trademark laws have some value in consumer protection, though they are still sometimes abused. Copyright in the US has clearly failed in serving creators and has long been a tool used by corporations to opress creators. Whether it's through the parasitic nature of things like record labels or going after hobbyist projects and archivists (I'm looking at you, Nintendo), it's a mess and not in the public's best interest.
(Seeing your avatar, I immediately feel a kinship with you. Lunar is a very important series to me.)
For myself, beyond the copyright angle, there is a basic trust and auditability issue here. If companies are going to ship vibe-coded software to production, users need source access so obvious security regressions actually get caught.
Look at Humble Bundle's recent redesign. They forced a half-baked migration straight to live users that stripped out app-based two-factor authentication and let you change passwords without entering the old one. Had that code been open or at least source-available during an opt-in beta, people would have flagged those glaring flaws before launch. Without any transparency or accountability, deleting my account was the only sensible move.
This comes up a lot, and every time I have to give the same reply: in Thaler v. Perlmutter, the human involved explicitly said that he considered the AI the sole creator and tried to get the copyright assigned to the model. This has zero relevance to the more common cases where the human will assert that they themselves are the author.
The decision explicitly says this:
The Copyright Office, in fact, has allowed the registration of works made by human authors who use artificial intelligence. See Copyright Registration Guidance: Works Containing Material Generated by Artificial Intelligence, 88 Fed. Reg. 16,190, 16,192 (March 16, 2023) (Whether a work made with artificial intelligence is registerable depends “on the circumstances, particularly how the AI tool operates and how it was used to create the final work.”
Public domain doesn't equal open source. You don't have to publicly share something that contains public domain materials. It just means that anyone else can also use the bits that are public domain in your software because it isn't copyrightable. They can still copyright the codebase as a whole so you can't freely use, modify, etc the whole software.
gnafuthegreat | 6 hours ago
I personally believe the world would be a better place if all software was Free and Open-Source Software, regardless of how it was generated. If there's one wish I have with the current "AI" craze is that copyright as we know it goes away or at least is drastically reduced. Copyright terms of less than 20 years and no corporate ownership of copyright, only individuals.
xeubie | 5 hours ago
I agree completely. Of all the AI doom scenarios, the deflation of copyright law is the one I welcome. I'd throw in patent law as well. I used to release all my code under the public domain, and only in recent years switched to the MIT license for pragmatic reasons (some countries like Germany don't recognize public domain dedications). The only form of intellectual property I think is reasonable is trademark law, as a prevention of fraud.
gnafuthegreat | 4 hours ago
I completely agree. Trademark laws have some value in consumer protection, though they are still sometimes abused. Copyright in the US has clearly failed in serving creators and has long been a tool used by corporations to opress creators. Whether it's through the parasitic nature of things like record labels or going after hobbyist projects and archivists (I'm looking at you, Nintendo), it's a mess and not in the public's best interest.
(Seeing your avatar, I immediately feel a kinship with you. Lunar is a very important series to me.)
boehs | 5 hours ago
While I agree with this article on the first premise (as lofty of a goal as it may be)
This is true, but non-copywritable does not mean open source or source available.
mayli | 5 hours ago
Like photo generated with Camara? How do you define written by human?
asem | 4 hours ago
For myself, beyond the copyright angle, there is a basic trust and auditability issue here. If companies are going to ship vibe-coded software to production, users need source access so obvious security regressions actually get caught. Look at Humble Bundle's recent redesign. They forced a half-baked migration straight to live users that stripped out app-based two-factor authentication and let you change passwords without entering the old one. Had that code been open or at least source-available during an opt-in beta, people would have flagged those glaring flaws before launch. Without any transparency or accountability, deleting my account was the only sensible move.
strongoose | 4 hours ago
Good news: everything made by AI is in the public domain.
quasi_qua_quasi | 3 hours ago
This comes up a lot, and every time I have to give the same reply: in Thaler v. Perlmutter, the human involved explicitly said that he considered the AI the sole creator and tried to get the copyright assigned to the model. This has zero relevance to the more common cases where the human will assert that they themselves are the author.
The decision explicitly says this:
https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/cadc/23-5233/23-5233-2025-03-18.html
sdk | 3 hours ago
Public domain doesn't equal open source. You don't have to publicly share something that contains public domain materials. It just means that anyone else can also use the bits that are public domain in your software because it isn't copyrightable. They can still copyright the codebase as a whole so you can't freely use, modify, etc the whole software.
lilac | 6 hours ago