All I wanted was to make a budget, and now I have all these feelings

27 points by h3x 6 hours ago on tildes | 26 comments

snake_case | 6 hours ago

When I used Claude to generate this budgeting app, I felt none of that. I didn't feel proud or even tired. I felt like I should keep going, keep making improvements. Keep having ideas and getting Claude to build them.

This is an issue at my job. Everyone around me is so busy vibecoding every whim they never stop to think if they should. We end up with massive releases of unruly vibe coded projects that we then have to support when someone actually sells that garbage to a customer.

Raspcoffee | 5 hours ago

Genuinely... sometimes I wonder whether I should leave tech because of this. There's this insane pressure of more more more more more more that doesn't seem to stop. I rarely use LLMs myself actually for the simple reason that I want to be able to guarantee quality of my work. And I don't doubt that you can do that more if I would use LLMs more but then... when do you stop?

If the recent issues with Microsoft is something to go by, we may say that happening more in the future. I'm sure there's more to it all than just vibe-coding because large incidents like that tend to have more than a single cause(which usually implies bad leadership one way or another). But... I don't want to become a janitor for other people who are riding highs on vibecoding.

snake_case | 5 hours ago

I've made a career of being a janitor for other people's fantasies, the important part is to just draw boundaries.

My company gets about 2-3 hours a day at most of hard focused work out of me, about 5 hours of meetings/Slack messages/random tidying and that's it. 40 hours a week, no more, no weekends. I just do my best while I'm there, make sure that my limitations are well documented, and whatever happens, happens.

Sure, my skills could be used to make the world a better place instead of this, but this pays the bills, and the people with the money aren't interested in making the world a better place so here I am.

Raspcoffee | 5 hours ago

Thank you. I'll need to mull this over for a bit, but I think I needed to hear someone say this, this frankly.

I know this probably wasn't even meant to help me but I think it did.

snake_case | 4 hours ago

It's a really doomer world view without the flip side of it though, so if you're going to take this to heart you should hear that setting boundaries at work means that you get more time and energy for your own endeavors, and those things that you set out to accomplish for yourself don't have to mean anything to anyone but you.

For me, less energy spent working is now energy I can spend building lego sets, feeding my porch lizards, reading a book, going for a bike ride, taking a day trip just to go to a specific restaurant. You can spend your energy making money and doing side hustles or "trying to change the world" or you can just do your best and live your life. Life is already hard, there are already things that we have to do that we can't avoid, so when you can choose what to do with your time, do something you want to be doing, do things that give back to you so that you don't end your days vegging out in front of a screen.

Minori | 4 hours ago

feeding my porch lizards

Explain...?

snake_case | 3 hours ago

(not meaning accusarory, but just lavk editing time for tone)

I feel it's only a doomer take if you feel your life should revolve around work. And if you're on a passionate mission, that can even be very fulfilling.

But lots (most?) people see work as a means to an end: leisure time.

Which is why we need to stop thinking of productivity gains in scope of accomplishing more, but rather doing the same, but for less effort.

[OP] h3x | 3 hours ago

Genuinely... sometimes I wonder whether I should leave tech because of this.

I actually cut a whole section from the essay about this, since I didn't want to publicly talk about that with the state of my workplace. But the grind in the tech world is really getting me down, and I just don't feel at all happy in the industry any more. I just wanna play music for half a year and then hibernate all winter. Is that too much to ask?

[OP] h3x | 6 hours ago

After holding off for a long time, I finally gave vibe-coding a go. This blog post is a write-up of the experience, and an attempt to try and hash out my feelings after the fact. It's a lengthy post, so I'll give you the TL;DR here:

Too long, didn't read

I was trying to replace my budget spreadsheet with a budget app. For one reason or another, all the options out there didn't really jibe with my brain, and I ended up trying to vibe-code the thing which I wanted. It was at once an impressive and scary experience, and it left me with a lot of negative feelings. I worry that with the increasing ability to generate custom-built applications on-demand that we are feeding the growing culture of impatience and frustration intolerance. I come to few concrete conclusions, except that I realistically just need to rewrite the fucking spreadsheet and stop there.

Your writing is great.

