Why the 'good old days' of American manufacturing are long gone

594 points by Empty-Lengthiness132 7 hours ago on reddit | 349 comments

WatercressOk8763 | 7 hours ago

Why manufacturing did not have a renaissance is because Corporate America does not want to move the jobs back to the USA from overseas. They get the Chinese to work for less than half American wages.

JockoMayzon | 7 hours ago

Yes.
My fathers and my uncles were all tool & die makers in Connecticut. Those jobs are gone. When I graduated from high school, I got a good job at an assembly plant making copiers at a huge industrial campus that is now an abandoned field.

Baxter9009 | 6 hours ago

More importantly, could you you raise a family with the paycheck you got?

JockoMayzon | 6 hours ago

Yes.
My dad was able to fully support us, as were my uncles in supporting their families on one income.
I worked for on year after high school before deciding to go to college. I lived at home, and made enough in that one year to buy a new car and pay for my first two years of college.

struct_iovec | 2 hours ago

What year was this

Southern_Roll_7035 | 6 hours ago

If you were willing to live the lifestyle those families lived with (smaller houses, one car, local vacations only, eating out only rarely), then you could easily live on one paycheck today. Real incomes are more than 40% higher than they were 40 years ago.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/mehoinusa672n

JockoMayzon | 6 hours ago

Take away housing and medical costs.....?

0o0o0o0o0o0z | 5 hours ago

No, you see the kids... they just need to stop buying avocado toast.

Southern_Roll_7035 | 6 hours ago

Housing and medical costs are included in the CPI that is used to calculate real incomes.

JockoMayzon | 6 hours ago

So, why are so many struggling? Houses built in the 1950's are still being used today. I find it hard to believe that medical costs are the same.

ItsJustAnOpinion_Man | 5 hours ago

Because financial literacy is a skill most don't put enough time into developing. There has also been an expansion in products, services, and people trying to get their hands on your wallet. So more discipline is needed than before to maintain a solid financial plan vs keeping up with the Joneses or overdoing convenience purchases.

JockoMayzon | 5 hours ago

So we got less literate since the 1970's?

Shreddy_Brewski | 4 hours ago

100% yes

Southern_Roll_7035 | 5 hours ago

Many households have always struggled with finances; it is historically myopic to think that money troubles are a recent phenomenon.

Average home size has roughly doubled over the last 50 years; this indicates that families are consuming more housing than previous generations, which speaks to its affordability.

I never said that medical costs are the same. CPI factors in all living expenses and produces a weighted average - some go up faster than others, but the aggregate CPI gives us a good measure of the overall increase in the cost of living.

Downtown_Winter3963 | 2 hours ago

Interesting but I find the house size thought process to be a leap. My father tried to pass off the crappy logic of, “All you millennials want to start in the house you grew up in! If only you were willing to start small…”

At what point has our generation had enough money to buy a house? Why could it not be that builders are primarily catering to rich boomers who are always looking to go to bigger houses they barely use? Why build a 1000sq ft house and make a little money when I could also build a McMansion with granite bullshit and make much larger margins?

Southern_Roll_7035 | 2 hours ago

Yes, there is a shortage of single family homes, particularly starter homes, largely because of regulations at the local level which restrict SFR construction. This means that the starter home is now probably a condo.

JockoMayzon | 5 hours ago

So, why are so many struggling?

Southern_Roll_7035 | 5 hours ago

I already answered that.

Already-Price-Tin | 3 hours ago

> So, why are so many struggling?

I think the question should consider whether there are more or fewer people struggling compared to 50 years ago. This article has a chart of the official poverty rate, which has fluctuated but generally has a flat trend the last 50 years.

Homelessness has spiked since the covid pandemic, but may have hit its peak in 2024.

You can look at other metrics, too, like unemployment, food insecurity, etc. And I don't think that's actually people's complaint, that things haven't improved. It's that things haven't improved as much as they believe it should have, given everyone's improvements in education levels, productivity, and overall economy-wide statistics like GDP. It feels like we've had to do more just to keep up, and there's some truth to that. But in absolute terms, most people are financially better off than the people of 50 years ago.

> Houses built in the 1950's are still being used today.

Right, but the houses being used in the 1950's were a much older housing stock, with houses built in the 40's, 30's, 20's, all the way on back. Even the older houses in today's housing stock have lots of fixtures and amenities that have been upgraded. My neighborhood is over 100 years old, but even in those 100-year-old houses pretty much everyone has modern HVAC, water heaters, stoves, etc. Most have modern wiring, plumbing, and plumbing fixtures, and lots have modern insulation. The quality of how we live in our homes is mostly improved compared to even the people who were living in the exact same homes 50 years ago.

animerobin | 3 hours ago

bro you just need to adjust for inflation a couple more times

ofcistilloveyou | 3 hours ago

Yeah that's bullshit. Houses cost a few percent of what they do today, even adjusted for inflation.

Southern_Roll_7035 | 2 hours ago

No, that's wildly incorrect. Real price per square foot of houses was actually lower in 2020 than in 1980. With the price spike since then, the price per square foot is now about 1/3 higher, but even including that, prices have risen more slowly than incomes.

Homes are more expensive today primarily because families are buying larger homes - meaning they are consuming more housing. If they chose homes that are comparable in size to 1980s homes, they would be paying less of their income for housing than a 1980 family.

Empty-Interaction796 | 2 hours ago

In general, 1980s size homes aren't being built anymore

Southern_Roll_7035 | an hour ago

True, localities' housing policy typically restricts smaller houses, which is a shame. This means that buying a smaller homes typically means getting a condo.

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

But mortgage rates were lower meaning that you paid less in interest. over that ttime.

Flintly | 5 hours ago

Maybe in some small select areas but not really I know me and my wife tried two kids

VeteranSergeant | 4 hours ago

This is the main problem with calculating real income the way the Fed does.

You can't actually live the way people did "back in the day" and still participate in most of society. There are a ton of expenses that are essentially mandatory not factored into those numbers.

Reasonable_Mix7630 | 6 hours ago

Are you stupid or a you a bot?

Most people younger than 40 don't own ANY house, much less big one.

Cost of housing relative to income increased by almost 10 times.

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

Homeowners

Under 35: 37.4%

35–44: 61.5%

Southern_Roll_7035 | 6 hours ago

You shouldn't be so snotty when you don't know the facts of a topic.

People under 40 do pay for housing, either rental or owned, and those costs are captured in CPI.

Housing CPI has increased 331.6% from 1980 to 2025, slightly more than the overall CPI increase of 290.7%, but less than the increase in incomes.

KilljoyTheTrucker | 3 hours ago

It does not accurately assess costs, particularly when it comes to rent. A ton of rentals only work because they're paid off, or the mortgage is old enough to reflect an interest rate that was wildly artificially low in the broader context you're trying to paint it in.

Hell, in the last 10 years, the median homebuyer age has increased by 10 years.

CPI isn't a good enough data point to be legislating with at all. It's not even really good enough for the fed to justifiably continue to use it in good faith.

animerobin | 3 hours ago

> Most people younger than 40 don't own ANY house, much less big one.

Look I agree housing prices are an issue but this statement has always been true. Like most people under 40 are children lol. And even if you're just talking about adults under 40, even in the 50s people in their early 20s were not buying new houses very often.

KingFebirtha | an hour ago

This is false on so many levels.

First of all, you're using median household income, which includes people living together even if they're not related. This means a group of 20 year olds renting a house is considered a "household". The better metric would be median family income, since we're specifically talking about families.

It's also misleading because household income specifically only goes back to 1984 on FRED but family incomes go back to 1953, which shows the longer trend. I'm not sure if you did this on purpose to omit any pre-80s data.

Secondly, both of these statistics would count both the parents working. It doesn't differentiate between single income and dual income households. So in what way do these stats show that a SINGLE income earner can still support a family? All it shows is that households/families gained more money.

As for wages, as you can see, they peaked in 1973, and it took almost 50 years to reach that same amount again. I don't know how anyone can look at that and say that a single income household is "easily" available. This is why most households are now dual income.

As for the median family income, from 1953 to 1973 (20 years), real family incomes increased by around 80%, and this was when single family incomes were common, meaning most of that came from just a single worker.

From 1973 to 2025 (52 years) family incomes only increased by around 50%.

This is why looking at a singular chart and saying "see, we make more than we did before!" is incredibly misleading and deceptive.

Also, as for the "CPI includes housing and inflation!" nonsense, all you need to do is look at this picture. I'm sure our 40% wage increase will pay for the +100% increase in things like healthcare and education, both things almost everybody needs.

Southern_Roll_7035 | 18 minutes ago

Sorry, you are just flat out wrong here.

> The better metric would be median family income, since we're specifically talking about families.

Fine. The growth of family incomes actually slightly outpaced household income over this period, so it shows that today's families are doing even better.

>It's also misleading because household income specifically only goes back to 1984 on FRED but family incomes go back to 1953, which shows the longer trend. I'm not sure if you did this on purpose to omit any pre-80s data.

The data show the same trend going back to 1953 - real incomes are increasing over time, which supports my point. There is nothing misleading here; I'm not sure what your point is.

>Secondly, both of these statistics would count both the parents working. It doesn't differentiate between single income and dual income households.

Workers per household has been fairly steady at 1.4 per household since the mid 20th century, so the trends for household income are about the same as those for individuals.

Household income is actually a better stat to use than individual, because the individual numbers include household members who only work part time or seasonally - their earnings don't give as much insight into financial wellbeing of the household. If you actually bothered to look at individual income data, you would see that it has outpaced household income growth over this period as well, so this data supports my point as well:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/mepainusa672n

>As for wages, as you can see, they peaked in 1973

This is largely meaningless. Wages are only part of compensation, and they are becoming a smaller percentage of total compensation over time as the US shifted to a service/knowledge economy. Bonuses and other irregular payments that are more common for today's workers are not captured in this dataset, so it will understate income growth over time.

Also, the dataset is 'Production and non-supervisory workers'; this excludes an increasing proportion of the workforce in the modern economy - small business owners, contractors, independent professionals and the like, who tend to be higher earners, are not captured in the dataset. This will also understate income growth over time.

You need to understand the data you present. The dataset you referenced captures a decreasing percentage of income for a decreasing percentage (which is skewed to lower income earners) of the population. It is not useful for long term data analysis.

>From 1973 to 2025 (52 years) family incomes only increased by around 50%.

Only? That means that people today have far more disposable income than their grandparents.

>This is why looking at a singular chart and saying "see, we make more than we did before!" is incredibly misleading and deceptive.

That's just wrong. The data show that real incomes are going up over time, because that is what the dataset captures. You can look at similar datasets and see similar results to bolster the thesis, but this chart I referenced gives a fair and useful idea of income trends over that period.

