The book seems to be angling more towards the impact of the Bell System and Bell Labs, which could certainly be argued as more impactful than the telegram, even if downstream. AT&T and Verizon both emerged from the Bell Breakup. Western Union still exists, but as a shadow of its Guilded Age self.
Telegrams also came to your home, by a boy. In Soviet block countries telephone network was limited and telegrams were often used up to about Y2K, for example 2.5M telegrams/year in Poland alone in 2002.
Great book. I also like America Calling by Claude Fischer, which calls itself a social history of the phone up to 1940.
The new Gleick book this piece is excerpted from gets the most into the technical aspects, which makes sense given Gleick’s background. There’s also a lot about the patent disputes in the early days of the phone and its impact in its early days on popular culture.
I think there’s still more phone history to be written. I’d like to see a social history of the phone in the period basically from WW II to the iPhone, including unexpected and deviant use of the phone: phone phreaking, prank calls, music over the phone, sex lines, collect calling, right wing voice message lines, phone zap protests, telemarketing, and I’m sure things I don’t even know about. Plus how the rise of technology like cordless phones, extension lines, etc. delivered privacy for phone users in their own homes.
Sort of related if you want to get a sense for the business side of these things: Cable Cowboy: John Malone and the rise of the modern cable-TV business
Comparing the US experience with other parts of the world, you see a dramatic difference in the amount of time Americans had to internalize life with the phone. I worked on international VOIP deployments in the late 90s and early 2000s and some of the populations were going from no phone access to first cellphones / very expensive rates to affordable rates, all in a few years.
Yes, you don't even have to go to the more remote or significantly developmentally behind countries. In Hungary (in Budapest, not some remote rural place), we didn't have a landline phone up until the mid-to-late 90s. It was not unheard of, just difficult to get, you'd be on the wait list for long. There were street payphones though, so we could call relatives who got theirs earlier. We went from getting our first landline to getting broadband Internet within a single decade (mid 1990s to mid 2000s).
The really interesting thing is that the big push to reduce the landline backlog in the mid-to-late 90s happened at the same time as GSM was getting popular. Lots of people in Hungary ended up getting mobile phones before they ever got off that landline waitlist!
(Also, I remember that, in the 80s and early 90s at least, the wait to get a phone installed was much shorter in many smaller towns and villages than it was in Budapest. The same sort of thing happened later with the advent of broadband. As I recall, I had 100Mbps service in a small village in the south of Hungary before it was available in Budapest - and I could only get 20Mbps at the time in the USA!)
I have argued elsewhere and at length that what matters isn't the telephone per se but the Public Switched Telephone Network, which I claim is the Second Network (the First being the Universal Postal Union which enables you to send physical mail to arbitrary people in the world, and the Third being the Internet)
The thing these have in common is that they're connecting all the people. There is no intermediary necessary. Probably you won't send a postcard to some child you've never met in Shanghai, make a phone call to a random farmer in Ukraine or use a video chat to call random Venezuelans on the Internet, but you can and that's why these networks are so powerful.
I'd argue mobile phones are as important as the other networks you mentioned - instead of finite amount of endpoints, suddenly *everywhere* was in the network
Well, if we're going to be pedantic, then you should make room for the Telegraph network which served a similar function between the postal and telephone networks (and later the internet) as documented in Tom Sandage's _The Victorian Internet_.[1]
Yeah, no. I have thought about this but the problem is that the lay person cannot use a Telegraph. Yes, of course they can go to an office and send a telegraph message, but that's different because now that's clearly mediated and what I came up with is that the crucial thing is the lack of mediation.
If the UPU begins a thousand years earlier that falls by the same reasoning, a thousand years earlier too many people aren't literate, so they need to have their letter written by someone else, and the recipient must find someone to read it - but by the time of the UPU literacy is widespread.
The telephone network required an operator to complete (mediate) calls for decades of it's early existence.
The telegraph is the most impactful of all the telecommunication inventions because it is the one that moved communication from days to transport a physical message to the other side of the world to near instantaneous.
> The telephone network required an operator to complete (mediate) calls for decades of it's early existence.
The Public Switched Telephone Network does not "require an operator to complete calls". Strowger's original machine is a bit fiddly but the dial telephone with its pulsed signalling and the switches developed from Strowger's ideas dominated for much of the 20th century.
If you only have the Telephone then yeah, initially you need to hope the other end is listening and make a noise to get their attention - ringing telephone bells happen later, but that, I argue, is not the Network. Sending a bloke on a horse with your message is also not the Network.
They were until they weren't. The original argument here is for communications without direct human mediaries, and so the human switched network does not count where the electrically switched network does.