I guess my one suggestion on this is that if you want to keep using LLMs but also feel like you are participating: push the bounds on the solution. Don't accept the first answer. Review the code. Do you understand it? If you don't, ask for an explanation, don't move on until you can trace it out in your mind. Ask why it did a thing. Suggest an alternative, etc. it's definitely not the same as doing it all yourself, but you should walk away with a better understanding of both the problem and the solution.

Of course, just fixing the spreadsheet is an option :) Especially if you want your wife to use it.

I also use LLMs a lot for work (ex: writing a sidecar for managing postgresql replication automatically, think kubernetes operator, but aws-native instead), and while they are good, they aren't that good. They don't live in your world, and don't know what the best solution is, and certainly seems to be very bad at big picture thinking, and while they keep getting really good at the micro, I'm not seeing the same improvements at the macro.

[OP] h3x | 3 hours ago

That's good advice, thanks. I think it would necessitate a bit of a reset in how I approach putting together programs. I tend not to plan things or make software modular at the outset, so I'd need to learn how to break down the solution into its constituent parts. But that's probably a better way to approach development, now I think on it!

I do agree that LLMs leave a fair amount to be desired on big picture thinking. Asking for sweeping changes to my company's Puppet repo didn't end in a particularly coherent merge request!

Your writing is great.

Thanks! I always get The Fear when publishing my own writing online, so the affirmation is really nice to read!

kacey | 5 hours ago

... it always feels weird commenting on someone's blog post, as authors otherwise tend not to be in the comment section with me šŸ˜… holding back punches a little.

[...] both sides lack a lot of nuance, and the arguments are just rehashed over and over again. There doesn't seem to be a lot of room for sitting on the fence [...]

IMO a significant problem with modern discourse is that we project complex positions onto a 1d spectrum, then start assigning people teams based on where they appear to lie. Even the "fixes" to this tend to be moving to a two dimensional mental diagram, which is probably 5% less useless, but still in utility ballpark of slicing bread with a spoon.

Not saying this is the rightest way of doing it or anything, but I try to visualize peoples' perspectives on a problem as being a radar chart. If one were to then visualize that -- in order to pull out population-level trends -- you'd cluster groups by overlap percentage. Displaying that in a 2d depth map (with height = overlapping population, and XY coords as effectively arbitrary -- use your favourite high dimensional embedding, such as t-SNE) would (probably) show that there are rich landscapes of opinions: there'd be mountainous clusters around which people have started to group think and pursued in-group vs out-group ideologies, of course, but also vast, undulating expanses of people who share very little opinion-wise on a particular issue.

Of course, if you then decompose that into a single 1d slice again, it'll sweep up a bunch of unrelated perspectives, making "fence sitting" a seeming impossibility: obviously people only exist over at the artificially gigantic mountains! Often we even decide the "middle" of the spectra based on our perceived two-sided distribution of people on problems, which creates a self-fulfilling prophecy. In other words, if you decide to place everyone into two buckets, you shouldn't be surprised when your analysis shows that there two buckets everyone fits into. In reality, I figure that in most problems lives an endless sea of fences, but analytical failings and social discourse encourage people to imagine them away.

If something breaks, it's the community or the developer that fixes it. But in this scenario if there's a problem with the app that was written on my behalf, then I am fully reliant on the LLM (which I may not have access to forever!) to fix it. If I were to dive in myself, I would need to take several business days to be confident enough to figure out what the actual bug is. I don't even know of a way to verify that this thing isn't uploading its data to some cloud platform somewhere!

IMO this is a teething issue. People have been talking about software development vs. engineering vs. architecture for ages, and I think "vibe coding" has brought the issue to the forefront: engineers specify, machinists (and fabricators) build, but software devs have traditionally been a weird mix of both. At this current juncture -- which also imo I don't think will last, but that's neither here nor there -- people are being forced into "engineering" roles where the work to actually build the thing has been offloaded onto a machine.

Er, more helpfully: if you have these concerns about your product, you should find ways to increase your confidence in the result. In principle, the job always should've been about increasing confidence in your claims before making them, but in practice people tended to use rather non-scientific means of achieving consensus instead. For your situation, I'd prescribe thorough-but-readable documentation from the LLM, and a software architecture which isolates off network connectivity to large swathes of the application in ways that you can trivially verify (or ideally, test for).

