Five cows abandoned on a remote island in 1871 grew into a herd of about 2,000 despite extreme inbreeding

1423 points by The_Weekend_Baker 21 hours ago on reddit | 83 comments

stolenfires | 18 hours ago

Sometimes in situations like this, the inbreeding can loop back around as all the negative traits get bred out of the population.

Stunning_Warthog_141 | 16 hours ago

The difference is that cows don't put a crown on the most deformed cow, they just let the bad genetics die out.

Phine420 | 16 hours ago

Mooga

leilani238 | 12 hours ago

Hapsburger.

South-Run-4530 | 7 hours ago

Pugs

CoverofHollywoodMag | 2 hours ago

The Hapsburger Hamburger

ErictheAgnostic | 13 hours ago

Looools

highbudsilver | 12 hours ago

Trump?

MaraiaLou | 10 hours ago

Regular monarchy I think

South-Run-4530 | 7 hours ago

Btw, did you guys find out where all these super rich conservative women with horribly blotched plastics and the... creative hair and makeup are coming from?

ScratchLatch | 14 hours ago

People just overestimate how much inbreeding effects a population. A small healthy gene pool can prevent issues entirely. Inbreeding doesn’t cause mutations, it lets recessive genes show through.

CaptinEmergency | 14 hours ago

That’s what I keep telling my sister, maybe the recessive gene is a super power.

WrongTea1631 | 14 hours ago

This guy inbreeds

stolenfires | 13 hours ago

Or it's a her and she's Bene Gesserit.

Hrstmh-16 | 13 hours ago

The cowsatz haderach!

stolenfires | 13 hours ago

The spice must moo?

The alfalfa must flow?

I'm trying to come up with a good one.

DocumentExternal6240 | 10 hours ago

It is generally a problem. Sonetimes it‘s ok, but inbreeding lowers long- time survival (meaning thousands of years and longer), especially if the environment changes. So 150 years is lucky but not a proof for evolutionary success.

ErictheAgnostic | 13 hours ago

..uh Never been through a pregnancy, huh?

Thirteenpointeight | 11 hours ago

stolenfires | 11 hours ago

I'd assume it would be easier for cows, humans have been breeding out their negative traits for millennia.

Thirteenpointeight | 11 hours ago

Humans excel at coping with negative traits, due to social structure, technology and medicine, reducing the selection pressure on many congenital defects. Not sure where you heard the opposite view but I don't believe it holds much if any water.

AnalBloodTsunami | 4 hours ago

I think they’re saying it would be easier for cattle compared to a non domesticated species, not compared to humans.

Due to the fact that humans have been selectively breeding cattle for millennia.

Thirteenpointeight | an hour ago

Gotcha. Then I would still argue a non-domesticated species would have fewer negative traits. Domestication selects traits that are beneficial to humans, not necessarily to the animal. Wool Sheep for example, un-sheared, are gonna have a bad time. Chickens with chest muscles that drag on the ground, look at the wide host of medical problems in purebred dogs, etc.

DocumentExternal6240 | 10 hours ago

Sadly, no.

pittwater12 | 6 hours ago

If we’re to believe the scientific consensus then the human population got as small as a few thousand due to various disasters in our early days as a species. So in a way we’re all related. Just over a long time.

macula8 | 18 hours ago

Habsburg cows.

run-on_sentience | 17 hours ago

Habsburgers. A Royale with cheese.

GroolGobblin0 | 15 hours ago

burger kings and dairy queens.

runnindrainwater | 7 hours ago

Burger Emperor and Dairy Empress.

K_Linkmaster | 16 hours ago

Bravo. 👏

RPDRNick | 7 hours ago

I can Habs Cheezeburgers?

Traditional_Isopod80 | 16 hours ago

Hapsburger.

obdewllax | 5 hours ago

Just like a regular burger but instead of a bun it’s inbred.

HugsNWhisky | 16 hours ago

Harrisburg cows?

Outrageous_Reach_695 | 15 hours ago

No, those are just very slightly irradiated.

Lasshandra2 | 15 hours ago

Were they 5 cows or four cows and a bull? Or maybe two bulls and three cows?

Cause with five cows, you aren’t getting a next generation.

Yurekuu | 14 hours ago

Could've been all cows with some pregnant already.

grau0wl | 14 hours ago

That's not how cows work. You can't take to species, combine them, and get the same species. A cow makes cow and a bulls make bulls. Read a book

highbudsilver | 14 hours ago

A bull is a male cow. A female cow is just a cow.

