A Newborn Died in a Faith-Healing Sect. The State — and One Ex-Believer — Stepped in to Save Her Twin.

117 points by NoLemon5426 4 hours ago on reddit | 13 comments

[OP] NoLemon5426 | 4 hours ago

God bless the Phillips family for their willingness to take in and raise Evelyn. I highly suggest watching the video that I posted if you read the investigative piece. Jennifer Phillips saying that "Just being free to love people, is amazing." is a worthy trade off for being totally cut off by your own family and the community you've lived in your entire life was very moving. These people sacrificed their entire lives to save a girl in a situation that could have been temporary.

[OP] NoLemon5426 | 4 hours ago

This was a collaborative investigation by The Oregonian and ProPublica. The Oregonian also published the story here. ProPublica also did a photo essay and there is also a video to accompany the article.

ErsatzHaderach | 3 hours ago

Love how this sect "makes exceptions for dental care". I guess the good lord has incomplete dominion over our teeth, or something.

Maybe it's an artifact of how the US separates dental health from the rest of insurance/care. Or maybe toothaches are so damn common and annoying that it just eats right through the courage of their convictions. Most people like the idea of grand gestures more than constant little sacrifices. They'll deal with letting babies die but everyday toothaches are just too heavy a cross to bear.

[OP] NoLemon5426 | 3 hours ago

I found it also strange that they don't even use the bible in their belief system. I'm not hip to every cult but I've never heard of this. I like that Marshall went investigating that. I am not a person of faith but I do respect people who have a faith that drives them to a higher, non evil purpose and I find other people's faith journeys very interesting. I am glad they found a welcoming church home.

WesternRover | 33 minutes ago

I think it's interesting that it was not only reading the Bible, but also hearing Christian sermons, and studying the meanings of Christian hymns that he had previously sung without reflection, that led Marshall, and later others, away from this sect that called themselves "Followers of Christ".

TheGreatRandomio | 52 minutes ago

Such a shame

questionsaboutrel521 | 16 minutes ago

I’m fascinated, in this story, by Marshall somehow finding the will to reject everything he ever knew to save his son. It’s so much harder to overcome social conditioning than people think.

I also think this article does a wonderful job showing that people CAN deprogram from cult-like religions, but sometimes intervention is needed.

Feisty-Resource-1274 | 2 hours ago

I do feel like it's kind of gross that the article uses a header picture of a child standing at her twin's grave, who had died shortly after childbirth. It seems weirdly performative and inappropriate to use a child for said performance.

[OP] NoLemon5426 | 2 hours ago

I think it's fine. She's 9 and has been aware of the situation of her life. I mean the whole story is about the needless death of her sister and her near miss with life.

Feisty-Resource-1274 | an hour ago

Sure, but personally I feel like grief should be allowed to be expressed privately so I feel like you don't need to stage a photoshoot with a child looking sad over a grave.

icecreamismylife | an hour ago

Her adopted parents take her to visit her twins grave every year near her birthday, its mentioned in the article.

Feisty-Resource-1274 | an hour ago

I missed that, thanks for sharing