She got a restraining order against her ex — and still ended up dead. Here's how the system failed her (2026)

171 points by discoislife53 15 hours ago on reddit | 20 comments

canarinoir | 12 hours ago

Castle Rock v. Gonzales (2005): A woman had a restraining order against her ex-husband for herself and her three daughters. He kidnapped them. She contacted the police multiple times asking for them to enforce the restraining order; each time they declined to do anything. He rolled into the police station in the early morning hours and started shooting; they shot back and killed him. In the trunk of his car were the three daughters he murdered.

The Supreme Court ruled that the cops had no duty to enforce and that it "wasn't mandatory". The system doesn't want to protect you.

iridescent-shimmer | 4 hours ago

At least the crime victims office is honest with you. They'll tell you the PFA is only a piece of paper. My ex put a photo of a gun he had on social media after he relinquished his guns under the PFA and the state police didn't do anything, because they were mad about the paperwork involved. They fought with me that night over the phone and said it was my county's responsibility even though the violation happened in theirs. It's so fucked.

xbhaskarx | 8 hours ago

Jesus

ArgentaSilivere | 2 hours ago

Why do we even have law enforcement if they have no obligation to enforce the law? Why have mountains of paperwork and miles of regulations that mean nothing? What’s the point of any of this if the system runs on “hope everyone always follows the law and do nothing about it if they refuse”?

PlantedinCA | 10 hours ago

This happens too often. And the women who kill their abusers in self-defense are also penalized.

Not sure if you heard about Keisha Golden. She was set to go to trial for murder last month. She had called 911 fifty times in a two year period from the abuse, had a restraining order in the past, and had previously survived strangling incidents.

He came back and began to assault her while she was 8 months pregnant. And she shot him. And suddenly they wanted her to go to jail. Come on.

We do not protect women at all.

[OP] discoislife53 | 15 hours ago

Archive link: https://archive.is/h27gY

theshadowofself | 12 hours ago

I’m on mobile and it works for me

AGroke | 14 hours ago

Hi, sorry op . This link isnt working for me . Can you double check it ?

[OP] discoislife53 | 14 hours ago

It’s still working on my end. Try clearing out your browser cookies and see if that works. If not, let me know.

AGroke | 13 hours ago

I'm on mobile. I tried typing the link out in browser but still no luck !

[OP] discoislife53 | 13 hours ago

I’ve seen some other comments on posts where the links tend not to work on mobile. I wish I was of more help - I’d try to accesss next time you are close to a laptop or PC.

AGroke | 13 hours ago

Alrighty. It might just be me then! Thanks

FriendlyDrawer638 | 11 hours ago

I'll save you a read, the system failed her because abusers run the system. Seriously, a cop got arrested for using flock to stalk his ex, and that's just one of them. The 40% statistic is outdated.

VarietySuspicious106 | 6 hours ago

I hate to say but I agree 😬. I’ve just read too many stories about controlling and violent LEOs 😩🤬.

FriendlyDrawer638 | 6 hours ago

Yeah, at a certain point you realize the job attracts a certain kind of personality

mxmoon | 6 hours ago

After I got my protective my order, my ex harassed me for a year. I had to appease him every time because I was utterly ALONE. It is terrifying. My first experience with police after reporting the abuse was horrifying.

After I moved, he harassed me. Bragged about how he had friends in high places. I finally called the police in my new town. The police actually did something. They arrested him and he plead guilty for violating the protective order.

This was in Texas. Shocker. Oh and years later, my ex was endorsed by none other than Ken Paxton. I hope they both rot in hell.

anl28 | 14 hours ago

Just awful

cstrdmnd | 8 hours ago

Unfortunately, you can’t rely on a restraining order. It’s just a piece of paper. If someone is intent on hurting you, then they have nothing to lose. The threat of going to jail will not stop them.

The best thing to do is get away, get a police paper trail started and disappear completely. I know it’s harder to do when minor children and custody are involved, like in the article, but I’d rather be alive and in legal trouble than dead.

iridescent-shimmer | 4 hours ago

Until they take your kids and give them to the abuser full time. It's impossible when minor kids are involved.

Creamowheat1 | 5 hours ago

Same thing happened in Sacramento last week. Woman killed by her stalker. She had a restraining order and he violated it several times with no repercussions.