But with the UPU you still have to take your letter or package to the post office (or, in some places, have them pick it up). There is as much of an person as intermediary there as with the telegram.
The Post Office is expressly not allowed to do anything to your communication. In the US Governments have repeatedly tried, whether that's the Comstock Act, the South trying to ensure Slaves don't find out about Abolition, or even Trump trying to stop the election from operating properly - but it gets shut down because it's clearly not what a Post Office is for.
For purely pragmatic reasons tampering with mail was never common, Comstock and the Trump attempt both try to co-opt a large Federal institution to do something everybody hates which is part of why they both failed. It's extra work to snoop through all those boring letters to see whether anybody said things you wish they wouldn't, "Ain't nobody got time for that" as someone once said.
The other day I asked some friends if they had a fixed phone. None of them did. It's something of a pity. The phone we had thirty years ago was a noble beast, but the one we carry today comes with an odd feeling.
The pocket-destroying cellphone I have from my company (which I must carry at all times, because of on-call) comes with spyware, it also comes with a two-factor authentication app that flashes an angry error message because I don't allow notifications. I'm of course exaggerating a little and speaking subjectively, but that phone feels more like a slave collar than something I really want to have around, and the feeling hasn't subsided one bit in the five years I've carried it.
Even with my personal phone (an iphone), things are not much better. It sends who-knows-what-of-my-data to god-knows-where, and of course keeping the radios active for all that chitchat costs battery time. It doesn't allow me to run any custom-made app I may need without paying Apple a hefty developer subscription and getting a Mac. And, ultimately, it's Apple's device, with security functions to protect Apple and to guarantee other companies with apps running in the phone that the device won't really let me if I try to, say, break their DRM.
Might be giving away my age, but almost everyone I know has a landline. I have one too, but also a mobile which is a highly modded and rooted Android that I don't enable the cell radio on unless I'm actively using it.
I find myself thinking of hype cycles / fads, and telephones are one of the earlier ones I experienced first hand.
Like in the 90s or so, pre-internet, phones were big.
There were phone lines to get movie times, the time, automated phone banking to get your balance and make transfers, buying things on the phone like 1-800-flowers, dial-a-pizza, taxis, qvc / "home shopping" channels, phone sex lines, all that stuff. It was peak phone. Also, people had cordless phones, speaker phones, answering machines, all sorts of accessories, and generally cared about their phone.
Then, in the late 90s/2000s, all that stuff shifted to the web. In the 2010s... it all shifted to apps / smartphones. Now... it's all shifting to AI / agentic.
The delivery medium keeps changing and cannibalizing the previous one, but the actual stuff being delivered stays kind of the same.
I plan one day soon to no longer have a mobile phone. Not a dumb phone, none. I'll likely set up a landline.
I've already started dry running this as an experiment. It is alarming how many companies, government systems etc are not possible to use without a smart phone with internet, a camera (computer one won't suffice), SMS capability, access to Google or Apple's stores or sometimes all of the above.
IMHO the ability to send full-duplex speech and signaling over a single twisted pair, with only late-19th-century technology, was what made it possible to grow the telephone network so quickly and relatively cheaply.
But in the next century the knowledge would be lost again
The number of young people I've seen not knowing how to hold a phone increased significantly the past few years; I've seen them holding smartphones with the screen up, and using them as half-duplex, alternating between the mic end in front of their mouth and the speaker end pointing towards an ear. For someone holding a phone in the customary full-duplex manner, this makes for a very annoying conversation with awkward pauses and missed words.
I'm really tired of HN auto-rewriting headlines. Any headline beginning with 'How ...' automatically has the first word removed, rendering many headlines trite or meaningless unless the submitter edits it in time.
mikestew | 9 hours ago
“How the Telephone Changed the World”
(Though in this rare instance the the title still makes some sense.)
xnx | 8 hours ago
Telegraph seems like the more significant milestone, but putting that in the title of a book wouldn't sell many copies.
z3c0 | 8 hours ago
smelendez | 8 hours ago
Which, after all, is why people want to read about it. Most people don’t have much firsthand experience with the telegraph.
folmar | an hour ago
LurkandComment | 8 hours ago
smelendez | 8 hours ago
The new Gleick book this piece is excerpted from gets the most into the technical aspects, which makes sense given Gleick’s background. There’s also a lot about the patent disputes in the early days of the phone and its impact in its early days on popular culture.
