Help github just deleted me

57 points by 01nate 21 hours ago on hackernews | 52 comments

orionblastar | 21 hours ago

Since Microsoft bought out GitHub, tech support has been subpar. Good luck, and if they don't restore your account, you can start over at GitLab or another place. I hope you get restored.

[OP] 01nate | 19 hours ago

Thanks, I appreciate it. I seem to be restored, I think my panic of spamming the internet with pls help might have been over-reactive. But still definitly going to be at least mirroring if not migrating.

orionblastar | 15 hours ago

I don't know why you were banned, but I am glad your account was restored. Mirroring the repo on other hosts should be a given.

ksudb | 21 hours ago

Switch to gitlab and change upstream on your repos?

criddell | 20 hours ago

Are gitlab easier to get on the phone?

biglyburrito | 19 hours ago

If you're looking a phone number to call for initial technical support, they don't support that. However, so long as you're on a paid subscription tier -- that is, Premium or Ultimate -- you have access to Priority Support ( https://support.gitlab.com/hc/en-us/articles/11626483177756-... ), where the initial response time SLA is determined by the priority of your message ( https://support.gitlab.com/hc/en-us/articles/11626416629660-... ). Once a ticket is opened, you can request a phone or video call ( https://support.gitlab.com/hc/en-us/articles/11626483177756-... ). You can also request a phone/video call in your initial ticket instead, but it'll be up to the support engineer to set it up either way.

ByteOfWood | 20 hours ago

Stop supporting companies that will not support you.

matltc | 20 hours ago

Feeling this more than ever recently

kokanee | 20 hours ago

Every company starts as a force for good, and ends up either dead or evil

anonym29 | 20 hours ago

That's why you use FLOSS and not commercial / encumbered code.

bakugo | 20 hours ago

The problem is finding companies that do support you. There don't seem to be many left.

orangea | 19 hours ago

companies support you in proportion to how much you pay them of course

[OP] 01nate | 19 hours ago

This. I was just thinking about ngit the other day (experimental decentralized git tool). Definitely going to be using that.

thephyber | 18 hours ago

Is there a "fediverse" version of GitHub?

I already left SourceForge when got became popular and SF became a spam website.

BitBucket is owned by Atlassian, so I'm immediately suspicious.

forsalebypwner | 18 hours ago

Tangled.sh is based on ATProto, close as you're gonna get I think

thephyber | 16 hours ago

Interesting find. Thanks!

[OP] 01nate | 17 hours ago

Radical.dev and ngit are the two I'm familar with, though forsalebypwner mentioned Tangled.sh that's new to me.

gumby | 17 hours ago

git is already "fediverse": when you pull you get the entire repo including all of its history.

thephyber | 16 hours ago

I am aware.

A Git server is a strict subset of the features of GitHub. The magic sauce of GitHub is that it is a social network on top of git.

And then GitHub has had like 15+ years of convenience features in addition to git features.

Hence my question.

behrlich | 20 hours ago

This recently happened to me. Support took around 4 weeks to resolve. I updated the support ticket every couple of days but I don't get the sense that it helped.

forsalebypwner | 18 hours ago

This also happened to me ~2 months ago, also took ~4 weeks to resolve.

Oh and right before they unbanned me, they said `Your account was flagged for activity that violates our Terms of Service and/or Acceptable Use Policies. We've reviewed these flags, and we have decided your account needs to stay restricted.`

I immediately responded saying there must be a mistake, its my only GitHub account with a decade of personal projects saved, can I at least get a copy of my data?

They responded right away that time and said "We've lifted the restrictions, so you have full access to GitHub again." Roller coaster

edoceo | 16 hours ago

One place i know sorts their action tickets by updated_at, so when you ping/bump a ticket that stamp is updated and you move to the bottom of sort. Another service I use does that, but warns loudly in their support portal.
There are little to no humans at GitHub. Nor is there any CEO of GitHub to contact to.

It's only Tay.ai and Copilot at the helm.

choult | 20 hours ago

This happened to a colleague - we're on an enterprise plan, and even then it took them a calendar month to reinstate him.

Tomdarkness | 20 hours ago

I have had a ticket open with Github that's gone unacknowledged for 2 weeks now regarding a repo that is leaking PII about people.

No idea what is happening over there, but they need to improve their support.

ShinyLeftPad | 20 hours ago

I have tickets with them unacknowledged for years

latchkey | 20 hours ago

Been there before, you just file the ticket to get it reopened and then a week later they magically give you your account back and won't explain why.

espeed | 20 hours ago

Who here works at Microsoft?

lallysingh | 20 hours ago

No I think Skynet effectively took it over and anyone left there just keeps it going.

cabaalis | 19 hours ago

Let's stop with the "hacker news is my support" stuff. The more that happens the worse these companies think they can treat us.

Having a problem solved by a public hacker news post should be a net negative for any company that does it.

eggbrain | 20 hours ago

This happened to my work account today — I had set it up as a new GitHub account a few weeks back when I started, and then got a notification today my account was suspended for terms of service violations (our org is also on an enterprise account).

I wasn’t working on anything nefarious — the most was that I was using the gh CLI to push pull requests up via Claude, but that’s about it.

I know in the age of attacks services like GitHub have to be careful, but you’d think this could be solved more easily.

sourweasel | 20 hours ago

GitHub support responds at a snails pace if at all. I reported a GitHub site that was actively infecting Windows users with a malicious .exe file and it took 11 weeks just to get a "message received, we'll look into it."