Porkenstein | 13 hours ago

Read a book! Lol

MonkaSDudes | 4 hours ago

That energy vampire just got fed

hasslefree | 14 hours ago

What books are you reading???

ErictheAgnostic | 13 hours ago

Its 1 book. And its the one that couldn't even tell people to boil water

hysys_whisperer | 14 hours ago

Bro thought he was on a CJ sub, lol.

apocalypticat | 13 hours ago

I genuinely want to read the book so I can understand better. What's the book please? No joke.

fuck-nazi | 14 hours ago

The owl hath spoken!!!

takofire | 18 hours ago

So are they royal cows then?

feelthesunonyourface | 16 hours ago

TrumpIsAPedoFr | 16 hours ago

Secret Cow Level

SnurrigHeter | 16 hours ago

So they eradicated what was a genetically unusual breed of cow, while farmers are doing their very best to try to keep old breeds alive? Hopefully this was done with thought, and not just cause someone wanted the land and it was the easy way to fix a "problem".

SketchedEyesWatchinU | 15 hours ago

Their widespread grazing was threatening the island’s wildlife and had already driven at least one species of seabird to extinction.

SnurrigHeter | 7 hours ago

Makes sense. Still, inbreeding to that extent, creating a herd that has been solid enough to live own and thrive for 150 years? Makes me hope that they did not accidentally kill off some super-cow when it comes to hardyness.

BrendaWannabe | 13 hours ago

Actually it was 5 humans, they just mutated into a cattle appearance.

temporalwanderer | 12 hours ago

Well, that's nice but there are zero, now.

They killed them all.

"Culls took place in 1988 and 1993, and the herd was eradicated in 2010 following a decision by the authorities."

KaizenHour | 8 hours ago

I'd be interested to see how the land and tree cover has improved/ changed sincce then. Cattle without natural predators can really trasha place, but after a couple of hundred years a balance of sorts might have occurred.

Shot-Sir8585 | 18 hours ago

So there are wild cows!! Cows, in the wild, for generations. Wild cows!

ShapeShiftingCats | 18 hours ago

Technically, they are feral

Tall_Economics_5881 | 13 hours ago

There used to be wild cow around Europe but they died out. I think they sti existed during middle ages.

servonos89 | 8 hours ago

Aurochs

Tall_Economics_5881 | 5 hours ago

Yep that one

Heimerdingerdonger | 19 hours ago

Five cows, no bulls and now a herd of 2000?

And they still say trans bulls are not real bulls!

sezit | 19 hours ago

The article states 5 cattle. The title is incorrect.

Heimerdingerdonger | 18 hours ago

Still does not say "bulls" ... I'm holding on to my pet-theory here. Please don't bust my bubble.

diablosinmusica | 18 hours ago

I can't believe you are leaving out the possibility of immaculate conception. Did you ever think that maybe God got one of the cows pregnant?

narnababy | 17 hours ago

Bloody Zeus again with the cow thing!!!

diablosinmusica | 16 hours ago

Is that what Carl is calling himself again?

Heimerdingerdonger | 18 hours ago

If God were involved they would have multiple Cow factions making Cattle Battle on each other ... they are living peaceably - must be atheist.

Atheist, Trans Cows! Whoa!

GodsGoodGrace | 16 hours ago

Not what immaculate conception means

diablosinmusica | 16 hours ago

Let's start yet another war over "Mary mother of god" vs "Mary mother of christ"

blue-mooner | 14 hours ago

But we’re talking about immaculate cowception

QuesoMuchacho | 17 hours ago

Life, uh, finds a way - Ian Malcolm.

hysys_whisperer | 14 hours ago

Could have been 5 unrelated cows all pregnant from different bulls.

xbhaskarx | 17 hours ago

Habsberg cows

GovernmentBig2749 | 12 hours ago

So, we just dump random cows and comeback in 100 years to the Moo Tang Clan?

BravesMaedchen | 17 hours ago

It sounds like it was because of extreme inbreeding, not despite.

chantsnone | 15 hours ago

Well now I wanna taste inbred beef

mr_christer | 15 hours ago

Cows were like - yeah no we sticking around

14X8000m | 15 hours ago

Extreme inbreeding, name of your sex tape.

FiveCrappedPee | 13 hours ago

I am from Chicago. I saw cows and 1871.

Yes I know Ms o Leary was innocent.

Open-Your-Eyes-Game | 10 hours ago

This is just the plot of a Bob's Burgers episode

No-Duck4828 | 12 hours ago

DESPITE inbreeding? I'd say it was probably BECAUSE of inbreeding

Angry_Foamy | 15 hours ago

So Florida?