>Also, as for the "CPI includes housing and inflation!"

You are making a silly and irrelevant argument here. An index will have some components that go up faster than the average, and some slower. The CPI gives a good indication of the overall inflation experienced by Americans over time.

Nothing you mentioned changes the point that Americans' real incomes are rising over time.

Constant-Plant-9378 | an hour ago

> smaller houses, one car, local vacations only, eating out only rarely

Lots of two income households can't support that today.

Southern_Roll_7035 | an hour ago

On the whole, households have a much higher standard of living today than in previous generations.

Constant-Plant-9378 | an hour ago

Conflating possession of an iPhone with affordability of education, housing, and healthcare is a favorite bad-faith tactic of Boomers.

variegated68409 | 5 hours ago

Yeah plus they didn't even got 4k TVs with AI-enabled GoonVision back then ($299.99 this Black Friday™.)

SghettiAndButter | 6 hours ago

If it was really that easy then why isn’t everyone doing it

Southern_Roll_7035 | 6 hours ago

Many are. It is a matter of personal priorities. If a family is willing to forgo keeping up with the Joneses and live a simpler life, they can generally afford to live on one income.

SghettiAndButter | 6 hours ago

I don’t take vacations or have expensive cars or live in a big house yet my family can’t afford to live on one income

0o0o0o0o0o0z | 5 hours ago

WTF r you smoking?

Critical-Werewolf-53 | 6 hours ago

Are you familiar with inflation sir? Apparently not.

Southern_Roll_7035 | 6 hours ago

I am, which is why I referenced real income, which is inflation adjusted.

Critical-Werewolf-53 | 5 hours ago

😆 you cherry picked CPI which excludes food and energy.
Good job. You picked a stat not reflective of current consumer markets - despite having the ability to acknowledge the existence of said data.

Secondly - houses are 5-8x higher than 40 years ago wages are not.
Food alone alone since Covid (not even 10 years) uo almost 50%

We can see why you’re a new account. Don’t want this level of of ignorance on your main.

Southern_Roll_7035 | 5 hours ago

That's not true. CPI does include food and energy.

Housing costs over the last 45 years have risen only slightly faster than CPI (331% vs 291%), and have risen less than incomes, meaning housing is more affordable today than previously.

Houses are more expensive primarily because people are buying larger homes (houses are roughly twice as large as they were 50 years ago); i.e., families can afford to consume more housing than previous generations.

You are just completely off base here.

SghettiAndButter | 5 hours ago

I would love to buy a small starter home but in my city they cost a lot of money cause they are close to downtown. They simply don’t build small homes anymore for people to buy. I think saying we consume more homes is missing the point that we simply don’t have the options to buy smaller homes

They don’t build small homes because the price to build a small home and a big home once you got the lot and the contractors is very similar

iThankedYourMom | 5 hours ago

You conveniently left out the most obvious metric. What is the median household income vs median house price from then vs now. Do not even reply without bringing up this number. In 1985 it was ~3.5x ($82.8k vs $23.6k) and now it's ~5x ($416k vs $83k) and that's already using dual income household numbers, not one paycheck. Also cpi shelter is just estimated rent, not actual home prices. Houses are more expensive because the land value and the regulations. There is a bigger incentive to build houses that are “luxury” and spacious vs starter homes because it’s so expensive to build anything.

INeedSomeTacoC | 3 hours ago

Tool and die makers make good amounts of money, even today. They're pretty high end.

A good experienced tool and die maker in my area runs somewhere around $140k/yr.

Entry level standard guys (so, like 5 years experience; before then, you're really mostly apprenticing type stuff) are coming in around $85k/yr or so.

Looking around there are about a half dozen postings ranging from $75 - $95k in my area.

MCOL.

SouthNo2807 | 6 hours ago

Yes, but that’s not anything to glorify. We got rivers caught on fire and widespread lung diseases. Lead in infant blood is down by 96% since 1980. Lung cancer is also down 95% for the same time frame.

SprayingOrange | 6 hours ago

yeah but we could just reduce those hazards and still have a domestic modernized industry instead of pushing those externalities on the developing world.

SouthNo2807 | 6 hours ago

Installing filters are not free, all those pollutions have to go somewhere. For the same desk to be American made, it’s currently 2.3x more expensive than a Vietnamese one. This is an unbearable cost for any sort of business unless there is a heavy subsidy on those domestic products. Otherwise, if there is an outright ban on foreign products, customers are just going to pay 2.3 times for a desk.

The entire developed the world has shifted away from manufacturing, not just the US. The US is actually the strongest one on domestic modernized industry.

Most high-end productions are still here in the US,  If you really believe the return of low profit high pollution industries can be returned, I got a bridge to sell you.

espressocycle | 6 hours ago

At one time almost everything consumed here was made here. And yeah, it was more expensive. We had fewer possessions, smaller houses etc, but a less wasteful and more equal society.

SouthNo2807 | 6 hours ago

It's easy to increase purchasing power, but taking it away meets even greater resistance than cutting welfare.

SprayingOrange | 5 hours ago

yeah but it wouldn't be that cheap in Vietnam if we never spent billions of dollars building up industries there. America would still hold all its manufacturing and research and development knowledge. China wouldn't be a near Peer and americans wouldnt have sold their children's futures to shareholders.

efficient markets arent the end all be all of humanity. economies are meant to serve people not the other way around

bp3dots | 2 hours ago

Economies in their current state are meant to serve certain people. Most of us just aren't those people.

lopix | 5 hours ago

The stupid thing is, if people made what they should make, which is probably roughly 2.3x what they make today, they'd be able to afford that desk.

It all started years ago, not sure which is the chicken and which is the egg. But as consumers demanded cheaper and cheaper products, corporations were essentially forced to offshore to bring prices down. That lead to layoffs and closures in the US, which lead to a decline in wages. Which meant people needed cheaper products, as they could not afford more. Which lead to more offshoring, more layoffs and the cycle continued. Trickle down didn't work. Profits became THE MOST important thing to a company. Just look at the post-COVID world where everyone jacked everything 30% and told us all to buy it or go fuck ourselves.

Siva-Na-Gig | an hour ago

I would bet that when wages started to stagnate because of offshoring is when Americans demanded the cheaper products to match those stagnate wages

WordWithinTheWord | 6 hours ago

Not if you want to compete with offshore. Go look at the German auto industry.

SprayingOrange | 6 hours ago

yeah and that's because Germany invested in its automotive manufacturing instead of passing it off to other countries

of course there will be growing pains but domestic manufacturing is essential

WordWithinTheWord | 5 hours ago

Essential and competitive are 2 different things.

Good luck getting a new customer to buy a $60k BMW when there’s a Chinese clone offering 80% of the product for 50% of the price.

They’re well past the growing pains part. They’re paying for consequences of their bet on nationalism.

SprayingOrange | 5 hours ago

no one said anything about being competitive. it's about supporting American heavy industry and American jobs. There are hundreds of countries that "arent competitive" and are just fine.

except we do that right now with our chicken tax and plenty of other tariffs and trade restrictions. Its literally a political issue.

WordWithinTheWord | 5 hours ago

And tariffs just passed the expense onto the consumer. You eventually push the consumer out of the market entirely if you can’t make the product a palatable price.

SprayingOrange | 5 hours ago

yeah we all know what tariffs do

except if we had done this for the past 40 years instead of selling out. we'd have the economies of scale needed already while also reducing the effect of multinationals on our government

Common-Concentrate-2 | an hour ago

BMW's largest factory is spartanburg, south carolina. They mostly hire american engineers. Their largest customer base is in mainland China.

KilljoyTheTrucker | 3 hours ago

Well yeah, until slavery is taboo in eastern cultures, comparative advantage goes to those who would purchase slave labor.

animerobin | 3 hours ago

You cannot build advanced high end products like cars with slave labor. No car country on earth builds cars with slave labor

KilljoyTheTrucker | 2 hours ago

You dont do the actual assembly with it, no.

But the raw material functions heavily rely on both bonafide slaves, and near slave type employment. As you go down the line, it becomes more "normal" labor, as far as western countries would consider it "normal". But then the advantages shift to mostly self inflicted things, like over regulation, or nonsensical rules that are applied to make certain people more money because of their investment choices, rather than a care for constituency.

WordWithinTheWord | 3 hours ago

Yeah that’s my point. And it’s why manufacturing is largely dead today in western countries.

KilljoyTheTrucker | 3 hours ago

No, our choice under Clinton to globalized markets that were never before global is why.

We didn't have to start letting the third do slave labor for everything we wanted. We hide a lot of the downside in the idea that the extra handling is technically market activity. Despite the supply chain being itself much less efficient from a raw material to finished product path assessment.

animerobin | 3 hours ago

We do have domestic modernized industry though.

Hodgkisl | 5 hours ago

>Lead in infant blood is down by 96% since 1980

This has far more to do with removing lead from gasoline than anything industrial.

>Lung cancer is also down 95% for the same time frame.

In that time rates of smoking, exposure to second hand smoke, vehicle exhaust, etc... have also drastically improved; again not purely de-industrializing.

GWS2004 | 6 hours ago

And we moved those hazards into poorer countries.

DankDankJuice | 6 hours ago

Plus, now we can point at how high China’s emissions are and use that to excuse our lack of climate action

acatinasweater | 6 hours ago

To their credit, the US government is working on that lead deficit in Iowa.

JockoMayzon | 6 hours ago

Everyone smoked tobacco back then. Are you telling me the USA lacks the know how to run manufacturing without widespread pollution?

Appropriate-Bid8671 | 6 hours ago

Know how has never been the problem. Corporations don't want to pay the regulatory cost of not polluting.

derpymunchkin | 6 hours ago

They have the know how but the regulations are expensive. You could be making the same product 2x the cost in the U.S. vs in Bangladesh. Customers don’t care. They just want cheap.

JockoMayzon | 5 hours ago

Yes.
I had the occasion to get to know a gentleman whose family owns a large manufacturing plant in the USA. They reluctantly moved some of their manufacturing to China. He said the labor cost savings were canceled out by the higher shipping costs but the real cost savings were in not being held subject to employee safety regulations and community pollution regulations. No one in the USA was willing to pay more for a product that killed and injured fewer people- because those people live a world away and it's not in their news feed.

Fuddle | 5 hours ago

We traded cheaper goods so more people could buy them, for the well paying jobs that made those goods in the first place.

Are we better off? I guess it depends who is asking. Was it all worth it, and can we go back to much more expensive TVs, washing machines, clothing, toys, electronics...?

JockoMayzon | 4 hours ago

As the man said. "I can't eat my iPad"

animerobin | 3 hours ago

what year did you graduate high school

HumorAccomplished611 | an hour ago

My buddy was a newspaper machine tech at 18 in the late 70s. Got out of school making 17 an hour. I'm like man youre making more then now. We were making about 35 an hour.

