Yet another WebKit-based browser. Why? We already have Orion [0] that does exactly what this one does.
Also why WebKit? It has monthly memory corruption vulnerabilities being discovered.
Why not just improve Ladybird? [0] instead of creating a worse version of existing browsers that still suffer from weekly memory corruption vulnerabilities.
fair question. orion is great, and closed source. Search is MIT-licensed, ~10 mb, and built around arc’s way of working (spaces, pins, split view, peek, arc import), plus chrome extensions. on webkit: it’s the engine macos ships and patches with each security update, so Search gets those fixes without us maintaining an engine. that’s a big part of why we picked it.
Many years ago when Brave had just came out and it was an Electron browser---and Electron had like 10 use cases world wide---I was so frustrated with browsers that I thought man I can fork this and just fix it for myself. It wasn't about a revolutionary thing like Ladybird or if Brave was good foundation; it was only the lowest hanging fruit for me, the only possible one back then. I couldn't even fathom compiling Chromium, not to mention changing it.
WebKit is designed to be easily embedded, is already compiled in the mac and has a very straight forward API and is a part of Apple world, so you just make the browser shell and what you want. That is probably the rationale behind 99% of WebKit browsers. Search was 6MB worth of download, you can't have that with Chromium, and I don't think if people have the patience to use a half done browser engine so that it can be finished---although I personally am counting down for the day I switch to ladybird.
Uhh.. I would argue that we don't have /enough/ Webkit based browsers. There are currently no Webkit browsers for Windows unless you want to run Something like Gnome web/Epiphany in WSL.
Kagi Orion looked promising, but they quit developing their windows version recently.
hi, I’m Drice, I make Search. some context: I started it when Arc stopped moving, wanting Arc’s way of working (spaces, pins, split view, peek) in something native and small. it uses the WebKit already in macOS, so the app is ~10 mb and gets WebKit’s security fixes with macOS updates. Chrome extensions run through Apple’s WKWebExtension, with a compatibility layer for the APIs it lacks; most popular ones work, not all yet. it’s MIT, code at github.com/driceroland/Search. happy to answer anything, and bug reports are very welcome!
Shouldn't the intro paragraph carefully, clearly explain the benefits?
This is the intro paragraph "Search is a browser for the Mac with nothing in the way. About ten megabytes, the engine already in macOS, and a window that opens in a third of a second. Free, for any Mac on macOS 14 or later."
I just think "with nothing in the way", is really lacking as the value proposition.
For me, simplicity is the value proposition. All I really want from my browser is for it to be lightweight, open source, good looking, and have basic organization (groups, bookmarks etc.). This checks all the boxes without any cruft.
The quality of the ad blocker and extension support are the main question marks for me, but they've been good enough so far.
What’s interesting is that it’s the averaging of many writers with voices which do sound human and enthusiastic and quirky sound like no personality at all.
There is an absolute obsession of using three variations for the message, the wording, and the life behind it. And the nonstop em dash! My favorite side effect of LLM slop is that it exposes people who have no respect for their readers, don't proof read their own works, and the life behind it.
Imagine thinking "I wish I could use my chrome extensions in safari" and instead of asking your agent to port the extensions over, you conclude that you should vibe code a new webkit browser with chrome extension support
I love search’s aesthetic, its integration with iCloud Keychain, its minimalism… but dude, spaces was really unintuitive it made me uninstall really quickly :(
In my opinion spaces and profiles should be tied together, and they should be dots along the bottom. I’m also not sure why we need bookmarks in these side bar folder style browsers.
I hate the effect of design minimalism bleeding into functional minimalism. I also hate the low information density and undiscoverability that also often accompany it.
Say it with me: Form follows function. Form follows function. Form follows function. Form follows function!
We'd hate if a car's climate controls were behind an aesthetically beautiful door in the console
I guess thats why good design is subjective? Peoples functions are different from one another. For myself I have never used bookmarks, even before Arc/side bars browsers. I also found it really unintuitive that I had to select a space, and then within the space I had to choose a profile. Isn’t the whole purpose of spaces to automatically split profiles into spaces? The dots are also much nicer to click rather than a click to open a select, to then select a space, and then select a profile…
Really wish they'd brought over the "command pallette" interface from Arc for searching, browser actions, and switching tabs. IMO, this is even more important for navigation across fullscreen tabs than Arc's sidebar is.
Been using it with vimium for about 2 months. Other than not always capturing the focus on vimium fields it does what it promises on its tin: a minimal (as in resources) browser, a renderer of pages, that brought many of arc defaults
[OP] rsaz | 6 hours ago
Made by design studio Office Commun
pankso | 6 hours ago
HelloUsername | 5 hours ago
Also related recently: "Show HN: Zigzag, a native Mac browser for people leaving Arc " https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50496787 74 comments
rvz | 5 hours ago
Also why WebKit? It has monthly memory corruption vulnerabilities being discovered.
Why not just improve Ladybird? [0] instead of creating a worse version of existing browsers that still suffer from weekly memory corruption vulnerabilities.
[0] https://orionbrowser.com/
[1] https://ladybird.org/
Squarex | 5 hours ago
driceroland | 5 hours ago
[OP] rsaz | 4 hours ago
Anecdotally, I also like Search's look better and have found it more stable (though it's been a while since I really tried using Orion to be fair).
mulderc | 4 hours ago
pmkary | 4 hours ago
WebKit is designed to be easily embedded, is already compiled in the mac and has a very straight forward API and is a part of Apple world, so you just make the browser shell and what you want. That is probably the rationale behind 99% of WebKit browsers. Search was 6MB worth of download, you can't have that with Chromium, and I don't think if people have the patience to use a half done browser engine so that it can be finished---although I personally am counting down for the day I switch to ladybird.
hxorr | 4 hours ago
Kagi Orion looked promising, but they quit developing their windows version recently.
zinc_chest63 | 5 hours ago
driceroland | 5 hours ago
andirk | 2 hours ago
Also, did you give Arc's baby, Dia, a try? I learned about it when they reached out to not hire me.
camkego | 5 hours ago
I just think "with nothing in the way", is really lacking as the value proposition.
[OP] rsaz | 4 hours ago
The quality of the ad blocker and extension support are the main question marks for me, but they've been good enough so far.
dofm | 3 hours ago
fnoobnar | 5 hours ago
I really can’t stand LLM language.
sixtyj | 4 hours ago
dofm | 3 hours ago
(Particularly if they use Claude. Even getting Gemma to write the text would be an improvement)
Affric | 2 hours ago
andirk | 2 hours ago
pmkary | 4 hours ago
drcongo | 4 hours ago
whh | 4 hours ago
cush | 4 hours ago
jawr | 4 hours ago
In my opinion spaces and profiles should be tied together, and they should be dots along the bottom. I’m also not sure why we need bookmarks in these side bar folder style browsers.
TimTheTinker | 3 hours ago
Say it with me: Form follows function. Form follows function. Form follows function. Form follows function!
We'd hate if a car's climate controls were behind an aesthetically beautiful door in the console
jawr | 20 minutes ago
However, maybe I’m misunderstanding your reply!
altern8 | 4 hours ago
Absolutely hate merging URL and tab, for instance. I like to see what URL I'm on.
RistrettoMike | 3 hours ago
[OP] rsaz | 3 hours ago
choxi | 3 hours ago
627467 | 2 hours ago