(ed: you mention having the LLM teach you stuff in a later section; yeah, that's partially what I was aiming for here)

In short I feel like I have cheated myself out of that sense that I can actually achieve things when I set my mind to the task. In its place is an uncomfortable sense of inadequacy and obsolescence.

Oh, yeah, I quit because craftspersonship hasn't been part of the industry since the 90s, and being told to rush crap out the door would only get worse once I could hypothetically be getting my agent to work on software while I sleep. This was always a bonus of the job, and it never will be again.

This likely won't help, but in case you're business brain-pilled: your job was never to feel fulfilled, to be challenged, or to personally develop. Your job was (likely) to (1) get your manager a promotion, (2) churn out barely functional garbage that just about works well enough to retain your customer base, (3) make profit for the next fiscal quarter. So from that perspective, you aren't cheating, you're actually doing your job really really well when you get the computer to do all the work for you!

[social pressure]

Mmhm.

Bit of personal commentary: I think I'm on year two of feeling like large swathes of my friend group would whip out the pitchforks if I discussed anything I work on in my spare time. I'm a crazy misanthrope and can tolerate absurd amounts of social isolation, though, so mostly I've been hiding in a corner and prodding the topic on occasion to tell if it's safe to come out again. We're probably 30% of the way to people coming to their senses and pretending that they were never huge assholes about this, from prior experience on LGBTQ-topics, veganism, kink stuff, climate change, etc.

Ultimately, we're greasy, hairless apes that happened to get decent at throwing spears and yelling at each other, so I don't blame people for behaving like this, but I'm sorry to hear when it affects others' lives. This is unfortunately one of those things that people will just get over with given time and space.

[feeling replaceable]

Some brutal thoughts first:
(1) the AIs have been there since about February and have only gotten better, with no real indication that they will stop,
(2) before that, most companies had been aggressively outsourcing anyways, and
(3) before that, most governments were pouring money into "learn to code" initiatives like there was no tomorrow. Investments in "STEM" were basically tech company subsidies to push down wages for software developers, because everyone saw how fast the tech sector had grown (see: the S&P 7), and they realized that code monkeys were fuel for the modern coal furnace.

Hopefully, this is not a surprise to you, and you've been socking away money for a decade. Because the advantage held by weird, outside the box people who enjoy challenges and getting lost in the weeds in a field that compensated them really, really well could very well be brief. But of the people I've met over the decades, I think approximately zero have agreed with me that the sky was indeed falling, so if it was a surprise then you're at least in good company.

[worthy endeavours and personal growth]

A lot of this is personal, but from one human being to another, creativity will never die so long as people are interested in creating. I think very very few looked at Stanley Kubrick and thought "wow what a freaking hack; he's as creative a rock. You know who's doing the real work?! The artists and the actors!". Because making a film is a team effort, and he expended his creative energies on honing a vision that went beyond the scope of what any individual person could create.

When you get a team of LLM agents to generate a piece of work, you're implicitly taking on a role that was traditionally reserved for the wealthy or accomplished. A director, of sorts. Economically speaking this is disastrous, of course, but I don't buy that it is any less creatively involved. Apparently Michaelangelo was initially fine with getting help painting the Sistine Chapel (citing Reddit here, so please look it up yourself); was he a hack? Was Orson Welles a piece of garbage for not acting in every single role for Citizen Kane (as well as shooting it and staging)? You can obviously still make The Room, but the existence of Tommy Wiseau does not preclude the existence of art elsewhere. I'm being a bit hyperbolic here, but the point is that large endeavours have rarely been individual endeavours, so offloading work onto an LLM seems about the same as delegating to an apprentice, or hiring an actor.

Now economically as noted yeah this is disastrous, but that's a very different issue than the question of morality, creativity, and worth. IMO, broadly: plan to have most white collar jobs implode within your lifetime, and also imo expect the value of art to plummet even further (and yes, the bar was already in heck). But once you've planned for it, just try to think about something else? It's generally going to be unavoidable, and fixating on misery is very bad for the human psyche.

[...] seed my creativity [...]

