Windows 11 collects data on which coding agents and dev tools you use

22 points by viccuad 6 hours ago on lobsters | 14 comments

thomas0 | 6 hours ago

I really wish we had user privacy laws in the US that actually protected us from egregious privacy invasion like this. Reading this reinforces my decision to switch from Windows 10 to Debian last year.

FedericoSchonborn | 5 hours ago

Microsoft Windows is an excellent spyware just lacking a decent operating system.

xyproto | 3 hours ago

I can understand that some companies and organizations within the US are using Windows, but for privacy and security reasons I can't fathom why anyone else would.

Is it because of salespeople and lobbying, or pure technical inertia?

MatejKafka | 3 hours ago

It's a good operating system that is both deeply customizable and tends to "just work" in its default state.

xyproto | 2 hours ago

That depends on the use cases. Windows is worse than Linux for many use cases. Which use cases do you have where giving up on privacy and sovereignty is acceptable? Gaming?

BenjaminRi | 14 minutes ago

Which use cases do you have where giving up on privacy and sovereignty is acceptable?

Printing. Good grief, printing. I am losing my mind trying to print on Linux with certain printers. Some are well supported, others... a struggle to put it mildly. Before I personally buy devices like printers, I briefly research to make sure it works on Linux.

liberty | 2 hours ago

The biggest thing remains compatibility with certain software that only runs on Windows. Most people don't care as long as they can effortlessly run all of their software. That especially includes businesses that have expensive licenses for software that's essential to their operation.

That's one of the reasons we need FOSS that both fills the gaps and expands the software available to users of free operating systems to make them appealing.

One issue is that the network effect tends to go one way. FOSS tends to care more about compatibility, and even if the main developers don't, anyone else can port it. That's a major benefit of free software, but does often put us in a catch-up game instead of being able to get ahead.

MatejKafka | 57 minutes ago

  • Nicer system administration and scripting (great settings UI and PowerShell is a much nicer shell than bash/fish/zsh with good system integration)
  • Windows API is quite nice (and it's the one mainstream API preventing a desktop POSIX monoculture)
  • .NET is a great development platform that's still Windows-first
  • WSL2 makes cross-platform development much nicer than from Linux
  • Windows are a single platform with stable APIs, making software distribution significantly easier (and making it easy to get new software)
  • Desktop security is taken much more seriously

cpurdy | 3 hours ago

It is important to understand that Windows exists solely to spy on you at this point. Microsoft has joined Google on the wrong side of "Don't be evil."

What makes you think there was ever any question on which side they stand on?

Pomax | 2 hours ago

This sounds like an unawareness of the history of Microsoft if you think they "joined" anyone in that, rather than being the people who pioneered it.

MatejKafka | 3 hours ago

Naive take that doesn't survive even a cursory analysis. The world is not a black-and-white place, Microsoft is not a monolithic entity.

Gaelan | 2 hours ago

If I was looking at a crash report or similar, I’d certainly appreciate knowing if the machine in question had a coding agent running wild, because it’s very likely the machine is in a weird state because the agent is doing something bizarre to work around some problem it’s encountered.

Maybe it’s still a bug, but quite different from a bug that happens to a normal user just going about their business.

There’s certainly a privacy trade-off here, but there are definitely non-malicious reasons to be collecting this.

strugee | 16 minutes ago

This reminds me of the dynamic with dual-use technology. (The irony being, of course, that AI itself is also dual-use!)