MoonBatsRule | 5 hours ago

If you listen to the revisionists they will tell you that those jobs didn't move overseas, that they were automated.

Not sure where these automation factories are all located though.

JockoMayzon | 5 hours ago

This is an anecdote, but I think it applies.
There was a manufacturing plant in my state that designed, built and assembled auto sup-assemblies. Steering wheels were one of the items. Unlike the steering wheels of the 1960's and 1970's, today's are filled with electronic controls and fancy leather covers.
They moved the entire operation to Mexico, just a few miles over the border. A few of the worker from the USA plant were flown in to teach the Mexican workers how to run the machines. Those Mexican workers were paid $50 a week.

MoonBatsRule | 4 hours ago

I agree that the manufacturing was moved. Automation has always been a part of manufacturing in the US. We moved from Lucy and Ethyl putting chocolates into boxes by hand to Laverne & Shirley watching the bottling machines put caps on bottles. Yes, the automation reduces the need for manual work, but it doesn't eliminate the facility, and there are still so many jobs that continue to be there (including maintaining the machines). Automation tends to happen gradually, too.

But there has been wholesale revisionism, particularly on Reddit, saying that jobs didn't move overseas, they were automated. It's bunk. There are dozens of empty factory buildings near me, in New England, that were operating 25 years ago. They're gone. The products say "Made in China" on them.

I do appreciate, I suppose thanks to Trump's ham-handed tariff impositions, that there are benefits from having lower-cost goods, often made in other countries, and that the US public is not ready for a rapid increase in prices that would accompany an "America-only" manufacturing policy. I also think that in the past 25 years, from when this all started, workers have adapted. The people that got really screwed were the people 25 years ago, when the factories actually closed. They were left to dry.

I can also see the vulnerabilities we have by not making certain things in this country, having them made in a country that has different global goals than the US. If China decided to, for example, invade Taiwan, Japan, Philippines, etc., we probably would want to try and stop them, even via sanctions. Could we survive cutting off all trade with them? I doubt it.

I think that there is room for sensible trade restrictions. Trump is not the person to achieve that though, especially since he is very clearly trying to personally profit from this presidency, and that is what drives his actions.

YaDunGoofed | 4 hours ago

Would you rather assemble copiers domestically and have the Chinese companies run the worlds internet?

JockoMayzon | 4 hours ago

False choice.

YaDunGoofed | 4 hours ago

Ok. Which current US labor would you exchange to China for your assembly plant.

JockoMayzon | 4 hours ago

Why must there be an exchange?

YaDunGoofed | 4 hours ago

Because that’s how labor works.

Otherwise we have to have autarky. Autarky means an American has to collect cocoa for chocolate.

Those people currently get paid $5/wk. Do you want an American getting paid that or do you want chocolate to cost 40x more.

…or do we outsource SOME needs to focus on the highest value added labor.

Both_Lynx_8750 | 6 hours ago

more than that american wages are always going to be higher than normal until we untie healthcare and employment

Useful_Argument_6490 | 5 hours ago

I was in a manufacturing centric field and a lot of those roles have been automated. It was dirty, dangerous work and automation is fantastic. Our society just hasn’t caught up.

elebrin | 5 hours ago

Also, the factories are employing highly skilled workers who need to understand a complex process. Factory work isn't screwing a nut on a bolt or pushing a shuttle on a loom any more.

To have American factories building things in a modern way requires smaller numbers of well educated, well trained factory workers that can't as easily be replaced. American companies do NOT like to put upfront capitol into training workers. They like workers and employment situations where an employee can be shitcanned whenever, replaced by some random guy off the street, and zero productivity is lost. If training is necessary, they expect that the employee will get the training themselves, on their own dollar. That's what modern college and vocational programs are.

lastdeadmouse | 5 hours ago

That is a very blanket view of the manufacturing that is missing a lot of nuance.

Regardless, our laws do not need to cater to companies' wants and could have fair trade requirements built in. If free trade is just used to capitalize on and extract from other countries it hurts many on both sides and only benefits the company.

DecisionDelicious170 | 6 hours ago

MAGA lives on hopium. Try explaining that even if manufacturing came back, the jobs won’t due to automation. And if the jobs did come back, they aren’t worth having in an anti-union environment.

Blank stares.

OptionConcoction | 5 hours ago

Automation requires workers, not as many but they're higher pay skill positions. And it isn't just a workforce to consider. There are national security implications with some manufacturing and those plants throw off a lot of property taxes for the local communities (schools in particular in many states).

chumpandchive | 7 hours ago

it's like you're saying corporate america intentionally created the "immigrants are taking your jobs" divide to shield themselves from the repurcussions🧐

carlos_the_dwarf_ | 5 hours ago

Huh? Skepticism of immigration and romanticism for manufacturing jobs go together—they’re rooted in the same fallacy.

chumpandchive | 2 hours ago

sorry, forgot the /s

hybridaaroncarroll | 7 hours ago

The small-minds around us have always blamed unions for driving jobs overseas.

Wise-Peanut9552 | 6 hours ago

If it makes you feel better unions are basically irrelevant in the US job market. They are a tiny percent of the working population and it would be trivial to start manufacturing in weak union states.

The problem is the infrastructure is crap, the workers are expensive, and the regulatory environment is challenging and inconsistent.

When you add in the high capital cost, low roi, and long capital return timeliness manufacturing is very difficult to raise money for in the US. Telling investors that you can 10x their funds in 10-15 years with a $20 mm investment typically gets people asking why you can't do it 3x faster, for 1/3 the upfront cost. Hiring 3 guys with lap tops to code the next SAAS start-up is much more palatable.

Appropriate-Bid8671 | 6 hours ago

And the inevitable outcome of the current system will be continued decline in quality until collapse.

Flimsy_Share_7606 | 6 hours ago

As long as it isn't next quarter then that isn't a real problem.

No-Understanding9064 | 6 hours ago

I made this point the other day. Venture has not had a real appetite for hard asset business since SaaS introduced low marginal cost scaling

Wise-Peanut9552 | 5 hours ago

It's actually a real problem.  I've been working for 20 years to get various US manufacturing plants off the ground and aside from finding a wealthy person who is passionate about US manufacturing there are very few viable paths.

The industrial warehouse space has gotten very expensive.  Tenant finish has gone up ridiculously. I'm working on a rare earth processing facility currently that it mostly paid for by government grants because just the build out and permitting before any operation starts is going to be close to 5 years and tens of millions. That's before you start buying equipment and training staff how to do the work. If I was trying to do this to build toasters there would be no funding because even if there is money to be made no one is passionate enough to front the initial cost on the hope of a payout.

BernedTendies | 6 hours ago

I mean, it didn’t help. Higher wages demanded, healthcare, pensions, safer working conditions, 5 day work weeks, etc. I’m not saying the unions were wrong for pursuing those modern work practices but each one of those is worse for the overall cheap output of goods

Unions did make up a decent size of the labor force and they’re probably too small now to make any impact/influence

VeteranSergeant | 4 hours ago

What "didn't help" was Congress and Presidents, usually driven by Republicans, constantly chipping away at labor power, and cozying up to the businesses and their wealthiest shareholders.

What "didn't help" were people like Reagan. Not the union workers demanding a more equitable share of the profits.

BernedTendies | 3 hours ago

Reagan definitely didn't help either, no argument there. My point is regardless of the politics, those union demands inevitably drive up the cost of production on the American side, making it much more expensive to manufacture goods here. Saying that had no impact is not a serious response to me

chumpandchive | 6 hours ago

wait when did it change from immigrants to unions? i must hate incorrectly at all times. accuracy matters

/s

VeteranSergeant | 4 hours ago

It changed to immigrants once enough of the unions were broken up.

chumpandchive | 2 hours ago

thank you for corrrcting my historical record. updated. fuck reagan

hybridaaroncarroll | 6 hours ago

Oh it's immigrants too. They'll literally blame anything that's not the actual cause.

YaDunGoofed | 4 hours ago

They’ve certainly been a significant contributor to the rust in rust belt.

There’s a reason most all big car plants are south of Louisville KY

toeknn | 5 hours ago

Unions arent blameless. The amount of union strikes the second an automotive group finally sees profit is pretty darn high.

ThaCarter | 6 hours ago

Chinese labor is no longer cheap.

Hodgkisl | 6 hours ago

Far more than wages, regulatory compliance, bureaucratic inefficiencies, supply chains, energy costs, energy reliability, etc… all contribute.

I work at an American manufacturer, working on year 6 of applying for a 5 year operating permit; every time employees change at regulating agency we have to pay our team to update them on all that’s happened; they call / email every question without reading mountains of past data, etc…

shwaynebrady | 6 hours ago

That’s part of it, but there’s a lot more that goes into the equation. The other half is the US is a still a manufacturing powerhouse. China has overtaken us, but we are still in 2nd place by a long shot. And on a per capita bias are manufacturing more than china. At least in terms of value.

Go look at the steel plant beachfront in Gary Indiana right on Lake Michigan and ask yourself if that’s really the direction you want the country to move back towards.

We had a good answer with data center buildouts. They required construction, skilled trades, engineers, infrastructure, power development, hardware, techs etc. real tangible resources that capital was being spent on. But people bought into Chinese and Russian propaganda and treat data centers the same way nuclear energy was treated in the past.

Interesting-Cod6486 | 6 hours ago

Then invite a data center into your neighborhood crash your property value and destroy any quality of life in the area for almost no jobs

modzRtarderz | 3 hours ago

Or we could just build them in bumbfuck nowhere instead, since the eventual plan is modular reactors for power anyways. And since we're in an economics forum, we should recognize the jobs and tax income created outperforms pretty much any alternative use of that land. But those datacenters are also receiving the same pushback, due to the same propaganda (which is rooted in some truth, as all good propaganda is).

shwaynebrady | 6 hours ago

There are plenty of jobs created, like automotive, there are suppliers and contractors, it’s a whole ecosystem and data centers aren’t popping up in the middle of suburban cities.

I’m not arguing it’s all sunshine and rainbows, but what do people think manufacturing or other heavy industrial works are? By comparison data centers are so much better in almost every way.

It should have never been “no data centers” which is the equivalent to “defund the police”. But unfortunately common sense doesn’t win elections these days.

Interesting-Cod6486 | 6 hours ago

Plenty of jobs? some to build out then a few to maintain plus the jobs being replaced by the data center so negative many thousands of jobs

shwaynebrady | 6 hours ago

Some to build and a few to maintain? Do you have any idea what you’re talking about?

Interesting-Cod6486 | 6 hours ago

Google says 150 to 300 plus for a giant data center so not a lot look up how many employees a factory of a similar footprint  employs.

shwaynebrady | 6 hours ago

So that’s the only equivalent? A factory that produces what exactly? Automation is the future whether you can accept that or not, go look at how many people used to staff fords route river plant and how many people staff those plants today.