... sorry I really can't help it; you're looking for "cede". At least that's proof an LLM didn't write this šŸ˜…

snake_case | 2 hours ago

When you get a team of LLM agents to generate a piece of work, you're implicitly taking on a role that was traditionally reserved for the wealthy or accomplished. A director, of sorts. Economically speaking this is disastrous, of course, but I don't buy that it is any less creatively involved. Apparently Michaelangelo was initially fine with getting help painting the Sistine Chapel (citing Reddit here, so please look it up yourself); was he a hack? Was Orson Welles a piece of garbage for not acting in every single role for Citizen Kane (as well as shooting it and staging)? You can obviously still make The Room, but the existence of Tommy Wiseau does not preclude the existence of art elsewhere. I'm being a bit hyperbolic here, but the point is that large endeavours have rarely been individual endeavours, so offloading work onto an LLM seems about the same as delegating to an apprentice, or hiring an actor.

Okay I know you made a lot of points, and I mostly read it, little bit skimmed it, but I'm gonna narrow in on just this one because I think I have a good point to make myself, about what you said right here.

To quote myself above: Everyone around me is so busy vibecoding every whim they never stop to think if they should.

Michaelangelo was paid to paint the Sistine Chapel. You could make a case that I am getting paid to support people's vibecoding, and that's also acceptable.

But when people start getting models to create the art that they see in their head, no one asked for that. No one asked for OP to make a custom budgeting app for his family, his family doesn't even want it. He created garbage for no reason. He spent his valuable time as a human being asking a machine to be creative for him.

The entire internet was filled with everyone's LLM garbage basically overnight, and there's large swaths of people who genuinely think that prompting a model to be creative for them actually contributes something to the world. There are people out there who prompted a model to write an entire book, and then actually sold that book, thinking it was worth reading.

The model is not creative. The model does not create. The model is a shadow of human existence meant to spew humanity back out at us such that we can use it as a filler for things where the creative part isn't the point, but a necessary task in order to make the thing that is the point, like advertising, like enterprise software. When you ask an llm to create art, you're asking it to make for you empty human filler, because the point of art is the intention behind it, not the skill used to make it, and the intention is the sum of the time and the resources used to make the art because no one finishes an art piece that wasn't worth making, it takes too much time and effort.

Again for those in the back: The model is a shadow of human existence meant to spew humanity back out at us. The model does not make art. Art is when you're trying to paint and your dog distracts you and now there's a stray paint line right through your painting that you have to turn into an extra mountain and now you love that mountain the most out of any feature in the painting because it reminds you of your dog who you love and you even named the mountain in the painting and the painting's name is based off the name of the mountain and when you sell it you tell people its because it reminds you of your dog who you love and they have no idea why until you explain the mountain cause to them the painting is of your favorite vacation spot you took when you were a kid because that was your original idea but as you worked on it it grew and took on its own life and now it's about your dog too. That's art. That's what we humans make and call art.

[OP] h3x | 2 hours ago

I completely agree about your distinction between what the model creates, and art. I don't currently believe that much (if anything) that an LLM spews forth can be considered art. I was about to say that I don't really consider code to be art, but thinking about it I have seen many, many projects which are code based which I would say have artistic merit. I think I don't consider my own code to be art, it's simply a means to an end. In the OP I talk about the struggle I have with the ethics of sharing what Claude generated on my behalf with the world at large (at least, I think I did? That might have been another section that went onto the cutting room floor), and I definitely took into account the sheer volume of shit there is out there. I didn't and don't want to be responsible for adding to the noise, and I'm not nearly arrogant enough to think the slop I spent an afternoon vibe-coding is worthy of the attention of anyone but me (and anyone who reads the post, I guess).

No one asked for OP to make a custom budgeting app for his family, his family doesn't even want it. He created garbage for no reason. He spent his valuable time as a human being asking a machine to be creative for him.

Also, hi, it's me. A woman :)

Reminds me of this incredible piece

I do understand: you want permission. There’s a machine in the corner wrapped in human skin that makes things out of shit and blood to look like whatever you want (as long as you don’t look too closely). You gave one to your teacher and they didn’t notice. Your boss told you to use it after they laid off half the team and it was fine. You fed one to your kids and they liked it. You want to know you can use it sometimes without me thinking less of you. You don’t need me to believe it’s useful, you just want me to be polite about it.

