L3Harris statement on the Nov. 13 ground stop

94 points by taspeotis a day ago on hackernews | 80 comments

madeofpalk | a day ago

I guess it’s technically a statement, even though it says nothing.

interestica | 19 hours ago

It's a technical statement

dlcarrier | 16 hours ago

At least they didn't run it through an LLM, so it could take three times linger to say nothing.

drooby | a day ago

I'm glad they're taking this seriously

oofbey | a day ago

I kinda wish they'd take it "very seriously". Corporate communications generally take issues "very seriously". The fact that they're only taking it "seriously" makes me wonder if they're really taking it seriously or not.

rr808 | a day ago

Its like the people who are 101% committed dont sound as dedicated as the people that are 200% committed.

InsidiousWombat | 23 hours ago

If they did it wouldn't crash

otterley | 21 hours ago

Let he who has never failed at an important task raise his hand.

fallingmeat | a day ago

personal perspective- L3X has repeatedly demonstrated a corporate culture of accountability allergy. spiderman meme was made for L3. I think it goes up and down the chain

cogman10 | a day ago

This is standard practice for basically all defense contractors. I don't think there's hardly any of them that strive for excellence, just for next year's contract.

saturn8601 | a day ago

Very surprised because I know several fellow alumni that went on to do extremely technical low level "frontier level" work there. Due to the secret nature of their operations, what they literally do day to day is an angle I don't know much about so maybe its all nonsense but I don't get that feeling.

Jtsummers | 23 hours ago

Defense contractors, as a rule, seem to have a corporate culture of mediocrity and poor performance. But you will find pockets within them that do better, possibly even actually being "frontier level". IT projects, though, are not one of the things they tend to excel at. The FAA stuff as one example, but most IT procurements end up bogged down with years of delays or just failures. It's tradition now.

cogman10 | 21 hours ago

Yes, to be clear I'm not trying to throw shade on the engineers working for defense contractors, but rather the business model and practice itself.

Failing to deliver is rewarded. Even in this instance, we see Sec Duffy asking for $50B to give to L3H because they failed so spectacularly.

These companies keep delivering edsels and our government's response is to double the investment on every failure.

saturn8601 | 16 hours ago

Yeah I was referring more to low level EE and CS related work. Its possible IT implementation is a different story.

bigstrat2003 | 23 hours ago

There are certainly staff members at defense contractors who strive for excellence (I know several personally), but yeah the management culture is pretty fucked. Lots of cases where engineers point out what a bad idea something is, get overruled (because we have a deadline to meet, dammit), and then management acts shocked when it blows up in their faces.

dlcarrier | 16 hours ago

They strive for compliance, and nothing more, because anything more would be non-compliant.

praet | a day ago

> L3Harris takes the nationwide ground stop and its impact on travelers, airlines and air traffic operations seriously.

Thank goodness

noir_lord | a day ago

I mean they could have taken it humorously I guess.

encrypted_bird | 20 hours ago

Lmao "Our lawyers advised us to be serious about this, but imma keep it a stack this is hilarious."

hurfdurf | 13 hours ago

The difference is hard to notice these days. And with Thanksgiving madness coming up, fingers crossed!

danso | a day ago

> This website uses cookies and similar technologies, which we collectively refer to here as "cookies."[sic] L3Harris uses cookies to improve your experience on our website

Great first impression from a technical company

jmbwell | 21 hours ago

L3Harris is a legal-financial instrument formed from the remains of former technical companies

class3shock | 20 hours ago

Welcome to the world of defense contractors! Here at Raytheon Grumman Dynamic we have business units in all technical domains with engineers, scientists, and technicians of every kind, all organized under the leadership of finance and business majors to maximize shareholder value!

dlcarrier | 16 hours ago

The best part is that one of the entries in the name is usually in some completely unrelated field. When I learned that the GenCorp in Aerojet GenCorp was a tire manufacturer, the joke in Portal of the portal gun having possible applications as a shower curtain hit a lot harder. Also, the Morton in Morton Thiokol, the company that made the boosters that failed in the Challenger disaster, is the salt company.

drewg123 | a day ago

Oh, these are defense contractors, that explains a lot about this non-statement.