I think there’s still more phone history to be written. I’d like to see a social history of the phone in the period basically from WW II to the iPhone, including unexpected and deviant use of the phone: phone phreaking, prank calls, music over the phone, sex lines, collect calling, right wing voice message lines, phone zap protests, telemarketing, and I’m sure things I don’t even know about. Plus how the rise of technology like cordless phones, extension lines, etc. delivered privacy for phone users in their own homes.
kator | 5 hours ago
paulorlando | 7 hours ago
bonoboTP | 5 hours ago
kiscica | 3 hours ago
(Also, I remember that, in the 80s and early 90s at least, the wait to get a phone installed was much shorter in many smaller towns and villages than it was in Budapest. The same sort of thing happened later with the advent of broadband. As I recall, I had 100Mbps service in a small village in the south of Hungary before it was available in Budapest - and I could only get 20Mbps at the time in the USA!)
tialaramex | 6 hours ago
The thing these have in common is that they're connecting all the people. There is no intermediary necessary. Probably you won't send a postcard to some child you've never met in Shanghai, make a phone call to a random farmer in Ukraine or use a video chat to call random Venezuelans on the Internet, but you can and that's why these networks are so powerful.
NooneAtAll5 | 6 hours ago
EarlKing | 6 hours ago
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Victorian_Internet
tialaramex | 5 hours ago
If the UPU begins a thousand years earlier that falls by the same reasoning, a thousand years earlier too many people aren't literate, so they need to have their letter written by someone else, and the recipient must find someone to read it - but by the time of the UPU literacy is widespread.
gbcfghhjj | 4 hours ago
The telegraph is the most impactful of all the telecommunication inventions because it is the one that moved communication from days to transport a physical message to the other side of the world to near instantaneous.
tialaramex | 3 hours ago
The Public Switched Telephone Network does not "require an operator to complete calls". Strowger's original machine is a bit fiddly but the dial telephone with its pulsed signalling and the switches developed from Strowger's ideas dominated for much of the 20th century.
If you only have the Telephone then yeah, initially you need to hope the other end is listening and make a noise to get their attention - ringing telephone bells happen later, but that, I argue, is not the Network. Sending a bloke on a horse with your message is also not the Network.
userbinator | 2 hours ago
The operators were the switches.
goodmythical | 2 hours ago
limagnolia | 4 hours ago
tialaramex | 3 hours ago
For purely pragmatic reasons tampering with mail was never common, Comstock and the Trump attempt both try to co-opt a large Federal institution to do something everybody hates which is part of why they both failed. It's extra work to snoop through all those boring letters to see whether anybody said things you wish they wouldn't, "Ain't nobody got time for that" as someone once said.
limagnolia | 3 hours ago
dsign | 5 hours ago
The pocket-destroying cellphone I have from my company (which I must carry at all times, because of on-call) comes with spyware, it also comes with a two-factor authentication app that flashes an angry error message because I don't allow notifications. I'm of course exaggerating a little and speaking subjectively, but that phone feels more like a slave collar than something I really want to have around, and the feeling hasn't subsided one bit in the five years I've carried it.
Even with my personal phone (an iphone), things are not much better. It sends who-knows-what-of-my-data to god-knows-where, and of course keeping the radios active for all that chitchat costs battery time. It doesn't allow me to run any custom-made app I may need without paying Apple a hefty developer subscription and getting a Mac. And, ultimately, it's Apple's device, with security functions to protect Apple and to guarantee other companies with apps running in the phone that the device won't really let me if I try to, say, break their DRM.
userbinator | 2 hours ago
nikanj | 2 hours ago
apublicfrog | 2 hours ago
juniperus | 3 hours ago
'member phone booths... 'member the party line...
tacostakohashi | 3 hours ago
There were phone lines to get movie times, the time, automated phone banking to get your balance and make transfers, buying things on the phone like 1-800-flowers, dial-a-pizza, taxis, qvc / "home shopping" channels, phone sex lines, all that stuff. It was peak phone. Also, people had cordless phones, speaker phones, answering machines, all sorts of accessories, and generally cared about their phone.
Then, in the late 90s/2000s, all that stuff shifted to the web. In the 2010s... it all shifted to apps / smartphones. Now... it's all shifting to AI / agentic.
The delivery medium keeps changing and cannibalizing the previous one, but the actual stuff being delivered stays kind of the same.
AnimalMuppet | 2 hours ago
apublicfrog | an hour ago
I've already started dry running this as an experiment. It is alarming how many companies, government systems etc are not possible to use without a smart phone with internet, a camera (computer one won't suffice), SMS capability, access to Google or Apple's stores or sometimes all of the above.
userbinator | 2 hours ago
But in the next century the knowledge would be lost again
The number of young people I've seen not knowing how to hold a phone increased significantly the past few years; I've seen them holding smartphones with the screen up, and using them as half-duplex, alternating between the mic end in front of their mouth and the speaker end pointing towards an ear. For someone holding a phone in the customary full-duplex manner, this makes for a very annoying conversation with awkward pauses and missed words.
anigbrowl | 2 hours ago