I mostly agree with it, but it's undeniably useful to me. I guess I just lack integrity in this regard.

[OP] h3x | an hour ago

That was a really good read, thanks for sharing it! I've sent it to my wife, as it goes; she'll be delighted to have her feelings so articulately reflected!

[OP] h3x | an hour ago

Woah, this is a very comprehensive reply, thank you! I suppose I deserve it given the length of the post I put you through :D I posted it for feedback and commentary, so never fear!

I definitely agree with you re: the state of modern discourse. Talking to people online tends to flatten them into monodimensional versions of themselves, and as more and more of our conversation happens digitally it's hard for that not to bleed out into real life. It's only when you have a lengthy conversation with someone where you can really get into the details that you find their views aren't so binary as we first seem to believe. I'll try to keep that more in mind, as I don't think it's helpful to decide that the conversation is so well defined and split as I make it out to be. For what it's worth, the people I speak to about AI do tend to be pretty well in the "it's all good" or "it's all bad" camps, but I don't spend a huge amount of time digging into why they think that.

Er, more helpfully: if you have these concerns about your product, you should find ways to increase your confidence in the result. In principle, the job always should've been about increasing confidence in your claims before making them, but in practice people tended to use rather non-scientific means of achieving consensus instead. For your situation, I'd prescribe thorough-but-readable documentation from the LLM, and a software architecture which isolates off network connectivity to large swathes of the application in ways that you can trivially verify (or ideally, test for).

At present, I don't feel the urge to do any further vibe-coding outside of work. But I'll keep this in mind if I decide to do any more, or indeed for the coding I do for work.

This likely won't help, but in case you're business brain-pilled: your job was never to feel fulfilled, to be challenged, or to personally develop. Your job was (likely) to (1) get your manager a promotion, (2) churn out barely functional garbage that just about works well enough to retain your customer base, (3) make profit for the next fiscal quarter. So from that perspective, you aren't cheating, you're actually doing your job really really well when you get the computer to do all the work for you!

While quite brutally put, I've held this stance for a good long while, to be honest! I do the bare minimum I can get away with at work, because I'll still get paid the same amount no matter how much effort I put in. I hope what I got at in the post was more that for a personal project I felt I had cheated myself out of the opportunity to feel challenged by something and fulfilled by overcoming it.

Hopefully, this is not a surprise to you, and you've been socking away money for a decade. Because the advantage held by weird, outside the box people who enjoy challenges and getting lost in the weeds in a field that compensated them really, really well could very well be brief. But of the people I've met over the decades, I think approximately zero have agreed with me that the sky was indeed falling, so if it was a surprise then you're at least in good company.

Ha! Putting money away for a decade? That's a good one! I never wanted to make a career in IT or tech or anything. I have two arts degrees and an insatiable urge to write music. The job was always just a means to an end, and I am under no illusions that my employment is also considered the same by the man who signs off my pay every month. I don't think I expected the sky to fall in quite as quickly as it feels to be, but the writing very much does seem to be on the wall for my particular branch of the tech sector. Hopefully all those new jobs that we can't even imagine will be just as well paid, eh? It's hard to shake the feeling that we're all slightly fucked, and that there are not going to be enough jobs that AI can't do to go around.

I'm being a bit hyperbolic here, but the point is that large endeavours have rarely been individual endeavours, so offloading work onto an LLM seems about the same as delegating to an apprentice, or hiring an actor.

I fall more into camp with /u/snake_case on this one; I don't believe that using a squad of AI agents to achieve a goal is equivalent to being Stanley Kubric or any other auteur. The actors, set designers, script writers, composers, and so on that are involved with filmmaking are true artists, and they each bring something to the table that contributes to the larger whole. Star Wars was saved by the editors, and all that. Look what happened when George Lucas was given unadulterated control, y'know? I struggle to believe even for a second that a squad of LLMs could produce something which actual artistic merit, even with a mind like Kubric's in the driver's seat.

... sorry I really can't help it; you're looking for "cede". At least that's proof an LLM didn't write this šŸ˜…

Well fuck! šŸ˜‚ Thanks for the heads up, I did a sneaky fix.