I had thought the L3 was from Level 3 Communications and Harris, but its actually L3 Technologies which seems to be a holding company for defense contractors.

ba1afd89f34cb23 | a day ago

FYI, CenturyLink bought Level3 something like 10 years ago and then re-branded as Lumen during COVID.

jki275 | 21 hours ago

L3 Technologies was a large defense contractor that was known for night vision and optics among a number of other things. They merged with Harris to create L3H. They're not a holding company.

class3shock | 20 hours ago

All the big defense companies look a bit like holding companies with a bunch of differently focused 'business units' under the same umbrella.

bastard_op | a day ago

Ahh, these frigging guys...

So I bought a Fortigate firewall on ebay some years back for a lab device, I password recovered it to break in and recover it, and it came up registered to them, and still under Enterprise license support for like 6mo. Great, that's exactly what I wanted for a lab device! I looked them up to see they were a defense contractor, ok, so more money than brains. I'll take advantage...

That 6mo came and went, and they renewed the support on it for another year, and my firewall saw the entitlement. Even better, I continued to use it. After 4 years finally the device went EOL/EOS and expired with no more support available, I was sad.

Obviously these guys are fsckheads, more money and contracts from friends in high places than brains. This totally explains why the air system melted down!

InsidiousWombat | 23 hours ago

I think just the fact they used Fortigate means that

skullone | 23 hours ago

Yet somehow Fortigate is everywhere in defense/government. How they manage to make such buggy pathetic devices with near monthly CVEs is beyond me. Oh wait, they have no incentive to improve their quality, they're already everywhere :(

dvno42 | 22 hours ago

What would you prefer to use? What else is there besides PaloAlto that's not even worse? Not saying Fortigates are great but they're the least shit I know of so please elaborate if you know of something better in the enterprise IT space.

Fordec | 22 hours ago

Pin alternatives on a dartboard, throw a dart to select one, and you're still better off.

Palo Alto, Sophos, Cisco, Juniper, UniFi... Anything except maybe Barracuda.

SturgeonsLaw | 20 hours ago

Sophos is a bug riddled mess and UniFi is prosumer at best, in no world are they better than Fortigate

shermozle | a day ago

By "modernizing" they mean making it equivalently fragile and flaky to such modern wonders as Github and Microsoft 363?

alfiedotwtf | 23 hours ago

> 363

LOL nice

icedchai | 22 hours ago

"Modernizing" is a favorite buzzword in government contracting. Moving some app to the cloud and doing nothing else to it? Modernizing. Rewriting the whole thing? Also modernizing. Putting a new API in front of an old system and then leaving the old system around for years? Also modernizing. Modernizing can mean everything and nothing.

jmbwell | 21 hours ago

Swapping out old problems for new ones is a great way to climb the ranks among government accounts payable though

slowin | 23 hours ago

For those unfamiliar with this company:

> In 2008, 72 Iraqi civilians sued L3 Services for human rights violations they had endured at Abu Ghraib and other prisons in Iraq, including "torture; cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment; war crimes; assault and battery; sexual assault and battery; intentional infliction of emotional distress; negligent hiring and supervision; and negligent infliction of emotional distress." A settlement was reached on October 10, 2012, which was the "first positive resolution to a U.S. civil case challenging detainee treatment outside the United States in the larger 'war on terror' context".

> In 2012, L3 subsidiary KDI Precision Products participated in the sale of 11,500 JDAM bomb fuzes to Israel, part of a $647 million contract deal. These were among the weapons used by the IDF in the 2014 Gaza War; the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights highlighted the IDF's weapons usages, which included attacks on densely populated civilian areas, as constituting potential war crimes.

> In June 2022, Chris Kubasik succeeded as the Chair following Bill Brown's retirement. That same month it was reported to have held talks to purchase the Israeli company NSO, which builds Pegasus spyware. White House officials heard of the talks and voiced opposition, resulting in L3Harris discontinuing its plans.

> In October 2025, Israel entered into a memorandum of understanding with L3Harris to facilitate the acquisition of new light attack aircraft intended for border defense, aimed at developing the Israeli Sky Warden variant.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L3Harris

skew-aberration | 23 hours ago

> purchase the Israeli company NSO, which builds Pegasus spyware. White House officials heard of the talks and voiced opposition

Is the implication that an American company would not be able to continue their business model legally? But they could just sell to the government instead, as L3Harris' other zero-day companies do.