150-300 high skilled jobs is nothing to scoff at either. How many people does an equivalent farm staff?

And how about to build? It’s takes years and thousands of construction workers, engineers, techs etc. People need to design the cooling systems, the power systems, the cable, the data racks, the hardware, the safety systems, the HVAC etc. people need to maintain those systems.

Interesting-Cod6486 | 6 hours ago

If there that valuable build a company town in the middle of the woods not a small town  then people would not complain build there own infrastructure but they would rather bribe steal and destroy people who can't defend themselves.

shwaynebrady | 6 hours ago

Unbelievable. You have swallowed the propaganda root, stem and all.

They are literally doing that, how long do you think it takes to build a power plant from the ground up in the US? Zoning alone takes years and that’s even assuming they get approval.

And then where are they going to find the construction workers, local companies, engineers, suppliers etc to support these operations? Again, that takes a ton of time but there are dozens of these plans currently in the works.

People wonder why no one wants to build in the US anymore. Or make huge capital investments or try to bring back jobs. It’s largely because people like you just want something, anything, to be angry about.

EmperorChaos | 4 hours ago

Do you think modern highly automated factories (which are the only ones that would be built in 2026) are going to require that many employees?

Interesting-Cod6486 | 4 hours ago

By definition yes they have machines making things which is always going to take more  than a few it guys to pull burned out parts and the security team trying to stop all the desperate townfolk who's energy bills have tripled, ground water is contaminated property value plummets  and have not slept in 6 months from the 24 hour " emergency"  jet turbines generators.

EmperorChaos | 4 hours ago

Even with all those guards in your weird fictional story, it won’t be as many people being employed as in the past.

If manufacturing comes back to the west it will be in highly automated dark factories like China has right now, so I guess those poor townsfolk of yours won’t get any manufacturing jobs then.

MSDOS401 | 5 hours ago

Seeing the factorys being built again would be great. I would love to see men and women working, building things that I can buy. I would love to be able to buy made in America again for all of my everyday essentials.

OptionConcoction | 5 hours ago

Unions also made it challenging to pivot and innovate. Corporate America wasn't a perfect citizen but neither were the unions.

Hugsy13 | 5 hours ago

This is just plain not true.

It’s the 2020’s, not 00’s or 90’s anymore.

Manufacturing in China these days need stuff all people. A lot of their factories these days require hardly any people and are known as “dark factories” because they don’t need lighting for workers.

Their factories these days are don’t largely by robots. Robots don’t need lighting for workers to work mostly, and when they do, the robot has a light on it.

The US sold out their factories in the 70’s 80’s and 90’s to save on human costs, and that was extremely profitable for shareholders holders for a while.

But lots and lots of manufacturing has undergone a renaissance since then. Where modern tech and robotics has taken over the human aspect for a fraction of the cost.

China has capitalised on this. The US, which sold out their factories decades ago, has not.

Besides the human cost, a large part of the cost is energy/electricity cost.

Solar is cheaper than ever and way cheaper than coal oil or gas. But the US isn’t interested in solar.

Energy/electricity is cheaper than ever in China because they’re constantly building fuck loads of solar.

When you build a car park, instead of a normal roof, you can make the roof out of solar panels, build a factory or warehouse, roof covered with solar panels. Tons of electricity from solar by just putting it on the roof. Don’t need solar farms. Just cover buildings and car parks with solar panels. The US isn’t interested in this.

Australia is covering the country with solar panels, and also has huge government credits for batteries too. Solar power fills the network, excess fills the batteries, the batteries cover the network once the sun goes down, electricity is not only cheap but sometimes free or you get paid for it. You can buy and install a battery and make money.

Australia is planning on bringing back some manufacturing with that free energy and negative cost energy. USA could do the same thing but they’re years behind and don’t want to promote green energy. It’s crazy

SouthNo2807 | 6 hours ago

That’s just the result, do you know why? People choose clean air over pollution and passed all sorts of regulation bills. More and more regulations created an environment that’s impossible for manufacturers to profit. Only specific high added value sectors or the ones that are highly automated are still here.  It’s not like the suddenly decided to move everything overseas. I don’t know which generation are you from? But if you ask anyone who lived in the 70s they remember the smog over most major cities.

samandiriel | 6 hours ago

>that’s impossible for manufacturers to profit.

Untrue. It just makes their profits smaller as they have to pay fair wages, benefits, etc. It also increases prices, which means consumers buy less and look for products that last as opposed to today's ludicrously wasteful consumption churn rate (see: fast fashion, planned obsolescence, etc).

I wish to heavens above and depths below I could buy furniture from a chain store that isn't made from chip board and will disintegrate within two years, or a paper shredder that doesn't die after exactly 3000 runs

eetsumkaus | 6 hours ago

The two are connected. Smaller profit means higher opportunity cost. If you push that opportunity cost too high, the money will go somewhere else.

samandiriel | 5 hours ago

Doesn't invalidate my point - just defines a limiting factor.

Wise-Peanut9552 | 6 hours ago

You can buy all that stuff today. Here is a couch made from actual steel mostly in the US and Mexico.

https://www.flexsteel.com

Unfortunately, the last time I looked a couch was $3,000. But the one I own has made it 20 years and they are still building them the same way. They are available at a lot of chain furniture stores.

But how many people can afford a 4 figure couch?

Lazy e boy is the same way mostly made in the US and Mexico but stupid expensive for the average person.

samandiriel | 5 hours ago

> You can buy all that stuff today. Here is a couch made from actual steel mostly in the US and Mexico.

Yes, you can. At specialty stores, such as you just linked to. That was why I was careful to add the caveat of department stores/big box stores to my argument.

I can and do pay for but it once stuff. It would nonetheless be cheaper if we didn't have an economy that prioritized quantity over quality as a function of late stage capitalism and cheap overseas labor, as demand would be higher for said higher quality goods.

Wise-Peanut9552 | 5 hours ago

That's what I was trying to tell you flexsteel isn't a specialty store thing. They are at normal stores all over.

https://www.woodleys.com/item/pulse-power-reclining-sofa-w-immersive-sound-tech/103534174

It's less speciality store than Ikea is.

samandiriel | 5 hours ago

I've never even heard of Woodleys. What are we counting as a normal store? Me, I'm looking at places like dept stores (Macy's, Sears, etc) or big big stores (Ashley, IKEA, etc.)

My own baseline is western Canada and the US, here, so obviously our mileage will vary.

Wise-Peanut9552 | 5 hours ago

Apparently,  they are a local chain with 8 locations in Colorado. I thought they were bigger.

https://www.wayfair.com/Flexsteel--Finnegan-Power-Inclining-Sofa-XTYA1638-L305-K~XTYA1638.html

Wayfair should be large and national enough.

I've never bought furniture at a Macy's or a sears I thought they mostly sold clothing and tools. Ikea is about as much of a specialty store as you'll find since they only sell their stuff. Ashley or American Furniture would be major retailers.

I've seen flexsteel at American furniture but their inventory changes frequently. Living Spaces is a large regional chain in 9 states and they carry it. I guess because it seems less inventory you won't find it in major box stores since they are looking to sell hundreds of pieces per day and there isn't demand for very expensive furniture.

I guess that's our core difference.  There is very little demand for expensive furnature so you won't find it in places that have high volume.  You're only considering high volume as places where it exists and back in the days when Long life furnature was common those stores didn't exist because they couldn't make money so it was only small regional chains at best.

samandiriel | 4 hours ago

> There is very little demand for expensive furnature so you won't find it in places that have high volume.

That is the point of my argument. If we didn't live in a disposable culture, driven to extreme by American style capitalism and in no small part to off shoring, there would far more demand. If cheap, crappy furniture was not as prevalent (thanks to off shoring in order to take advantage of economic and social imbalances), the price gap would be much closer, and likely whole pricing tiers of cheap crappy furniture simply wouldn't exist.

Which in any but the shortest term viewpoint would be of the most benefit generally.

Wise-Peanut9552 | 3 hours ago

I'm not sure if I agree with you.  A person making 40k per year is never going to spend 10% of their income on a couch.  They are much more likely to use milk creates boards. It's certainly what I did in college when I couldn't air real furnature.  A desk was four 2x4 from home depot and some plywood.

Even in the 50s and 60s at the peak of middle class wealth people were still looking for the cheapest way to stretch a buck.  All that getting rid of cheap furnature will do is destroy demand it won't shift it to more expensive pieces.

derpymunchkin | 6 hours ago

Lower profits mean less money for the stockholders. Who do you think gets kicked out if the company doesn’t make enough money? Capitalism incentivizes this.

samandiriel | 6 hours ago

> Lower profits mean less money for the stockholders.

That's my point, yes.

> Who do you think gets kicked out if the company doesn’t make enough money? Capitalism incentivizes this.

No, capitalism doesn't require it. Corporatism/neoliberalism drives this part.

derpymunchkin | 6 hours ago

Capitalism is about maximizing profits and minimizing costs.

samandiriel | 5 hours ago

For an elementary school level definition of capitalism, absolutely.

Well below the bar for an economics forum discussion, however, which is where we're at.

derpymunchkin | 5 hours ago

But nevertheless it’s still capitalism? neoliberalism and corporatism are different models of capitalism. It sounds like we categorizing what a blue whale is, I say that it’s an animal, and you say that akshually it’s a mammal. Ok?

samandiriel | 5 hours ago

Sure. Obviously all theories, models and practices of capitalism are functionally identical, with identical outcomes. Economics has not produced anything new since Adam Smith. Case closed.

derpymunchkin | 5 hours ago

Your first sentence was: capitalism doesn’t require it. It’s wrong. Admit this. Then you could construct as many theories and models of capitalism as you want.

montaire_work | 4 hours ago

You can. Lots of handcrafted stuff gets sold. Even costco will sell some from time to time.

Its just INCREDIBLY expensive.

pinkflirtyy | 6 hours ago

[ Removed by Reddit ]

lopix | 6 hours ago

Even if it were to cost the same to manufacture in the US, the cost to move everything is not something they're willing to spend. Corporations have had decades to build new factories, creating new supply lines, entrench the way they do things. It makes zero sense for them to upend everything to move it all back to the US, especially when it would cost a ton to make the move and then cost a ton to manufacture there. Profit is EVERYTHING and they will not sacrifice one penny to help Americans over shareholders.

pandabearak | 5 hours ago

Why would they move them back when

  1. all the machines to do the work is overseas. The machine that rolls the crayons in that Sesame Street video? That was sold, too. All the automated parts of manufacturing is in a country that isn’t the USA, and we aren’t buying those back. Without those, we can’t bring most of these “good” manufacturing jobs back, either.