Zorind | 6 hours ago

Thanks for sharing this post, I found it interesting and relatable. (Also, I really like your websites design). I don't have access to an AI subscription outside of work, so I haven't really delved too deeply into it myself (for outside of work projects). I'm very bad personally at finding the motivation for projects, whether those be programming or something else (see my Timasomo project that I did basically on the last day of Timasomo...), and AI/LLMs have not helped in the slightest in that regard.

The niggling temptation was right there in the back of my mind: you could just Claude to finish this off for you, you know.

For a while, I'd been wanting to make a video game, but I've generally lacked the ideas that have truly captured me for making it. And then AI/LLMs got prevalent and have pretty much sapped my desire entirely, because if I don't truly have a great idea for the concept of the game, why make it at all, especially when I could just have an LLM do it for me.


On the budgeting app side of things, time for me to evangelize about plaintext accounting...I personally use ledger, but I've heard good things about both beancount and ledger as well. I'm not sure what features you are missing from your spreadsheet, but theoretically you could import from a csv/spreadsheet into one of the PTA apps. But also, the plaintext accounting stuff can be a bit of a pain to learn (and I did spend some time last year building custom Python graphs for it...so maybe just stick with your spreadsheet).

[OP] h3x | 3 hours ago

I can definitely relate to your struggle getting projects finished. I tend to burn out partway through, or just run out of time and energy. To date, I'm not convinced I've ever submitted to a TiMaSoMo (on time, or at all!). It sounds like you also struggle with the perfectionism that I suffer from. It takes a lot of mental effort to constantly remind myself that "good enough" is... well, good enough.

I've not heard of PTA, thanks for the suggestions! I'll give them a look, although I think the play is honestly just to stick with the spreadsheet :P

(Also, I really like your websites design)

Thanks! I can't claim a huge amount of credit for it, sadly; it's one of the default templates that Bear Blog offers. I've done a few tweaks here and there, but it's mostly Herman's work!

Minori | 4 hours ago

The correct answer is definitely fixing the spreadsheet. So many problems can be solved with a good spreadsheet.

[OP] h3x | 3 hours ago

100%! I think I hindered myself by opting to set it up in Numbers, more than anything.

teaearlgraycold | 2 hours ago

I genuinely enjoyed the pre-LLM days of slow coding. But ultimately the job of a computer man like me (both paid jobs and how I use my skills to help people for free) is to provide automated solutions to others. I never got into software primarily for the money. I got into it because I could help people and make computers do cool things. Of course more money is more better. But there’s a narrow band ahead where the pay is still enough and those that never really cared leave for something more lucrative. That’s not the most likely option but I’m not feeling doomed given there are a few good outcomes still left.

Overall vibe coding seems to provide me a 10x or greater speedup when building things that are well represented in the training data. I won’t complain about being able to help people more by creating more solutions to problems.

Until no one is employable I forsee career paths for jack-of-all-trades like myself that keep me housed and fed. And once no one is employable at least we’re all in the same boat and can act collectively to improve the status quo.

Zorind | an hour ago

I got into it because I could help people and make computers do cool things.

I got into programming because I could make computers do cool things too. But now, I am no longer the one making the computer do cool things, I’m the one telling something else to make the computer do cool things, and that provides zero satisfaction to me. There is no longer the sense of creativity and joy I get from seeing the computer do the cool thing.

I was never very artistic in the drawing or painting sense, I can’t picture something in my head and bring it to life (I think I have mild aphantasia but, who knows). But I loved putting together legos, or building the physical theatre sets, executing on someone else’s design (with small bits of my own creativity in how the execution is done).

But I could think through how to get the computer to do neat things. Idk, unlike @delphi, the parts of computer stuff I enjoyed was not the designing side (I’m quite shit at that), but the mechanical side. The putting of technological legos together, and watching the machine go brr.

So really, AI is just making me feel unfulfilled and sad. I’m not looking forward to having to try to pivot into finding something else that can make me feel both fulfilled and pays money, because I’ve spent about 15 years pursuing this, only for it to ā€œgo wrongā€ 5 years into me actually getting paid for it.