MarsZebra | 23 hours ago

They are also behind Golden Dome -- putting offensive weapons into orbit

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Dome_(missile_defense_s...

frankharv | 20 hours ago

I would not classify a missile than intercepts other missiles as offensive.

MarsZebra | 20 hours ago

Trump said it can do "left of launch" ground strikes

Very similar to this, which SpaceX was also involved in:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Falcon_Project

bigyabai | 14 hours ago

Please find a better use for HN than linking the same Wikipedia article over and over again - this is the seventh time you've posted it. It is bannable behavior and not a gratifying use of the site.

MarsZebra | 2 hours ago

You are trolling around HN trying to interrupt any discussions about Golden Dome,

claiming anyone who talks about it is the same person? What?

bigyabai | 2 hours ago

Yes, your commenting pattern is identical to several other accounts that behave the exact same way and link the exact same article.

Refer to prior moderation comments on this topic; if you cannot change your behavior, you will be banned:

> HN's purpose is to gratify intellectual curiosity, and the site can only work if submitters post a variety of articles about different topics, rather than posting articles about the same topic repeatedly.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48343570

numpad0 | 22 hours ago

L3Harris is the US military's electronics guy. They make everything electronic and complicated, from handheld radios to motorized camera pods to satellites.

frrlpp | 22 hours ago

Has L3Harris anything to do with Harris Radio?

jki275 | 21 hours ago

L3Harris is the merger of L3 and Harris. Yes, they still make radios.

encrypted_bird | 20 hours ago

They're definitely straining the imagination wrt creativity in coming up with that name.

class3shock | 20 hours ago

They are the 6th biggest defense contractor in the US but don't have the same name recognition as the 'big five' (Boeing, RTX, Northrop Grumman, General Dynamics, and Lockheed Martin - listed in no specific order)

Funny story. Chris Kubasik was the heir apparent at Lockheed but got kicked to the curb when he couldn't keep his dick in his pants at work. Ended up getting the CEO job at L3Harris and then what does he do?

https://www.cnbc.com/2026/08/17/l3harris-ceo-chris-kubasik-l...

shusaku | 20 hours ago

> don't have the same name recognition as the 'big five

Well, as they say, all publicity is good publicity?

Barbing | 23 hours ago

  L3Harris has been modernizing the communications infrastructure supporting the National Airspace System in close coordination with the FAA. With safety and reliability as our highest priorities, L3Harris, together with its telco partners and the FAA, has completed more than 70% of the planned airspace communications conversion from legacy copper wires to a fiber optic system. We are supporting the FAA in its investigation to understand the conditions that led to the Nov. 13 ground stop of our nation’s air travel. L3Harris takes the nationwide ground stop and its impact on travelers, airlines and air traffic operations seriously.
<end entire statement>

droidjj | 22 hours ago

This went through so many rounds with their lawyers that I now feel I know less than before I read it.

otterley | 21 hours ago

Makes me wonder why they bothered.

dlcarrier | 16 hours ago

We can neither confirm nor deny that we have enough information to determine whether or not we messed up.

stogot | 19 hours ago

Ending so abrupt. No “apology”. The comms PR team mustve removed something better

SanjayMehta | 14 hours ago

> L3Harris takes the nationwide ground stop and its impact on travelers, airlines and air traffic operations seriously.

Not "very seriously." Just "seriously."

intrasight | 23 hours ago

> “Which begs the question for us: What did L3Harris do? Did they make mistakes yesterday?” Duffy told reporters. “They own this network. They’re our prime contractor. I can’t go somewhere else. They own it. Or was it a faulty router? And we’re going to find that out. And frankly, we’re going to hold people accountable.”

Someone's gotta educate the asshole that the buck stops at him. He is responsible.

joering2 | 22 hours ago

he did 100% what this administration does daily: blamed someone else, reassure they will "get to the bottom of it", and that someone will pay the price (someone else). Meanwhile in few days/weeks/months there will be something else to terrorize American citizens with, and 99.9% of citizens will forget about what happened Friday the 13th. Only hope is that we're so close to January and new leadership, that hopefully they won't forget and launch proper investigations. But make no mistake - any other administration if one faulty router would cost $250 million dollars in halting the whole US airspace to stop, at least Sec. would immediately resign!

jimt1234 | 22 hours ago

I feel sorry for the poor, underpaid network tech that's gonna take the blame for all this.

jmbwell | 21 hours ago

With any luck it will be recognized as an organizational failure and changes will be made to avoid it rather than punishing any one individual

otterley | 21 hours ago

You think he’s personally responsible for a network equipment maintenance failure, for a project that was apparently already 70% complete and which likely started long before he took office? He’s the head of a government agency, not a network tech.