  2. no American wants to spend more money because it’s “made in America”. If they do, it’s performative and temporary. Everything from toilet paper to socket wrenches. If Americans cared about paying more for American made products, Hobby Lobby, Harbor Freight, and Walmart would be the first to feel the pain. Last time I checked, they are doing just fine.

TimSylvester_ | 4 hours ago

Wouldn't it be cool if we had a fully vertical and horizontal economy, so that we could be economically independent from the dirt to the sky, but at the same time maintained robust trade with a globally diverse network of economic and political allies, helping to reinforce each others' economies, diversify choice, and provide resilience in case of interruptions or complications?

Or we could just go super narrow, milk it for all its worth, send all the profit uphill to the wealthy, run it into the ground, then blame someone else.

ZipBoxer | 3 hours ago

and we're all richer for it, not just the Epstein class.

animerobin | 3 hours ago

The way everyone talks about American manufacturing is like it's 1987.

Before Trump, America had the highest per capita manufacturing output in the world. We build a lot of stuff here. We also don't have very low unemployment. And on average, Americans are very wealthy and enjoy regular luxuries more often than any other citizens of any other country.

The jobs building cars and toasters left decades ago, probably before a lot of us here were born. The people most affected by that are elderly and retired now. Working age people work in different jobs, a lot of which are much nicer and better paying than working on an assembly line.

The idea that America sold all its jobs overseas and now there are no jobs just isn't true and hasn't been true for a long time. The world changed, and on average, it has gotten better. Trying to bring back jobs building toasters is dumb. Heck, even China is not the impoverished third world country it used to be. It has a huge middle class now that enjoys American level luxuries. They build AI chips and electric cars now. Their workers are paid decently and not all working in sweatshops (obviously some are, but they are putting together Temu plastic crap, not building electric cars). A lot of the really low level manufacturing isn't done in China anymore because their wages rose and it's not that cheap anymore.

People complaining about offshoring are fighting a battle that ended when we were kids. Like it seems like we're about to build a sentient supercomputer. That seems like a bigger deal than you not being able to get a job hammering metal pieces in a factory because we built a robot that can do that in 2003.

OrangeJr36 | 6 hours ago

It could be that.

Or it could be because the US doesn't have the population, the cheap currency, the willingness to pollute every city and river, and most importantly a lack of modern labor saving technology.

OrangeJr36 | 6 hours ago

Repeating a comment I made over a year ago:

Adding more manufacturing capacity was always going to include increasing levels of automation, anyone who wants more manufacturing in the US has to accept that reality.

The middle class manufacturing jobs of the past were mostly killed off by automation, killing more off will only increase US manufacturing output.

The dream of somehow seizing the past and getting those jobs back was a pipe dream sold by conmen.

Those factories that employed thousands of young men with little to no education are long gone and modern factories employ engineers, roboticists and a few dozen custodians.

ncroofer | 3 hours ago

They also employ machinists, electricians, control techs and general maintenance and those are all good jobs. But you are correct they are much less numerous than in the past. A half a billion dollar plant may require 40 maintenance personnel

spikey_wombat | 2 hours ago

This. If we're going to get more manufacturing, it's going to similar to the dark factories China has where huge numbers of robots are doing the work in the dark with a very small human crew running the operations and performing robot maintenance.

maporita | 6 hours ago

The idea that manufacturing in the US has declined is a myth. By value it's as strong as ever. What's happened is that it's changed. Instead of making refrigerators and washing machines we now build jet engines and microchips.

As countries get richer their manufacturing sector moves from low tech to high tech. This is generally a good thing since it adds more value and the jobs are better paid. But it requires fewer workers and those workers need better skills. The ones who lose the most are the low skilled employees who would normally be working on an assembly line .. those jobs are now done overseas, or by robots. The solution is not to mourn those positions but to focus on how we can give all our workers the education they need to compete on the world stage.

UncleGreenwood | 6 hours ago

An inconvenient reality I rarely see discussed is that a huge portion of the human population is simply incapable of ever having such high skill jobs/training. A lot of people just aren’t cut out to be engineers or devs or whatever.

Your suggestion sounds nice on paper but I don’t think it’s an actual solution. I’m not trying to be misanthropic, I hope I’m wrong but my personal experience bears this out

Rock-n-RollingStart | 6 hours ago

The people who hold the mindset that "we're a high-level service economy and we just need to educate everyone" haven't learned diddly squat since 2016. That's because they view themselves as the educated elite, and they're completely divorced from the reality that a country that can't produce its own basic needs has absolutely no resilience. One black swan event is all it takes to send you right back to 1850.

joepez | 5 hours ago

You fail to mention that a the probability of a truly devastating black swan event is incredibly low. Even the example you used was tackled quickly by modern tech. We recovered just fine. In fact the whole situation would have been better if the scientists and grown ups were allowed to do their jobs without political one upmanship and grift getting in the way.

We’ve had plenty of these kinds of disruptive events over history and while our overall arc may have been disrupted we’re still here. You can’t plan your economy around unknown events.

Rock-n-RollingStart | 4 hours ago

And yet we just had the entire COVID fiasco where there was a single country making N95 masks for the entire planet in the middle of a pandemic. How well do you think the health system would have fared if China told us to pound sand because they needed all their PPE production for themselves? They're threatening rare earth production now, and that will hurt far more than the military industrial complex.

Incredibly shortsighted.

SkiingAway | an hour ago

> They're threatening rare earth production now, and that will hurt far more than the military industrial complex.

The US is making some progress at reviving that industry domestically. Long way to go, but something that is actually moving in the right direction.

daft_trump | 5 hours ago

What is a black swan event. I feel like we've been through some shit.

Rock-n-RollingStart | 5 hours ago

Something localized and devastating that no one could directly predict. COVID nearly did it, but the fact that the entire global economy suffered at the same time meant that no single link in the chain broke.

If a Category 5 hurricane hits Houston, that's it for American oil distribution. If a Carrington event hits North America, where are we going to get millions of electrical transformers to rebuild the grid? Hey, China, we really need you to ramp up production for us, after all, we've been handling all the financing! If a rogue AI agent cripples the banking system, all hell will break loose.

Defendyouranswer | 4 hours ago

A carrington style event would do it

StickFree1359 | 6 hours ago

Yeah, that is why the ai bulls were saying that UBI might be required. Also remember that all those people who lost their jobs due to foreign competition and automation overwhelmingly voted for tariffs and isolationism as a response.

azelll | 6 hours ago

I love that apparently the goal of the tech bros guys will be actual communism.  like guys, just pay your damn taxes and we can have a normal mix of western socialist/capitalist society, I am done with dystopian futures

-JBWentworth | 5 hours ago

Tech bros want to bring back feudalism.

No-Understanding9064 | 5 hours ago

Technology has been increasing labor efficiency since the industrial revolution began. The result is labor constantly needing to upskill to be relevant.

-JBWentworth | 5 hours ago

I think AI will remove that ability permanently.

dopechez- | 4 hours ago

Yeah, anything a human can learn to do, AI can learn to do in a fraction of the time.

No-Understanding9064 | 4 hours ago

AI still needs purpose. It is still software even though it is capable of probability analysis far beyond human

Mayor__Defacto | an hour ago

Can’t offshore construction.

joepez | 5 hours ago

Your point about people’s skill level limits is correct, however what is your solution outside of UBI?

We can’t just “invent” jobs for low-skill/motivation workers that pay a localized fair wage. A manufacturer can’t dumb down their lines to keep people employed while losing out in the market. Even operating at a razor thing margin wouldn’t work over time.

So as much as it is true what do you propose other than UBI?

pywang | 4 hours ago

I mean what are people doing now? Primarily, the U.S. is a service economy. The commenter is right about manufacturing getting upskilled and leaving people behind. Educating everyone then managing to assign them jobs that they want in their location is tough too. Allocation and personal desire, right.

Even in China with the brutal education system, there just aren’t enough high skilled jobs to go around, not everyone wants to be educated, but no one wants to do back breaking work anymore. 1) manufacturing is getting upskilled and china is losing manufacturing of low end products out of sheer competition and wage and 2) tons of educated youth don’t even want to enter the manufacturing space, choosing a less back breaking service economy job, a lot of which is delivering food. The pattern is simply repeating America, even if America accelerated its hollowing out of manufacturing, it was bound to happen (we just also happened to lose out on the ecosystem as a whole, not just that we lost jobs).

The low wage will be utilized and taken advantage of somehow. However, it can’t be back breaking. As generations get better living standards, they refuse to do lower standard, back breaking work. Exemplary to this is the farming and shrimping communities in the U.S., and manufacturing lines in China.

Unlike China, America’s answer is immigration for back breaking work, and creating service economy businesses that take advantage of American’s globally relatively high but locally low wage. I guess this is in response to your “fair wage” point, but I doubt we’ll be able to have fair wages. Wages are only fair in respect to the cost, so maybe the solution isn’t wage but domestic policies to lowering cost of living.

8ngryW0lf999 | 3 hours ago

For China, it means advanced robots doing most of the physically intensive work.

Mamasugadex | 22 minutes ago

Well, as they said, people don’t want back breaking jobs. Not in China and definitely not in US.

What people want is doing low skilled service job such as handing out flyers at Walmart or passing small items on a convey belt at the factory, and hoping to be paid the equivalent of high skilled labor such as jet engine mechanics or healthcare providers, without the effort of getting that higher leveled skills in the first place.

That’s why Redditor constantly complain about 2 things: wage theft/wage not being able to maintain a high quality of life, and lack of “free” healthcare that is supposedly funded mostly by someone else’s money. The fantasy is someone with a big heart will bring UBI and universal healthcare for all, which ultimately will close that gap to achieve that goal.

The average Redditor users have zero clue what real lives of delivery person and factory workers in China actually looks like. They don’t even have a chance to bitch about microplastics the way Redditors do. They just live in it due to lack of choice and platform to really vent.

Liizam | 4 hours ago

You can absolutely make jobs for low skill worker. Our infrastructure is crumbling. Just have a fix pit holes workforce would employee people forever. Not sure why out taxes can’t just pay people to fix infrastructure

stoneman30 | 3 hours ago

Your right and we do have jobs for low skill workers. But people aren't happy about the pay which led us to this whole MAGA thing (and probably WWII, the fall of Rome and everything). I also don't think we can do anything about it.

Liizam | 3 hours ago

Absolutely can do a lot about it. Start electing progressive leaders in your local elections.

I don’t understand why we can’t have a new new deal. Government absolutely can employee people and pay them well. Why does everything have to go to private companies? Cut private contracts and pay employees of the gov to fix our infrastructure

Kershiser22 | 2 hours ago

> Government absolutely can employee people and pay them well.

Pay them to do what? Can we actually generate enough tax revenue to pay unskilled people to do unnecessary jobs?