Next time I'll just report the malicious URL to Google's Safe Browsing and MS Defenders SmartScreen. If GitHub isn't interested in actively keeping their site free of malicious software then I'll treat them as a distributor of it.

talkingtab | 20 hours ago

1. Sue them. If you are a person go directly to small claims court. Send them a legal letter registered mail. They will need to respond or they lose the case. That means they will have to pay a lawyer just to say "dismiss the case".

If everyone and their brother and sister walked into small claims court every time this kind of idiocy occurs guess how much motivation they would have to FIX the problem.

Finally, probably you will not do that (but really if you can code why can't you file a small claims case?). In that case run, do not walk away from any service that is #1 machinary #2 tuned to extract as much money from you will providing as little service as possible. Run away!

edoceo | 20 hours ago

What if the TOS requires arbitration? Like Amazon, and they dictate the arbiter, which has a 2k fee.

stuaxo | 20 hours ago

Surely depending on what country you're in that might not even be valid.

esseph | 19 hours ago

Might take legal representation just to find out.

zamalek | 18 hours ago

Then go to arbitration, it isn't completely one-sided.

edoceo | 16 hours ago

I guess the point was missed. In many cases there is an Arb clause. Then Arb costs more than the matter in dispute. So TOS requires Arb, and Arb cost $2k to justify $200 "wrong doing". That common scenario puts the individual at disadvantage.

thephyber | 18 hours ago

Why are you using a hypothetical? It takes 10 seconds to investigate whether GitHub ToS requires arbitration.

Hint: it doesn't.

If you are trying to create a rule for dealing with other sites, the ToS doesn't prevent your small claims court suit. It may short circuit it, but the company still has to pay a lawyer to deal with the suit, even if it's a quick template letter.

It might still be cheaper for them to verify the facts of your account before escalating to a lawyer (which is the pressure your parent comment was referring to).

talkingtab | 15 hours ago

Just sue them. They play by the rule that they can out lawyer you. And they can. It is just like tanks and drones. Be the drone, Luke. Don't hire a lawyer. Do not go to arbitration. As soon as they have to pay a lawyer their cost-benefit equation goes out the window. You will probably not win. But there was a guy in New Hampshire who had his account canceled with Instagram. His case was denied so he appealed to the New Hampshire Supreme Count and won. This is not easy, but that was before AI, but even so the NH Supreme Court reversed the lower courts decision.

[OP] 01nate | 20 hours ago

I seem to be back, but yeah, lol the thought crossed my mind. Make a good faith and fair dealings claim (or whatever the catch all law is) and ask for $1 and a copy of my data. It'd have least been a way to get ahold of a human and maybe a copy of my stuff.

>but really if you can code why can't you file a small claims case Lol you're making some assumptions lol. My human written code is rather room temp IQ, the rest is AI or non code (blog, novel, ect on github pages).

autoexec | 15 hours ago

> That means they will have to pay a lawyer just to say "dismiss the case".

Pretty sure Microsoft is already paying a lawyer (or law firm) to handle whatever they happen to need and probably paying them enough that they won't even see a separate bill or line item for something as trivial as filing for a dismissal.

That said, they might not notice in time or even bother with it and you can get an easy win of a small amount of money and still not have your data. The tiny check you eventually get in the mail (assuming they don't just blow you off and make you fight to collect) won't matter enough to them to change their practices. If enough people did it, they'd probably get better at responding, which is all they'd need since they can point to their ToS which no doubt obligates and constrains you while promising to give you nothing and waiving all responsibility for anything ever. A large enough class action lawsuit might get their attention, but I doubt it. What we really need are consumer protection laws on the books with actual teeth.

sigio | 20 hours ago

Account seems to work again... so bug / oopie by github?

[OP] 01nate | 19 hours ago

Must be, can confirm I'm back. Still no email or notification of any kind, just completely nuked and back without any sort of explanation lol. But in other news:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAXZbfLzJUg

[OP] 01nate | 20 hours ago

Hey guys, Nate here (the guy who made the blog post). I seem to be back, and I'm immediately cloning a local copy of everything, but I hope it was just some weird bug or AI moderation that'll hopefully be reversed and won't nuke me again.

eggbrain | 20 hours ago

Good to hear, although I went through the same thing today, so hopefully they can help others in the thread.

[OP] 01nate | 19 hours ago

What's your username? Can always add you to my blog post as an update

ivanjermakov | 19 hours ago

Reminder to self host git mirror or at least have important work distributed across multiple devices.

[OP] 01nate | 18 hours ago

Lesson leanred, just glad it was a rather light lesson given I got my stuff back. First thing I did with my account was cloned everything locally .

ShinyLeftPad | 19 hours ago

Slightly ironic to happen to someone who seems to be all in on decentralization (Nostr)

[OP] 01nate | 18 hours ago

Lol yeah rather ironic. Here I am yapping about anything and everything and anything decentralized be it the social protocols, IPFS, Tor/I2P ect then going "guys help" the second my un-backed-up GitHub data gets nuked. Lesson learned I guess.

ada-h00k | 11 hours ago

Something similar happened to me back then, too. I was banned for 48 hours on the grounds that I had violated the rules. But support never told me what I had done, and my code and all the issues, etc., that I had created were still there. So it wasn't really that I had violated a rule otherwise, they would have deleted it.