I’m not really trying to shit on people who do use AI, I’m just finding myself both stressed and almost set adrift without knowing how to find a new direction. So I am sorry if I’ve ever come across as actively hostile in these AI discussion threads, as that’s not really my intent.

teaearlgraycold | 15 minutes ago

Do you not think there's a scale where you'd still need to think hard and figure out the mechanics of solving a problem? LLMs are often described as a "force multiplier". The multiplier isn't infinite, so by taking on bigger problems the work is still meaningful.

Is it perhaps an issue that existing corporate structures aren't suited to this new world and people are given the wrong kinds of tasks? If you're still handed similar tickets as you would have gotten 4 years ago those are now just a firehose of things an LLM can bang out in 5 minutes. Or if you're not given any more freedom to explore the solution process, even though LLMs can help people work in adjacent domains they previously would have needed a lot of practice to contribute to.

I suspect in a professional environment there's a fight to maintain the status quo even when it doesn't make sense in the LLM age. A manager who could nearly be replaced by an LLM. A team that could be scaled back if their users have LLMs. A user -> designer -> developer -> QA -> user feedback loop that is now proportionally more overhead than it was before. And maybe the product suite that the company sells is on the edge of irrelevance once the users realize they could clone (and maintain) the SaaS for less than they pay in an annual contract. Once all these things shake out whoever is left standing at least won't have that cognitive dissonance hanging over them. I would hate to be in a role right now that I know could be accomplished at 80% of the quality by simply letting someone else wear one more hat. Like if you're a dedicated front-end engineer implementing designs it would be miserable to know that as long as the organization requires you to hold that narrow role the designer and the back-end engineer could just cut you out as a middleman. The solution there is to allow people far more agency, but that's chaos in the meantime.

People should be given time to answer the "What the fuck are we doing now?" question by standing back and rethinking their job/product/company from first principles. Most corporations aren't anarchist enough for that process. But the ones that do figure it out will find more success in the free market and win out in the end.

delphi | 3 hours ago

When I used Claude to generate this budgeting app, I felt none of that. I didn't feel proud or even tired. I felt like I should keep going, keep making improvements. Keep having ideas and getting Claude to build them.

This is true, and I get where you're coming from here, but there's - at least for me, and I'd like to share - a simple solution here. I am not an IT person. I can write mostly valid PHP because I was making personal and corporate websites well before AI, but my solutions were never elegant and frankly about 60% StackOverflow by volume. AI has changed that. As far as I can tell (and, I probably can't), the code is better. It does more things, runs faster and more securely, and in fewer lines to boot. All Zachtronics graphs are improved here. But then again, as a habitual programming amateur, I'm not the highest benchmark. And yes, indeed, it makes me feel useless as a programmer. At this point, if I have a programming task, I will - provided the pitch is complex enough - not even attempt it. I know I can't compete with the machine.

Thank god I don't have to.

I also have an AI policy, and broadly speaking it's "nothing any other unrelated human being outside of the field could ever see must ever be AI generated". This means that I write front end code myself. I write Handlebars-flavoured Ember by hand. I write HTML and CSS by hand. I open Affinity and Sketch and I do my god damn job, because I am a designer. And I know it can't beat me in the place I'm actually quite comfortable.[1]

Claude in specific but AI in general has not impressed me with its design work. Not because it's incompetent, it is, in fact, very competent, but because it lacks opinions and interesting ideas. The reason and proof of this is trivial, and left as an exercise to the reader. That's how I don't feel useless in my projects. The machine is my subordinate. It does the machine things, which is to write the code (and even then I often feel more comfortable doing a quick proof of concept or pseudocode idea by hand). I do design. I'm a designer, and my standards are higher than Claude's.

The solution to AI fatigue is to be good and care about some aspect that AI could conceivably do, but will never do as good as you (even if that opinion must be held up by delusion). You must ask: Is this the best I can do?

[1]: It hasn't, even if this is a product of my own ego. Even Fable 5.2 still doesn't understand the way I think in terms of design, and I highly doubt that any of the models ever will. The only thing I do let AI do in this regard is to reuse objects from my handmade UI kits, since I don't really think it matters if I write <CanonBigNumberField> and <CanonTooltip> by hand or by using what's essentially a macro. Also, I'd hope this goes without saying, but I of course never let it write any copy or generate any images, video, audio, even colour choices or what have you.