QotNews Hacker News, Reddit, Lobsters, and Tildes articles rendered in reader mode.
Russia's fuel crisis deepens as Ukraine's strikes force record petrol imports. The surge marks a dramatic reversal for Russia, once a leading global exporter of refined oil products
His assessment just means he doesn't understand long term or strategic level impacts.
He's right that the attacks don't directly change the tactical situation on the front lines, but that's a foolish thing to critique since strategic level efforts aren't supposed to do that.
Someone who graduated from Harvard with honours, served in the US State Department, the intelligence community, the CIA and the Department of Defence. Led the development and rollout of the 2018 National Defense Strategy.
Someone who is a published strategic thinker whose work focuses on deterrence, military power, industrial capacity and the geopolitical balance between major powers.
And, you think this person doesn't understand the long term strategic impact of Ukrainian deep strikes?
It is certainly curious that almost any assessment of the war in Ukraine that is negative about its trajectory, or likely outcome attracts furious pushback, while even the most wildly unrealistic, assessments seem to pass with barely a word of criticism.
Even if he believes that (might be just pondering to his boss like many others near Trump), saying in publicly is retarded. It's in best interest of US to get Russia bogged down in Ukraine for years and have their energy sector comprehensively destroyed. They are competitor with USA in energy markets lol.
I think that view is incredibly callous and dismissive of Ukrainian lives and suffering.
I don't presume to speak for Mr. Colby, but I suspect his argument would be something along these lines of the following.
A prolonged war can become increasingly costly to American interests. Russia isn't America's primary strategic competitor. Higher energy prices can also damage the American economy, which is particularly sensitive to energy costs. Finally, a stable Europe obviously benefits the US, while a prolonged period of European instability carries significant economic and strategic costs.
Blaming the west for the suffering is Russian propaganda. The suffering is caused by the invader, no one else. The same goes for European stabilty. Russia having a free hand to invade it's neighbors is theblast thing you want if you care about stability in Europe.
Then they should probably stop the invasion of Ukraine which they started and is the direct cause of the Russian fuel crisis. . . It's really all in Putin's hands
fwiw, what jumps out to me is the refining bit, not the crude. Russia can still pump oil, but if it can't turn it into petrol at home it ends up selling crude cheap and buying petrol dear, and that spread is what really bites. Refining capacity is the bottleneck here, and bottlenecks are slow and expensive to fix. I wouldn't bet on that reversing quickly.
aKamikazePilot | 8 hours ago
Happy that Elbridge Colby was called out by Germany at NATO talks yesterday (regarding the deep strikes on refineries). The amount of pandering by U.S. officials towards Russia is getting tiring. Also source: https://thehill.com/policy/international/6229395-colby-criticizes-ukraine-long-range-strikes/amp/
Sanmonov | 6 hours ago
He’s giving his assessment. Maybe it’s correct.
dravik | 5 hours ago
His assessment just means he doesn't understand long term or strategic level impacts.
He's right that the attacks don't directly change the tactical situation on the front lines, but that's a foolish thing to critique since strategic level efforts aren't supposed to do that.
Sanmonov | 3 hours ago
That’s rather presumptuous.
Someone who graduated from Harvard with honours, served in the US State Department, the intelligence community, the CIA and the Department of Defence. Led the development and rollout of the 2018 National Defense Strategy.
Someone who is a published strategic thinker whose work focuses on deterrence, military power, industrial capacity and the geopolitical balance between major powers.
And, you think this person doesn't understand the long term strategic impact of Ukrainian deep strikes?
It is certainly curious that almost any assessment of the war in Ukraine that is negative about its trajectory, or likely outcome attracts furious pushback, while even the most wildly unrealistic, assessments seem to pass with barely a word of criticism.
Jdm783R29U3Cwp3d76R9 | 3 hours ago
Even if he believes that (might be just pondering to his boss like many others near Trump), saying in publicly is retarded. It's in best interest of US to get Russia bogged down in Ukraine for years and have their energy sector comprehensively destroyed. They are competitor with USA in energy markets lol.
Sanmonov | 3 hours ago
I think that view is incredibly callous and dismissive of Ukrainian lives and suffering.
I don't presume to speak for Mr. Colby, but I suspect his argument would be something along these lines of the following.
A prolonged war can become increasingly costly to American interests. Russia isn't America's primary strategic competitor. Higher energy prices can also damage the American economy, which is particularly sensitive to energy costs. Finally, a stable Europe obviously benefits the US, while a prolonged period of European instability carries significant economic and strategic costs.
devliegende | 2 hours ago
Blaming the west for the suffering is Russian propaganda. The suffering is caused by the invader, no one else. The same goes for European stabilty. Russia having a free hand to invade it's neighbors is theblast thing you want if you care about stability in Europe.
Jdm783R29U3Cwp3d76R9 | 2 hours ago
And you suppose that suffering will end the moment Ukraine will surrender to Russia, do you? Give me a break.
Lemp_Triscuit11 | 2 hours ago
What if I think he may understand it just fine but is just saying what Trump tells him to say, like 100% of the rest of this admins appointees? lol
raresanevoice | 3 hours ago
Then they should probably stop the invasion of Ukraine which they started and is the direct cause of the Russian fuel crisis. . . It's really all in Putin's hands
MrMarketsDiary | an hour ago
fwiw, what jumps out to me is the refining bit, not the crude. Russia can still pump oil, but if it can't turn it into petrol at home it ends up selling crude cheap and buying petrol dear, and that spread is what really bites. Refining capacity is the bottleneck here, and bottlenecks are slow and expensive to fix. I wouldn't bet on that reversing quickly.