What exactly do you expect him to do? Put yourself in his shoes.

empath75 | 21 hours ago

Well, he has been running the DoT for the last 2 years and spent the summer making a sponsored reality tv show.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_American_Road_Trip_(...

otterley | 21 hours ago

Nearly every officer that Trump has appointed this term is unqualified. That doesn’t make them necessarily culpable for everything that happens in their portfolios, especially for projects underway before they took office.

kakadu | 21 hours ago

> What exactly do you expect him to do?

Resign.

It happened on his watch.

otterley | 21 hours ago

Why? What good would that do other than make you feel better?

Jtsummers | 21 hours ago

What good does it do for him to stay? He hasn't been doing his job, he's been filming a reality show instead. He doesn't deserve his paycheck.

If he leaves maybe Trump would hire a competent replacement instead (unlikely, but can't be much worse than the current Cabinet of Clowns).

otterley | 21 hours ago

That seems like a different reason for him to be fired. If he had a competent boss, I could see that happening, but not with Trump as president. Trump is all about reality TV. He probably wishes more of his cabinet and department heads made it.

Jtsummers | 20 hours ago

Why do you want him to stay? You seem to be awfully keen to defend a man who isn't doing his job and allowed a major ATC failure to occur on his watch. You're all over this thread defending a useless man.

otterley | 20 hours ago

I don’t care if he stays or goes. I care that others, particularly in a forum of engineers (who are supposedly more intelligent than most) are demanding his head for the wrong reasons.

It’s stupid to fire engineers for accidentally causing operational incidents, and it’s similarly stupid to fire their bosses unless they intentionally or negligently set the stage to increase the risk of serious incidents. Mistakes are the fertilizer that bears the fruit of wisdom and experience.

Meanwhile, people here think Jensen Huang should be allowed to return to the helm at Nvidia even though doing so would be about the stupidest act the board could take; doing so would put the entire company at even greater risk of criminal liability.

AngryData | 18 hours ago

I think it is silly to not fire people and yet expect people to still learn from the mistake. If the only downside to taking down the nations ATC is some lawyer composed response, why would anyone be more careful about it in the future? Why wouldn't they take it as a sign that they could play it even faster and looser in the future if there is no downside to them?

otterley | 18 hours ago

I take it you’ve been fired for every mistake you’ve made that resulted in or contributed to an incident, then?

AngryData | 15 hours ago

Ive never made a mistake that costs more than I am worth, so no. I would expect if I made a mistake costing millions of dollars or more I would be fired.

otterley | 11 hours ago

I wouldn’t expect that. Your employer is going to discuss whether you have learned from your mistake and determine what changes to make to reduce the probability of it happening again. They’re unlikely to fire you, only to replace you with someone who could end up making a similar or worse mistake because they haven’t lived your experience yet.

thunderbong | 18 hours ago

I went through the whole thread and I totally agree with you. Regardless of anything else, unless there are proper processes in place, blaming an individual becomes just theater. The overall goal for any system failure should be to improve the process, unless the failure was intentional or due to negligence.
He handled it terribly. His top priorities were spreading blame and kissing the president's ass. God help us if there's a more serious problem with anything while these people are in charge.

mannyv | 23 hours ago

We plugged the copper wire into the fiber optic terminal because that's what you do when you upgrade wires.

Unfortunately, light didn't move through the copper wire effectively and some meth heads stole the copper wire we had removed, forcing us to upgrade the whole copper wire wire to fiber optic wires.

Our new fiber optic wires carry much more light than the old copper wires, which will make the FAA system much more responsive in the future.

Thank you very much and have a nice day.

Freestyler_3 | 22 hours ago

It could be FTL and FAA systems would still be just as responsive

dlcarrier | 16 hours ago

Fun fact: Copper wires work by carrying light. Well, technically it's much lower wavelength than light, but photons are involved any time a signal travels along a copper wire. See also: virtual photons