Private companies also have employees. If you cut private contracts then those employees lose jobs.

Mayor__Defacto | an hour ago

Filling potholes isn’t actually the correct way to repair that particular type of damage. It’s only a temporary fix until the correct fix can be done.

dopechez- | 4 hours ago

Robots will soon be able to do most jobs though. Paying people to do them less efficiently won't make sense.

VeteranSergeant | an hour ago

Only from a limited viewpoint does it "not make sense."

Ultimately, human society won't function on "maximum efficiency" without a level of totalitarian control. You're falling into a very common form of big picture blindness where you look at small-scale short-term goals like "We can maximize profits by reducing labor overhead" and not looking at the long-term macro picture of "What do we do with all the people once we've replaced too many of them with robots."

Robots aren't consumers. Well, yet. Robots can do the work, but they don't then take the wages they make from that work and use it to purchase goods and services.

dopechez- | an hour ago

Human society is a giant game theory simulation. A bunch of individual actors pursuing their self interest. Each individual company will replace their human workers as soon as it's economically viable to do so, the impact on the macro economy is not going to factor into it

Gullible_Bicycle_853 | 4 hours ago

I think the other outcome of this situation is the declining birth rate.  People/families that don’t have the skills/income are being priced out of having children.

Mayor__Defacto | an hour ago

That’s not true. The people who aren’t having kids aren’t the poor, it’s the upper middle class.

allez2015 | 4 hours ago

I've said a few times "The Machine needs meat to operate." Essentially, not everybody can be a brainiac high skilled Masters degree specialist even if the resources and opportunity were provided. That's not how humans work. That's not how the world operates (at least until AI and robotics can make a convincing low cost humanoid). As the economy is currently structured, it requires low skilled labor at least in some capacity.

OnlyInAmerica01 | 5 hours ago

A lot of those people end up on Reddit posting leftist garbage. "I can't survive in a world that requires intelligence, discipline and useful skills" is replaced with "End stage capitalism!" and "Viva la revolucion!". It's just their "Sad song" playing on repeat...

teshh | 6 hours ago

It's not a myth. Fed data clearly shows huge declines in manufacturing since the 80s. If we needed 10 super tanker vessels right now, the us simply couldn't manufacture them.

Similar story across a wide range of products. We barely make chips, not enough to negate the mass importing of them we do.

Smooth_Phone2 | 6 hours ago

It depends on what you’re measuring.

By value, it’s up, by non-carbon emissions, it’s down, by employment, it’s down.

espressocycle | 6 hours ago

Two different things. It's great to produce high value stuff, but it's not so great to outsource the manufacturing of essentials so that you're dependent on other countries.

Smooth_Phone2 | 5 hours ago

It’s not possible to make a single product 100% domestically unless you literally mean a rough-hewn plank or something. There is a literal book about trying to make a chicken sandwich from scratch - it’s a good read.

To your point, friendshoring (having supply chains or atleast critical parts of them) in friendly territories (domestic, Canada, Mexico, Japan, Europe, etc) is helpful.

Unfortunately, this admin has severed a lot of the supply chains in friendly territory (including domestically) so… that’s a choice!

Nearby-Chocolate1840 | 5 hours ago

If you mean it isn't practical cost-wise on a consumer-facing level then that seems pretty fair to say, but it's definitely possible. The DoD has stipulations about exactly this for certain tools, components, and materials.

Smooth_Phone2 | 5 hours ago

Sorry, I should have been more clear.

It’s not possible to make a single product of arbitrary complexity 100% domestically. There will always be materials and components and coatings and other things that are single sourced to a non domestic company somewhere, even if it’s tier 10 component.

It would be hellishly expensive to get to 95% domestic. It wouldn’t be possible to get to 100%.

This is true for the US and China, and is even more true as you get to middle/lower tier powers.

Nearby-Chocolate1840 | 4 hours ago

What exactly do you mean by a product of arbitrary complexity? Can you provide examples?

Likewise a tier 10 component. These are terms I'm unfamiliar with.

Smooth_Phone2 | 4 hours ago

Sure. Anything of any significant complexity.

We can directly cut street down with men with hand built saws. You can’t use a chainsaw though, that’s global components!

You couldn’t build a lawnmower using only domestically sourced parts and domestically sourced tools. You could build the capacity (expensive and slow), but you couldn’t build a lawnmower domestically today.

Tiers refer to the level in the supply chain.

General Motors is a OEM.
Enova premier is a tier 1 who provides assembled wheels to GM.
Dunlop is a tier 2 who provides tires to enova premier.
Bobs charcoal company is a tier 3 who provides charcoal to Dunlop.

Etc etc etc

Nearby-Chocolate1840 | 3 hours ago

Ok.

Then I'll repeat again: while it's true that this isn't done for consumer projects, due to cost considerations, it absolutely is done for (some, not all) US military hardware. Which is precisely why so much of that hardware is as expensive as it is.

Furthermore, the US absolutely could, if it decided to, manufacture lawnmowers domestically from start to finish. And with only a couple months of lead time.

Those lawnmowers would be far, far more expensive than anything you'd buy from Home Depot. But the capacity is there, if there's a perceived need based on national security. Though why that would apply to lawnmowers would be anyone's guess.

espressocycle | an hour ago

You're describing the problem, not how it has to be.

teshh | 5 hours ago

Well obviously as resources are geographically dependent, but that doesn't mean you have to ignore manufacturing.

Certain things you need to be able to manufacture at home.

Smooth_Phone2 | 5 hours ago

My position isn’t “you have to ignore manufacturing”.

My position is “you can’t make a product of arbitrary complexity 100% domestically”.

I agree it would be stupid to ignore manufacturing.

espressocycle | an hour ago

It's absolutely possible. We did it for the better part of 100 years. The US had to import certain commodities like rubber, but it didn't import finished products apart from very niche specialties for the wealthy. China makes almost everything today from raw materials to finished products.

froz3nt | 30 minutes ago

Nominally its up. But total output is not up proportionally. Its less than 20% of total world output. It used to be around half.

OptionConcoction | 5 hours ago

There is a perception issue. Kansas is viewed as a farming state but when it comes to GDP or the biggest employer, or the biggest tax base the answer is aviation. Lots of big plane manufacturers in the Wichita area and what folks even in Kansas may not realize is that some small shops get work from those plants as far away as Independence KS. They're a bigger footprint than people realize but lots of manufacturers are some large tin building that people drive by and don't realize is creating important stuff.

cheefMM | 6 hours ago

Having higher education not cost a year or two of salary would be a good start

Eating_Astros_9677 | 5 hours ago

There was a thread on AskEconomics yesterday which pointed out that higher-educating a high-tech / highly skilled population (like engineers and doctors) costs substantially more in tooling/resources/teacher wages than educating lower-skilled jobs like accountants, educators, media, etc. Thus, as the ratio of high-skilled jobs and graduates vs low skilled rises, as /u/maporita says we are aiming/headed towards, the cost of higher education must rise.

This was the thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEconomics/comments/1xytkk5/what_makes_college_in_the_us_so_expensive/

cheefMM | 5 hours ago

Then I guess the elites will keep getting richer while the rest of stay poors

modzRtarderz | 3 hours ago

Oh come the fuck on, an engineer making $150k / yr is not a fucking 'elite'.

cheefMM | 3 hours ago

I would consider them a poor as they most likely are paying off $60-90k in student loan debt and $150k/yr. In fact I would say you’re not an elite if you’re not raking in more than $10M/yr and don’t have to work really cause your money is working for you. Sorry engineer, you’re a poor like the rest of us

evantom34 | 5 hours ago

Buffett cited this briefly when referencing the specialized economy. Although it’s easy to spout populist drivel, America is home to extremely talented individuals that move here from all across the world.

Juicecalculator | 6 hours ago

People always forget about food manufacturing. Not a great phrasing, but processed food manufacturing is here to stay whether people like it in theory or not.

Nearby-Chocolate1840 | 5 hours ago

True. Though that's also off-shored to no small degree. It's the actual growing of food that the US dominates in.

canuck_in_wa | 4 hours ago

No, the processing of it as well. Most of the boxed and packaged food sold in the U.S. is made in the U.S.

Nearby-Chocolate1840 | 4 hours ago

Sure. I was mostly referring to US agriculture that is exported and then processed within another country for either domestic consumption or export to another, third country.

Mayor__Defacto | an hour ago

That’s usually due to logistics concerns rather than labor costs.

INeedSomeTacoC | 4 hours ago

Yup, and the problem with no longer making washing machines is that you don't have an existing wide enough industrial base to pump out the hardware needed in event of having to retool for national defense.

We didn't build new production lines to win WWII. That refrigerator manufacturing line got retooled to make chillers for radars. High tech high end radars don't work without chillers.

You need a low and high mix of manufacturing if you want a resilient industrial base.

Peyton-Hickman211 | 6 hours ago

But USA is very far behind Taiwan on chips

bigmt99 | 6 hours ago

I mean I guess but not really in the context of OP’s point

TSMC is obviously the undisputed GOAT, but the US still produces 12% of the world’s semiconductors

INeedSomeTacoC | 4 hours ago

The TSMC node in Arizona is the most advanced chip node they have.

Peyton-Hickman211 | 4 hours ago

How much is it producing?

INeedSomeTacoC | 3 hours ago

Fab 1 is up and producing about 20,000 wafers a month for Apple and Nvidia. That's currently TSMC's cutting edge fab and is about 25% of their global capacity for this tech.

Fab 2 is in production sampling and is also expected to ramp up in 2027 up to 20k+ wafers a month as well. That is the next gen fab that they will launch the new chips on for Apple and Nvidia in 2027 for their cutting edge devices.

Fab 3, the gen after next is in initial layout and technology checkout stages on AZ.

Once all 3 fans are online, they'll be the three most advanced chip fans in the world on a single campus, and will produce about 100,000 wafers a month.

Peyton-Hickman211 | 3 hours ago

Good news

ezodochi | 4 hours ago

They gave up on manufacturing chips and Taiwan successfully exploited that fact. Manufacturing semiconductors is super expensive and super labor/capital intensive and US firms wanted out of manufacturing, Taiwan backed TSMC who offered to take over on the manufacturing end but not intrude on the designing end, and the US left manufacturing semiconductors mostly to Asia since then.

Common-Concentrate-2 | 57 minutes ago

The ASML machines that TSMC uses are comprised of 6 sub components. The light source and tin droplet generator is made in San Diego. The mechatronics are made in Connecticut. The metrology and control software is developed in San Jose. Apple, Nvidia, Intel and AMD are the largest GPU and CPU design houses in the world. There are 3 major ram manufacturers in the world, Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron. Micron is from Idaho. This isn't really a nationalistic exercise anymore. Things happen all over, and we can work together

OnionsAbound | 5 hours ago

More education is not always solution. Just look at China.

dopechez- | 4 hours ago

The US is also starting to have an unemployed graduate problem

GeneralTonic | 5 hours ago

Thank you for the reassurance and license to stop mourning.

Perhaps some day we can have the most high tech and rich economy, where one person with extremely high education does all the manufacturing and gets all the money. That would be a generally good thing.

Outside_Reserve_2407 | 3 hours ago

Also, as countries get richer the young population doesn't want to do dirty manufacturing work. Even South Korea has to import welders from poorer countries like Vietnam on work visas to work in their shipyards. And the farms and fisheries in South Korea are staffed by low wage migrants.

froz3nt | 2 hours ago

Nominally yes. But as a percentage of total world putput, its like less than 20%. It used to be around half. And its still falling

And this, folks, is how someone living in la-la land sounds like.

You're delusional if you think 100% of population can be trained and later employed in high-tech sector.

95% of all people would stay permanently unenployed in such economy.

fathed | an hour ago

We're only 4th in microchip manufacturing, while the countries ahead of us in that category are who we also buy our microwaves and refrigerators from.

Yes, we lead in microchip design, but not in manufacturing.

DangerousCyclone | 51 minutes ago

That's basically the argument in the article.

8ngryW0lf999 | 4 hours ago

The only chips we've making here are potato chips buddy.

arah91 | 6 hours ago

just look at this graph US manufacturing is basically been level since 2000, and it was rising steadily since "the good old days", the problem isn't that we aren't making stuff in the US we are making more than ever, the problem is the share that goes to the average population instead of straight to the top is going down, automation's been going up, Union involvements been going down, worker pay as a % of profits is going down.

CasualEcon | 6 hours ago

Manufacturing output in the US is actually near an all time high

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/INDPRO

Manufacturing employment drops off though https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MANEMP

sneakoo | 4 hours ago

The job count is the wrong scoreboard. US factory output kept rising for decades while factory jobs fell, because output per worker rose faster. Trade shocks cut specific towns hard, but the long slide is mostly productivity. Policy that ignores that math brings back plants, not the old job count.

Original_Animal3065 | 3 hours ago

The rich assholes sold out the USA during the Clinton administration with nafta. The REAL Communists are all the American companies that literally gave their top-secret manufacturing recipes directly to Communist China in exchange for cheap labor profits. That’s what happened! Real Communists are the American Capitalists YO

PromotionOk2443 | 6 hours ago

lmao, they did exactly what any capitalist would, looked for cheap labor. we laud capitalism like it's some great solution, but it's just slavery by different means. They left because americans demanded safety at work, pay that would allow them to actually participate in the economy and hours that allowed them to still have a balance with work and life. They want you to "WORK HARD ALL DAY" so they can take the dividends home to their mansions and yachts. They won't come back until worker's rights are equal across the planet, which is a pipe dream because the "good" guys are all actually evil shits with good marketing teams.

Levitlame | 6 hours ago

If you want to make that argument then The term you are looking for is indentured servitude rather than slavery.

And capitalism isn’t either anyway, but it sure as hell encourages them by definition.

PromotionOk2443 | 6 hours ago

semantics, but indentured servitude is as close to slavery as can be without being exactly equivalent. and yes it is. our system is designed to funnel wealth and power up, not down, a system that encourages indentured servitude is a system that encourages slavery.

toeknn | 5 hours ago

Our system is not designed to funnel wealth up.

Its designed to raise the floor of everyone. And its done so. The problem is the system was expanded to include billions in poverty 50 yeara ago and they are still catching up. But undeniably capitlism has lifted 100s of millions of them out of poverty.

RockingMAC | 3 hours ago

Capitalism isn't designed. It's a label for a system of exchange that evolved. Private ownership of the means of production 100% funnels money to the owners. That's why they own it, to make a profit.

BernedTendies | 6 hours ago

Capitalism is slavery by different mean? Man Reddit is insane. Yall need to touch grass

espressocycle | 6 hours ago

Profit is theft.

BernedTendies | 6 hours ago

Profit is the difference between the cost to produce and the price a willing and able buyer paid for the product/service. There’s no theft involved

toeknn | 5 hours ago

Good luck getting anything advanced with zero profit. No profit is all risk no reward.

Vralo84 | 5 hours ago

I think what you’re trying to articulate is that paying wages to employees to build products for you then selling those products for a profit then keeping that profit for yourself and not sharing it with the people who did the actual work- is theft.

It’s not, but that’s what you mean.

Just the act of selling something that you crafted for more than the cost of raw materials is not theft.

Bluegrass6 | 4 hours ago

Yall are desperate for grinding poverty

WashedSylvi | 2 hours ago

If you don’t work, you will die?

Whether that’s because I made bread cost money or whether I shoot you myself, you can’t “just not work”, it’s not a real option. You also cannot go “live off the land” anywhere on the planet, there is no opt out process for work unless you’ve inherited massive wealth.

If you’re coerced into doing something on pain of death, by exposure to elements or a whip or a medical bill, what else is it? Physical compulsion to labor?

Offshore-Tigr | an hour ago

If a bear doesn't hunt, he dies.

Is nature capitalist?

Jesus_es_Gayo | 57 minutes ago

A handful of bears just formed a honey and fish cartel! Fuck

MrsPennyApple | 6 hours ago

The production of a product requires a long line of applications. You have R&D, supplies, manufacturing, logistics, service, sales, marketing, etc. The least paying and dirtiest of those is manufacturing. If you take an iPhone for example, the majority of the cost is actually in logistics. The U.S. offshored manufacturing and put all their eggs in the other higher paying easier jobs.

Manufacturing isn’t coming back and it shouldn’t. You have a population not willing to do that dirty work for the smallest pay.

PromotionOk2443 | 6 hours ago

it should, but manufacturing shouldn't be the lowest pay, nor so low as to not be desirable work. Unfortunately instead of improving conditions the people with power just really want slaves so they're investing in robots that they can have as true slaves. after that, good luck poor folks, they're planning your deaths as we sit.

MikeExMachina | 5 hours ago

This kind of circles back to your original topic of capitalism. You vilify it by saying its slavery, but then what is your alternative solution for efficiently determining the value of goods and services?

You say manufacturing shouldn't be the lowest paid, says who? Capitalism determines that it should be because so many others at this point can do it and can do it for less. I'm not saying I love capitalism or that its by any means perfect, but its the only system we have. We've tried centrally planned economies were a bureaucracy that tries to dictate the values of things and they just don't work, they can never keep up with the dynamics of the real world.

All capitalism does is assign value to things that are both needed and rare. Why would you deal with the stress, cost, and time commitment of becoming a neuro-surgeon if doing so only bought you the same quality of life as someone mindlessly turning a wrench on an assembly line? A handful of people might do it for the love of the game, but no where near enough.

Disclaimer: This is by no means a defense of laissez-faire unregulated capitalism in all things. Capitalism has constraints, free market principles only work in competitive markets of elastic goods. Healthcare is an example of something that should never be left unregulated as its fundamentally inelastic and frequently sole source.

Rattus_NorvegicUwUs | 5 hours ago

Diamonds.

Needed? Rare?

GameStop?

Needed? Rare?

mmbon | 3 hours ago

Needed is the wrong word, demanded is the correcter one. Natural diamonds are pretty rare and lots of people want them. That may be irrational, but doing economic policy on what somebody thinks the people should want is a recipie for failure.

Rattus_NorvegicUwUs | 2 hours ago

You don’t know about DeBeers?

Capitalism has weaknesses that can be exploited if you have a large enough monopoly.

Spinthar | 4 hours ago

It shouldn’t be, but it often has been. The Industrial Revolution produced a lot of good jobs, and drove middle class spending power at its peaks, but it also produced a lot of terrible jobs and sweatshop conditions when and where labour wasn’t in short supply or wasn’t able to push standards up though political power.

The “Good Old Days” of manufacturing largely was a boom grown on the back of the post war boom, and peaked in the U.S. and in Europe in the 50s-70s … as soon as they could side step high manufacturing costs that’s exactly what they did, and they’ll do the same again in China.

MrsPennyApple | 5 hours ago

Well there’s reality and there’s the utopian bs. A country also wants its citizens making more money than manufacturing can pay. Unless you want to have the U.S. make shoes again and pay $500 per pair.

PromotionOk2443 | 5 hours ago

That's a slave's mentality talking, Yes master, the system is great, we can't change the system, that would be too much, think of the owners!

WeHaveToEatHim | 3 hours ago

At some point in the future I wonder what happens when these developing nations start to progress and demand the same?

Like every nation should theoretically evolve to higher pay and safety standards. It may take generations, but it’s likely. What happens when there is no cheap labor globally? Destabilization? AI? It’s difficult to think this far ahead, but it’s an interesting thought experiment on how society will need to evolve with a changing global labor force.

lateformyfuneral | 6 hours ago

I mean, they’re being undercut on wages and workers’ safety by a communist country.

PromotionOk2443 | 5 hours ago

no, they're working WITH a communist(arguable) country because they love the discounts. they undercut american workers by utilizing slavery and indentured servitude. we do too, we just call it prison labor. they love globalism because it means they don't have to adhere to any laws from any country, they can continue to enslave and rape at will. America shouldn't have allowed them to ship jobs overseas for the sake of profit, that single-handedly destroyed the American work force. Americans said "we demand safe well-paid work" and they said "fuckouttahere, we're leaving."

First_Stat | 5 hours ago

You sound unhinged.

China hasn't been a source of "cheap labor" for 25 years. Workers aren't slaves or indentured servants for crying out loud.

The United States is a bad place to do business, you people worship Billionaires and elect batshit crazy Republicans to give them everything. Crisis after crisis they crash your economy ever few years.

US labor is ahit

Dobby068 | 4 hours ago

Why do you post this nonsense about China not being cheap ?!

China’s average hourly labor cost is roughly 15% to 25% of U.S. and Western European levels, though it has risen sharply over the past decade and now rivals or exceeds the lowest-cost Eastern European Union members.

Labour costs in Eastern Europe are substantially lower than in Western Europe, with hourly rates in the lowest-cost eastern EU countries sitting at roughly a quarter to a third of those in the highest-cost western nations.

Bay1Bri | 4 hours ago

> lmao, they did exactly what any capitalist would, looked for cheap labor

I'm sure if you needed a plumber and two similarly skilled guys gave wildly different quotes, you wouldn't hire the cheaper guy. I know you would hire the guy charging twice as much for the same job because that's good somehow.

PromotionOk2443 | 4 hours ago

yes because that analogy is completely accurate to the situation. that was sarcasm, just in case you're too shallow to get it. also, if you always pick the lowest bidder, don't cry when your house falls down.

First_Stat | 5 hours ago

China hasn't been cheap labor for 25 years.

You are still arguing like it's the 80's

Sorry sport, USA sucks and the world has passed you by.

Try sucking Billionaires off harder next time 🤣🤣

Dobby068 | 4 hours ago

Why do you post this nonsense about China not being a labor cheap country ?!

China’s average hourly labor cost is roughly 15% to 25% of U.S. and Western European levels, though it has risen sharply over the past decade and now rivals or exceeds the lowest-cost Eastern European Union members.

Labour costs in Eastern Europe are substantially lower than in Western Europe, with hourly rates in the lowest-cost eastern EU countries sitting at roughly a quarter to a third of those in the highest-cost western nations.

JoeTiccalo | 4 hours ago

You have no idea what you’re talking about. They put up nets around the Fox corp in China because people kept jumping off the roof(this has been documented by multiple media outlets, the company that makes most of our cell phones). They work people to death over there.

Bay1Bri | 4 hours ago

> China hasn't been cheap labor for 25 years

Labor costs in china are absolutely lower than in the US, by a huge margin. And we are the second largest manufacturer in the world, with nearly triple the output of the third place country (Germany)

DwarfBoxFort | 3 hours ago

Nixon and Kissinger destroyed this country. Kissinger stopped USSR from destroying China in the sino split may he rest in hell. Nixon gave China manufacturing help and then over the years China sabotaged western manufacturing along with any competing nation, stole IP and then bribed us politicians to look the other way. They also manipulated their currency to make themselves even more competitive.

HedonisticFrog | 3 hours ago

American manufacturing has been going up over time, it's only the number of workers in factories that has gone down. The entire notion that manufacturing has been fleeing America has always been wrong. Unless Trump was going to ban factory automation, we were never going to get those jobs back.

TimSylvester_ | 4 hours ago

Now, why would the Epstein class want to manufacture in America, when it would reduce the Epstein classes' profits, produce a stronger, wealthier middle class, and reduce their political control over the nation?

Legitimate_Hunt_5802 | 4 hours ago

Arent more manufacturing js going to need robots like in china? what "wealthy middle class" r you talking about

TimSylvester_ | 4 hours ago

Robots and factories and all the equipment and supply chain are not self-producing. Every form of automation increases the aggregate labor demand, and increases aggregate production demand.

That means no matter how much you automate, you are always producing more jobs faster than you are producing labor.

More robots => more humans employed in the supply chain to deliver the robots => wealthier (not "wealthy") middle class.

Legitimate_Hunt_5802 | 3 hours ago

I just think there are better ways to empower the middle class but yes, more manufacturing needs to come in the state automated or otherwise

TimSylvester_ | 3 hours ago

Can you point me to where I said that this was the only, best, and exclusive means to empower the middle class?

Legitimate_Hunt_5802 | 3 hours ago

Sorry your initial comment suggested it

TimSylvester_ | 3 hours ago

It most certainly did not. Showing a method does not imply that the method is unique or exhaustive.

mcchicken_deathgrip | 2 hours ago

True that more automation paradoxically means more demand for labor. But you eventually either hit a limit of producing more goods than the market will consume, or goods become so cheap that companies can no longer make a profit from them. It has never been the case that demand for labor just grows infinitely forever. When those limits are hit companies lay off workers or fold.

TimSylvester_ | 2 hours ago

> But you eventually either hit a limit of producing more goods than the market will consume, or goods become so cheap that companies can no longer make a profit from them.

Show me an instance.

>It has never been the case that demand for labor just grows infinitely forever.

Infinite elastic demand for labor does not mean "infinitely elastic in every labor category, for every product, for every organization". It is a cross-economic metric, not applicable to every instance of labor demand.

>When those limits are hit companies lay off workers or fold.

Show me a company who folded because demand for their products was too high, and their production costs were too cheap.

mcchicken_deathgrip | 2 hours ago

There are literally countless instances. But one I always come back to just because it's so well written and perfectly describes the contradiction of capital investment in automation being a profitability trap is Warren Buffett's 1985 letter to shareholders on closing the Berkshire Hathaway textile mills.

>Show me a company who folded because demand for their products was too high, and their production costs were too cheap.

You misunderstood what I said, or maybe I wrote it poorly. I'm saying companies fold when demand is insufficient for their productive capacity. Companies invest more and more into capital for factories because it makes production cheaper, only to hit a wall when they have excess capacity for production than the market will consume. Then they can't afford to upkeep equipment and either have to close factories or lay off labor. Literally dozens of examples here, look at the European auto industry, American chemical industry, or Chinese steel industry.

As for production costs being too cheap, read that Buffett letter closely because it describes how the textile industry fell into that trap. Companies have to invest in automation to keep up with other companies who have already automated and can sell the same product for cheaper. Then everyone keeps automating until the market is oversupplied and not enough profit can be made off the price of the goods your selling. Eventually they can't even make enough return to upkeep all the the equipment they invested capital into and they fold. This has been the fate of dozens of not hundreds of industries which have left developed countries and only operate profitably where labor is dirt cheap.

CatLord8 | 4 hours ago

And why would they give up oppressive labor standards that can enable human trafficking

TimSylvester_ | 3 hours ago

Do you have any idea how much less work one has to do when they own slaves?

I can't believe no one's tried this before!

foodank012018 | 3 hours ago

Wouldn't that Make America Great Again™?

TimSylvester_ | 3 hours ago

I always wonder what exact point in time and socioeconomic conditions we're hearkening to when America was of this mythological "great" status.

Where have we centered this nostalgia for what was, that we wish was yet again?

foodank012018 | 3 hours ago

They're selling a vague idea so people can insert their own concept of what it is and follow along. It's marketing manipulation.

TimSylvester_ | 3 hours ago

Right, and most people, when they get older, start to nostalgize the period when they were 18-25. They were old enough to have a sense of freedom, and young enough to be ignorant of most of the worlds' problems.

Durian881 | 6 hours ago

Believed US had moved towards higher value service sector. Are there many Americans wanting to do manufacturing jobs? It's one thing to complain about manufacturing moving to cheaper countries, and really wanting to do those jobs at low wages.

smythy422 | 6 hours ago

I think there are plenty of people who would enjoy working with their hands making things if it still offered a path to a decent life. In many places, that comes with around a 6 figure income. It's very hard to employ a large workforce making things while paying those rates for labor. You have to be making something that is very complex and commands a good profit margin. Established tech that is generally only judged on price will not command the profit margins that will fund such wages. There are no good options for both keeping general goods prices in check while providing a market that can fund labor to the extent needed. The US has chosen to focus on aggregate prices and output in almost all sectors.

Skrillaaa | 4 hours ago

I’ve been in pharmaceutical manufacturing for 8 years, and I’m currently transitioning to aerospace manufacturing. Pharma was a great experience. It provided a clear career path, growth, and a decent salary and benefits. I actually had a hand in a vaccine that my son received and I was incredibly proud of that fact. I enjoy manufacturing because it provides, but also I can disconnect from the work once my workday ends.

Funny thing though, I have offered help to friends/family who are struggling to establish careers get their foot in the door and none of them take me up on the offer.

RareWelder9212 | 6 hours ago

While I do not think manufacturing will move back to the US exactly, with automation the value of cheap labor becomes less important and proximity to the customer becomes more important. Eventually, we will see more regional manufacturing hubs nearer to Europe and the Americas, rather than consolidated manufacturing in China.

Alone-Supermarket-98 | 6 hours ago

industrial manufacturing was sent overseas for a reason: it is a low margin, cyclical business with high environmental costs.

US companies realized the true value was in designing the intellectual property

No_Sense_6171 | 6 hours ago

I'm baffled by why journalists are still doing articles about this. It's been beyond obvious for decades that those jobs are gone and are not coming back. Even if the manufacturing came back, the jobs wouldn't. Chinese factories operate in the dark because there are no people needed to run the machines. The same would be true here.

That ship sailed in the 1970s. Get over it.

Physical_Focus4683 | 5 hours ago

American companies also at a disanvatage when they have to provide healthcare coverage for employees on top of stricter EPA regulations and local and state laws. I guess it pays to be in a country when none of those things matter or someone else provides health insurance.

seansdude | 4 hours ago

Manufacturing gone? Hah! We are the best in the world at manufacturing bullets and fat kids that can race their thumbs over their smart phones.

Maneruko | an hour ago

because the concept of inflation means that production makes less and less money over time thus making it an incentive to move away from the hard profit caps that come from manufacturing and transition to a more service based business model.

as long as the price you buying at is fixed and the price of selling it is volatile you'llalways make more money as a service.

FrankCostanzaJr | 18 minutes ago

OK so, I was technically alive in the 90s but i had no idea what was going on with politics, or what nafta meant at the time....but i believe to have a vague understanding NOW that this was one of the bigger moments in the United States's history of international trade agreements and possibly the beginning of large scale offshoring of American factory/labor jobs.

so, for all the economics experts out there, what SHOULD the US have done? what would have been the best strategy? and if we wouldn't have offshored so many jobs, would the world look extremely different right now? because it's pretty clear that since the 90s the erosion of the US middle/working class has increased rather quickly...

it feels like basically, America saw some very poor countries, and decided to build trade relationships with them that would simultaneously HELP build their infrastructure and HELP them create a middle class faster than anyone ever thought possible, while also allowing the wealthiest Americans to rake in billions, maybe trillions in profits...meanwhile our own working class has withered away and essentially all we got were cheap TVs.

it feels like most of my life, politically...."free trade" has mostly been a bipartisan issue...

I seem to remember Clinton taking a lot of credit/flack for NAFTA, but, did that trade agreement have anything to do at all with propping up the Chinese economy? when did that start? and when did it become a "serious issue" that was too late to fix? was it inevitable? is it even considered "a problem that should be fixed"? were any of these trade negotiations ever dominated by ONE political party over the other? did the dems EVER give a lot of pushback and ask for more concessions than the Republicans?

And, now that we have around 30 years of hindsight, what do you guys think would have been the BEST strategy for the US government to take regarding trade/offshoring jobs on a global scale? starting in the 90s with NAFTA....what could we have done better?

Obvious_Chapter2082 | 6 hours ago

3 main reasons:

  • Labor costs are too high
  • tax costs are too high
  • dollar is too strong

1 and 3 aren’t bad things, but we should work to fix 2

Bay1Bri | 4 hours ago

You're forgetting environmental regulations are higher. Again, not necessarily a bad thing.

FuzzyAd9407 | 3 hours ago

>tax costs are too high

So you want more tax cuts for corporate America when theyve repeatedly shown to fuck over Americans despite handing them tax cuts already?

Obvious_Chapter2082 | 3 hours ago

I’m talking specifically about the tax cost of manufacturing in the US. Not US corporate taxes in general